r/kpoprates • • Dec 01 '22

Rate [RATE] The 1st K-Pop subreddit song rate!

59 Upvotes

NEW UPDATE: In the spirit of the holidays, we have decided to extend the deadline! The new submission deadline is: January 3rd (Tuesday) by 11:59 PM PST (Compare your time zone here).

Hello everyone! This will be the very first K-Pop subreddit song rate, and we (u/Zypker125 and u/bigcatagenda) are excited to get things started here! (Make sure to join this subreddit to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


So, what is a rate?

Guide to Rates Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQ1SDlLZcpM

If you don't know what a rate is, basically users just assign a given list of songs scores from 1-10 (with one 0 and one 11 reserved for your least favourite and most favourite song, respectively). You're also welcome to include comments with your scores - just make sure you follow the hosts' directions on how to do so! Once all the scores have been collected, the hosts then do a reveal over a few days (usually the weekend) where the full ranking of all songs in the rate is revealed. More rules/clarifications are listed down below.

Rates have been conducted frequently on r/popheads (and semi-frequently on r/indiehads) for a long time. Here is r/popheads's Rate Wiki, archiving all the previous rates and recording all the statistics that come with them.

For those who want a more specific example, I'll link the most recent K-Pop rate on r/popheads: the 2021 K-Pop Essentials rate! Rate Announcement Thread ||| Day 1 Results Reveal ||| Day 2 Results Reveal ||| Day 3 Results Reveal


Is there a theme for this first rate?

Yes, our theme for this first rate is Best of K-Pop. The general goal of this 1st rate was to select the K-Pop subreddits' most highest-rated and highest-ranked songs of all time. There were a multitude of other factors that also were considered for this rate, though. For example, a maximum of 2 songs were chosen from each artist. We generally wanted to represent songs from a wide variety of artists, focusing more on the artists that are popular in the K-Pop subreddits, though some priority was also given to artists that are generally popular overall.

The primary system used for selecting songs was using the r/kpop Top Ten Tuesdays, as they are by far the most comprehensive community-based rankings for K-Pop songs in the K-Pop subreddits. We also used sources such as individual K-Pop artist subreddit surveys (if available) and the r/popheads K-Pop rates to try and pick out the best selection that we could.

But... where's this group or that song? Why is X in over Y? [etc.]?

As is always the case with "grab bag selection" rates, especially for rates like this with a wider scope/theme, it's impossible to curate a list that can fully satisfy everybody. 75 songs is nowhere nearly enough to represent all of the highly-acclaimed and well-loved K-Pop songs, and given the other factors we considered for the rate (ex. representation of artists popular on Reddit), a lot of songs just barely missed the cut. However, we took a lot of time in meticulously selecting this list of 75 songs, weighing the pros & cons of including each and comparing them to other possible contenders to put on the list. We consulted numerous rankings/ratings and reviewed the list multiples times, and while this certainly isn't the definitive "75 best songs of K-Pop", we believe it does a good job at representing that mission while simultaneously balancing other missions as well.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 75 songs that were selected for this rate:

  1. (G)I-DLE - Lion

  2. 2NE1 - I Am The Best

  3. Aespa - Next Level

  4. Apink - Eung Eung

  5. ATEEZ - Answer

  6. Baekhyun - UN Village

  7. Beast - Fiction

  8. Big Bang - Haru Haru

  9. Blackpink - As If It's Your Last

  10. Blackpink - Playing with Fire

  11. BoA - No. 1

  12. Brave Girls - Rollin

  13. Brown Eyed Girls - Abracadabra

  14. BTS - Blood Sweat and Tears

  15. BTS - Spring Day

  16. Chungha - Gotta Go

  17. DAY6 - Zombie

  18. Dreamcatcher - Deja Vu

  19. Dreamcatcher - Scream

  20. Enhypen - Drunk-Dazed

  21. Everglow - La Di Da

  22. EXID - Up & Down

  23. EXO - Call Me Baby

  24. EXO - Monster

  25. f(x) - 4 Walls

  26. fromis_9 - Love Bomb

  27. GFriend - Mago

  28. Girls' Generation - Genie

  29. Girls' Generation - Into The New World

  30. GOT7 - If You Do

  31. iKON - Love Scenario

  32. Infinite - The Chaser

  33. ITZY - Wannabe

  34. IU - Good Day

  35. IU - Twenty-Three

  36. IVE - Love Dive

  37. IZ*ONE - La Vie En Rose

  38. KARA - Step

  39. Key - Bad Love

  40. LE SSERAFIM - Antifragile

  41. LOONA - Star

  42. LOONA/Kim Lip - Eclipse

  43. Luna - Free Somebody

  44. Mamamoo - Hip

  45. Monsta X - Beautiful

  46. NCT 127 - Limitless

  47. NCT 127 - Superhuman

  48. NCT Dream - Hello Future

  49. NCT U - The 7th Sense

  50. NewJeans - Hybe Boy

  51. Oh My Girl - Closer

  52. Pentagon - Shine

  53. Red Velvet - Bad Boy

  54. Red Velvet - Psycho

  55. Seventeen - Rock With You

  56. Seventeen - Very Nice

  57. SHINee - Sherlock

  58. SHINee - View

  59. STAYC - So Bad

  60. Stray Kids - God's Menu

  61. Stray Kids - Miroh

  62. Sunmi - Pporappippam

  63. Taemin - Criminal

  64. Taemin - Move

  65. Taeyeon - INVU

  66. TVXQ - Mirotic

  67. Twice - Fancy

  68. Twice - Feel Special

  69. TXT - 9 and 3/4 (Run Away)

  70. TXT - Lovesong

  71. VIXX - Error

  72. Wanna One - Energetic

  73. Winner - Really Really

  74. WJSN - Secret

  75. Wonder Girls - Why So Lonely

Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist

Apple Music playlist


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 9.9 is fine, but 9.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also very encouraged but not required for such scores.

  • Please be sure to submit your scores using the prepared message format linked here, it makes it infinitely easier for us to record your scores using the rate machine program.

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

2NE1 - I Am The Best: 10 They said it themselves, they are indeed the best!

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • DO NOT SABOTAGE! Hopefully this shouldn’t be a problem as we trust you guys (famous last words) but we reserve the right to reject your ballot + ask you to change your scores and/or leave comments, especially for scores on the low end. Ultimately, please just rate all of the songs truthfully – this will make the whole process a lot easier and more fun for everyone involved!

  • You have three methods of making a submission: one, you can use message link to message it to u/KpopRates. Two, you can make a copy of this Google Docs template to your Google Drive. Three, you can copying this pastebin into a Reddit message. (Keep in mind that private messages on Reddit have a character limit, so if you are the type to write long comments, don't use the 1st option, use Google Docs or Pastebin instead.) If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).

  • If you want to change scores or add comments at any point, don't hesitate to message this Reddit account (u/KpopRates), or send us a modmail on the r/KpopRates subreddit!


