"The hollowing-out of the rim opens up a distinct level of functionality in autism that surpasses the one described by Asperger and associated today with Asperger’s syndrome (APA, 2013). This is a level in which autistic subjects become independent, even to the point where a psychiatric diagnosis of autism can sometimes be disregarded (Maleval, 2015, p. 766). Maleval terms this level of functioning the “invisible pole” of autism. He adds that this pole is not only invisible to observers and clinicians but, in a lot of cases, is also invisible to the subject itself and, as a result, can be diagnosed only late in adulthood (p. 778). On this level, the resources accumulated in the different modes of the development of the rim, supported by the open synthetic Other, are utilized in what might be called a “normal” lifestyle—what under psychoanalytic terms could be determined as a seemingly neurotic conduct of a structured autistic. Interestingly enough, the Leforts (2003) devoted their last book on the subject of autism to the analysis of the autistic traits of such notable figures in the history of humanity that might be associated with the invisible pole, such as: Edgar Allan Poe, Fyodor Dostoevsky, Comte de Lautréamont, American President Woodrow Wilson, Blaise Pascal, and Marcel Proust."
To start with, I wanted to share this quote from Brenner's book on autism, because it gives you a very different impression than you would get if you were going by some of the comments and posts in the subreddit. What I find interesting is that Brenner is willing to acknowledge an invisible pole, which comes very close to the kind of language used by disability, activists and the autistic community in general when they talk about invisible disabilities and what not. I'm not saying Brenner would disagree that some people are wrongly diagnosed with autism and that they actually have a different structure. But it does seem to be the case that there are two different emphases here: Brenner is interested in elucidating autism for autistic people and others, where as many people in this subreddit see more concerned with proving that people aren't autistic enough to count as autistic in order to preserve some kind of purity of their theory or whatever.
But the question I wanted to ask that's only kind of tangentially related to the quote—aside from people like pruced and my personal favorite Lautréamont— could you classify Socrates, specifically as Lacan. Understands him— as autistic?
For Brenner, the autistic subject has retained the voice object. I'm not trying to pretend to be an expert in Lacan, I'm still learning, but somehow this retention of the voice object is equivalent to or related to the foreclosure of the rim and with it of the symbolic and whatnot. But for lacan, Socrates's daimon seems to be the same voice object that is retained rather than being allowed to open up some field for the Other or whatever.
It would be very easy to label soccer teams as an autistic using stereotypes and superficial symptoms and whatever, but it seems like Lacan has already put some thought into the structure of Socrates and that if nothing else it would be kind of useful for understanding how it differs from autism if it does.
But I mean if nothing else, I really think this quote should shut up the people saying that Brenner is only talking about kanner autistics or whatever. I've actually seen a few people claim that Brenner said the exact opposite of what he explicitly says in a few cases. For example, someone said grandin wouldn't count as autistic, but then why does Brenner mention her so much as an example of autism? It doesn't confirm or falsify his theory or anything, I just think some people are having trouble grasping the basic theory he's putting forward when he's actually pretty clear about it. And the misunderstandings have nothing to do with knowledge of lacan, they just have to do with people bleedingly not reading what brainer is saying because they don't want to deal with it.