r/landmark • • Jun 14 '16

This is not the game I purchased. Interest in a Class Action Lawsuit?

0 Upvotes

TL;DR: I pre-purchased the EQN Landmark "Explorer Pack" in 2014 however the just released game is not what I paid for. Promising a game that would allow one to "help us build EQ Next" and then not delivering on that fits the definition of deceptive advertising. Also, their customer service is abysmally poor and I will keep as many people away from Daybreak games as I can.

Long Version: Two years ago I was one of the people excited enough about the prospects of EQN Landmark and how it would interact with EQ Next to pre-purchase an "Explorer Pack" for $60. Like many people I've been hungry for a well made MMORPG for many years and Everquest Next seemed like it would be worth playing. Everquest Next Landmark was advertised very explicitly as a tool to help influence the formation of EQN and, at the time, that seemed like a good reason to purchase it. At this point it was still owned by Sony (SEO) and was seeing a decent amount of development, and even after it was sold to Daybreak I was hopeful that EQN and EQN Landmark would fulfill their promises.

In March of this year Daybreak announced that Everquest Next was canceled, but they would go ahead with releasing EQN Landmark. The issue here being that the advertising behind EQN Landmark very explicitly tied these two games together, and made EQN the purpose for purchasing EQN Landmark. The advertising clearly stated that the player's best creations would be used in EQN and that "you can help us build (EQN)" (See image for examples, I also have videos). This wasn't a small promise tucked away in a list of reasons to purchase EQN Landmark, it was the foremost reason, prominently displayed multiple times across the front of their website. Additionally there were other advertising promises that have been made forfeit by the cancellation of EQN such as the promise that "aspects such as PvP, AI Tools, Story, and Dialogue" would be continually shared between the games to enhance them both.

As EQN Landmark would no longer be the game I had purchased, and I had yet to receive the final purchase (my conversation with Daybreak started back in March) I contacted Daybreak customer service through their website's ticket system in search of a refund. A couple days after submitting my first ticket I checked on it and found it had been deleted from the system, so I submitted another. This to was deleted. My third ticket was finally replied to, but with a short non-helpful reply and when I replied there was no follow-up. After three weeks I posted on Daybreak Games Support twitter and finally received a full, but very canned "No refunds" response. Replies from me could elicit no further replies on their part even though I had included several valid concerns and questions. It wasn't until I emailed several members of their company directly that I received another "no refunds ever" reply, with some insulting inferences in it, and an offer to give me "Daybreak cash" as compensation. I explained I wasn't interested in this, as I'm more interested in justice than the worth of the money. I also couldn't see myself ever playing another Daybreak game. I've received no further communication from them despite my best efforts to be amicable about the situation.

Daybreak Games is clearly at fault here of "deceptive advertising" under the definition set forth by the FTC: An ad is deceptive if it's claim "Is likely to mislead a "reasonable consumer" – that is, a typical person looking at the ad; and Is "material" – that is, important to a consumer's decision to buy or use the product. Examples of "material" claims include representations about a product's price, safety, performance, features, or effectiveness.". The advertisements set for for EQN Landmark fit both these criteria as they led me, a reasonable customer, to purchase a product based on information that was critical to that purchase. Again, the game that was recently released is not the game I paid for.

Daybreak is fully aware that Landmark isn't a game worth any additional time on their part, or that should be purchased by anyone. The price was drastically lowered to what is now just $10.00, and it lives up to very few of the promises made in advertising. It's currently full of bugs and half-finished concepts and, despite the absurdly low populations on the servers, is running quite poorly. the game was rushed out shortly after the news of the cancellation of EQN simply so they would have more legal standing to deny refunds against people claiming the game was never released. Again though, this is not the game I purchased. That game, the game that would help build Everquest Next, was never released.

My question is this. Are there enough people that purchased the Founders packs to warrant a class action lawsuit? Is there enough legal standing based on their false advertising?

Thank you for your time.

Imgur

Also, I'm aware there was a refund period in 2014, however this was well before the cancellation of EQN, and thus not relevant to the conversation. Also, I was never made aware of this refund at the time.


r/landmark • • Jun 01 '15

Landmark is the red-headed step-child.

0 Upvotes

Zero people at Daybreak care about Landmark. If Landmark get's improvements they are hand-me-downs from the EQ Next team, and then quickly taken out.

