r/learnjava • • Mar 22 '20

For beginners: Don't start java from Udemy course "Masterclass Java" by Tim Buchalka.

(It's my opinion and my experience.)

You can buy the course but come to that when you have solid beginner foundation. Don't start java from there.

Why?

Up until the concept of object he was doing OK explaining loops, data types, methods, etc. When it came to OOP, I was banging my head to the wall, trying to understand what he was saying. Spent hours on different YouTube videos after watching his tutorial on a subject.

Almost all his examples are based on initial temporary project at the beginning of the video or the one before. If you lost track in between, you must start from the beginning, otherwise you are wasting your time.

NOT A LOT OF PRACTICE to solidify a subject. After doing some of his Udemy-problems, I thought I was getting the hang of it. When it came to solving problems outside of his course, I didn't know what to do, how to do and where to start.

Starting from OOP he starts giving you twisted challenges while you still learning how to loop from 1 to 100. The way he explains the challenge, using advanced level language, adds to confusion.

So, if you are starting from 0, don't start from his course.

144 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

81

u/desrtfx Mar 22 '20

That's exactly the reason why we don't have it in the recommended learning resources.

The single best starter course is the MOOC Object Oriented Programming with Java from the University of Helsinki.

10

u/jamming123321 Mar 22 '20

I ended up buying a book “Building Java Programs: A Back to Basics Approach (4th Edition)” by Stuart Reges. A golden book IMHO. Lots of easy to challenging exercises on every subject. The way they explain concepts and do a relatively major project at the end of evey chapter worth commending.

Now I’m doing leetcode problems (although easy and medium ones).

8

u/Ghordrin Mar 22 '20

Introduction to java programming by Daniel Liang is also a good book.

12

u/Alaharon123 Mar 22 '20

Speaking of which, the sidebars have not been updated yet for the new course

1

u/desrtfx Mar 22 '20

The link is the same - still working. Just checked both, old and new reddit.

2

u/Alaharon123 Mar 22 '20

I mean the references to using Java 7 and whatnot. The new one uses OpenJDK... 11? Also the mention of scrolling down to use the 2013 version because the 2020 version wasn't available yet

1

u/desrtfx Mar 22 '20

I will change the mentioning of the 2013 version once the 2020 version is fully up.

The one about the Java version is gone. Thanks.

7

u/sonrivera Mar 22 '20

Wish I knew about MOOC (GREAT FOR BEGINNERS) before I started the Java Masterclass Program on Udemy. Tim Buchalka does a decent job explaining the basics, but OP is right on point when he says Tim starts getting extremely confusing when Object Oriented Program lessons start. His exercises for those are trash and WAY TOO VAGUE. There is absolutely no direction and you pretty much have to make a whole goddamn function from scratch

2

u/bbbitch96 Apr 11 '20

I can proudly say that everything I have learn about basics of programming, I’ve learned about great teachers from Finland. And not saying that ’cause I’m from Finland, just compared my classes with my friend who moved to Germany and she said she didn’t learn much ’cause teacher never explained things twice and he (professor) sounds like Tim Buchalka. Some people may be good at something, but they can be lousy teachers.. Been there when I was studying aircraft mechanic. That’s sad when you pay something what’s total sh*t and even can’t get money back😐

1

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '20

Finland.!exist.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '20

[deleted]

1

u/LouisLeGros Mar 22 '20

I went to multiple schools that used that book. I think they all skipped over that section. It is ultimately unimportant for learning java & core programming principles.

IIRC there is a section using a custom little graphics package that is early on that provides a fun way for better learning to use oop. I think classes usually do that chapter, but I've never seen anyone bothering with swing/javafx.

10

u/Nephyst Mar 22 '20

Just to add context, I've worked as a java dev for over 10 years, and I have never heard anyone in the industry mention swing/javafx. It's not a skill employers care about because they aren't portable. If someone wants to use a javafx app they have to make sure they have java installed, download your app, and run it. Why would anyone bother with that when you could just build a website that does the same thing?

It would be more more valuable to learn html/css/javascript/typescript and react (or angular, or vue) in tandem with java. Even if you want to focus on being a back-end developer, having some experience with front-end technologies and architectures is still really helpful.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '20

[deleted]

2

u/LouisLeGros Mar 22 '20

Depends on what you want to get out of the course. If you are just focused on learning programming principles then the 2013 course will be fine. You can always learn the latest frameworks/languages features later on, a good foundation is the most important imo and the foundation would not have really changed between the 2013 & 2020 courses.