DUE DATE:

Saturday, December 31st, Tuesday, January 3rd, by 11:59 PM PST - Make sure to submit your rate before this date! (You can also ask for a deadline extension by messaging u/KpopRates, although we cannot guarantee that we will grant you an extension.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveal posts will take place on this subreddit, so make sure to join this subreddit during these dates):

Day 1 - January 7th (Saturday) at 2 PM PST

Day 2 - January 8th (Sunday) at 2 PM PST

Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist

Apple Music playlist

LINK TO PRIVATE MESSAGE TO SEND IN SCORES


Looking for more help!

Ideally, we would like to continue doing K-Pop rates in the future. However, K-Pop rates take a lot of effort and time to host, and we're currently just a two-person team. Therefore, if you all want to see rates continue to be conducted, it is important that we get more helpers & people willing to host rates! For those interested in helping out, all information can be found here on this r/kpoprates post. Additionally, feel free to send a modmail to the r/kpoprates team and/or message u/Zypker125 if you're interested in helping out on future rates!


r/kpoprates • • Sep 09 '25

Rate The Dreamcatcher Rate!

42 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We’re excited to announce that we’ll be taking an in-depth look at the years-long, genre-spanning career of Dreamcatcher! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts.)

Quick Links:

How the songs were selected:

We looked at Dreamcatcher's results from the r/kpop TTTs over the years, and also held a discography survey on r/Dreamcatcher to gauge how fans comprehensively felt about the discography. Then, to finalize the rate selections, we held a feedback survey on r/KpopRates.

Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 42 songs (& 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically:

.

2017

Chase Me

Good Night

Fly High

Sleep-walking

2018

Full Moon

You And I

Mayday

What

Wonderland

July 7th

2019

Piri

And There Was No One Left

Deja Vu

Silent Night

2020

Scream

Red Sun

Black or White

Jazz Bar

In The Frozen

Boca

Break The Wall

Can't Get You Out Of My Mind

2021

Odd Eye

Wind Blows

Poison Love

BEcause

Whistle

2022

Locked Inside A Door

Maison

Starlight

Entrancing

Vision

Fairytale

2023

Reason

Bonvoyage

Demian

Propose

OOTD

Rising

Shatter

2024

Justice

Fireflies

.

Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is basically an extension of the main rate! There were several songs that received high praise during the songlist feedback survey but just missed making the main rate, so we put them into the bonus rate here to give them a chance to be rated.

.

Wake Up

Diamond

Breaking Out

The Curse of the Spider

Sahara

New Days

Stomp!

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list. If you do it, you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.

Playlist Links:

Spotify playlist

Apple Music playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)

Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Maison: 8.5 Save my song in the rate list!

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average; once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}

SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

* Link to Reddit Chat to message a ballot

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates.

If you do choose to message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).

* Google Docs ballot template

* Pastebin ballot template

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to both the rate hosts, u/Zypker125 and u/RBSun. You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 prediction form at any time.

DUE DATE:

Monday, October 13th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - October 18th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - October 19th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing First Half of 2025 Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Jan 25 '23

Rate [RATE] The K-Pop B-side Battles Rate!

41 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We're excited to announce that the second rate is officially underway, the B-side Battles Rate! We (u/Zypker125, u/MeijiDoom, and u/Past_Opportunity7344) are excited to get things started here! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


How the B-sides were selected:

Similar to our first rate, my (Zypker125's) goal is to select the "best" B-sides according to the K-Pop Reddits, while balancing another mission of representing the most popular artists on r/kpop and r/kpopthoughts, using the most recent censuses as sources.

I primarily used the r/kpop Top Ten Tuesdays to make this songlist: I first looked at the "Top B-sides of the Year" TTTs (which have been ran every year since 2017) to crowdsource the top B-sides. I also looked at individual artist TTTs to figure out what the most well-liked B-side(s) from each artist were. I also consulted individual K-Pop artist subreddit surveys if I could find them, and various other posts/threads on the topic. If there still wasn't a clear pick based on the TTTs, I became the last-resort tiebreaker and picked which song to include the list.

Additionally, we had two feedback threads on r/kpoprates where I sourced feedback from the r/kpoprates community on what changes they would like to see made to the songlist, and I used the suggestions from the public to change several of the songs in the songlist.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 50 B-sides that were selected for this rate:

Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (Audio-only version)

Youtube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also very encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Kep1er - MVSK: 7.2 Mashiro if you're ever free on a Saturday night, my phone number is 669-

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • DO NOT SABOTAGE! Hopefully this shouldn’t be a problem as we trust you guys (famous last words) but we reserve the right to reject your ballot + ask you to change your scores and/or leave comments, especially for scores on the low end. Ultimately, please just rate all of the songs truthfully – this will make the whole process a lot easier and more fun for everyone involved!

  • If you want to change scores or add comments at any point, don't hesitate to message this Reddit account (u/KpopRates)!

NEW Rules:

  • For this rate as well as for most future rates moving forward, we will be imposing a ballot average minimum (ie. the average score of your ballot must be above a certain threshold for us to accept it). For this rate and most rates, we will be imposing a ballot average minimum of 4.50. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.50-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}

  • For this rate, if you use a 0, you are required to leave a comment next to the song you gave a 0. Since a 0 is a powerful score/statement to give, we want to see why people gave songs 0s.


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template


DUE DATE:

Tuesday, February 28th, by 11:59 PM PST (Last day of February) - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveal posts will take place on r/kpoprates, so make sure to join the subreddit during these dates):

Day 1 - March 4th (Saturday) at 2 PM PST (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - March 5th (Sunday) at 2 PM PST (Time zone converter here)


Looking for more help!

Ideally, we would like to continue doing K-Pop rates in the future. However, K-Pop rates take a lot of effort and time to host, and we're currently a very small team. Therefore, if you all want to see rates continue to be conducted, it is important that we get more helpers & people willing to host rates! For those interested in helping out, all information can be found here on this r/kpoprates post. Additionally, feel free to send a modmail to the r/kpoprates team and/or message u/Zypker125 if you're interested in helping out on future rates!


r/kpoprates • • Jun 17 '25

Rate The 2nd Grab Bag Rate!

40 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We, your hosts u/Zypker125, u/kawaii_mokona and u/kirakiranatsu are excited to start the sequel to the most chaotic, voted fan favorite, the 1st K-Pop Grab Bag Rate, this time aptly titled The 2nd K-Pop Grab Bag Rate!


Quick Links:

Deadline: July 28th (Monday), 11:59 Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

This rate was entirely user-submitted by the public filling in the Google Form on our subreddit! Since our raterbase has increased since last year, we have placed restrictions on who got the songs in. 2 slots have been allocated to the most active participants of r/kpoprates (hosts, people who have participated in most rates since last Grab Bag Rate, Top 5/Bottom 5 predictions as well as those who have participated in our Discord Spotlight of the Week activity).