Daybreak has no confidence in this game, no vision for this game, no plan for this game. It seems as though Landmark is the child of a marriage that was dissolved when they fired Dave.

Maybe it's worse, maybe we're the foster child they adopted so they could keep getting the foster care subsidy. So as long as people keep buying early access, and inventory/claim slots, then the servers will stay up.

Even though on Steam you can still purchase early access, and the developer's are quoted as saying there are weekly updates, there is not a single Daybreak developer working on new updates for Landmark.

Buyer beware, this game is going nowhere, no-one at Daybreak gives a rat's ass about it.


r/landmark • • Dec 06 '14

Will EQ Next even work?

3 Upvotes

I was so excited about EQ Next and Landmarks once. But now... I am full of doubt. The entire Landmark hype seems gone. Where I once knew so many who worked and played in Landmark, eager for the new stuff to come, it seems the development speed of Landmark has slowed down to a crawl, and that doesn't bode well for the development of EQ Next either.

When I started Landmark about a YEAR ago, I didn't think one year later we still don't have mobs, let alone anything even remotely like a real game.

The FPS is still not really well, given that Voxels are only handled by the CPU, I have this nagging feeling EQ Next may have the same issues as once EQ2: ambitious but only running on NASA computers. The game already runs slow, and a lot of stuff isn't even IN the game! Even with some reasonable improvment, I start to wonder, will it ever run really smooth? I think Devs often think too much of what private people can afford in computers.

And of EQ Next we have heard almost nothing, from the few race debates aside. And it all makes me very uneasy. I wonder if SOE did not just chew off more than they can bite? Trust me, I really want this to work, to see something really new. But did we really need a Voxel engine with a world where ALL can be damaged for a MMO? All of these grandeur ideas like cool housing or migrating mobs could be done without a demanding and complicated Voxel graphics.

The entire slowness now of Landmarks really makes me uneasy and wonder if the entire project isn't actually dead.


r/landmark • • Jun 25 '16

Anyone taking bets?

1 Upvotes

On the shut down date?

I'd say the odds of it not surviving into 2017 are 2 to 1

Waiting for the announcement of the shut down date is more entertaining than playing the game itself.

It's amazing how hard they failed with such a great concept. Even the closed alpha gameplay was better than what it is now.


r/landmark • • Mar 16 '15

This is a reminder of what early access game development should look like.

0 Upvotes

http://www.spaceengineersgame.com/news.html

Each week for the last year since release on steam early access we have had an update with an accompanying video outlining it and its uses.

KSH is now producing 2 games and updating them both weekly.

This is what every developer should be shooting for with early access games and day break is currently falling very short in this department.


r/landmark • • Feb 12 '15

EQN/Landmark layoffs -> i want a refund

0 Upvotes

now that they have fired the people that where making the game that was promised. i find it hard to believe that some new guy or the skeleton crew that is left will be able to deliver.

I should have known better than to buy another SOE product. I hated what they did at the end of SWG and this just is another big F U to their customers.

i have to stop buying into promises from developers.


r/landmark • • Jun 07 '16

Thank you Daybreak and Community Members. This Launch Video is a Two Year Retrospective!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/landmark • • Jun 08 '14

CASTLES & CRAPSHACKS

0 Upvotes

Hi Folks!

Castles & Crapshacks is a show which I do every Sunday from 2 to 6 PM Pacific, touring various destinations across Landmark while calling out any crapshacks I come across and providing feedback for improvement. I also do 2 monthly item giveaways every week, so tune in for a chance to win awesome stuff!

Be sure to tune in at 2 PM Pacific on my Twitch Channel: http://www.twitch.tv/legendaryneurotoxin This week I'll be touring Dark Elf structure designs!

