r/kpopthoughts • • Dec 29 '24 This

Discussion Reasons why I'll forever be against HYBE acquiring other groups and Kpop companies moving forward...

7 Upvotes

As stated in my title, I don't think I'll ever be in favour of HYBE acquiring groups and their companies, and here is why...

Also, I honestly want to know if other people have ever thought and felt this way also? So please feel free to share your thoughts as well, and also brace yourself for a long "essay."

The 3 MAIN reasons are:

  1. Most of the groups they had since acquired have now disbanded or are VERY soon going to. Well, all except ONE.

  2. They have not proven they can sustain, support and help grow the groups they have acquired outside of the very ONE group that was already vastly more popular than the rest.

  3. They have shown little care for the groups they have acquired under the labels they have an overwhelming majority of shares and ownership over.

1) The Acquired Groups' Disbandments:

I don't think I'll ever stop thinking about how insane it is that all the groups (GFriend, Nu'est, and Fromis_9) that HYBE has acquired have either disbanded already or are going to disband VERY soon. Well I guess technically speaking, all the groups except for ONE. Though, I don't think it's surprising that the very group out of the acquired bunch who hasn't gotten the boot out of the 'HYBE exit door,' is SEVENTEEN. Who by all accounts (touring, sales, charting, records) are arguably the biggest active kpop boy group at the moment (with BTS on hiatus), and are also HYBE's 2nd most profitable group (only after BTS). I'll be honest, something about these acquired groups disbanding comes off a bit sinister on HYBE's end. And I say this because these were groups HYBE legitimately claimed they would help grow and support. Yet, we have all witnessed and seen that at the first chance of being able to get rid of them, they get disbanded (through their contracts conveniently coming to an end), and with no option of being able to re-sign with the company as a group. Keep in mind, that two of those groups (Gfriend & Nu'est) were more or less blindsided by their disbandment (the members have come out and spoken about it), while the other (Fromis) had been completely neglected & mistreated up until their subsequent end with the company. Furthermore, you can't tell me that it's not strange how all these groups HYBE went and sought after have now all disbanded within the last 2-3 years they were acquired.

2. They haven't proven they can support & maintain them:

Honestly speaking, when you think about it, starting from the year each group was acquired and up until their subsequent disbandment, you'll notice that it is quite a short time frame. And frankly speaking, I don't think that is enough to allow these groups to grow properly despite being integrated under such a big company like HYBE. These groups weren't at the level of SEVENTEEN's popularity when they were acquired, so of course it would be expected that it would take time and much effort to get them to grow...something that HYBE didn't seem to take into consideration or care about doing. If anything, it doesn't seem like HYBE really gave them a chance, instead, it seems like HYBE were indeed expecting instant & bigger results from them once these groups & their labels were officially integrated under them. But atlas, once that didn't happen they were quick to throw in the towel and just wait until their contracts ran out to toss them out. For instance, just look at the time frame from when each group were acquired to then their subsequent disbandment, and you'll notice that they were all done roughly within a 2-3 year time frame.

  • GFriend (Source Music) - Acquired July 2019 / Disbanded May 2021

  • Nu'est (PLEDIS) - Acquired October 2020 / Disbanded March 2022

  • Fromis (PLEDIS) - Acquired August 2021 / Disbanded? December 2024

As you've seen, that's quite a short time frame, and definitely a cause for concern that other companies with existing groups would look at if HYBE potentially came knocking on their door trying to acquire them, and I am guessing this was probably the case with SM Ent. I'll be honest, as much as I hate SM Ent, I genuinely do understand the fear and frustration they had when HYBE came trying to acquire them (via Lee Soo Man). Because even though SM Ent have their own issues (often illegals ones at that), and are far from perfect. However it's been made pretty clear for the last few years, that out of the BIG4 companies HYBE is THE MOST money hungry and greedy for success, especially instant success. Furthermore, HYBE have shown that unless a group is giving them astronomical results, they will have no problem neglecting them and subsequently choosing to abandon them, and this has become quite evident when looking at the groups (Gfriend, Nu'est, & Fromis) who no longer are under HYBE. Unless those groups were out here selling 500K or 1M with each album release, or racking in a substantial amount of money through touring & concerts, then honestly it was pretty clear they were going to get left behind. But again, this is one of the main reasons SM was heavily against HYBE taking over. Because unlike most HYBE groups who do pretty much bring in astronomical numbers (especially with their album sales), this can't really be said about most SM groups CURRENTLY, especially their older groups. And yet despite how trash of a company SM is, and how badly they have neglected their older groups who no longer carry the same fame they once had, they still end up having the highest outcome of maintaining legacy acts. In other words, they are still somehow capable of keeping their older groups despite their older groups not pulling in insane numbers and aren't as popular as they used to be. Something HYBE will struggle with if they keep disposing of their older groups, much less the ones they've acquired. Which frankly speaking, they technically already have.

