Little bit of background before I go into the meat of the post. I took Krav Maga at a Krav Maga Worldwide school (which is supposed to be among the best from the research I did) for about 10 years while simultaneously taking a decent amount of boxing (I took Krav about 4-5 hours a week on average and then about 2-3 hours a week of the boxing - with medium to hard sparring in every class). I got far enough into the system that while I never hit blackbelt, I got far enough that I saw the very vast majority of all of the hand to hand stuff it offers (I only missed out on a couple throws from Judo I believe but I did see the leg sweeps and takedowns) and a couple of the weapon disarms (but I got the majority of those as well).
I also occasionally took a ground class which those were just straight up BJJ taught by people that had verified were experienced and qualified to teach it. I didn't take as much of the BJJ but I took enough to make sure I wasn't helpless on the ground and to get a feel for the fundamentals. In addition to all of that I also wrestled in high school so I have a somewhat diverse background which I hope makes me at least somewhat qualified to speak to what I think is good and what I think is bad about Krav Maga.
Onto the main point here... I feel like Krav Maga seems to get *very* mixed reactions when brought up in the martial arts community so I wanted to give some insight and offer my thoughts. I think the absolute biggest issue that Krav Maga suffers from is the lack of quality control. And it's horrific.
The organization I trained under has a reputation of keeping the Krav "pure" and of a high quality and while they make changes to the curriculum at times it has to go through a large approval process from other high ranking practitioners - including a man who trained directly under the founder of the system. So between that and general fighting experience I can say I feel like what ***I PERSONALLY*** received was proper Krav Maga - and I liked the majority of it. But... when I look at most Krav Maga online, most of what I see is SUCH ABSOLUTE DOGSHIT and is NOT what I would consider Krav Maga. It's either just crap that would never ever work on a resisting opponent or it's someone trying to make a flashy cool video to attract students with the super duper lethal military style and it's... not Krav - it's hollywood. Additionally, there is a really big problem with instructors from other styles that want to incorporate self defense at their dojo in addition to their core style so they go take an 8 hour seminar from someone and they get a piece of paper that says they know Krav and they end up teaching some bastardized crap and calling it Krav Maga. Then actual fighters see that shit and go ew Krav Maga sucks. Because yeah - that shit sucks.
The next big, big issue that Krav Maga *in the United States* seems to suffer from, or at least Krav Maga Worldwide suffers from (where I experienced it), is a lack of actual sparring - and that is largely why I started taking the boxing. Basically they don't let level 1 students spar because they want them to get the basics before they start hitting eachother. So I had just passed my level 1 class and I thought I was the bomb and I could take anyone. I was starting to take level 2 classes, learning new stuff (including genuine boxing techniques because real Krav has very strong roots in western boxing), and it was great. So I was training the one day with a guy who had spent years and years boxing. Roughly my size and weight and overall a really cool guy. He offered to be my first sparring partner and I agreed to it. Now in my head I was like "hell yeah I got this, I'm a badass level 2 student". I did not have that whatsoever. I got my ass beat so bad it's not even funny and the guy wasn't even trying. It wouldn't have mattered if I took off the gloves and started using some of the other stuff I had learned - I didn't have the timing or distancing or general feel for a real fight that you only get from actually fighting so I literally couldn't touch the guy. This is what pushed me into adding the boxing into the next 9.5 years of my training. The actual Krav I took had *some* sparring but not nearly what I would consider enough (maybe one of every dozen classes I took had sparring).
Before I get into what I like about it I will touch on a final issue I have which ties into the last paragraph and that is the target audience in the US. In the US it has come over and been marketed as a very strong self defense system. And it absolutely can be. But in reality Krav Maga was not designed for a soccer mom that wants to kick a bad guy in the balls and run away. It was designed for soldiers trying to kill someone with their bare hands. So while the techniques here in the US and overseas may be about the same, the emphasis on how to use them/how to string them together are very different. So for example over here you might get taught to kick someone in the balls and run away where as over in Israel you might get taught to sweep someone's leg to put them on the ground and then finish the fight in a way that would be more appropriate in a war setting. I'm *NOT* advocating schools here trying to teach people to go above and beyond and cause grave harm to people that could be avoided, but it partially accounts for Krav Maga appearing to only have cheap little tricks with no substance because the classes I took where it was me and a bunch of the rougher guys were taught very differently than when half the class was full of soccer moms. This also accounts for the lack of sparring over here because unfortunately it does boil down to money over here (which unfortunately is apparent at Krav Maga Worldwide but that would take a separate topic to flesh out) so if they stopped catering to the soccer mom crowd (sorry soccer moms! I promise I don't hate you!) they'd probably lose a third of their business because they tend to not actually want to get hit.
