Maybe people will agree or maybe not. I don't know but I just need to get this thought out there.
Kyle and Masai are employed by MLSE so this would be easy to do and has so many benefits to offer. The Raptors and Leafs already adapt a lot of the drafting, development, and training systems from each other that they should be discussing philosophies as well.
I have been a die hard Leafs fan since the mid-90's and they will always be my #1 team. But I also got really into the Raptors since the early 2000's due to family and friends so I got to experience a lot of those ups and downs as well.
The Raptors went through a lot of adversity as well and STILL managed to win a championship. Really getting into Masai Ujiri's mindset for how he pushed through that wall would be so invaluable.
The Referees
I definitely agree that some of the calls against the Leafs this year were terrible but they don't even compare to the amount of bad calls against the Raptors for their entire existence. Like, I was genuinely confused for YEARS about how referees could be so blatantly biased, costing the Raptors key games and playoff series. It was insane.
It's widely known that the NBA tells their referees how to officiate games and certain outcomes they would prefer. Ex-NBA referees have come out and admitted that they would receive instructions from the league on how to approach certain games. And with the Raptors being the only Canadian team, they usually got the short end of the stick.
As much as this sucked, it worked for the league. The NBA is considered the fastest growing league in the world and is a worldwide brand. Not something the NHL can even come close to right now.
The NBA has been influencing the referee calls for years. So many teams have already called out the referees and officiating but nothing really changed and likely won't. There really wasn't anything to be done. Teams just needed to adapt which is exactly what Masai did with the Raptors.
League Growth
The NBA was able to grow by putting their most marketable talents on full display which worked well from the fast pace of the game. It was more appealing to casual viewers.
This was where the NHL struggled. The game itself was too slow and not as exciting for casual fans. It's really only been in the last decade that the game has gotten faster and more exciting to watch but the NHL still has a long way to go before they are anywhere near the NBA. The NBA was projected to net more than $10 billion at the start of the year vs. the NHL at $5 billion.
The NHL was on such a good growth trajectory before Covid which really had an impact on their TV deal. The league only got half of what was projected before the pandemic which meant a much lower year-over-year salary cap growth.
So if I'm the NHL right now, I couldn't care less about what individual teams want. I'm more focused on attracting new fans to grow the league ASAP. "The Battle of Florida" sounds way more appealing than "Toronto vs. Florida" so I'm going to try and influence that outcome a bit more.
There is a much higher chance of attracting new fans from the Florida rivalry than if the Leafs were involved. Also taking into account that many Americans are looking for excuses to go out and party so there is a much higher chance of people down south spending a ton of money over the next few weeks.
The league needs some new storylines to bring in more money and fans since the original plan of propping up the expansion teams failed drastically this year. As much as this sucked for the Leafs this year, I get it.
Team Dynamics
The way the Raptors were built was fundamentally different from the Leafs out of necessity. They never drafted any high-end talent players and were the first NBA Championship team to win without a lottery pick (top-5 draft pick player).
They never had the luxury of getting a generational talent like Auston Mathews, let alone Mitch Marner and William Nylander. Demar Derozan was as close as they got and I would compare him more with Nylander than anyone else.
Instead, the Raptors focused on drafting/signing players who had raw talent, hustle, and a good work ethic to see if they could develop them into star players. Unfortunately, that didn't work out but they were able to build a very competitive all around roster with great depth players at each position. So when the opportunity came to acquire Kwahi Leonard and then Marc Gasol, two bonafide superstars, they had enough complementary players to get it done.
The Leafs on the other hand DID have a bunch of players who could turn into bonafide superstars and then brought in one more in Tavares. High end talent was never the issue but it came at the cost of continually having to replace and update the bottom six. The Leafs tried out so many different combinations and some of them worked for a while, but in the end it wasn't enough. When it comes to Playoff hockey, a good bottom-six vs. a bad one makes all the difference.
While I really do like some of our bottom-six guys in Engvall, Mikheyev, Spezza, and Blackwell, they just don't add a different element to the game that can energize the team. I'd also add Kerfoot and Kase too this list. When playing a cup-contending team like Tampa, they all struggled to make an impact.
Big Decisions
I would say right now the Leafs are at the same crossroads the Raptors were at in the summer of 2018: running the same team back or make a big move.
At that point, the Raptors had Derozan and Lowry signed for another 2 years which is where the Leafs are right now with Auston Matthews and William Nylander. It's big decision time but the Leafs are in a different scenario than the Raptors.
Masai risked everything by trading Demar for Kwahi and it paid off massively. There is no way the Leafs would be able to do the same thing by trading any of the big 4 but they could use it to get the right kind of depth needed for a deep playoff run.
In my mind, if the Leafs want to put the team in a position to go all the way next year, they need to accomplish three things:
Give Tavares the linemates he needs to succeed.
Improve scoring and competitiveness in the bottom-six.
Give the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th lines their own personality and style.
