First of all, this will going to be pretty long, there's a TL;DR at below, so feel free to skip if You don't want to read the entire content. I'll appreciate if you read the entire content though
I'm a Divine3(5320MMR) Pos5 Player and one of My colleague who has recently started playing DOTA asked me how long did i take to get to my MMR? Because He find it pretty much impossible to get out from his "low MMR trench".
I've been giving him constructive advice for some times like how macro management is important in dota, how to draft/common strategies and lane controlling techniques. And He mainly played pos 5 because most of the heroes I've guided him were roamer/hard supports.
However, his MMR has been stuck for the past 3monthes and He asked me trying to play his account and so I did. I've only played 5 games because I didn't want to ruin too many people's gaming experience ,also , didn't want him to get "boosted" only for him to ruin the games for other players in the future.
As for the result, I've won 4 out of 5 games and I'm going to evaluate each games below.(names and match IDs are hidden for privacy purposes)
Although I am a pos5 player, I was pretty confidence with winning against Crusaders/archons/guardians, so I've 1st picked mid all 5 games.
Game1 Necro-Won
/img/va0gs6b24p811.png
I was amazed because Pudge and ES on my team was playing Pos 4 and 5 accordingly, thought low MMR games aren't bad at all.
Crushed the sniper mid, 15minutes veil radiance into a complete snow ball.
However, the draft is absolutely terrible(Sven/Morph in a same team, 2 melee supps).
Wait a moment, take a look at enemy's draft. It was an offlane invo,PL, Mid Sniper and Safelane DK Mirana. No concept of position, synergy and counterpick . No support, they did not even have a courier in the beginning of the game.
Game2 QoP- Lost
/img/kz95hnq54p811.png
So After playing a relatively decent game(at least on my team), I thought these players aren't too bad at all and tried to do something extraordinary for fun(Radiance QoP).
The Draft of Radiant side is absolute garbage(4cores+1techies) and the draft on dire side looks REALLY good, something that I see in my original MMR games(QoP mid, Bane 5 Riki4 Morph Carry Mirana Off)
The Game was a complete disaster, the moment the game started, both side lanes were constantly feeding NONSTOP, despite me shutting down the OD by having a 5 level advantage(I was level11 when OD was 6). I had to constantly gank side lanes to cover My team's ass and couldn't focus too much on my farming.
I've ended up doing more damage than the total damage of 4of my other team mates, tried EVERY SINGLE THING I could to win the game but the game couldn't be won. Why? Because no matter how many kills you get, QoP can't siege for nuts.
Take a look at Riki and Bane's item, and last hits on the each side. Dire team had no concept of position, everyone just farmed whatever they see infront of them, Bane rushing maelstorm as a 1st item with a brown boot although he was purchasing some wards, riki was farming in the jungle, morph had completely no idea to play his hero(Did not know attribute shift STR would heal him) , Mirana doing completely nothing but farming in the jungle.
After experiencing this game, I've realized that playing in this bracket is all about "team luck", unless you are EXCEPTIONALLY good enough to completely CRUSH your lane, there's no way on earth you can get a constant +55% Win rate(relatively good number to "Climb" in MMR). I am almost 3000MMR above this average and I've tried so hard, yet the game couldn't be won(although my build was kinda trollish)
Also, I've realized to constantly win in this bracket without relying on anyone(yes, no one but yourself), You HAVE to pick a snowbally hero that can SIEGE
Blood Seeker is a complete beast in this bracket, People walks while ruptured, doesn't carry TP, doesn't know how the thirst works. Hence I've decided to play blood seeker for the rest of my 3 games.
3Games of Blood Seeker all Won
/img/tkwfnj994p811.png
/img/zoeogk994p811.png
/img/gb6lyk994p811.png
All3 games won single handedly, average of 10minutes radiance into a complete snowball.
What shocked me to the ground was among these 3 games(total of 27 unique player beside me), In both side, 0 Supports were picked and all 3 games were 5 cores vs 5cores(1st game was 2mid, the huskar gave me headache). this is NOT DOTA , it's more like "pickcarryandfarmandgetitemsandkill" , 0 strategies, 0 concept, 0 game plan, 0 ,0,0,0 NOTHING was literally there.
The Only reason I was able to crush all of the games were because I was EXCEPTIONALLY BETTER, than these players, once again, i'm more than 3000 MMR higher than these players.
Imagine if you are an average/slightly better player in this game, there's no way you can constantly win under this kind of environment, even if you're the person who spam 1 HERO to get consistent performance, it will take a LONG TIME. 2carries in each lane contesting for last hits, 0 wards, 0 communication, again, this is NOT DOTA.
Conclusion
Players in this bracket have literally no idea how to play DOTA, and if YOU are in this bracket(due to calibrating when you was a complete beginner), and now wants to improve, have some knowledge , constantly watching pro replays and learning strategies/ basics. Bad news for You, It won't work. The only way you can climb out from this hell is to get an exceptionally better mechanical skill and crush the game completely alone.
However, playing in this bracket does not give you any sort of micro/macro management/mechanical skill because the quality of the game is just too trash.
Think of this as an archery, People practice to get better precision by moving the target further and further, however, in this bracket, the target is literally RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOUR NOSE and there is a WALL behind you, no room of improvement can be found here.
No strategy, no positioning, its all about hoping to god that your 5x carry line up has better laning affinity than the enemy's.
You can't rely on ANYONE , and there's no point supporting these players because no one knows how to push, 5x cores are actually BETTER than having a pos4 and 5 in this bracket.
It is the cold truth but beginners playing 1000 games in this environment doesn't bring them anywhere, in fact, it makes them hate this game and move on to another game. DOTA is a beautiful game and its such a shame, I thought i was going crazy when playing these 5 games.
So If you're the person who currently in this bracket, but REALLY want to improve, don't hesitate to create a new account, calibrate it on somewhere around high 2k~3kish(thanks to anti smurf system, anyone besides a complete beginner can calibrate around there) , buy a battle pass, join roled rank queue and actually start improving.
You will definitely lose more games than you win post calibration and probably gonna lose few hundred MMR, but trust me, playing 10 3k games makes you a better player than playing 1000 games in this trash hole.
Yes if you are exceptionally good player than you won't have hard time climbing out from that bracket, but sadly, it is quite not feasible for a player who plays in that bracket to get what it takes to get out. Unless, you are whiling to spend months and years inefficiently.
TL;DR
Trench do exist, if you're someone who is currently playing here and sick and tired of dota, abandon that account and create a new one.
Yes, if your skill is like above +1.5k~ the your MMR there and exceptionally better than the others, just pick a core that can siege and win most of the games. But it's not rationale to grind in that shit hole until you become competent in doing that.
Too bad you can't Git gud playing 1000 games here.
This is a repost of a thread I've made 3monthes back, this friend of mine had made himself a new account, calibrated at Legend 2 and Now he's Legend 4 .After being stuck in guardian/crusader playing Pos5 for half a year