You see, I was watching SM's Game Caterers the other day, and I was genuinely impressed to see how much SM was still able to keep their older acts, starting all the way from 1st Gen (Kangta x H.O.T) to 5th Gen (Wonbin x RIIZE). While watching SM's Game Caterers I couldn't help but compare how when it came to HYBE's Game Caterers the groups that were present were mostly 4th Gen groups (Fromis, TXT, Enhypen, Le Sserafim), and with only two 3rd Gen groups present (SEVENTEEN & Nu'est). But now one of those two 3rd Gen groups has now since been disbanded with one of their 4th Gen groups also soon heading towards disbanding (or at the very least their contract ends with Plybe very soon). Now since then, when you really think about it, there really isn't any other group in that company that is as old or older than BTS & SEVENTEEN, especially now that Nu'est & Gfriend are gone (yes I know the girls are having a reunion, but they aren't officially back together). Plus, we know BTS is an exception...they aren't the rule they are the exception, both with regard to Kpop and with HYBE, and so we know by this point that they won't get disbanded unless the members themselves choose to. But now I can't help but think, what about SVT? They aren't in the same frame as BTS. Yes SEVENTEEN is big, but BTS is BIGGER. And now seeing how HYBE has treated the acquired groups thus far, I am sure lots of us (especially Carats) can't help but think it's very likely that had SVT not been as big as they were before the acquisition, then Pledis would have never been sought after by HYBE in the first place. Furthermore, IF Pledis had still been acquired, it's clear that had SVT not been as big as they are right now and pulling in these astronomical numbers that they do for HYBE, then they would have gotten the boot out once their first contract had ended. It now begs the question, what was the point? What was the point of acquiring these labels and their groups if they weren't going to help support and sustain them?

3. They don't care, They never DID!

Since the disbandment of GFriend, Nu'est and now soon Fromis, it's been made pretty clear that HYBE isn't really here to help grow and sustain groups (much less the ones they acquired), but rather here to grow and sustain themselves. It's clear that unless these groups under HYBE are bringing in huge numbers to the company, then the company could care less about keeping them, and it sure as hell is proven that it doesn't matter if these groups are popular domestically, cause at the end of the day that popularity needs to reflect well with the numbers. HYBE is a company that very much looks at dollar signs and numbers, and so even if a group is mildly popular (mid-tier) if that popularity doesn't actually reflect with the numbers or even show a higher potential for greater and more popularity, HYBE is leaving these groups in the dust. HYBE is a company that is currently still going through their expansion phase (which is another issue I have with HYBE), and so they are heavily reliant on instant success for their groups (and other ventures) to help speed run their expansion so they can quickly establish and cement themselves as one of the big dogs, and not just in Kpop but worldwide. This is why they are running around like Thanos picking up labels and/or establishing ones in different parts of the world (US, Japan, Latin America, etc.), but also pumping out new groups (different labels or not), with 7 groups debuting in the last 2 and a half years, and supposedly 4 more groups on the way starting next year. With this in mind, it's been made pretty clear that acquiring these groups were just part of their ongoing quest to reach their actual goal, and so they never really cared to put in effort in helping support, grow and maintain these acquired groups. These groups were infinity stones that were needed for a larger goal, and once used or shown to have no more value, they were gonna be discarded.

I mean, think about it...if HYBE truly cared, they would have definitely done more for them. Just take Fromis for instance...yes Pledis is also to blame, but I feel as though people either fail to consider, or willingly choose to ignore that 1) HYBE is the parent company, 2) As the parent company they also own an overwhelming majority of the shares under these acquired labels (most especially Pledis with 90%), and 3) It has been already made clear that most of the original management and staffs who had worked under Pledis don't anymore, and have been replaced with people from HYBE or BigHit. This was especially the case with the original Pledis CEO (Han Sungsoo), in which it wasn't up until recently (literally just last month actually) that HYBE decided to bring back the original Pledis VP (Kim Yeonsoo) to become the new Pledis CEO. But make no mistake that before Kim Yeonsoo, the new Pledis CEO who had replaced the original Pledis CEO (Han Sungsoo), was a former BigHit VP (Lee Dahye). So yes, I very much blame Pledis for the mishap and mistreatment that goes on in their label, but HYBE to me holds the majority responsibility and blame. Because at the end of the day, if HYBE truly cared they could have intervened (like they typically do) and gotten the situation with Fromis settled before one of the members had to publicly speak out about their unfair treatment and not getting paid compared to their other HYBE label mates.

CONCLUSION:

All in all, I will forever find it strange that HYBE went and acquired these groups & their companies (even took a loan from the bank to acquire one of them), and claimed they would help support them. But yet most of these groups have since been disbanded within the last 3 years since they were acquired. And yes their labels hold some blame too, but I am definitely pinning most of blame of these groups' disbanding and their neglect on HYBE. Because since observing HYBE and their treatment of their acquired groups, it's been made pretty clear to me that instead of helping them grow, and providing them with proper support to sustain and maintain these groups, they instead chose to neglect them and then throw them out at the first chance they saw that their contracts were coming to an end. SEVENTEEN being the only group out of the ones that were acquired to ever get the option and chance to renew as a group under HYBE and their respective label (who are under HYBE), will always have me looking at HYBE sideways. These groups were done dirty forreal.

Please share your responses and thoughts respectfully, thank you.


r/kpopthoughts • • Jul 27 '23

Thought Blackpink songs dont age well..... I feel in the near future their songs (specificially the ones that have been released up till now) would a bit awkward to sing.

