r/leanfire • • Jan 20 '19

My values conflict with MMM

12 Upvotes

I understand to retire early it's very important to invest so you're money is working for you. I'm a teenager and I had $2000 in an index fund. But as an anticapitalist I wonder if investing is an ethical thing to do, seeing as I don't support the system. I tried posting this in anarchist subreddits but didn't get much response.

I was following the principles MMM set out for a while but got discouraged about my abject poverty and spent a ton of the money I had saved. Should I start over with investing? Save in a normal savings account (I bank with a credit union)? I appreciate any advice on my situation.

Edit: I appreciate all the thoughtful responses I got. I didn't come here to debate my stance on capitalism or hear that I will change my views with age. I think that going back to investing in a socially responsible fund is the best option for me.


r/leanfire • • Jan 17 '24

Why are rich people so careful with money?

0 Upvotes

I know someone who is on government benefits. He makes fun of his brother (who is a venture capitalist of a fund with $200M) because he only tips 18%.

That got me thinking though. Like why not 20? I tip 20.

Also why are old money families who are worth billions and likely hold a lot of their assets in tax shelters not try to be more generous?

I do get old money buying non fancy cars just because they're not nueavu riche.

Thanks


r/leanfire • • Jul 16 '23

Knowing my net worth is "pre-tax" makes me sad

0 Upvotes

Whenever I feel like "hey, I'm doing alright" I'm reminded that everything noncash is actually only 80-85% of the number on the screen, due to Uncle Sam.

Vent. That is all.


r/leanfire • • Sep 07 '18

Update: Pulling the trigger at 28 with $600k

7 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/leanfire/comments/8ibggu/pulling_the_trigger_at_28_with_600k/

I posted this about 4 months ago, and had quite a bit of discussion, with mixed feedback. In this time, crypto has taken a pretty impressive dive, leaving me with just over $500k. That said, it's all part of the ride, and I'm not really worried--even at $500k, I think I could tighten by belt and move forward without too many concerns, especially since I expect cryptocurrency to go back up in the long run. On the other hand, it looks like /u/z_fi wins the prize for predicting the future, as it looks like I will indeed be going back to work after this "sabbatical". I recently heard from one of my old bosses (who I really liked working for) that they were looking for someone again, and I was able to negotiate an increased compensation of $340k/year, which is a more than 50% raise over what I was getting before. It's a sweet enough deal that I probably would have jumped back in even without the drop in the cryptocurrency market.

In terms of budget during my brief 4-month retirement, I did spend a bit more than I'd been hoping--my spending came in at about $1.7k/month, which isn't bad, but isn't quite where I wanted it to be. However, that includes a lot of luxuries that I could easily cut out if I needed to, plus some one-time-ish purchases that I don't know if I should really count (e.g. a dining room table). That said this last month before I go back to work is certainly going to be overbudget since I'm traveling the whole time--I expect it to be closer to $2.5k because of the travel expenses. Overall, I think this probably informs my future budget that I want to have about $2k a month of income to not feel like I'm limiting myself, which would be about $700k or so in assets.

All in all, I'm glad that went for it, even if my 4-month "retirement" ended up being temporary. I feel way happier and more refreshed than when I was working, and the job I'm coming back to is better than the one I left (both in terms of happiness with the work and in terms of pay). My next step is going to be working this contract out through it's conclusion, and when that's done, I'll re-evaluate and decide whether to pull the trigger again or to keep working. If anyone has more positive or negative feedback, let me know--I'm happy to hear it.

(By the way, I did get that vasectomy, and let me tell you, it's way easier than I expected. If you work an office job, you could get it done on a Friday and go back to work on Monday, no problem.)


r/leanfire • • Aug 02 '24

16, hoping to retire by 30

0 Upvotes

Trying to be a bit ambitious. I have $9k saved from boosting people in video games and selling gold from some other games I play. I helped my parents set up a brokerage and I’ve been investing all of it into VTI for the past year (I pay them for any tax incurred from the dividends, which isnt much). I started learning to code 2 years ago but obviously no work experience. Planning to major in CS and going to community college after I graduate (free with financial aid). I have a GitHub and I’ve deleted all the tutorial projects I had on it, leaving only my own independent projects. I should have ~2 semesters completed with AP classes by graduation and will try to get a full time job by the time I finish my associates, if I don’t have one, the backup will be state school for a bachelors. Alternatively, if I get a full ride scholarship to a state school, I’ll take that over community college, but I doubt it. My parents are okay with me living at home during college so I won’t have any dorm costs.