Previous episodes can be found on my Youtube Channel https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ht0Fs9y7cxQ&list=PLQEU1gWGE7DnKv5jx3Yb7yAqYzn5IP8GX

Images from previous episodes can be found on Twitter by searching #CastlesCrapshacks

UPDATE Tell us why you enjoy Castles & Crapshacks, top reply wins a Lunar Anklet or this month's item (your choice!) Decisions will be made at the 2-hour break!


r/landmark • • Apr 28 '15

My interest in Landmark is waning

1 Upvotes

this 3x3x3 restriction of claims in landmark is pretty much a dealbreaker for me, if they are unable to extend the footprint past a 3x3 in Landmark do to performance issues then how are they going to ever allow us to attach claims to each other? attaching two claims together from two different people is 100X the performance hit than say attaching claims in a 4x4 or a 5x5 would be, so if there isnt much hope in that, then the possibility of ever building a large city or large build in Landmark is pretty much gone. and that is what I have been waiting for for the past year, I had 8000 SC saved up to buy claim flags with, now that they announced that we will be unable to extend past a 3x3 footprint I see no reason to buy claim flags anymore, its such a pity.


r/landmark • • Oct 07 '14

When I play this game, I want Minecraft Not Maya. Setup a mode so the game plays similar to minecraft to ease in new players. Then allow me to try the powerful engine.

0 Upvotes

No really that is my biggest hangup... Trying to build in this game is as frustrating and feels like working in a 3D modeler... Which is not fun for me.

Create some method to allow the game to play like minecraft in a few ways from block placement, to gathering, to snapping a bit differently.

That is all. Thank you.

EDIT: Please note when I say "I Want Minecraft" I mean i want a method of building that is more enjoyable and intuitive. Not a Minecraft clone.


r/landmark • • Feb 16 '15

SERIOUSLY

4 Upvotes

allow me to skip the fucking intro video. That is single handedly the dumbest fucking thing. The fact that my computer freaks the hell out and forces me to watch this 10 minute video when I try to start playing the game is strait pants on head retarded.


r/landmark • • Mar 31 '14

No Mini-map please

0 Upvotes

According to the blueprint for landmark we will be getting a mini-map soon. i really dislike the idea of having a mini-map. IMO it hurts exploration and immersion. Mini-maps have a tendency to draw the players attention away from their surroundings to focusing only on the mini-map itself. IMO a game that highlights on exploration and adventure should limit navigation features, otherwise it diminishes the experience. Instead of a mini-map I think a compass would be a better substitute.


r/landmark • • Sep 19 '15

Waiting for beta key for over a year, any spares?

0 Upvotes

Please /r/landmark, your my only hope! - Jeremy Lin

Thanks /u/Zylus_River :D :D :D


r/landmark • • Apr 24 '14

Is combat in yet? Limited bandwidth for patching/etc.

0 Upvotes

I don't have a good connection, so I wanted to ask you guys first: Is combat in-game yet? That determines whether I'll be wanting to patch up or not.


r/landmark • • Jun 10 '16

[Landmark's Fate](/s "Daybreak's Quick Cash Grab.")

3 Upvotes

With Everquest Next's cancellation earlier this year, Landmark has no purpose. The current state of the game is abysmal, and launch is only in a few hours. Landmark was supposed to be free to play at launch if I remember correctly, now it's going to be ten dollars. Daybreak/Columbus Nova is just going to try to sell as many Landmark copies and cash shop crap at launch, and cancel it in a couple months. Believe me or not, but you've been warned. Don't sink money into this game.


r/landmark • • May 26 '14

Giving away unlimited Landmark Closed Beta Keys in twitch stream at 150 followers!

Thumbnail
twitch.tv
0 Upvotes

r/landmark • • Feb 24 '15

Let's Play Landmark! -{Episode 38}-

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/landmark • • Jun 26 '14

It's finally time! I am streaming :) Next episode is tonight at 6:00PM MST

Thumbnail
twitch.tv
0 Upvotes

r/landmark • • May 11 '14

Will Landmark link with EQ Next? Or is it its own thing?

0 Upvotes

I always thought that Landmark was JUST going to be a tool where players could create stuff that the devs for EQNext would then take the best bits of and lift them into that? Has it evolved to be it's own thing now, completely detached from EQNext?

I mean, it's not a bad thing; a crafting MMO is sorely missing in the market and A Tale In The Desert is a bit aged these days. I just thought it was something different!


r/landmark • • May 19 '14

I have an idea on PvP, should I try to suggest this to a dev?

0 Upvotes

Okay, this will most likely be a wall of text so forgive me.