0 Upvotes

Let say they disband one day and after a few years they have a reunion show or concert I can imagine their songs like ddu du ddu du, pretty savage and majority of their TT being a bit awkward to sing cause I feel they wont age properly.

Or another example lets say they have to perform for Olympics or any large non music related event to represent their country. Even here I feel their songs would a bit awkward and out of place.

The reason I feel so is because a lot of their popular songs are about how rich we are, how bada** we are, you cant touch us, how young and pretty we are etc . I cant imagine performing these songs on events like olympics or when they are in 30s and beyond cause these songs sound one dimensional and tone deaf.

Here in this discussion I am mainly talking about their TT and I know not all blackpink songs are like these, there are songs like you never know, happiest girl etc but a good amount of their dicography fall under the discussed category.

This is not a blackpink exclusive situation there might be other popular groups who also fall under this category but the reason why I am talking about blackpink is because I know their whole discography, I dont know whole discography of any other groups.

I would love hear what rest of you think about my take, I may be wrong about some point feel free to correct me.


r/kpopthoughts • • Apr 20 '24

Appreciation Music is more than just vocals. Lets celebrate all kpop.

14 Upvotes

I hate this current trend of bashing idols who can't sing. I hate the toxic MR removals that perpetuate lies and myths.

Music isn't just about vocals. Hell, i should know because I am a metalhead and our singers sound like they are vomiting LOL My advice to anyone upset is to just enjoy the music of kpop. Enjoy the dance choreography. Enjoy the visuals. Love and support all kpop.

Some of the most famous musicians and singers couldn't sing. Jimi Hendrix and Kurt Cobain are two off the top of my head. But I am sure you guys can come up with more examples of famous pop stars, rappers etc who couldn't sing well but were still super talented regardless.


r/kpopthoughts • • Jul 04 '23

Controversy the infamous "typa girl" blackpink lyrics

3 Upvotes

the whole argument of "blackpink puts other women down" based on the sole line of "i'm not like these other girls at all" is ridiculous to me. there's not a single mention in the song to being better than anyone else, other than this arguable line, and it's not even an explicit statement, rather it can be interpreted in different ways. there is not any other line in all of their discography remotely comparing themselves to other people, rather lifting themselves up, so i don't understand where this idea comes from other than nitpicking and being purposely hateful, since nobody outside the kpop bubble seems to have a problem with it either.

nobody thinks blackpink are feminist icons, they've never labeled themselves that either. however, portraying the image of being powerful, confident and succesful women in their songs (like this one too) can feel empowering and inspiring to people.


r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 21 '25

Fandoms It’s funny seeing newer fans act like ARMYs suddenly “took over” these subs

32 Upvotes

Its clear how a lot of people complaining about “ARMYs running these subs” weren’t actually here back when things were really bad and are clearly new to Reddit Kpop spaces.

A few years ago especially around the pandemic every Kpop related sub was absolutely flooded with anti BTS posts every single day. It got so bad that mods had to ban BTS related posts for a while and literally limit them to certain days because it was just nonstop negativity. Endless threads mocking their music, their English releases, their fanbase, everything.

If you were active back then you’d remember how vicious it was. Anyone who tried defending BTS was instantly downvoted into oblivion or had their comments removed. Most ARMYs just stayed in BTS spaces because it wasn’t worth the headache. But after years of seeing the same hateful nonsense more people started pushing back. “BTS fell off,” “BTS sold out,” “ARMYs are toxic” on repeat. Eventually fans got tired of pretending it was normal and started participating in these subs.

And now, those same “days” are clearly coming back. The amount of hate posts and nasty comments about BTS lately is wild. It feels like pandemic era energy all over again. As soon as they are seen breathing the comments about them turn insanely vicious. Tell me why I see BTS being compared to Diddy on every platforms?

BTS's success in building HYBE is also a big part of why every HYBE group gets hated on so disproportionately. People hold resentment toward anything even slightly connected to BTS. Look at NewJeans: for years some people trashed them for being “HYBE’s privileged group.” But the moment they had conflict with the company suddenly the same people who were dragging them two years ago are now tokken stanning them just to drop them as soon as they are seen as a "threat" to their fave groups again. (obligatory I miss NewJeans' music comment 🥲)

If these subs were really “run by ARMYs,” the Yoongi incident last year wouldn’t have gone down the way it did. Thousands of people spread fake info and trashed him while mods left it up for days before quietly deleting it. When the truth came out, no apologies, no accountability, just silence until the next opportunity to hate.

Come on. Acting like this is about constructive criticism is a joke. There has never been a BTS thread that didn’t devolve into people piling on and demonizing them or their fans.

But now that people can’t freely bash BTS without pushback, suddenly it’s “ARMYs ruin everything and are running every.single. Kpop subreddit!"


r/kpopthoughts • • Sep 24 '25

Girl Groups Gnarly is a good song that does exactly what it’s suppose to do.

2 Upvotes

All these posts from months ago saying it was a waste of a concept, waste of effort, mistake, won’t be a hit were dead wrong because everything here it taken at face value. Was the first listen shocking? Yes. Was it risky? Yes. Did it pay off? Also yes.