The goal is 0 cost for college, I don’t want to pay anything for school and paying for it will be the worst case scenario.

I will look into proper part time work when I’m 18 as long as I have enough time to not hurt my grades since internships are much more valuable and they will be my goal over part time work. Boosting does not pay enough for the hours spent to be worth continuing with.

I’m hoping to enjoy my younger years as soon as possible, so that’s why I am hoping to retire so early.

I’m hoping to get some more guidance on ways to optimize more and add more guarantees to the plan. I don’t have anyone that works in the industry to get me a leg up, and I know internships for freshman college students are nearly impossible to get, so any advice is appreciated.


r/leanfire • • Jul 17 '24

How ethical is FIRE when we use the market to generate our wealth?

1 Upvotes

I remember a thread posted recently with asking about some of their ethical concerns about FIRE and balancing not working with the social contract and it got me thinking more generally about FIRE. I'm relinking it here because it got a lot of great discussion: https://www.reddit.com/r/leanfire/comments/1dtornt/philosophical_question_about_lean_fire/

I want to ask more generally how people feel about various methods of building wealth and how ethical people believe those particular methods are.

Most people here are set-it-and-forget-it ETF investors. That means we implicitly support companies that make some of their profit from exploiting prison labor, foreign sweatshops, and destroying local competition with economies of scale to gain market share. We abdicate responsibility for what the market causes and give our money to every company in the name of diversification.

Real estate has also been colossally fucked for a while now. Our desire to protect home values on the homes we live in and the expectation that it should appreciate has had especially drastic consequences in places like California, but expecting housing to be an investment (and people forming NIMBY groups to protect their housing value) is the core of what has made housing unaffordable in the US. This isn't even getting into people who buy property to rent it out in the future, just people buying homes and condos with an expectation that it will appreciate over time and that they can eventually sell if they want to. I guess this is different from people who buy houses to do live-in renovations and resell at a profit, as they're doing work to earn money in a different way.

Does that mean the only way to earn money ethically is by running an ethical business, working in trades, or by working for an ethical company? Do people believe there are ethical issues with investing or renting to earn profit?

Kind of a brain dump here, but curious what people think.


r/leanfire • • Sep 10 '25

$50K is more than most people actually "spend" in a year.

0 Upvotes

Based on my own observations/experience, people have no idea how much they generally spend. They tend to misclassify debt repayment as spending, not grasp the difference in taxes on different levels of income, and overestimate the cost of healthcare at low income levels.

$4,000/month is more than I currently spend, even though I actually use over $8,000/month.

House Payment: $2,000

  • $650 of this pays down the principal on the loan (this is not spending).

  • $650 of this goes to escrow (this will be the actual monthly housing cost once the loan is paid off).

Daycare: $1,350

  • Obviously this expense only exists because both of us work full-time.

Charitable giving: $1,350

  • We try to give away close to 10% of our after-tax income (this amount would likely drop in retirement).

Car Payment: $700

  • 9 months remaining on a loan at 0%

Actual bills: $2,750 (food, clothes, dining out, travel, fun, personal items, utilities, etc.). At least $1,000 of this is discretionary spending that could be cut out in a pinch.

Total: $8,150

Total actual spending on needs: $3,400 ($4K including mortgage interest).

Yahoo finance put out a Budget for $100K salary. The actual spending portion of the budget is just over $4,800. The transportation and housing buckets likely include an allowance for some loan repayment.


r/leanfire • • Jan 10 '21

26M Software Engineer wanting to leanfire. How do I learn about compound interest, investment and leanFIRE online/youtube for free?

9 Upvotes

My time is so occupied with a very busy coding lifestyle currently building web applications and mobile applications that I need some help finding good youtube channels that can teach my leanFIRE, how compound interest works and investing my good earnings so I can retire around 45 years old.


r/leanfire • • Nov 06 '24

Help me stop panicking about the tariffs.

37 Upvotes

I know the plan, I know the mantra, I know you just let your VTSAX chill and don’t panic, I know that you have to trust that the US economy is going to keep doing what it has done for the past 100 years and continue to climb in the long run, but I am panicking hard about the tariff plan. If this proposed plan happens, cost is going to get passed on to consumers, and inflation is going to get worse. Trust in the USA will fall on the global scale and our economy will fail. I know I am spiraling, I know I need to do nothing.

I feel like I have been doing everything right. I save a high percentage of my income, I invest in total market index funds, I invest regularly over long time periods. I am not planning on touching the money until I retire. I feel like I’m about to lose it all because I am heavily invested in the US stock market.