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs that were selected for this rate!

If you want to read the comments submitters left for their songs, you can read them here

First, we'll go over the songs by "submitters who want to have their names revealed with their songs at the start", ordered reverse alphabetically by submitter's username and then reverse alphabetically by the artist's name:

.

SongSubmitter
Luhan - Luu/Zypker125
DK - LTNSu/YeyeDumpling
Seola - Without Uu/snowswinters
BoA - L.O.V.Eu/snowswinters
Bewave - Hard to get to youu/SkylarV
Playback - Playbacku/ruhroh386
TAN - Heartbeatu/redalert30
AKMU - RE-BYEu/rbsun
Everglow - Don't Speaku/Randummonkey
LABOUM - Shooting Loveu/popularsong
Fantasy Boys - Feelingu/popularsong
NCT Wish - Skateu/ohsomeday_
JAY - BLUE MOONu/necromanta_101
Mamamoo - Yes I Amu/naegerowwa
Jay Park (ft. pH-1, BIG Naughty, Woodie Gochild, HAON, TRADE L, Sik-K) - The Purgeu/naegerowwa
QWER - run! run! run!u/MurkyGalaxies
ME:I - Sugar Bombu/MurkyGalaxies
T-ARA - Why Are You Being Like This?u/msargent24
Seventeen - Wateru/MartialST
Young Posse - OTBu/MartialST
Touched - Highlightu/laulite
The KingDom - Black Crownu/laulite
Infinite - Man In Loveu/kirakiranatsu
NINE.i - BEAUTY iNSIDEu/ke1per
Ampers&One - On And Onu/ke1per
Jonghyun ft. Younha - Love Beltu/Jennywren2323
Han Young Ae - Anybody there?u/imzhongli
BAE173 - get him UGHu/ieatbe
G-Dragon (ft. Missy Elliott) - Niliriau/ganos-b-thanondorf
WOODZ - Bustedu/flawedconstellation
9Muses - Koong Chit Dak Chitu/CheesesPriced
Kim Jung Mi - It’s Rainingu/aidshha
Fei - Fantasyu/aidshha
N.O.M - I'm not butu/1998tweety

Next, we'll go over the songs by "submitters who wish to only have their names revealed with their songs during results-reveal weekend". These are ordered alphabetically:

.


* Spotify playlist (2 songs missing!)

* Apple Music playlist (2 songs missing!)

* Youtube MV Ver.

* Youtube Audio Ver.

* Youtube Lyrics Ver.


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

HDnG - 4Shadows: 10 this is the modern masterpiece that proves that small groups do not need big budgets to put out fantastic songs like this one!

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • DO NOT SABOTAGE! Hopefully this shouldn’t be a problem as we trust you guys (famous last words) but we reserve the right to reject your ballot + ask you to change your scores and/or leave comments, especially for scores on the low end. Ultimately, please just rate all of the songs truthfully – this will make the whole process a lot easier and more fun for everyone involved!

  • If you want to change scores or add comments at any point, don't hesitate to message this Reddit account (u/KpopRates)!

  • For this rate specifically, we have a ballot average minimum of 3.50. In addition, if your ballot average is between 3.50-4.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}

  • For this rate, if you use a 0, you are required to leave a comment next to the song you gave a 0. Since a 0 is a powerful score/statement to give, we want to see why people gave songs 0s.


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Reddit Chat to send in scores

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates.

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to either of the rate hosts: @Zypker124, @kawaii_mokona or @kirakiranatsu.

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).


DUE DATE:

Tuesday, July 28th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - August 2nd (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - August 3rd (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing "Early Gen 3" Girl Groups Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Feb 25 '26

Rate The Second Half of 2025 Rate!

39 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to revisit some of the biggest songs from the latter half of last year with the "Second Half of 2025" Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links:

Deadline for this rate is Sunday, March 29th, by 11:59 PM Pacific (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)


How the songs were selected:

Using r/kpop's Upcoming Monthly Releases as a starting point, we created a tentative song list of notable releases from the second half of the year. We did this by examining multiple factors: the number of upvotes the MV release received on r/kpop, how many streams a song achieved on Spotify, the overall popularity of an artist/group both in the wider K-pop sphere and on Reddit, and the general balance we usually aim to achieve for a rate.

Following this, we conducted a pre-survey period on our Discord server, before hosting the usual feedback survey on r/kpoprates in order to decide the final song list.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (and 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by release date:

July

AHOF - Rendezvous

ILLIT - Jellyous

Xdinary Heroes - FiRE (My Sweet Misery)

Super Junior - Express Mode

VIVIZ - La La Love Me

NOWZ - Everglow

ATEEZ - In Your Fantasy

BLACKPINK - Jump

TWICE - This Is For

NCT Dream - Chiller

Lee Chanhyuk - Endangered Love

ifeye - r u ok?

Purple Kiss - Doremi

WayV - Big Bands

TXT - Beautiful Strangers

XngHan&Xoul - Waste No Time

August

xikers - Iconic

BoA - Crazier

KiiiKiii - Dancing Alone

Yves (ft. PinkPantheress) - Soap

CORTIS - Go!

Key - Hunter

Jeon Somi - Closer

NCT WISH - Surf

AtHeart - Plot Twist

Monsta X - Do What I Want

Stray Kids - Ceremony

IVE - XOXZ

September

ZEROBASEONE - Iconik

aespa - Rich Man

Haechan - CRZY

CORTIS - FaSHioN

Dayoung - Body

Chaeyoung - Shoot (Firecracker)

XG - GALA

October

Yerin Baek - Mirror

Babymonster - We Go Up

TWS - Overdrive

NMIXX - Blue Valentine

MEOVV - Burning Up

Hwasa - Good Goodbye

BOYNEXTDOOR - Hollywood Action

Hearts2Hearts - Focus

LE SSERAFIM (ft. j-hope) - Spaghetti

&TEAM - Back To Life

November

XLOV - Rizz

SUNMI - Cynical

Yeonjun - Talk To You

JUSTB - True Heart

ITZY - Tunnel Vision

CRAVITY - Lemonade Fever

CLOSE YOUR EYES - X

GIRLSET - Little Miss

Allday Project - One More Time

Baby DONT Cry - I Don't Care

RIIZE - Fame

ILLIT - Not Cute Anymore

RESCENE - Bloom

Stray Kids - Divine

December

VERIVERY - Red (Beggin')


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is a selection of host picks! We wanted to showcase some of our favourite, less popular songs released in the later half of 2025.

JO YURI - Farewell For Now

ONE PACT - Yes, No, Maybe

AMPERS&ONE - That's That

KickFlip - Band-Aid

IRISÉ - Love Game

Kim Lip - Can You Entertain?