The lyrics being entirely SATIRE makes it even better. I honestly don’t know how people took the lyrics and thought it was meant to be serious, meaningfully, and written to be good. If something is written to evoke that type of “what the fuck” reaction then I think it’s done well. It’s very obviously mocking that high-life California influencer culture and does it well.

I’m glad it became a moment, a hit, a trend your favs have been doing, and even a pop-culture moment. People are calling songs that are hated but turned into hits a “Gnarly moment” and that’s good. All love.


r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 07 '21

Bands Aespa is a breath of fresh air in kpop

9 Upvotes

In the past few years, kpop has been leaning towards the American mainstream side. Most songs literally sound like American pop music but translated into Korean. It’s a bit frustrating for those who like the originality and, I guess you can say, “weirdness” of kpop.

But with Aespa I think that we can finally get back into what kpop truly is, not some American pop song reject. Not only are Aespa’s songs unique, but they also have the vocals to back it up. I won’t name any idols but it’s clear that entertainment companies are choosing dancers over singers now when both should be equally important. Shinee, girls generation, exo, mamamoo, etc. all have amazing vocalists but they are from previous generations. Some are getting married and moving on, which leaves us with 4th gen groups.

I have high hopes for Aespa, and I hope that other companies are paying close attention to what sm is doing. I personally appreciate that sm groups sing about a wide variety of things instead of boxing themselves into only concepts about love. They sing about concepts, like a story. This story turns into an epic music video, which is much much better imo than just watching the idols lip sync the song in front of a background for 3 minutes straight (they can’t have a male actor or female actor role play bc…fans).

Exo mama, Aespa savage, taemin move, red velvet peek a boo, red velvet red flavor, shinee don’t call me, Superm jopping, f(x) electric shock??? STRAIGHT BANGERS

  • Btw Aespa’s album was sooooooo good. I don’t even want to call them B sides, it should be called A sides!!

EDIT: I am not an SM stan, I just happen to like groups who are under SM because I like vocals, strong vocals. I like other groups in other companies btw. Y’all are completely putting words in my mouth, its like that pancake and waffle tweet.

“So you hate love songs?” NO I never said that. I said I hate it when companies box their idols into concepts about love to the point where they can’t sing about anything else.

“So you hate all 4th gen groups?” NO I never said that. I ult txt and like enhypen and everglow. However, Aespa has the potential to be the 4th gen girl group leader.

Edit: thanks for the awards!


r/kpopthoughts • • Apr 13 '25

Thought Lisa is getting unnecessary hate and it's sad

20 Upvotes

I'm not even a big fan of her music but Christ the people dunking on her are being silly, it's obvious others are using her as clickbait for their tweets and videos by now.

Okay you don't like her or her music great move on. She was fine at Coachella and yes she was singing, stop being disingenuous because you have to stick to a narrative that she can't perform for some reason. Grow up and move on


r/kpopthoughts • • Apr 02 '23

Appreciation Have you even watched Jimin's live performances of the last 2 years?

1 Upvotes

I know there are two types of people. One type is ready to jump on the hate train since they are already haters but the other type are neutral people acquiring wrong information because of the first type of people...

I wanted make a quick informative post to let this negative mood go away! Firstly, I genuinely want to ask you, have you watched all the "Like Crazy" and "Set Me Free pt.2" live performances (including Jimmy Fallon and the music shows)? Or have you just seen that "encore performance" where his in-ears literally do not function properly hence he is off-tune?

If you have not, you probably don't know he is %100 singing live, adding incredible adlibs and dancing at the same time in his live stage performances. And to add to this, he had another encore after /that day/ but no one is talking about that encore because it wasn't a bad performance cause by a non-functional device 😭

I will link all the performances here, you can have a look at ANY or ALL of them since he is amazing in all:

Jimmy Fallon

Inkigayo - Like Crazy, Inkigayo - Set Me Free pt.2

KBS - Like Crazy, KBS - Set Me Free pt.2

MNET - Like Crazy, MNET - Set Me Free pt.2

Leemujin - Like Crazy

And other than his solo comeback, he has been very good in his live performances of the last 2 years. Starting with 2020, you can see he is very good in his live vocals. My suggestions would be for you to see (if you are interested) Black Swan, Dynamite, Butter performances... 2020 end-year MAMA/MMA performances... but especially PTD Live concerts where you can see him singing their old and new songs at the same time.

Don't get me wrong, I am not saying Jimin did not have frustrations with his singing. The man himself said it multiple times on camera, there is nothing to deny about that. But I can see how his hard work has been paying off because I can see how much better he gets each time.

And I couldn't just stand by and watch him get dragged with "jimin is bad at live singing" during his solo comeback when he delivered INCREDIBLE live performances for his songs.

I am not addressing this post to the haters because I know they will be hating no matter what, but I want to address the people who only saw comments that spur from that unfortunate stage and the people who think jimin is not giving good live performances because of all the focus being made that stage by /some people/.

I mean I have seen at least 3-4 reddit posts about that encore day but no posts about how he is doing a very good job. If I wasn't an army and had not seen his performances, I would think he wasn't doing a good job either (because of the posts made about the issue by people with bad intentions).