Please someone tell me I am wrong about all of this, but I just feel like we just elected someone who is going to drive our economy off of a cliff that it won’t rebound from. Please keep me from doing something stupid with my money.


r/leanfire • • Jul 31 '21

Why are all these new posts from people making 100k per year?

339 Upvotes

Seriously, I thought leanfire was for those of us making something like a median income at most? If I made 100k a year I'd be done working in ten years max. Yes I'm gatekeeping. But why do I have to be reminded that I'm poor because I chose to be a teacher nurse laborer every time I log onto reddit? Can the rich people please go back to fire or fatfire where they belong? Thanks


r/leanfire • • Nov 13 '23

Is it possible to leanFIRE by 30?

0 Upvotes

Hey all, hope your day is going well!

I (21M) recently graduated college and got a job working in big tech in the Bay Area, making ~220k annually.

My current NW is 140k:

  • HYSA (emergency fund + to be invested): 50k

  • Investments + 401k (SPY/QQQ): 80k

  • Cash: 10k

My monthly spending is ~3500/mo:

  • Rent: 2300/mo

  • Other: 900-1100/mo

  • Send to Family: 100-200/mo

I realize the biggest expenditure is my rent, but I live in HCOL, I wouldn’t mind living with 6 roommates if I could bring this down.

Most of my net worth came from money I saved during internships, plus my signing bonus from my job. I graduated college debt-free because I went to a state school which covered tuition, and graduated early to save money.

I realized I am in an EXTREMELY blessed position, and am grateful for luckily being able to choose the path I did.

So with that said is it possible for me to leanFIRE by 30? Maybe I have a spoiled attitude and mindset but I realized I just don’t enjoy the working corporate lifestyle and I honestly don’t need much money to support my lifestyle anyways. I love learning (languages, instruments, history, competitive games, etc) as my main hobby which doesn’t require much money long term and would love to do for 50+ years.

I also realize I may need some other form of basic income to supplement me for the rest of my life if I retire as early as 30 yo. Don’t have many ideas about that. Also I obviously haven’t considered the fact that I may eventually have a family and expenses might increase with that, but hopefully I’ll have enough saved up to retire independently and with a spouse’s salary, I would love to be a househusband.

Also if I sell my soul and grind for the next 3-4 years I can surely increase my income 400k-500k a year. I would rather sacrifice my time now if it means I can achieve leanFIRE relatively soon.

Am I being delusional?


r/leanfire • • Jun 01 '21

Do you really need an Emergency fund?

3 Upvotes

So finance 101 always tells people "have X$ as emergency funds".

Why? Banks have credit margins. Credit cards lend money. You could have family to give you money as well. As you get older if you're financially savvy, you will have investments you can liquidate with the click of a button.

That 5k emergency fund you've kept in cash from 25 to 65? Well if invested, that would be an inflation-adjusted 80 000$.
If kept in cash that would be an inflation-adjusted 2000$.

Is your emergency fund worth basically giving 80k to the bank over your lifetime?


r/leanfire • • Apr 10 '22

Just brute-force it: easily achievable fire for the common man.

0 Upvotes

I often hear that fire is impossible on a normal salary. Partly this comes from normal people who are looking for an excuse not to change, and the well-off who want to think they're special and don't need to cut any frivolous expenses.

I'm in my 30s, have 300k euros in stocks(nothing else), less than 1k/month in expenses, all from a series of average/low jobs (average net pay : 24k/y) I held in the last 10 years, with some air in between. I have no college degree, no career, and I wouldn't know python from a lizard. I also have huge gaps in my CV due to quitting college twice and bumming around a few years.

I did get lucky with some of my stock picks, the big one being an oil company I bought during the corona oil crash that 12X-ed. But then, luck shines on the bold, no one says you have to be conservative in the accumulation phase. I specifically bought that stock because I thought it could either go to zero or 10X, and both outcomes seemed about equally likely. Of course, chasing risk for risk, wallstreetbets style OTM FD's(week-dated options that mostly expire worthless) is not the way, but I'd say some out-there stock picks or even ITM leaps calls (years-dated leveraged long bets) can be part of smart financial planning. But anyway, it's not strictly necessary.