Dubas needs to talk to Masai so he can learn exactly what he was looking for at each of his positions and the rotation to make those key moves. Masai followed the same plan for 5 straight years but knew when it was time to make a big change. He is the right person to advise Kyle on what to do.
Types of Changes I Can See Happening
Trading William Nylander
Unfortunately, he is the odd man out in my mind and the easiest to move. He has the most reasonable cap hit at $6.9M, is only owed $8.5M ($4.25M per year) in real dollars after his bonus is paid out in July, and is coming off of an all-around career year. He has the most attractive contract and his trade value has never been higher.
Nylander is an incredible player but is too much of a perimeter player and needs to have the puck on his stick to be successful. His play style just doesn't mesh well with Tavares and when he's with Matthews, it's a noticeable downgrade on both lines.
If players like Toffoli, Hagel, and an expiring contract Claude Giroux were all able to command multiple players and multiple draft picks (including 1st rounders), I can't see a scenario where the Leafs don't get some great high quality players for Nylander.
Trading Kerfoot and Holl
Kerfoot is a good player and has value but isn't worth keeping around for his salary at this point. Yes, he put up a career year in points but I'll argue that was mostly attributed to him playing a lot of games with Nylander and Tavares since we didn't have anyone better to fill in up there.
Holl...I just can't stand him anymore. I don't care if his analytics were more favourable than other pairings, the amount of times he gave away the puck in our own end or messed up an outlet pass that killed our momentum was far too much to stomach. That $2M can be put to better use such as using that money for Sandin/Lily's bridge deals and resigning Lyubushkin.
Acquiring 3 Young and Offensively Talented Two-Way Players
Two of these could be acquired in a trade for Nylander and the other one in a deal that involves Kerfoot/Holl. We need guys who can grind it out, cycle the puck, and play well defensively while also having the offensive talent to score and play with someone like Tavares or move up the lineup in case of injury. These players don't come cheap but would change the entire dynamic of this team.
If we were to move Nylander, we might be able to target players like Jeannot/Tolvanen from Nashvile, Greenway/Boldy from Minnesota, Strome/Dach from Chicago. These are just examples of players and would definitely need to be finessed more to ensure fair value.
Kerfoot and Holl in a deal together could get another good quality young player. We also still have Kase's rights which could serve as a small kicker to some teams. I don't feel like he is a good long-term fit for this squad anyways.
Another thing to consider for how the Leafs can afford any of these new players in the future. After next season, both Muzzin and Brodie's contracts go from a full no-trade clause to a 10-team no trade list, meaning the Leafs have an out for up to $10.6M after next season.
Promote Some of the Younger Players and Let Them Learn
The Leafs still have a pretty solid prospect pool and more than a few of them could be ready next season. The Leafs burned through a lot of their prospects over the last 6 years. First, by promoting so many of them including Matthews, Marner, and Nylander during the 2016-2017 season and afterwards, and secondly, by trading more than a few over the years to plug other holes on the team.
Since 2018-2019, the only full-time player to graduate from the Marlies who is still on the team is Pierre Engvall. A lot of players have come and gone and more than a few prospects didn't pan out. But now, it looks like we could have a number of young (and cheap) players who could take on full time roles.
Firstly, the Leafs need to commit to Sandin and Liljegren full-time. They are both ready for the NHL and the only way they will get better now is if they are given the chance to learn, grow and make mistakes regularly. Yes, this could be painful for the first half of next season but could pay off MASSIVELY when playoffs come. They are both also more gifted offensively than any other defensemen in the system aside from Rielly and would take a lot of pressure off of him.
When it comes to forward prospects, the Leafs have Nick Robertson, Joey Anderson, and Alex Steeves who could be pushing for spots out of training camp along with players like SDA and Josh Ho-Sang who might have a case to make.
The Leafs also have a fair few other prospects who could start making a case in 1-2 years such as Nick Abruzzese, Mikhail Abramov, Matthew Knies, Roni Hirvonen, Topi Niemela, Ty Voit, Pontus Holmberg, Mac Hollowell, and Filip Kral right behind them. Rodion Amirov as well hopefully when he's back in shape after winning his current battle.
It looks like the Leafs might be on the verge of having a regular stream of prospects ready to go like we did 6 years ago.
This doesn't mean Toronto shouldn't try to re-sign guys like Spezza, Giordano, Mikheyev, Blackwell, and Engvall as well as keeping an eye out for other quality free agents if the price is right. It just means that they should commit to some of our younger players who might be ready and put them in a situation to make an impact.
Conclusion
...I don't know, let's see what happens. I just needed to brain vomit and get a lot of my thoughts out there.
All I know is that relying on Matthews, Marner, Nylander, and Tavares alone to provide most of the offense is not enough for a deep playoff run. Other teams basically only need to worry about two lines which makes the Leafs too easy to game plan for in a 7-game series.
Outside of the first line and Tavares, Toronto needs to completely revamp how the rest of the lines look so they can really become a team to be feared.