Here's what I do like about genuine, properly taught Krav Maga. Real Krav Maga, with an actually appropriate amount of sparring, will teach you the ins and outs of western boxing and will make you an actually competent boxer. We learn footwork, ducking, bobs, weaves, slips, head movement, hooks, punch combinations, etc. Additionally there is a lot of crossover with MMA. I drilled single and double leg takedowns, leg sweeps, Muay Thai clinch, knees, round knees, leg kicks, spinning heel kicks, etc. When it wasn't just boxing when we sparred we were also allowed to use those as well. I actually remember in my level 3 test I was about 3-4 hours in and was completely exhausted and they were like ok guys sparring time and I was fighting this guy who was also a very experienced fighter from his past in other styles and I needed a breather so I pulled off a leg sweep under pressure no problem, even completely exhausted because he was swinging at my head pretty hard. This says to me that I at least learned the material well enough that it's applicable to real life for me personally.
The system is also very "wide" if that makes sense - it attempts to cover a lot. This is a double edged sword though because while something like MMA is still somewhat wide, it's not as wide as Krav Maga but goes deeper into what it is good at. The people I had the hardest time with in sparring were in fact MMA guys. I could generally keep up decently enough (thanks largely to the fact that I cross trained heavily in boxing and a little bit of ground) but dude... those guys really know how to engage with another trained fighter in a 1v1 and they are ****ing hard to deal with if they've been doing it for more than a few months. But that's what they do - they get really damn good at 1v1's with other trained fighters in contained environments. Krav addresses that too, but a MMA guy is going to be *better* at takedowns than me (and probably know a couple more variants) and they're going to be *better* at clinch work, etc because there are less situations that they are attempting to account for. Krav tries to account not only for an encounter with a trained fighter on even ground/no weapons/etc. but it also tries to account for things like:
Weapons (guns/knives/bats/batons/broken glass)
Multiple attackers
Active shooter drills
Waking up and an intruder is, for example, choking you from the side of the bed out of a dead sleep
A fight in a tight space like in an elevator where you can't use distancing or have open ground to roll on
Being choked up against a wall
In regards to the top two bullets, a decent Krav guy knows that weapons and/or multiple attackers are really bad. They outright tell you that these techniques are *reasonably* effective but are far from being 100% reliable regarding a gun or a knife and should only be used as a last resort because unless you spend all day every training gun and knife attacks there's a fair chance you're gonna get shot/stabbed. The idea is now we at least have something to try in a bad situation and even if it goes a little wrong you have an understanding of at least what you should or shouldn't do while you're trying to get control of the situation if you have to try and manufacture a technique on the fly. Same with multiple attackers. Krav gives you training and experience sparring a couple people at once to give you an idea of best practices for dealing with like 2 or 3 people but you find out pretty quick you're almost definitely going to take at least a couple hits or get outright overwhelmed.
Point 3 we have had actual active shooter response drills. Guess what. Lots of us died in the simulations. But it shows us how damn fast it all goes down - a LOT faster than you'd think. But it goes over hearing gunshots (they used blanks and they were damn loud) and getting down, getting behind something, and if by the grace of god you were close to the shooter and you hadn't gotten "shot" yet which technique to approach with to try and disarm the attacker. But the emphasis was actually on living first and if that meant hiding you do that before you go for a disarm. But overall educational stuff that in MMA you'd just spend that time drilling takedowns or something.
As far as the other points goes, and those were just a few examples, I know good and well that a good MMA guy or a good BJJ guy could likely manufacture an answer to those situations on the fly, but they're not necessarily something that they would immediately have a mindset for (or ideally a pre-practiced technique) right off the bat so there might be a second or two there where they have to figure out how to best handle the situation and there could be cases where those few seconds could make or break the situation. Krav is also about efficiency in it's answers to a fight which is another reason everyone thinks Krav says oh just kick them in the groin and that's 100% of Krav Maga. It's not. If I'm in a parking lot and I see some angry dude square up and I can tell good and well he knows boxing or MT I'm probably not going to try to kick him in the groin because I'm probably not going to land it. That's why *good* Krav will legitimately teach you how to box. But if I am in that elevator I named earlier and it goes to the ground, I might not have room for an armbar or a triangle or basic movement. Some BJJ guys may have the mindset to just jam his thumb in the attacker's eye (we're assuming this is a serious fight for your life kind of a fight here) but there are guys and gals who only do what they know so a purebread BJJ person may panic under the pressure of not having the room to use what they know so they may not actually think to do that where as like yeah, we get some ground stuff in Krav (these days) so Krav folks know a sloppier version of a BJJ armbar or triangle choke that they could go for too but really if it's *easier* and makes more sense to just go for an eye gouge rather than fighting for a submission or even joint break, the Krav person will go for that first and use the martial arts second. It just depends on what works better for the issue at hand.
So that's kind of where I stand on things. TLDR, good, real Krav will teach you how to be a competent boxer along with some other "break glass" quick and dirty MMA flavored techniques and will prepare you for more situations, but in a straight up 1v1 a pure Krav guy (no cross training) vs a pure MMA guy (no cross training) the MMA guy will have the edge but the Krav guy will not be completely helpless. But this is assuming the Krav guy actually got real Krav from a good school and not one of the zillion mcdojos out there that call their crap Krav Maga