Xdinary Heroes - ICU

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

Apple Music playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

ifeye - r u ok?: 9.5 me when i see someone give my favourite song their 0

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Reddit Chat to send in scores

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates_ghost.

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to all of the rate hosts, @_melizard (u/pollutedrain), @kawaii_mokona (u/kawaii_mokona), and @ame_zim (u/AmeZim) (please message all of the rate hosts, not just one).

There is also a Google Sheets Spreadsheet Template that you can make a copy of to calculate the averages of your scores.

You can also submit the top/bottom 5 prediction form at any time.


DUE DATE:

Sunday, March 29th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/j3wCF43x)

Day 1 - April 4th (Saturday), 7 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - April 5th (Sunday), 7 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing Female Soloists Album Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • May 26 '25

Rate The "Early Gen 3 Girl Groups" Rate!

39 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to take a trip back in time to revisit some K-Pop classics once again, continuing with this rate, the "Early Gen 3" Girl Groups Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links:

Deadline: July 7th (Monday), 11:59 Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Top Ten Tuesdays results to grab the most adored songs from each of the artists on Reddit, and we also had a songlist feedback survey on /r/kpoprates to help decide the songlist!


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 55 songs (& 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically for each artist (artists were also ordered by debut date):

.

Spica:

Russian Roulette

You Don’t Love Me

EXID:

Every Night

Up & Down

Ah Yeah

Hot Pink

Night Rather Than Day

DDD

I Love You

HelloVenus:

Wiggle Wiggle

I’m ill

Mysterious

Crayon Pop:

Bar Bar Bar

AOA:

Miniskirt

Short Hair

Like a Cat

Heart Attack

Good Luck

10 Seconds

Excuse Me

FIESTAR:

One More

You’re Pitiful

Ladies’ Code:

Pretty Pretty

Galaxy

The Rain

BESTie:

Love Options

Excuse me

Mamamoo:

Piano Man

You’re the Best

Décalcomanie

Starry Night

Egotistic

Wind Flower

Gogobebe

HIP

Laboum:

Journey to Atlantis

Hwi Hwi

Lovelyz:

Ah-Choo

Destiny

WoW!

Now, We

That Day

Sonamoo:

Friday Night

GFriend:

Me Gustas Tu

Rough

Navillera

Fingertip

Time For The Moon Night

Apple

Mago

Brave Girls:

Deepened

Rollin’

We Ride

Chi Mat Ba Ram

After We Ride

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is basically an extension of the main rate! There were several songs that received high praise during the songlist feedback survey that still were barely not able to make the main rate, so we have put them into the bonus rate here to give them a chance to be rated.

.

EXID - Lady

HelloVenus - Venus

Crayon Pop - FM

Fiestar - Mirror

Ladies’ Code - Bad Girl

Laboum - Between Us

GFriend - Labyrinth

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Hip: 2.4 Ofc the title track that utilizes Mamamoo's vocal power the least ends up becoming the most popular (yells angrily at cloud)

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give comments for individual artists! Just write your comment after the :, such as the following:

EXID: Are they pronounced like "exit" or are you supposed to say every letter separately? I'll never know

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

* Link to Reddit Chat to message a ballot

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/KpopRates_Ghost.

* Google Docs ballot template

* Pastebin ballot template

Google spreadsheet template that you can use to calculate averages, record scores, and make predictions

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to both the rate hosts, @Zypker124 and @aidshha.

You can also submit the top/bottom 5 prediction form at any time.


DUE DATE:

Monday, July 7th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/4YY2ksBbT6)

Day 1 - July 12th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - July 13th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Sep 30 '25

Rate The "2022 in K-pop" Rate!

38 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to do another retrospective year-in-review rate, finally wrapping up the 2020s with the "2022 In K-Pop" Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links:

Deadline: November 3rd (Monday), 11:59 PM Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

We used various stats to decide which songs to add to the rate, (ex. r/kpop's Top Songs of 2022 TTT results, Reddit upvote numbers, Spotify streaming numbers, etc.), and we also had a songlist feedback survey on /r/KpopRates to help decide the songlist!


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (and 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by release date:

.

January:

GOT The Beat - Step Back

Kep1er - Wa Da Da

WOOAH - Catch the Stars

Enhypen - Blessed-Cursed

fromis_9 - DM

Yena (ft. BIBI) - Smiley

February

VIVIZ - Bop Bop!

Taeyeon - INVU

Treasure - Jikjin

STAYC - RUN2U

NMIXX - O.O

Billlie - GingaMingaYo (the strange world)

Rocket Punch - Chiquita

March

Tempest - Bad News

i-dle - Tomboy

Solar - Honey

Stray Kids - Maniac

Red Velvet - Feel My Rhythm

April

Kwon Eunbi - Glitch

BIGBANG - Still Life

IVE - Love Dive

Onew - Dice

Psy (ft. Suga of BTS) - That That

May

LE SSERAFIM - Fearless

TXT - Good Boy Gone Bad

B.I X Soulja Boy (ft. DeVita) - BTBT

Astro - Candy Sugar Pop

Seventeen - Hot

June

aespa - Illusion

BTS - Run BTS

Kep1er - Up!

Nayeon - Pop!

Sunmi - Heart Burn

July

j-hope - More

WJSN - Last Sequence

aespa - Girls

ITZY - Sneakers

NewJeans - Attention

CSR - Pop? Pop!

ATEEZ - Guerrilla

August

NewJeans - Hype Boy

Girls' Generation - Forever 1

Blackpink - Pink Venom

IVE - After Like

Twice - Talk That Talk

September

Blackpink - Shut Down

NCT 127 - 2 Baddies

October

Seulgi - 28 Reasons

Stray Kids - Case 143

Kwon Eunbi - Underwater

i-dle - Nxde

LE SSERAFIM - Antifragile

Jin - The Astronaut

tripleS - Generation

November

BIBI - BIBI Vengeance

KARA - When I Move

December

RM (ft. Youjeen) - Wild Flower

NCT Dream - Candy

NewJeans - Ditto

ATEEZ - Halazia

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is a selection of host picks! We wanted to represent some of the lesser-popular gems from 2022:

.

MAMADOL - WooAh HIP

JUSTB - RE=LOAD

Seventeen - _WORLD

Jaehyun - Forever Only

Youha - Last Dance

Kang Daniel (ft. PH-1 and WDBZ) - Nirvana

P1Harmony - Back Down

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list. If you choose to do so, you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

Apple Music playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

aespa - Illusion: 3.2 "You're so yummy yummy yummy in my tummy tummy tummy" Okay but what if I'm not into vore

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Reddit Chat to send in scores

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates_ghost.

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to all of the rate hosts, @pollutedrain (u/pollutedrain), @solsys (u/RBSun), and @Zypker124 (u/Zypker125) (please message all of the rate hosts, not just one).

There is also a Google Sheets Spreadsheet Template that you can make a copy of to calculate the averages of your scores.