If you want to immediately work on UI projects using swing or javafx it'd probably be worth going to the course with the framework you want to use.

4

u/Coraljester Mar 22 '20

Actually going through his course now, also had to do the same as you where I would find his explanation confusing. He often talks about a complex subject saying things in the most jargony, and roundabout fashion possible. Im not even at OOP section yet, and I've had to several times go and find another video which explained the subject better than he did. I also find it very annoying where he would start explain something and then say that actually we will learn about that in a later part, well why bring it up now?! While i'm trying to understand something else your just adding more things to the pile in a haphazard fashion.

Some of the challenges he sets are confusing as well because he explains what he wants poorly. Its head banging against the wall frustrating, and based on what everyone here says I may just find a different source!

2

u/jamming123321 Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20

After he explains abstract classes, he gives a challenge. Again, lot’s of jargon-y words. I spent an hour or so, trying to understand what he meant here and there. Created an abstract class without variables or methods (that’s probably the only part I got right). So I gave up and started watching his solution. Lo and behold, he is implementing doubly LinkedList. If he just said: “Implement LinkedList” I would probably have spent that one hour more productively and actually researched how to do the implementation.

3

u/Coraljester Mar 22 '20

yeah, as I've gotten older, I've realised that having knowledge doesn't make you a good teacher, and while I don't doubt his knowledge, I do doubt his teaching skills

11

u/blabbities Mar 22 '20

When it came to OOP, I was banging my head to the wall, trying to understand what he was saying.

That's nearly everybody. It's a poorly explainable concept in general. It's always done non-practical examples and jargon-y terminology. I'm going on decades now of "learning to program" and I often time barely get the point of using OOP. Or rather some of the concepts I dont think I ever will or one can fully grasp utnil you need to make a complex program that involves other people outside yourself participating on your program(s).

That being said I pretty much finished breezing thru the the "Java for Complete Beginners" by Cave of Programming recommended in the sidebar. It was very useful to me. I dont know if all beginner's still since I had an advantage of being familiar with various bits of programmimg from multi-decade failure lol.

Also, I'm up this early because I've been reading selected Chapters of Head First Java 2nd Edition. That's been a really good help too. Surprisingly, well done from what I read. I actually appreciated a few of the extended non-essential sidebar explanations, ( although theyre definitely jargon-y too but theyre at a level that can be understood by potential CompSci students. and since it's in the non-essential portions you can probably skip over them)

7

u/like_my_likes Mar 22 '20

fuck man, And i was here thinking i am just an idiot. I abandoned his course long ago, after trying multiple times to get thru. I learned better by creating projects and thru oracle's documentation.

1

u/Acoolusername7 Mar 22 '20

What projects did you do? Did you follow tutorials

2

u/like_my_likes Mar 23 '20

When starting i sometimes see a tutorial video on how something is created with java, what is required, etc etc etc. But then i just get ideas from internet on what to make and start making by googling stuff on how to do this and that in java. That way i started doing it.Do ask if any other doubt. Would love to help :)

6

u/FT_Anx Mar 22 '20

Damn, thank you! I thought I was one of the few who was having this problem with learning this course. I spent months learning/trying to learn through that course, in the end I gave up.

I was giving top priority to app dev at that time, now I'm in game dev and I even feel motivated with coding (although in another language). I felt like I've wasted so much time trying to learn through that course. And I even recommended that course because at the beginning it seemed so nice. Big mistake.

10

u/TonyMacaroni1 Mar 22 '20

I had the same feeling when taking his course and expressed it one or two times in this sub. To me the explanation was so very confusing, hectic and sometimes irrelevant that I canceled the course and got a refund. There are better courses on Udemy about this topic or youtube.

2

u/chris1666 Mar 22 '20

Wish youd shares some of those better ones from Udemy,

I have enjoyed Study easy and Paul Dichones

2

u/ramides Mar 23 '20

I’m a fan of Imtiaz Ahmad’s courses. He was a lot of exercises/projects and is a much better presenter, imho.

1

u/chris1666 Mar 23 '20

I think I have his beginner course, but im working on Study easy right now, it goes a lot farther.