So I wanted to make a post to show Jimin's incredible comeback stages, I hope it helps!


r/kpopthoughts • • Jul 28 '24

Appreciation I have a lot of respect for BTS and how they still lrelease even after Military Service

9 Upvotes

I may have moved on to NCT Dream, but I really respect them a lot.

Their music has a unique sound that can't really be replicated.

An their dedication to releasing even through military service is damn amazing. They must've worked their asses off during the hiatus to record and film all these, just so Army had new things to listen to.

They'll always have a place in my heart. I used to be super obsessed. Even though I'm a casual Stan now, Jeon Jungkook, you'll always be known as my first ever Kpop bias. You're still #27 on my list, right after every NCT member


r/kpopthoughts • • Nov 16 '24

Appreciation NewJeans’ KMGA 2024 Performance Highlights Their Growth as Performers

0 Upvotes

Today marked the first edition of the KMGA, and while I don't think we really need more award shows—and I couldn’t care less about the awards themselves—I always look forward to seeing artists perform and showcase their creativity with their sets.

NewJeans delivered a staggering 12-minute performance featuring all four songs they released this year: Right Now, Bubble Gum, How Sweet, and Supernatural. In my opinion, NewJeans has never been explicitly bad as performers, but I do recall that during their early days, they faced quite a bit of criticism for their perceived lack of "stage presence." Their debut-era performances were charming but often relied heavily on backtracks and lip-syncing, with minimal variation from the original choreography.

The Get Up era saw some improvements, with cool remixes for award shows and more instances of live singing, though their lack of audience interaction was still an area for growth. Unfortunately, NewJeans hasn’t had many opportunities to headline their own full-length concerts, aside from their appearances at festivals like Lollapalooza and Summer Sonic, as well as fan meets. Still, this year, I think they’ve improved immensely.

I’ve watched their Tokyo Dome performance, university festival appearances, and Coke Studio concert in the Philippines, and I’m thoroughly impressed with how much they’ve grown. Their KMGA performance could be seen as a summary of all that progress.

Their set began with a dramatic intro inside a glass cage, allowing them to showcase their theatricality. While it wasn’t technically incredible, it was executed quite well. With Bubble Gum, they introduced a live band and live singing, highlighting their vocal abilities and engaging the audience—something I think many K-pop acts often struggle with during award shows. The members were clearly having a lot of fun, and their energy was contagious. They played around, hyped up the audience, performed a skit, and kept everyone engaged throughout. With How Sweet and Supernatural, they continued to interact with the crowd, creating a fun, lively atmosphere. To me, that’s the most important part of any performance.

It never felt like they were just doing a choreo they’d done countless times before. Instead, it had an organic, freeform vibe—even if that isn't the case. I was especially impressed by how comfortable they seemed on stage, how much they laughed, and how great they sounded. A perfect mix of live singing and backtrack. Their dances are already not that easy, but the nailed it, even the fast-paced dance break in Supernatural.

I’m not sure what the future holds for NewJeans, but considering how much they’ve improved as live performers lately, I truly hope fans worldwide get the chance to experience their performances live at least once.

Anyway, what do you guys think of their performance? Did you like it? I hope this doesn't get buried just because you hate newjeans. I really want to see what people think of all of this.


r/kpopthoughts • • Sep 30 '26

Thought The narrative that "ILLIT fans are pity stans" is sickening

0 Upvotes

2026 is almost end. ILLIT's discography is growing. And kpop stans still have it in their head that ILLIT only have pity stans, that their fans don't really like them they just hate X group, or whatever people said.

Do liking ILLIT bcs people like the music is an impossible thing to grasp? You don't like the music, doesn't mean other people too. Do pitying a group make you listen to their songs? Bcs I'm not. Why would I listen to smth I don't enjoy just bcs I feel bad for some groups?

Do liking ILLIT bcs people like the girls is not possible? Even if you think the girls have no personality, not talented, etc, that's your opinion. Other people can have different opinions from you and found the girls are lovable, funny, talented, etc.

If ILLIT's fanbases don't like them for the girls, then why they bother watching their YouTube contents, joining their Weverse live, etc?

Just bcs some chronically online interaction you have with some ILLIT fans are arguing about X topic, it doesn't mean their fanbase is just a bunch of X haters, or that majority of their fanbase is from other fandom. ILLIT is growing their own fanbase like any other groups. Stop discrediting it.


r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 25 '24

General People should show more respect to legendary K-pop groups.

1 Upvotes

Edit 2: adding this on the beginning since people seem to miss the point of my post. 1) I already mentioned 2nd gen groups setting the foundations for 3rd gen to get worldwide but everyone seem to have missed it, it's in the post 2) my post is written in order to promote positivity yet everyone for some reason believes I'm ignoring 2nd gen effect and success and purposefully talking only about 3rd gen. I talked about 3rd gen because that's when K-pop became worldwide.

I mean I know we're on the internet and everyone and their mothers have access to it, so toxic behaviour is guaranteed in any and every space, but the amount of toxicity and lack of respect in K-pop related media and forums is starting to become unbearable.