You can also submit the top/bottom 5 prediction form at any time (ie. even without submitting your ballot!).


DUE DATE:

Monday, November 3rd, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/j3wCF43x)

Day 1 - November 8th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - November 9th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific Time zone converter here


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing Dreamcatcher Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Aug 11 '25

Rate The First Half of 2025 Rate!

37 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to rate some of the biggest songs of the year so far with the "First Half of 2025" Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)

Deadline for this rate is Monday, September 15th, by 11:59 PM Pacific (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Upcoming Monthly Releases to comb through all K-Pop releases from the second half of the year. From there, we examined multiple factors: how many upvotes the MV received on r/kpop, how many Spotify streams a song has, how popular the artist is overall and on Reddit, overall balance, and several other factors.

Once a tentative songlist was decided, we have asked for feedback on our Discord server and have later hosted a songlist feedback thread on /r/kpoprates. The feedback from this survey was weighed alongside the aforementioned statistics to determine the final songlist!


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (and 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by release date:

.

January:

BOYNEXTDOOR - If I Say, I Love You

Gfriend - Season of Memories

BSS - CBZ (Prime Time)

IVE - Rebel Heart

GOT7 - Python

ZEROBASEONE - Doctor! Doctor!

Minnie - Her

CIX - Thunder

February:

IVE - Attitude

ALL(H)OURS - Gimme Gimme

Lisa (ft. Doja Cat and RAYE) - Born Again

Chungha - Stress

Jisoo - Earthquake

ONF - The Stranger

Jennie (ft. Doechii) - ExtraL

Hearts2Hearts - The Chase

KiiiKiii - I Do Me

G-Dragon (ft. Anderson .Paak) - Too Bad

March:

NMIXX - High Horse

Jennie - Like JENNIE

Seulgi - Baby, Not Baby

Yeji - Air

LE SSERAFIM - Hot

NMIXX - Know About Me

The Boyz - VVV

STAYC - Bebe

Ten - Stunner

Beomgyu - Panic

JUSTB - Chest

April:

Close Your Eyes - All My Poetry

Mark - 1999

Kep1er - Yum

NCT WISH - poppop

UNIS - Swicy

Chuu - Only cry in the rain

Kai - Wait On Me

MEOVV - Hands Up

Katseye - Gnarly

May:

Tablo (ft. RM) - Stop the Rain

TXT - Love Language

P1Harmony - DUH!

Jin - Don’t Say You Love Me

i-dle - Good Thing

SHINee - Poet | Artist

Red Velvet Irene & Seulgi - Tilt

Seventeen - Thunder

June:

Enhypen - Bad Desire (With or Without You)

Itzy - Girls Will Be Girls

ARTMS - Icarus

ATEEZ - Lemon Drop

j-hope (ft. GloRilla) - Killin’ It Girl

XLOV - 1&Only

ILLIT - Billyeoon Goyangi (Do the Dance)

HUNTR/X - Golden

Katseye - Gabriela

Saja Boys - Soda Pop

Saja Boys - Your Idol

Allday Project - Famous

fromis_9 - Like You Better

aespa - Dirty Work

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is a selection of host picks! We wanted to represent some of the lesser-popular gems from 2024 so far, and we hope that it will be a fun dive!

.

PLAVE - Dash

ONE PACT - 100!

NouerA - N.I.N (New Is Now)

ME:I - Muse

Xdinary Heroes - Beautiful Life

from20 - Eye Candy

Younite - Rock Steady

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Saja Boys - Soda Pop: 9.5 Wait, guys, isn’t Feel the Pop a 2024A song?

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Reddit Chat to send in scores

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates_ghost.

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to both the rate hosts, @kawaii_mokona and @kirakiranatsu.

There is also a Google Sheets Spreadsheet Template that you can make a copy of to calculate the averages of your scores.

You can also submit the top/bottom 5 prediction form at any time.


DUE DATE:

Monday, September 15th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/j3wCF43x)

Day 1 - September 20th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - September 21st (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing Early Gen 3 Boy Groups Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Apr 08 '25

Rate Neo Culture Rate!

37 Upvotes

Hello everyone! The day has finally arrived and we over at r/kpoprates are celebrating NCT's debut anniversary with the best activity we can think of: rating each unit's most iconic and beloved tracks and figuring out which one will wear the pearl neo champagne crown. It is time for Neo Culture Rate a.k.a NCT Rate and we are your hosts, u/kawaii_mokona and u/pollutedrain !


Quick Links:

Important Note: Reddit is replacing Private Messages (PMs) with Reddit Chat, so our submission process going forward is going to be affected. Read instructions below (under the rules) or feel free to ask in the comments!

Deadline: Monday, May 12th, by 11:59 PM Pacific (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)


How the songs were selected:

We used r/kpop 's Top Ten Tuesday results for NCT, NCT U, NCT 127, NCT Dream and WayV, then looked at r/NCT's favorite tracks by each unit (here is the most recent post with links to previous ones) and finally held an additional songlist feedback survey over on r/kpoprates to determine the final songs to round up the rate as well as the bonus tracks.


Songlist

Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (and the 6 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered by unit debut date, release date and then tracklist order:

.

NCT U

The 7th Sense

Without You

Boss

Baby Don't Stop

Yestoday

Make A Wish (Birthday Song)

Faded in My Last Song

90's Love

OK!

Round&Round

Baggy Jeans

Pado

NCT 127

Fire Truck

Limitless

Back 2 U (AM 01:27)

Cherry Bomb

Touch

Regular (English Ver.)

Simon Says

Superhuman

Highway to Heaven (English Ver.)

Kick It

Love Song

Punch

Sticker

Love on the Floor

Skyscraper

Fact Check

Walk

NCT Dream

Chewing Gum

My First and Last

We Go Up

Boom

Déjà Vu

Dive Into You

Hello Future

Life Is Still Going On

Dreaming

Teddy Bear

Candy

Broken Melodies

ISTJ

Poison

WayV

Take Off

Moonwalk

Love Talk (English Ver.)

Turn Back Time

After Midnight

Domino

Nectar

Kick Back

Action Figure

On My Youth

Poppin' Love

Frequency

NCT Dojaejung

Perfume

NCT Wish

Wish (Korean Ver.)

Songbird (Korean Ver.)

Steady

NASA

.

Bonus Rate

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating. Bonus rate songs were songs by each unit that barely missed the main rate.

NCT U - Misfit

NCT 127 - Sun & Moon

NCT Dream - Better Than Gold

WayV - Give Me That

NCT Dojaejung - Kiss

NCT Wish - Hands Up

.


Playlist Links

* Spotify playlist

* Spotify playlist (songs in release order)

* YouTube playlist (MV version)

* YouTube playlist (Audio version)

* YouTube playlist (Colorcoded Lyrics version)


RULES:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0). You cannot give scores from 0.1 to 0.9 as well as 10.1 to 10.9.