2

u/ramides Mar 23 '20

I’ll have to check it out.

Imtiaz’ courses are broken up over a couple of classes. He covers a lot though. I was lucky that I had access to Udemy for Business, so I didn’t have to pay for 4 videos (at the time).

9

u/dipanzan Mar 22 '20

I think understanding the concept of OOP requires lots and lots of practice by writing OOP code and then learn by improving it on each iteration. The code will probably be horrible from an initial perspective, but you'll slowly get better once you start churning out more and more applications written in OOP.

If you can get a Book and learn the concept of OOP from there, and try to do the MOOC.fi from the University of Helsinki (which is an excellent resource) btw, you'll get a good amount of practice.

Also designing classes, and figuring it out which shoudl be the parent class, child class or what are the interfaces and abstract classes requires experience and intuition about the underlying system you're designing. You'll likely refactor your code several times and then arrive at a OOP design and take takes time to learn.

Hope it helps!

3

u/chris1666 Mar 22 '20

What made me feel that way was going through methods in that course, he spent far more time adding little calculation than explaining the use and purpose of methods. And then what some 95 lines to code.... just for methods, hmm ok.

Chaaad explained it more and method overloading and had a pdf also explaining them.

"using advanced level language, adds to confusion. " OH yes,

2

u/thee_almighty_thor Mar 22 '20

Object oriented programming seems to be a hit or miss concept where you either understand it or you don’t. From experience it seems like a concept that is challenging to get everyone to understand.

I personally have purchased and gone through his course and found it very helpful and informative but I have prior knowledge so I can’t say how good it is for someone with absolutely zero prior knowledge

2

u/j619s Mar 22 '20

True that.

2

u/sonrivera Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20

Tim Buchalka does a decent job explaining the basics, but OP is right on point when he says Tim starts getting extremely confusing when Object Oriented Program lessons start. His exercises for those are trash and WAY TOO VAGUE. There is absolutely no direction and you pretty much have to make a whole goddamn function from scratch

I stopped a little after the Object Oriented Program lessons from the Udemy course and have used the other top recommended learning resources instead. Glad I made the switch away from Udemy :)

2

u/easypeasylemonsqueez Mar 23 '20

I actually started this course not too long ago. Granted I did have some knowledge on Java before going into this, but only the basics. Never had a full concept on regards to OOPS. Honestly for me I rather enjoy this course. For me it teaches the basics and allows me to explore other options and the capabilities of the concepts.

2

u/Digitalman87 Mar 29 '20

Thanks for posting this. I was using the course to lay a foundation of knowledge before starting a software class for school (class pretty much picks up at OOP). I was pretty good with his challenges/exercises up until OOP. I was a little fuzzy and completed some of the challenges but just watched him complete most of them. Started List, Arrays, and Boxings tonight and felt f*cking stupid. His challenges are extremely challenging starting with OOP. I think I am going to stop this Udemy course, start my course/project at school and do MOOC.fi on the side. I will come back eventually and finish it just to finish it.

TLDR; I'm glad I'm not the only one and its not just me feeling stupid. haha.

2

u/koaladlt Apr 16 '20

I came here being really disappointed thinking that programming it's not for me, after failing trying to solve Tim's exercises. Thank you for bring me back to life!

2

u/DasTapan May 09 '20

Bro you are right. I'm currently studying there. And in OOP section. I'm currently looking for a good book for java. And stumble upon this thread

2

u/funkybuddha_mtn Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20

If you combine Tim's course with Head First java , then you will yield maximum knowledge from it. His course gradually gets complex and challenging. By the time you complete the course you will have good grasp over Java. I would suggest don't rush to complete it. Learn theory side by side from How to Program by Deitel and Head First Java!! Tim's course gets challenging for beginner programmers who have zero experience of programming whatsoever. But if you are willing to put in some effort , it will familiarize you with almost all the vast and dark topics of Java Programming Language!!

Programming is not easy, and only the ones who don't give up at every road block end up being a programmer.

2

u/Ruttelisious Mar 22 '20

I bought the course and learned java from scratch from it. I honestly have no idea what you are talking about. The course worked splendid for me but i guess we all learn in different ways.

