r/learnjava • • Apr 14 '21

What do you think about Tim Buchalka's Java Programming Masterclass?

I work for a company and they hired a new guy in my team and he needs to learn Java. Someone recommended me to let him follow Java Programming Masterclass course from Tim Buchalka on Udemy.

Did any of you follow that course? If you did what's your opinion on it?

59 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21

Thank you guys! I think I will recommend both MOOC.FI and Tim's course to him.

40

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21

I did it for a while. It's good, but I found I started to get lost and I was struggling to keep up with the pace.

I found that the University of Helsinki MOOC was a better paced and the explanations were easier to understand.

I was almost a complete beginner though (I'd played about with a bit of VB and HTML during my degree, but that's all) so for a more advanced student Tim's course might be a better fit.

17

u/mynameiscba Apr 14 '21

+1 for MOOC. Very well explained and structured. I don’t know why but I couldn’t get used to udemy. I feel like information floats around and not make its way into my brain but that’s just me 😅😅

3

u/AHistoricalFigure Apr 14 '21

The problem I could see with using MOOC is that it's a very beginner oriented learn to code course. If the guy they hired has never written a line of code in his life, MOOC is probably the best bet.

If the guy is an experienced or even intermediate coder with other HLL experience who just needs to learn Java, he isn't going to need to grind through 120 example questions on loops and if statements.

The basic syntax is probably best learned through just picking up a quick reference book and writing a multi-class console program. Most of what someone new to Java from another language needs to learn is about Java-specific libraries and how Java implements its OOP conventions.

15

u/RartedPanther Apr 14 '21

I'm a big fan of it, I took it for a few months before starting uni CS, went through a good chunk of it, very good for learning Java. Some of the starters of it like data types are pretty basic and straight forward, but if you do all the practice work he recommends, I think its one of the best courses out there, especially for around 10 bucks. If you go to a private/incognito window and go to Udemy you can always find it for under 15 bucks and just gift it to your Udemy to get the lower price, and at worst if he doesn't like it it was only 15 bucks.

11

u/Skiamakhos Apr 14 '21

It's great value if you get it on sale at Udemy, around £10-12. He covers all the main things about the language. If you already know basic computer science / software engineering, it's a great way to get started learning Java. I'd counsel you to get another course to follow it up, something that gets you building different projects, to cement it in your memory.

1

u/julien_xiii Apr 15 '21

What course would you recommend as a follow up? I'm going through the course right now and like it till now. I have a fair knowledge on programming with python and a little bit with c++ but trying to build a desktop application with java now what would your recommendation be?

2

u/Skiamakhos Apr 15 '21

This one looks pretty good to start off with, if we're just talking basic Java projects for beginners: https://www.udemy.com/course/build-10-java-beginner-projects-from-scratch/ There are 10 projects there for a start.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21

+1 Mooc.fi was better for me.

6

u/DoctorSchwifty Apr 14 '21

It's really good. The other thing is that he updates his videos years after you bought them. There's a lot of value in that.

5

u/Fernando3161 Apr 14 '21

For 15 Bucks it is the best you will find. It helped me to transition from python to Java for my Doctoral Dissertation

4

u/Apprehensive_Royal77 Apr 14 '21

Done both, (first did Tim's), then after reading here about the MOOC I wanted to see if it was as good.

I completed Tim's, and there were a lot of sticky points but it was very comprehensive and in the end I learned so much. I did have to repeat some videos.

The MOOC is good as well, it covers and repeats concepts nicely.

In the end, I prefer Tim's course, but you do have to repeat videos that you don't understand.

My opinion: You can't go wrong with either one.

4

u/Symmetric_in_Design Apr 14 '21

Helsinki > > Tim buchalka imo.

4

u/Dexteroid Apr 14 '21

I just hate that intro music before every lesson. Sometimes the video is 2 mins long with 30 second of intro.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21

There is no intro anymore.

3

u/TheJones777 Apr 14 '21

I really enjoyed it and learned a lot, but at times it can be very verbose. I think pairing that course with reading the documentation is an excellent way to gain a foundational knowledge of Java

3

u/TheMetalMilitia Apr 14 '21

I would definitely recommend it! I'm up to section 7 right now and I've learned so much. I found the examples that he goes through incredibly helpful. I also recommend O'Reilly's "Java In A Nutshell" book

3

u/LTFGamut Apr 14 '21

It's really an excellent course. As far as I'm concerned, it's the best Java course there is. Tim's explanations of the concepts are really clear, the course covers most things you need to know to start programming in Java and the exercises are great for learning. I don't like all of his academy's courses equally well, but this one is truly great.

But you have to understand: it's a learn java course, not necessarily a beginner's programming course.

2

u/jahian119 Apr 14 '21

I'm going through his Android App Development masterclass using Java (instead of Kotlin). The content of the class is great, although personally I think he talks slightly slow. Not an issue though since in Udemy you can speed the video up. I have it set to 1.25 and it's perfect. He updates his courses fairly often, but even so the SDK that I'm using is a couple versions ahead of what is in the videos. This is mitigated by "non-video" lessons prior to the video that gives you the work around.

2

u/nowhereneverywhere Apr 14 '21

You can also check John Purcell's Java 11. Really good and easy to follow and well explained.

1

u/hythonyx Apr 14 '21

Can't speak for his java tutorial, but his kotlin tutorial was great

1

u/Curious_homosepian Apr 14 '21

I did it last year. I would give it a 3.5 star. Since the course portion is gigantic in size. It's more of what specific someone wants to learn. Like someone might not be interested in javaFx section can completely skip it without any issue. Compared to other instructors. Tim speaking is quite fast in pace. One needs to keep attention not to miss out any important detail.

The other issue was I found is some of his examples were really confusing and baseless. For any concept according to me simpler examples would do the work to explain the stuff.

If someone wants to clear OOPs concepts then this is good course.

1

u/Cmgeodude Apr 14 '21

It's a great course. It's quite comprehensive - the earlier sections are a little long if you know anything about programming - but it covers some breadth and some depth of content in a pretty stress-free way. I strongly recommend it.

1

u/Byte_Seyes Apr 15 '21

It’s a good course but he often talks about things really quickly and kinda just glosses over a lot of stuff. For someone that’s already a programmer and only needs to learn the language, it would be a good course.

Main issue with his course is there’s simply not enough challenges.