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

ISTJ: 9.8 Wow, they actually made a song about my MBTI type? Thank you, kings!

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also add a comment for a specific unit, by typing it in the "ARTIST: [unit]:" line, like so:

Artist: NCT U: Does U in NCT U stand for You? Are we also finally NCT members?


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Reddit Version (quick)

  1. Go to Pastebin and press "Copy"

  2. Click on Reddit Chat link to message u/kpoprates_ghost

  3. Paste your ballot template from Pastebin into the chat box and add your scores as instructed by the rules in section above.

  4. Send and wait for confirmation!

Note: if you plan on adding comments (more than just for your 0), we HIGHLY encourage you to create your own Google Doc/Pastebin/any other text sharing platform copy of the Ballot Template and share a link with us, as it helps us process scores. PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise))

Discord Version

  1. Be a member of our Discord Server (and you should be, it's a great place to discuss K-pop)

  2. Find one of the rate hosts, u/kawaii_mokona or u/pollutedrain (same usernames on the server)

  3. Direct message either of them your ballot (either a link to it or a .txt file).

Reddit link where you need to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Google Spreadsheets you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions: 01_NEO_Ver., 02_CULTURE_Ver., 03_TECHNOLOGY_Ver.

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


DUE DATE:

Monday, May 12th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - May 17th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - May 18th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Nov 24 '24

Rate SHINee Solo Albums Rate

37 Upvotes

Welcome to SHINee Solo Slayage a.k.a SHINee Solo Albums Rate!


Deadline

[NEW] January 8th @ 7AM UTC (in your timezone)

Ballot Link | Google Doc | Spotify | Youtube Audio | Youtube Lyrics


SHINee's back back back back back! This time they are continuing to be absolute trailblazers not only in choreography, fashion and performance but also on r/kpoprates where they are paving the way and are featured in our very first album rate, solo-hosted by yours truly u/kawaii_mokona . And what is a better way to start than to celebrate SHINee's artistry and rate some of the finest albums that were released by each member? From 2016 to just a few weeks before the rate start. We will be covering five full length albums by each SHINee member, with each helmed by their larger than life singles and backed by a stellar selection of some of their finest b-sides.

I've included links to each individual album separately if you wish to listen to them out of the chronological order! Feel free to comment on cohesiveness and flow of each record in album comments (read the rules to check how)! Now, let's get acquainted, shall we?


Taemin - Press It - The 1st Album [2016]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

A year and a half after his explosive debut with Ace and its single Danger Taemin gave mere mortals Press It. In late 2024 we have Bruno Mars shaking up Korean charts with APT., and back in 2016 it was another Bruno Mars's offering, Press Your Number, that was shaking up K-pop fans all around the world. One does not simply judge an album by its title track as Press It alternates between groovy and upbeat Drip Drop, Guess Who and Sexuality, haunting Mystery Lover, classic R&B numbers like Until Today, One By One as well as Jonghyun-penned Already, and last but not least we have ballad-leaning album closer Hypnosis and Soldier written by Taemin himself. Throughout the years, the album has held up impressively against Taemin's later discography by the virtue of dipping into timeless genres and is perhaps one of the underdiscussed releases save for the centerpieces, hence why I am excited to have raters pick it apart today.

When faced with a tough choice of which album to pick between Taemin's offerings to the world, I chose Press It after consulting Taemin's Top Ten Tuesdays as well as having this as an opportunity to rate songs that have not had the opportunity yet and singles that might be overshadowed by the later releases.

Tracklist:

  1. Drip Drop

  2. Press Your Number

  3. Soldier

  4. Already

  5. Guess Who

  6. One By One

  7. Mystery Lover

  8. Sexuality

  9. Until Today

  10. Hypnosis


Jonghyun - She Is - The 1st Album [2016]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

What hasn't been said about this 2016 masterpiece? An absolute rarity of pop music brilliance meeting personal songwriting that has come out of the spiritually pink building of SM Entertainment. Embodying a lovesick persona and playing up to the sweetness and slyness of his character, Jonghyun is in his element all throughout the record from its dancefloor moments on She Is and White T-Shirt all the way to Orbit and Suit Up's sensuality and all the little bits and pieces that he is toying with on the five equally standing out songs in-between. A Cocktail of electro-funk and contemporary R&B that is happy to Dress Up into the Red-hot mature themes and shed the "idol" label that a member from a popular boy group has to irrevocably deal with. It is perhaps one of the most acclaimed, universally praised and beloved albums in K-pop and needless to say fills me with delight to have it featured.

Tracklist:

  1. She Is

  2. White T-Shirt

  3. Orbit

  4. Moon

  5. Aurora

  6. Dress Up

  7. Cocktail

  8. Red

  9. Suit Up


Key - Killer - The 2nd Album Repackage [2023]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

From upbeat and sunshine-like of She Is we skip 6 years forward to have a moment with the only repackage on the list and the honor belongs to none other than Killer/Gasoline. With its futuristic b-sides that would not look out of place on Bad Love (Bound, Another Life), more introspective Key's own lyrical contributions (G.O.A.T, I Can't Sleep and Proud) and Halloween-esque Villain. Key also masterfully makes use of the album's length and taps into all sorts of R&B as per SM traditions, but he also doesn't forget shades of electropop, synthwave and even rock sounds.

Gasoline/Killer is the only case where I've decided to choose a follow-up full length album for a multitude of reasons: the original album is Reddit's highest rated album by a male artist of 2022 (9th overall) and Killer left its mark as 4th highest rated song by a male artist in 2023 (29th overall). Compared to Face, more of Gasoline/Killer's b-sides ranked higher on Key's Top Ten Tuesdays. It makes Killer the only track on the rate to be rerated but such change was also made because of last minute addition of Minho to the rate.

Tracklist:

  1. Killer

  2. Heartless

  3. Gasoline

  4. Bound

  5. Villain (ft. Jeno of NCT)

  6. Easy

  7. Burn

  8. Guilty Pleasure

  9. G.O.A.T (Greatest Of All Time)

  10. I Can't Sleep

  11. Ain't Gonna Dance

  12. Another Life

  13. Delight

  14. Proud


Onew - Circle - The 1st Album [2023]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

What can be described as the underdog of the rate (with the profound balladphobia omnipresent) is by no means the weakest album of the five. An intentional stepping stone for his future work, Circle features none of Onew's own songwriting (which would change on his first mini album Flow following his departure from SM Entertainment) instead opting for contributions from various songwriters and directing the process of album creation nonetheless. The shining gem of Circle is its title track leading the performance-like tracklist. From Kim Eana's brilliant songwriting establishing the key narrative of passing of the seasons, the rest of songs on the album gently guide listeners through a cycle of loneliness, hope, doubt and comfort in difficult times making it an incredibly cohesive experience that fully blossoms through engaging with its lyricism.