2

u/echoes675 Mar 22 '20

I started this course in 2018. Completed half of it and then stopped when my son was born. In Sept 2019 I went back to college to study software development. I restarted the course at that time and, while studying for the college course I completed about 75% of the course. I found the course informative and it gave me a good grounding for everything I was learning in college. Admittedly some of the challenges were somewhat confusing and difficult to grasp as I sometimes had difficulty understanding what was being asked. Any videos I had trouble with I would rewatch and generally got the concept being taught eventually. I've done a number of his other courses too,( c#, python, data structures, SQL) and have got value from them too. I completed the college course in sept 2019 and am now working as a junior software engineer and I don't think I would have the same understanding of software development if it wasn't for his courses.

2

u/batmanthefapman Mar 22 '20

I hated this guy, had a very similar experience

1

u/iserendipitous Mar 22 '20

I’m currently in the learning path from Udemy. I recommend this. Java in Depth by Dheeru Munudluru Also, java notes from ntu.

1

u/PizzaHuttDelivery Mar 22 '20

His course is only good to get you started: install JDK, IDE have your first program compiled and run. But apart from that it's a terrible course. I had to stop many times and seek explanations elsewhere. He fails and transition from simple to complicated things.

I've have become a Java developer, but not because of his course or Head First Java. All these resources only served as an intitial start before i could jumpstart my Java certification studies. And those certification books are much much better at teaching java.

1

u/PanBerbeleck Mar 23 '20

Thank you for that opinion. I'm dobrze no that course with some problems, too. I overcame them but I want to be more efficient in the future.

1

u/Intermittentcm Apr 11 '20

I had the exact same experience. I ended up dropping my Java class at university because I was so confused by Tim and my professor; they have a very similar approach to OOP pedagogy. I have been working my way through the ninth edition of Dietel and Dietel's Java: How to Program. This book is very comprehensive. It offers tons of practice at the end of every chapter. It's probably been suggested before on this thread, but I am new to the subreddit

1

u/Axle9887 Apr 12 '20

I definitely agree with you, he throws in very complicated examples in between, but he and many others( almost all cources that I have see) use previous code to build on, it saves them time and honestly if you undersand the previous concept properly, it saves you time too. But if you just want to understand that one concept that is the topic of video, it becomes very difficult. I had some knowlege of java but wanted to be good with it so I purchased the course. It is very good and in depth, but you cannot randomly see videos. They all build on each other, atleast in the same section. If you are someone who wants help with only a few topics, it is just much better to see youtube tutorials and explanations. But if you are new I do think it is a very comprehensive cource that covers everything that you might want to learn, and then you can build your knowlege about other libraries yourself. In my opinion it is a good course.

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '20

I thought that i am the only one who doesn't like his course.. oh boy, i am not alone here. Thank you guys for pointing out his mistakes, i definitely feel your pain.

He is literally teaching custom linked list data structure in list section. For beginners its like running in a race while they are just learning to walk. Please beginners, avoid that course. Adding unwanted complexity to increase the time of video. For beginners its a pure trash.

Too much time is wasted by solving twisted challenges. It may be good for advance learners. but it is definitely not for beginners.

1

u/boomers26 Sep 05 '20

I miss bucky. That’s how I learned java.

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '20

Please, don't recommend/use thenewboston.

They are a discouraged resource as they teach questionable practice. They don't adhere to commonly accepted standards, such as the Java Code Conventions, use horrible variable naming ("bucky" is under no circumstances a proper variable name), and in general don't teach proper practices, plus their "just do it now, I'll explain why later" approach is really bad.

Derek Banas covers about the same ground, but in much better quality.

If you're looking for an in-depth, comprehensive, high quality, free Java course, use the MOOC Object Oriented Programming with Java from the University of Helsinki and maybe Java for Complete Beginners by John Purcell as secondary resource.

I am a bot and this message was triggered by you mentioning thenewboston. Please do not respond to this comment as I will not be able to reply.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/bwLearnsProgramming Mar 23 '20

I had exactly this same confusion!! I even stuck with it all the way up to when he started getting into abstract classes. Then I just felt stupid as hell, gave up, and went to freecodecamp to learn html, css, and now I'm learning javascript. Which makes me feel a lot better.

It was really nice to read I'm not the only who felt this way about it. He seems like a decent teacher in ways, but definitely not for the beginner.

0

u/theprogrammingsteak Mar 23 '20

In my opinion, that course is awful. Even for intermediate or experienced java developers.