Obviously that doesn't mean you shouldn't try to increase your salary, but if you're anything like me, making any sort of concerted effort in that direction is like pulling teeth out, extremely slowly. But fire can still be easy without doing that. I really don't know why most people gift their lifetime for gadgets like a more shiny car. So just do it, man. Cut those useless expenses and I'll see you on the other side.


r/leanfire • • Aug 24 '22

How I achieved Lean FIRE with 2 rental properties

36 Upvotes

How I achieved FIRE with only 2 rental properties

I decided to make this post to motivate others to do the same. And because real estate (for whatever reason) seems to have a terrible reputation on Reddit.

Disclaimer: I'm a single guy (German) and I love to live in tropical counties. If you want to retire in the West or want to have a family you have to adjust the numbers. I'm self-employed and I love my job. I'll still have an income but I'm technically FIRE because I could live from my rental income alone. I also recommend at least an additional 20-50k in savings before you completely let go of your other income (in case something comes up).

Here's what I did:

  1. I saved 300.000 Euros

  2. I bought two rental properties in a medium sized city in the UK.

  3. Each property brings in about 800 Euros rental income which makes 1600 Euros per month in total.

  4. The threshold to pay taxes on rental income is about 12.500 pounds per year which means I almost pay no taxes (My business and residence is in another country)

  5. I hired the property management company with the best reputation and reviews and they are doing a phenomenal job.

  6. I'm financially free because even after taxes and expenses I still have more than 1000 Euros a month in profit which is more than enough for me to live in most parts of the world.

Property in the UK and most parts of Europe double in value every 10 years. You are basically putting your money in an apartment instead of a bank account AND you get kinda like a monthly salary. And in the West almost all big cities have more people who want to rent than available apartments.

I don't know why not more people in this community aim for this because it's so simple.

It worked for me.


r/leanfire • • Dec 10 '18

$28 USD Per Month Condo in the Philippines - Near the Beach!

0 Upvotes

Living the dream. This guy is married in the Philippines and only pays $28 a month for the condo. $300K is more than enough for FIRE! Come on real leanfires make it happen.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HeZGFygmQ6g


r/leanfire • • May 20 '24

Why lean fire?

0 Upvotes

I have a hard time understanding why people want to lean fire. I get that work sucks but you only get to be young once. People are giving up an awful lot to save such large portions of money. For example many are giving up dates, outing with friends, entertainment, eating out, having kids and travel.

Then when you do retire, the amount available to spend is so low that there would be very little to do. Do people just want to sit around all the time?

I think a lot of people could retire by age 50 and certainly 55 with reasonably aggressive savings vs. maybe 35-40 with lean fire.

Help me understand why this is worth it.


r/leanfire • • Nov 24 '22

how can an undocumented emigrant invest in ETFs?

0 Upvotes

not for me but many people in my community like this...how would this work, they dont file taxes typically (or not undre their name) so they would have to invest in ETFs in their native country?

Thiking of a startup idea, if it matters, but yes to help folks directly too


r/leanfire • • May 18 '21

Can we all relax about inflation concerns?

0 Upvotes

Inflation is a self fulfilling prophecy and if we keep talking about it and keep posting about it in these FI subreddits, then it will happen.


r/leanfire • • Jun 21 '22

The Mike Rowe "learn a trade" mindset is BS. Reddit recommends trades too much.

0 Upvotes

This has practically become a meme on reddit. Everyone and their mom saying all these tradesmen earn over 100k a year. It's BS. Those who do earn that are either in big city unions or are entrepreneurs. Mike Rowe has been deceiving people for years about working in the trades because he's not even a tradesmen. If you want to learn a trade because Mike Rowe said you should, at least look up the actual pay of the trade. Also be weary of the wear and tear on your body.

It doesn't seem like skilled trades are that good for FIRE.

What do you guys think?


r/leanfire • • Jul 29 '26

38M, just crossed $1M net worth with $32k in annual dividends — am I at Coast FIRE?

0 Upvotes

​

Looking for some outside opinions on my financial situation.

I’m 38, work as an accountant, make around $150k a year, and just crossed a $1 million net worth.

Current breakdown:

• Net worth: \~$1.0M

• Brokerage: \~$673k

• Retirement accounts: \~$326k

• Cash: \~$7k

• No debt

• Still renting

• Dividend income: approximately $32,000 per year

Roughly $643k of my brokerage account is invested in Prudential Financial stock, accumulated through employee stock purchases, additional contributions, and dividend reinvestment. I fully understand that this is a major concentration risk.

My goal is to reach Coast FIRE—getting to the point where my existing investments can compound toward retirement without requiring me to keep saving aggressively. I’m not necessarily trying to stop working immediately, but I want the freedom to reduce contributions, take a lower-stress job, or make career decisions without being dependent on maximizing income.