Tracklist:

  1. O (Circle)

  2. Cough

  3. Rain On Me

  4. Caramel (ft. Giriboy)

  5. Anywhere

  6. Paradise

  7. Expectations

  8. No Parachute

  9. Walk With You

  10. Always


Minho - Call Back - The 1st Album [2024]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

Last, but certainly not the least, is Minho's Call Back. The album that was not on the list during this rate's inception in early 2024, but who has had to make the list to complete the puzzle much like Chase completed SHINee's plagiarism series in 2022. As commented by the man himself, compared to Chase where he held most of the control over album's creation, SM handles most of the album direction this time around and no matter the commentary on the agency's decisions... The result is a tight, laidback and fantastically groovy selection of songs that packs quite the surprising bounce in its midsection and may surprise a listener unfamiliar with Minho's solo output. Continuing with the features we got 2 more, this time from lovely main vocalists, Sohee and Ningning.

While the recency bias may be called into question, I believe the rate would not be complete if I had omitted Call Back entirely and with how little attention this has sadly gathered outside of Shawol community, it felt fitting to use this rate as an opportunity to showcase it to a wider audience as well!

Tracklist:

  1. Call Back

  2. Slow Down

  3. Fireworks (ft. Sohee of RIIZE)

  4. Came And Left Me

  5. Something About U

  6. Round Kick

  7. Affection

  8. I Don't Miss You

  9. Because Of You (ft. Ningning of aespa)

  10. Would You Mind


Rules

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message to add the remaining scores.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! IMPORTANT: if you give song a 0 you MUST give a comment on it.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Don't use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!!

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except when you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score. If you like to write a lot, REFRAIN FROM PARAGRAPH BREAKS. You can comment on a song like so:

Call Back: 9.9 Yeah, but when are YOU calling ME back, Choi Minho?

  • This above is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give a comment for each album rated by adding a colon after the "Album: [albumname]", like so:

Album: She Is: Jonghyun is so humble, because I would have added "Perfection" after the album title.

  • Remember when I said Halloween rate will be the only rate with no minimum average? Well, I lied, so there is no minimum average score here either. I will, however, ask though that you participate in the rating process diligently and score songs fairly.


SUMMARY:

Dates:

You can apply for a 24-hour extension if you let me know beforehand (at least a day before the deadline) (DM u/kawaii_mokona or u/kpoprates_ghost)

Reveals will take place on r/kpoprates as well as, of course, our lovely Discord server where the main live chat is held and we as a community listen to songs, look at the state of art slideshows and participate in various guessing games!

Submission Links:

Playlists:

Various options how you can participate (pick and cho-o-o-o-o-ose):

  1. Send your scores via Private Message to u/kpoprates_ghost

  2. Send the link to your Google Doc Ballot to u/kpoprates_ghost : just delete the ballot in the PM Ballot link and put your gdoc link there instead! (don't forget to double check the permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document")

  3. Send the link/txt file as it's linked on Discord (you can find me on our server)

You should ALWAYS get a confirmation that your ballot is accepted/sent back for edits. If you haven't received a message: let me know on Discord or DM u/kawaii_mokona or u/kpoprates_ghost).

And when you think this post is over I hit you with this ✨ link ✨ to our dedicated Google Form for this rate's top 5 and bottom 5 predictions! and this ✨ link ✨ if you want to make a spreadsheet and record your scores and full list predictions!


Also encouraging you to participate in the ongoing The "2019 in K-pop" Rate! (Deadline is December 16th)


r/kpoprates • • Jan 20 '25

Rate Japanese Songs Rate!

36 Upvotes

皆さん、こんにちは! (Hello everyone!)

It's our (u/kawaii_mokona & u/MurkyGalaxies) great pleasure to announce the first rate all about an often overlooked category of kpop releases, the Japanese release!

Deadline for this rate is Wednesday, 24 February 2025, by 07:59 AM UTC. (Time zone converter)


Playlists: Spotify | YouTube (MV) | YouTube (Audio) | YouTube (Lyrics)

Note: Some songs in playlists or songlist below may be region-locked. Try one of the different playlist options below if a song doesn't work, or try looking up the song on your streaming service of choice.


How the songs were selected (and "Why isn't %songname% here?"):

We have consulted Japanese Songs TTT as well as artists' individual TTTs. We also went through Oricon sales to see the artists' best performing Japanese albums as well as their Spotify streaming numbers. Lastly, we have gathered feedback from the members of our Discord server and held a Songlist Feedback Survey (join the community and our very friendly and active Discord server if you want to participate in these and have more input!).


さあ、始めましょう! (Let's begin!) .

After School - Shh

AOA - Ai Wo Choudai (ft. Takanori Nishikawa)

Baekhyun - Get You Alone

Billlie - Domino ~ Butterfly Effect

BoA - Masayume Chasing

BoA - Valenti

BTS - Don't Leave Me

CNBLUE - In My Head

DAY6 - Breaking Down

Dreamcatcher - Don't Light My Fire

EXO - Electric Kiss

EXO-CBX - Ka-Ching

F.T.ISLAND - Shadows

Girls' Generation - Mr. Taxi

Girls' Generation - Paparazzi

ITZY - Ringo

IVE - Wave

IZ*ONE - Suki to Iwasetai

KARA - Go Go Summer!

Kep1er - Straight Line

Kep1er - tOgether fOrever

LOONA - Hula Hoop

MISAMO - Funny Valentine

NCT 127 - Chain

NCT 127 - End to Start

NCT Dream - Moonlight

NewJeans - Supernatural

OnlyOneOf - chrOme arts

Red Velvet - Sappy

Red Velvet - Wildside

Seventeen - 24H

Seventeen - Call! Call! Call!

SHINee - 1000 Years, Always Be By My Side

SHINee - Password

STAYC - Poppy

Stray Kids - Social Path (ft. LiSA)

Super Junior - Blue World

Taemin - Sayonara Hitori

TVXQ - Android

TVXQ - Bolero

TVXQ - Why Did I Fall In Love With You?

Twice - Breakthrough

TWICE - Perfect World

TXT - Everlasting Shine

U-Kiss - Tick Tack

WayV - Deep Ocean

Yena - DNA

Younha - Houkiboshi

Yuta - Prisoner

ZEROBASEONE - Yura Yura

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate this time consists of 3 picks from each host. .

Chen - Free World

IVE - Classic

tripleS - Untitled

Le Sserafim - Jewelry

MONSTA X - X-Phenomenon

xikers - Tsuki (Lunatic)

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating. If you don't, please keep the bonus section of your ballot intact as it helps the processing!


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Please do not use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!!

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! IMPORTANT: if you give song a 0 you MUST give a comment on it.

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Kep1er - tOgether fOrever: 9.0 I wish they'd stayed together forever...

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate only, there is not going to be a ballot average minimum. We will, however, ask though that you do not give each song the same score and participate in the rating process diligently and scoring songs fairly.