I'm going to specifically talk about legendary 3rd generation K-pop groups that basically made K-pop what it is today worldwide. At this point we can safely say that it's almost considered normal for people to hate and judge on anything BTS/Blackpink/Twice do and don't do. They're not judged in a critical way, rather than a hateful one and are held to a different standard than the rest of K-pop (I can understand that's partially because of other groups stans being jealous of their success, people love to hate on anything successful). People can even get viral online for hating those groups.

Now, is that any different from toxic fans in other kinds of interests? I would say yes and the reason why is people don't really have that lack of respect to the individuals that made the genre of their preference popular, that's exclusive to K-pop. I haven't seen Pop fans massively attacking Michael Jackson or Rock fans lacking respect to AC/DC or Led Zeppelin in order to support their own newer generation favourite artists.

K-pop wouldn't have been at the point where it stands now without BTS, Blackpink and Twice (EXO as well and huge props and thumbs up to 2nd gen for setting the foundations for that first, focused on 3rd gen in the post because those groups are the ones that keep on getting targeted by haters). Those groups need to be respected to say at the least. At this point in their careers they don't have anything to prove to anyone and hate towards them won't make them any less successful or impactful, but people please, respect the groups that made K-pop what it is today. Your 4th gen faves admire and have tons of respect to them. If you read the whole post thanks, I had to get it off my chest.

And for the ending:

"Keep talking we shut you down" - Blackpink

"Did you see my bag? Did you see my bag? It's hella trophies and it's hella thick" - BTS

"I ain't going nowhere I'm an Icon, when all them other nobodies are long gone" - Twice

Edit: I mentioned 2nd gen, but most people seem to have missed it.


r/kpopthoughts • • Feb 28 '22

Company Is HYBE eliminating the competition and threats?

44 Upvotes

“The best way to reduce competition is not by outside, but by inside“ LMAO

This has to be the dumbest take ever, GFRIEND (SourceMusic) and NUEST (Pledis) disbandment has anything to do with HYBE trying to eliminate them because they represent any sort of threat to their other artists, that are by the way managed by their respective labels, HYBE is only the big umbrella.

I completely understand fans being upset and dissapointed but in both cases were the members that chose to do so, only thing as fans we can do is respect their decision because it is their career.

Also i don‘t want to get into how fans think both of those groups represent a threat to BTS and big younger groups like TXT and ENHYPEN. Let’s not be delusional, you are mad? ok but don’t come here with that narrative because you just end up looking stupid.


r/kpopthoughts • • Jul 21 '22

Discussion J-Hope's solo debut made me realize the obvious gap of popularity and fandom support between BTS members

0 Upvotes

Now I get it, some members are inevitably more popular than others (looking at you maknae line), but recently the gap has been more obvious after Hobi's solo debut.

Jack in the Box is a fire ass album. It's been critically acclaimed by musical experts, journalists and outsiders. Hobi has been promoting it non-stop, posting almost new content everyday. He's worked so hard on it and I'm especially proud of him headlining Lolla.

Numbers wise though, the math ain't mathin. The album sales are low, the views for MORE and Arson are low and his recent content (vlog, visualizers, W Korea cover, etc) are not as hyped up as the other member announcements. You can tell the hyped died down post-release. He made an appearance yesterday at the stationhead listening party and only got 33K listeners (vs Butter listening party with 200k - now I know I shouldn't compare against group activities but the gap is just insane lol)

As a comparison, JK's L&R and Jimin's OST already reached 100M streams on Spotify, JK Stay Alive is the most streamed song of 2022, JK reached 20 monthly listens, L&R already reached 100M views on Youtube... hell BH even released a physical CD for the Snoop Dogg collab and gave Hobi a QR code lol. I'm aware these are not official solo debuts so not quite a fair comparison but the similarity is these numbers are backed by army support.

I feel bad because he's been working all day and night for this album (even RM said in his live he's literally been living in the studio) but the fandom is not giving the same energy back. I'm sure he doesn't gaf about the numbers (as he should) but in general it looks like fandom, who are charts and numbers obsessed, doesn't either lol

Forgot to mention: BH announcing the Snoop collab in the middle of his promo lol

Sad reality


r/kpopthoughts • • May 21 '22

Appreciation I think it’s time to admit that NMIXX are the best gg performers in the entire industry right now

0 Upvotes

There are many ggs who are great dancers. There are many ggs who are great vocalists. But how many do you know that are absolutely top tier in both categories? How many do you know that have some of the toughest choreography of any gg and still choose to sing live every single time? How many do you know that can cover a bg song and make you forget you’re not watching a bg dance?

Their kcon performances are opening a lot of eyes and rightfully so. It’s insane to me that these girls debuted only a few short months ago but are literally raising the bar when it comes to performance in this industry. The best time to get on the Nmixx hype train was leading up to their debut. The second best time is now. Don’t sleep on these girls now bc they will be HUGE in the future mark my words.

Edit: to the people downvoting me in silence stop being cowards and at the very least offer a counter argument

Edit 2: y’all I just got invited to a Reddit community for the most controversial Reddit users bc this post is apparently the most controversial post in all of Reddit over the past hour? I’m literally dead 😂


r/kpopthoughts • • Apr 25 '26

Appreciation BigHit groups have been killing it so far this year

46 Upvotes

I saw a recent post where the poster said they had been disappointed with releases from HYBE groups this year so far. I was surprised to see it, because I had just been talking to a kpop friend irl about how I've had the exact opposite experience. All of the 2026 releases from BigHit groups in particular have been killing it for me, and after a few years, I finally feel excited to see what will be coming from kpop again.