I've noticed a couple of things so far. One that there's very little community so far because there's no reason. The game doesn't force you to be interdependent, so it's easy to be a lone wolf. Also I've read that there's a real gap between the elite builders and everyone else and that might not help build community. I mentioned in a reddit post how they could allow for Guild builds and that might help, and then I got thinking, and came up with an idea, so here goes.

So we currently get a claim flag and I gather we can have up to 9 more extending flags (eventually to expand our claim). Well I think after forming a guild each member should get a special "Guild claim flag". The flag come with a few limits. Any flag used must be connected on two sides by more Guild flags and there's a time limit (10 minutes?) in which to do this. This will prevent area destroying claims. Everyone in the Guild can build within the Guild claim. This gives elite builders a reason to mentor less skilled players, and everyone can feel like they've contributed to an epic build, even if you're only gathering. Very community building. Right? But wait there's more!

The next idea is how this could work for PvP. In WoW I loved the pre-battlegrounds PvP. It was very organic and ad hoc and I can remember some really epic battles in the South shore/X rds. areas. Battlegrounds took this away and made PvP into more of a competitive sport than just a bunch of players goofing around and having fun. I'd love it if Landmark was more like pre-Battlegrounds.

So to do this when a guild is formed the guild master/leader gets a special block called a guild stone. With this idea player builds are not ever destroyable by other players and unflagged guild builds are not. But once the guild leader places the stone, and it needs to be surrounded on all sides to be placed, the guild and guild build are flagged for guild on guild PvP. Once placed no one in the placing guild can move it, until reset, and for any guild players to flag for PvP both guild builds need to be flagged.

G on G PvP works like this. The object is to find the opposing guilds guild stone and carry it outside of their guild build claim. On doing this they get whatever reward PvP decides to give, lets say a point. Once this is accomplished the stone resets and reappears in the losing leaders inventory. This unflags the guild build until the leader again places the stone, giving some time for the guild to rebuild the claim and re-group.

There are two ways a player can flag themselves for PvP. Either manually or by destroying anything within another guilds flagged claim. So the moment a player starts trying to find a stone they become flagged and are at the other guilds mercy. On PvP death a player spawns in the general area of their stones placement. This means defenders will be close to the action on respawns and attackers will have to run back to the battle from their home. As well defending player respawns will give the attackers hints on where the stone might be hidden. Lastly all guild members will be able to make the stones location a crystal hearthing location for fast assembly of the troops if attacked. So no worries about your guild getting wiped while your at your personal claim.

The last thing that I thought of was having guild alliances. Every guild can form one alliance. When formed it will create a alliance chat channel, so the two guild leaders can coordinate tactics between them. This could lead to some interesting tactics for all involved.

For example: Guild A has 50 members, B has 35, and C 30. B and C form an alliance because they both fear A's ability to take either of them out. Guild A decides to attack B and has 35 players doing a frontal assault, 10 sneaking in to the build to locate the stone, and 5 guarding their own build. B calls for C's aid in the battle, but they decide to only have 15 run over to B's location and have 10 attempt an assault on the under defended A guild's build.

Well little did C and B know but A has a alliance with a 40 man guild D. So when A's members defending their stone tell the leader that they're under attack by C, A springs it's trap. There are 15 D members each hiding close to A and C's builds and they leap up to help defend A's build and to take C's build. With this idea guilds sharing an alliance would both get a "point" for any wins.

I could go on and on with the possibilities of this idea, optimal guild build layouts depending on guild size. All sorts of potential build strategies to hide the stone and confuse attacking guilds. Do you have some speed builders repairing damage or just everyone flagged for PvP and fighting? Things like that. This could be the massive guild on guild PvP that Conan promised but never really delivered on. But I don't know, maybe I'm too stoked on the idea because it's mine. What do you guys think?

Tl/DR My idea on killing two birds with one stone, by making guild claims/builds and then using it to base epic guild on guild PvP battles on, and also creating a community where everyone is interdependent and feel they're contributing. Looking for feedback.