The portfolio currently generates about $32k annually in dividends, which I reinvest.

If you were in my position:

Am I already at Coast FIRE, assuming a traditional retirement age?

Would you gradually diversify away from PRU despite the capital-gains taxes?

Would you stop reinvesting PRU dividends back into PRU and direct them into index funds instead?

Would you prioritize buying a home or continue renting?

What would you change over the next 5–10 years?

Looking for honest opinions.


r/leanfire • • Sep 22 '26

Is 100k the magic number for me in Europe ?

5 Upvotes

My goal is to eventually work 3 or 4 days a week and cover all my monthly expenses with that income. Ideally, 3 days of minimum-wage work would be enough. That would give me a lot more freedom to simply choose a job I enjoy, without salary being as important.

My total expenses are currently around €1,850 per month, excluding holidays or major unexpected expenses, and I have almost €70k invested. Still, I find myself getting a bit obsessed with reaching €100k as quickly as possible. It will probably take at least another 2 years with my current contributions, assuming the market doesn't completely crash.

With a 3% withdrawal rate, €100k would provide around €3,000 per year, which is already quite significant for my lifestyle. Is this plan realistic? At the same time, I wonder if €100k really is some kind of magic number. For many people it might not be that much, but given my situation it would be quite a significant amount, especially if I'm also working part-time.

My current job is becoming less and less motivating. On the other hand, I'm thinking maybe I should just stick with it for a few more years, hit €100k, and then see where I stand. If I switch jobs now, you never really know what you're going to end up with.

Ideally, I'd find a job that I actually enjoy and that still pays reasonably well, so that after reaching €100k I can just keep steadily investing. Rather than permanently going into some kind of Coast FIRE situation and also starting to spend down the portfolio. But at the same time, I do have a bit of a "die with zero" mindset since I don't have kids.

I also think working a few days a week would be nice for the structure it provides, while still having more free days to actually enjoy life. Full FIRE would take a very long time with my current salary and contributions anyway.

Does anyone else recognize this? And what do you think about this plan?


r/leanfire • • Jan 23 '24

What is the quickest way to be able to stop working 9-5s? How much do I need saved?

7 Upvotes

I have ALWAYS hated working / having to work in general.

I thought maybe I was just being lazy, but after reading some Reddit posts I see I’m not alone. I have LITERALLY held over 30 jobs and I’m only 28 years old. I’m not proud to admit it but it’s true.

I have numerous degrees (masters degree in economics, grad cert in Project Management, pmp certification, bachelors in psychology) so I’m not “lazy” but I HATE working & feeling like my entire life is working & sleeping then repeating that process.

The only way out IMO is to save a lump sum of money & become a successful day trader and/or start an easy to sustain business (car wash, laundry mat, small apt owner, something I can make six figures off of annually & maintain off that)

Idrc about being a billionaire or anything I just want enough to support a family & do what I want when I want & I know it’s possible.

My family always said things like “go to college, get a degree, & get a good job”. One day I told some family members I no longer wanted to work & all the adults looked at me confused / ashamed & one said “you just don’t know what you want to do yet”. Yes I do, I want to be free from this mental prison of work sleep work sleep work.

Thank you everyone for letting me see that I wasn’t crazy for thinking this all these years! We weren’t made to work our entire lives for scraps!

tldr: I HATE WORKING! What is the minimum amount of money needed to start a business and/or start day trading? How long did it take to save up that amount?


r/leanfire • • Dec 14 '23

Do you support basic income?

8 Upvotes

I can speak from personal experience that I'm a "doomer" when it comes to basic income.

I got laid off from my job a decade ago and just used the time to get drunk every night and go clubbing. I started out reading books but by the end I wasn't doing anything.

To be honest, I think most people would end up getting drunk every night and watching TV (or worse). Society couldn't handle it.

In the show Star Trek, there's Star Trek socialism that MMM idolizes. But they're all in the military basically.

That's the average person. I'm sure many on this subreddit are different.


r/leanfire • • Feb 04 '24

What does $130k plus paid off car and apartment mean?

2 Upvotes

The title showcases my assets. I'm 29 years old and from India. If I lived frugally starting today could I retire today?

On the flip side I'd like to travel but that takes money. Is there another country friendly to retirees that is also beautiful? Maybe in Latin America? I don't know how to manage goals. Please help.

Edit: my expenses are USD 8K per year and currently I save 60% of my income every month.