First we had Arirang, which is one of the best full albums I've heard out of kpop in a while. Body to Body, Hooligan, FYA, 2.0, Merry Go Round, Normal, and Like Animals have been going platinum in my bedroom (and, looking at the streams, outside of it).

Then TXT released The 7th Year, which was again a great album from start to finish. I hadn't been feeling the last few TXT releases as much as their earlier ones, but this album felt like a true return to their classic dreamy, atmospheric form.

And then Cortis released Redred. Most songs don't connect with me on first listen, but on rare occasions, I can hear a song one time and know immediately that it will be a hit. Some previous examples include Crazy by LSF, Supernova by aespa, and Bite Me by Enhypen. I was pretty mixed on Cortis' debut album, but Redred immediately sounded like a hit to me. Its streams increasing every day since it was released is a good indication that my hunch was right. It's my kpop soty so far!

Tbh, the last couple years in kpop had made me so bored that I was considering just moving on and finding a new hobby, like reading books or applying for grad school. I'd like to offer my sincere appreciation to BigHit groups for coming through to help keep me stupid. Thanks BTS, TXT, and Cortis!


r/kpopthoughts • • Sep 08 '24 Heartwarming Third Place Celebration Heart of Silver

Appreciation Really impressed with NewJeans' dancing at TMA

0 Upvotes

I just found this video of NewJeans performing at TMA, and I am so impressed with their dance breaks. They are all so good at dancing. I feel like NewJeans were always good dancers, but they are just on another level since Get Up era and I am so proud of them. Their stage presence has improved too and their vocals also sound really good (though they are likely edited)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Y41JybAaLU


r/kpopthoughts • • Oct 08 '24

Discussion Why are people so obsessed with putting hybe and their groups down?

87 Upvotes

I will just start this off by saying I took a long break from kpop, at the time I stopped listening, pledis hadn’t been bought out by hybe yet.

Now that I’ve gotten back into kpop, I’ve just noticed a lot of people just hate on hybe, and their groups a weird amount? It seems like a lot of the posts I see about hybe or their groups just get downvoted these days.

So I was mostly wondering why on earth people insist on hating everything hybe groups do so much.

Edit: just saying it so people don’t keep saying it, I’m not Stan of any hybe group. I listen to some music, but I’m not an active fan of any of the groups. I’m not trying to be like ‘oh poor hybe’ or ‘oh poor x group’


r/kpopthoughts • • May 16 '22

Thought it’s kinda suspicious that the year BTS was supposed to tie justin bieber for his 6 year win streak of Top Social Artist they remove it from the award roster…

5 Upvotes

(not hate to justin bieber btw) now it’s self explanatory but if you didn’t know the BBMAS removed the Top Social Artist award from their award roster therefore it’s no longer an award,now from 2011 when the award was first introduced to 2016 justin bieber won TSA (top social artist) every year until 2017 when BTS won it for the first time blocking justin’s streak and BTS have won TSA every year from 2017 to 2021 but this year they mysteriously took it off the roster when BTS was gonna tie justin for his 6 year win streak. Now call me superstitious but it’s odd seeing as justin has had his past run ins with accusations of having award shows rigged in his favor sooo it would align tbh but idk let me know your opinions or stances on it i’d love to hear them :) edit:this also ties into BB getting rid of the whole social artist chart just bc it was majority kpop groups and the whole AleXa situation with the BBMAS which are both very disappointing (P.S. Congrats to BTS for breaking Destiny’s Child’s record for group with most BBMA awards!!)


r/kpopthoughts • • Aug 19 '23

Discussion I still don’t get the hype around Queencard

0 Upvotes

Yes, it’s catchy. But my god, is it infuriating.

Please don’t come for me, I love how unique GIdle are and it’s so rare to see a female artist like Soyeon who is so involved in their groups song writing. Hwaa is my favourite GIdle song by far.

I just find the lyrics, the English ones in particular to be the worst.

The song should be called ‘Queen car’ surely because the ‘D’ is unheard the whole way through the song. Any time I hear it, I picture a car with a crown on, and I can’t unhear it.

Also, I am a woman and I can confirm we have boobs plural. Yes, I do have a favourite boob, as I imagine most women do, but if I was singing about them, I’d definitely mention them both.

And, for the love of god I beg you, please don’t get me started on Tomboy.

I just feel like they’d really benefit from either having an English speaker just check over the lyrics first for them, or going back to more Korean led songs. Soyeon’s Korean rap is the source of all fire on planet earth in my opinion.

Please don’t attack me, I am genuinely a fan, but I feel like it’s important to still be able to comment on what frustrates us with the artists we like.

Edit and update: turns out my Kpop thought isn’t original and has been posted in this sub before, meaning that it isn’t valid for some reason. I am a casual fan and listener of Kpop and I don’t spend an awful lot of time in this subreddit, or engaging with other Kpop fans and some of the responses on this post have reiterated to me why :(

Thank you to the people who corrected me and explained to me some stuff I wasn’t aware of in the song. Thank you to the people who saw I wasn’t trying to disrespectful to GIdle and engaged in interesting discussions. I really appreciate your input and thank you very much.