Edit: a word


r/landmark • • Apr 01 '14

The 53 second tutorial.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/landmark • • Apr 18 '14

Ask the Druid - #Bootypants, or How I Learned to Love My Landmark Character

Thumbnail
eqhammer.com
0 Upvotes

r/landmark • • Feb 18 '16

Voxels with UVs and the irrelevance of Landmark

0 Upvotes

https://twitter.com/miguelcepero/status/700137677841108993

https://twitter.com/miguelcepero/status/700353072149762048

https://twitter.com/miguelcepero/status/700384937506119680

https://twitter.com/miguelcepero/status/700442597727281153

These are some new screenshots of UV mapped voxels being shown off in VoxelFarm (the voxel engine Landmark and hopefully EQN uses.) They have been shown before but this is the first time they have been shown in a more "real world" scenario that isn't just a demo.

For those that don't know UV maps are information used to precisely align a texture to a 3D model. In this case the model is comprised of voxels. Landmark currently only has a form of what is called planar mapping on voxels that basically just covers the voxels with a a wrapping paper like repeating texture.

UV mapping is the technology pretty much every single video game released today uses. Lack of it is one of the reasons why things in Landmark don't look very good. If it was used in the game then things like boulders would be able to be made of voxels and destroyed just like terrain. It would greatly improve architecture, allowing fine detail work where before there was only chunky expanses of generic stone texture. But chances of this tech making it into Landmark very slim.

UV maps have to be custom made for an object and there is no way to create them in a simplified game like interface. This is some standard professional development grade stuff. The limitation is that, except for maybe some currently unseen cases, these UV mapped voxels will only be able to be placed as a whole "model". They can probably be removed or deleted but you can not freely create with them. Creating things using UV maps would be more similar to submitting things in Player Studio for Daybreak's other games where creators use their own tools rather than using the voxel building tools in game.

This is the kind of technology that EQN needs to become a reality and compete as a AAA game. Not many in the target MMO demographic is going to be interested in a clunky, chunky world of player made early-Second Life looking buildings with inconsistent quality. Especially when the destructible voxel world gimmick will have been more than passe by the time the game releases. To create a compelling world and visual experience for EQN the majority of work is still going to have to be done by the developers. And they simply can't compete visually with today's, and more than likely tomorrow's, games with the current voxel tech.

If you follow Miguel/VoxelFarm then you will have seen some other interesting developments recently that seem perfectly aligned at filling the technological gaps that Landmark currently has. Things like automatically generated LODs, voxel occlusion culling, and now this seem like things that Daybreak really really need to make anything compelling that is even close to the original game plan for EQN. So let's assume that EQN will use all this improved tech.

Assuming that EQN is still a thing then Landmark seems like nothing but a burden. They already split the codebases for the two games and at the time Steve Klug kind of made it sound like that would lessen interoperabillity between both games. It seems they are mostly ignoring Landmark as the have been for the past year, probably because there is no real reason for its existence now. If any of this is true than even implementing the new claim and camera settings seems like a waste of time. EQN probably has become a less "user creation" focused game and more of a standard MMO. I don't know if using voxels has any developmental fluidity benefits or not (allowing the developers to modify the world more easily than a standard 3D model based approach) but lets assume they are still using them just for the destruction gimmick at least. Let's also assume that since that is the case they are using as much of this new VoxelFarm tech as they can to make the game... good. So, if that is the case, then you would now have Landmark. It's a game that can't create content for EQN anymore, has statistically nobody playing it, and is more than likely bleeding money just staying online. Barring some kind of popularity resurgence that is doubtful to come if it ever went into open beta there is really no reason for Landmark to exist anymore, if what I've speculated has any basis in reality.

So what's to do? My suggestion, with Daybreak's recent willingness to make drastic changes to their in development games (H1Z1) in mind:

  • Shut down Landmark to focus all development on EQN, if it isn't already.

  • Within a short amount of time give everyone who had access to Landmark access to the closed EQN alpha/beta/prototype/whatever exists.

  • Give people who bought Landmark exclusive EQN perks based on their founder pack level

  • Hope nobody tries to sue you? I dunno people will still be mad but people will also be mad when Daybreak shuts down due to bankruptcy, the entire EQN project is cancelled, etc. Seems like this is one of the best case scenarios currently.


r/landmark • • Jul 06 '15

Is Landmark and Everquest Next the same game?

1 Upvotes

Sorry, i know thats a dumb question, but i'm looking for a nee mmo to play since "ArcheAge" is dead.


r/landmark • • Jun 17 '14

If anyone has an extra key I will loves you forever:)

1 Upvotes