I don’t think I could’ve made it any clearer in my post that I like GIdle very much, and I am obviously aware that if I don’t like something I don’t need to listen to it, but I am still entitled to an opinion, and to post my thoughts the same way others do in this sub, regardless if others have done the same before.

I have always been a Reddit/internet lurker for my whole life and only recently plucked up the courage to start interacting with communities but I think I’m done now, or at least will take a break. I will go back to enjoying my interests from afar for at least some time. Peace out and chill out homies ✌🏻


r/kpopthoughts • • May 03 '24

General It's fascinating how BabyMonster have managed to completely change people's opinion about them in just a few weeks.

0 Upvotes

I have been following their journey since the first teasers dropped in early 2023 and let's just say they didn't get a very warm reception, especially on Reddit. They were getting the Blackpink treatment without an actual large fandom to defend them. Everything was an issue even pre-debut according to highly upvoted comments and posts: they were too young, their group name was too cringe, they were too similar to their seniors and so forth.

Then Ahyeon had to take a hiatus due to health issues, but of course everyone started having random theories about the reasons for her absence. 'Batter Up' only made things worse, and it was pretty much very doom and gloom around here for BabyMonster fans (myself included). Any positive remarks about them or their music were downvoted and calling them flops was an easy way of getting some free karma. 'Sheesh' teasers didn't improve the situation and the general sentiment was quite negative among the K-pop community.

'Sheesh' debuted at #296 on daily Melon charts, that's how bad it was. Yet here we are now, with the song being top-10 on all Korean charts and BabyMonster having great numbers across the board: sales, streaming, views, social media, fandom etc. In just a week they will be doing a 2-day fanmeeting in an arena.

And the most fascinating thing about this complete reversal of public opinion is that they haven't really done anything special. They just showcased that they were really good at their job, and that's it. They attended only 2 weekly music shows for 3 weeks, guested on a few variety programs and appeared on 2 radio shows. Arguably their promotions weren't as packed as most of their peers' - they didn't even do the usual myriad of TikTok challenges with other idols (including with their popular seniors). They sang the same song that a lot of people didn't like just a month ago. There was nothing extraordinary in their strategy or marketing, they literally just went out an won everyone over with their skills by performing and singing.

Not going to lie, after what felt like a year of them being a punching bag for K-pop fans, it's been really nice to witness them getting the well-deserved praise and acknowledgement. I can't help but feel a bit smug to see the haters not being able to find any reason to come after them. 'Overperforming'... seriously?

And what's even more exciting is that people giving them a chance has always been the biggest barrier. Not only K-pop fans, but also casual listeners dismissed them because of the reasons out of their control, but now that they got the public's attention, they are more than capable of utilizing it to the fullest. They are talented, extremely well-trained and ambitious. You can tell from the pre-debut content and the interviews after debuting that they are confident in their skills and have big goals. Coachella was mentioned by several members (and who knows, I wouldn't be surprised to see them there next year), their own tour etc.

They have Japanese and SEA members, Ahyeon speaks Mandarin, some of them speak proficient English, they are great live performers, they have a backing of a big company, they can sing, rap and dance. Despite the rough start of their career, I do believe that BabyMonster have everything they need to prove all doubters wrong. If YGE don't drop the ball with their discography and active schedules, they'll be more than ready to continue the tradition of YGE girl groups doing extremely well.


r/kpopthoughts • • Mar 14 '22

Thought It hurts me to know that I'll never get to be friends with Namjoon

4 Upvotes

Namjoon is my bias and i love him so much, and I wish I was his friend just for the conversations we would've had. Like he is such an interesting person, talking about arts, books, movies, song and lyrics structures... omg... I even feel like talking about life with him would be so EYE OPENING. You know those rare convos you have and then at the end you're like "WOW.. who am I?"🤣

I really like bonding with people on a spiritual and intellectual level, it really makes learn so much more about yourself and I feel Namjoon would be the key to all my doors💀 (sounding a little too dramatic here)

Anyways just a thought🤷🏾‍♀️


r/kpopthoughts • • Feb 24 '23

Appreciation NWJNS Hanni slayed at gucci fashion week + becoming a global ambassador

1 Upvotes

First of all i'm not surprised she did so well she seems like a very social person but she did look a bit nervous.

Her outfit looked good honestly i dont know much about fashions but i've seen worse form luxury brands.

Gucci announced her on twitter saying "it's brand ambassador" even on her way to the show she was wearing a gucci bag with her name printed on it

Her talking to asap rocky and him saying they need to do a campaign together.

She wa also seated first row beside the ceo of gucci and julia garner and halle bailey and he thanked her for coming and complimented her

She was also at the after party

Maybe it was her marie clair cover selling out or something but she seems to be treated very well rn as compared to the other members and their brands(chanel did give minji that whole welcome set though).

Overall she did so well it's crazy to think that six months ago she was a normal girl and now she's at fashion shows wearing luxury brands and talking to big names it probably must be so overwhelming in general. I know there's the whole nwjns dont fit their brands talk but i think she goes well with gucci