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/kpoprates_ghost. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise). Also for this rate you can DM the host (kawaii_mokona on Discord with your ballot).

DUE DATE:

Tuesday, 25 February 2025, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, we will accept extensions only if notified beforehand and only for a maximum of 24 hours. (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord)

Day 1 - March 1st (Saturday), 4 PM UTC (Time zone converter)

Day 2 - March 2nd (Sunday), 4 PM UTC (Time zone converter)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing 1st K-Pop Soloists Rate!! (The deadline is February 3rd) Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Nov 11 '24

Rate The "2019 in K-Pop" Rate!

36 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to do another year-in-retrospect rate, this time doing a 5-year-retrospective with the "2019 in K-Pop" Rate!


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Top Ten Tuesdays results to grab the most acclaimed songs from 2019, and we also had songlist feedback threads on /r/KpopRates to help decide the songlist! We wanted to focus more on artist representation this rate and include more K-Pop artists that we have never rated before (ex. Yukika, SF9, Sulli, X1, Yerin Baek and more!).


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (& 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by release date:

.

January:

Chungha - Gotta Go

N.Flying - Rooftop

Apink - Eung Eung

ONEUS - Valkyrie

GFriend - Sunrise

ATEEZ - Say My Name

Astro - All Night

CLC - No

February:

Taemin - Want

ITZY - Dalla Dalla

Dreamcatcher - Piri

Hwasa - Twit

LOONA - Butterfly

Yukika - Neon

Sunmi - Noir

March:

TXT - Crown

Everglow - Bon Bon Chocolat

Taeyeon - Four Seasons

Stray Kids - Miroh

Pentagon - Sha La La

April:

IZ*ONE - Violeta

Blackpink - Kill This Love

BTS (ft. Halsey) - Boy With Luv

Twice - Fancy

May:

Oh My Girl - The Fifth Season (SSFWL)

Weki Meki - Picky Picky

A.C.E - Under Cover

AB6IX - Breathe

NCT 127 - Superhuman

CLC - Me

June:

fromis_9 - Fun!

SF9 - RPM

Red Velvet - Zimzalabim

Stray Kids - Side Effects

(G)I-DLE - Uh-Oh

Sulli - Goblin

July:

Baekhyun - UN Village

DAY6 - Time of Our Life

CIX - Movie Star

Woosung - Face

NCT Dream - Boom

ITZY - Icy

August:

X1 - Flash

September:

Seventeen - Fear

Dreamcatcher - Deja Vu

Twice - Feel Special

AKMU - How Can I Love The Heartbreak, You’re The One I Love

October:

SuperM - Jopping

ATEEZ - Wonderland

TXT - Run Away (9 and Three Quarters)

WayV - Moonwalk

(G)I-DLE - Lion

November:

GOT7 - You Calling My Name

WayV - Love Talk (English Version)

Mamamoo - Hip

IU - Blueming

WJSN - As You Wish

EXO - Obsession

December:

Yerin Baek - Square (2017)

Red Velvet - Psycho

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate composes of songs that we couldn't include in the main list, but wanted to see rated in some capacity!

.

Jus2 - Focus On Me

DALsooobin - Katchup

PinkFantasy - Fantasy

The Boyz - D.D.D

DAY6 - Sweet Chaos

Youngjae - Forever Love

OnlyOneOf - Sage

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

Youtube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Yerin Baek - Square (2017) 9.9 Song is so good that it got sent 2 years into the future just so it could make this rate

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).

Also, if you like, we have a spreadsheet for the rate to calculate averages and a Top/Bottom 5 Predictions Google Form you can submit ahead of time!


DUE DATE:

Monday, December 16th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/4YY2ksBbT6)

Day 1 - December 21st (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - December 22nd (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Jul 22 '25

Rate The "Early Gen 3 Boy Groups" Rate!

35 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to take another trip back in time to revisit some K-Pop classics once again, continuing with this rate, the "Early Gen 3" Boy Groups Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links:

Deadline: August 25 (Monday), 11:59 PM Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Top Ten Tuesdays results to grab the most adored songs from each of the artists on Reddit, and we also had a songlist feedback survey on /r/kpoprates to help decide the songlist!


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 54 songs (& 6 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically for each artist (artists were also ordered by debut date):

.

VIXX:

On and On

Voodoo Doll

Error

Chained Up

Dynamite

Fantasy

The Closer

Shangri-La

Scentist

GOT7:

Just Right

If You Do

Hard Carry

Look

Lullaby

Page

You Calling My Name

Winner:

Empty

Don’t Flirt

Sentimental

Really Really

Fool

UNIQ:

EOEO

N.Flying:

The Real

Hot Potato

Rooftop

Moonshot

Blue Moon

Monsta X:

Trespass

Hero

Beautiful

Dramarama

Jealousy

Who Do U Love?

Love Killa

Gambler

Beautiful Liar

DAY6:

Congratulations

I Wait

You Were Beautiful

I Need Somebody

Shoot Me

Days Gone By

Time of Our Life

Zombie

Love Me or Leave Me

UP10TION:

Blue Rose

Attention

iKON:

Rhythm Ta

Dumb & Dumber

Bling Bling

Love Scenario

Killing Me

Why Why Why

But You

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is basically an extension of the main rate! There were several songs that received high praise during the songlist feedback survey that still were barely not able to make the main rate, so we have put them into the bonus rate here to give them a chance to be rated.

.

VIXX - Love Me Do

GOT7 - You Are

Winner - Love Me Love Me

N.Flying - 4242

Monsta X - Shoot Out

DAY6 - Afraid

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

Apple Music playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Dumb & Dumber: 9.8 finally, someone wrote a song about me and my best friend

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give comments for individual artists! Just write your comment after the :, such as the following:

GOT7: Finally a group with a number in the name that hasn't actually lost a single member

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

* Link to Reddit Chat to message a ballot

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates.

* Google Docs ballot template

* Pastebin ballot template

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to both the rate hosts, @Zypker124 and @kawaii_mokona and @pollutedrain.

You can also submit the top/bottom 5 prediction form at any time.


DUE DATE:

Monday, August 25th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - August 30th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - August 31st (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Apr 29 '25

Rate The "2024 in B-sides" Rate

35 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We've explored the singles of K-Pop in 2024, but given that K-Pop has thousands of B-sides released every year, we wanted a chance to rate some of the most acclaimed B-sides of 2024, so we have our "2024 in B-sides" Rate! (if you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to stay tuned for the future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links:

Deadline: June 2nd (Monday), 11:59 Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

The songs were decided through a combination of r/kpop's B-sides of 2024 TTT results, as well as the songlist feedback survey we conducted on r/KpopRates!.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 50 songs in the main rate (& the 5 songs in the bonus rate) that were selected for this rate, sorted by reverse alphabetical order:


.

ZEROBASEONE - Insomnia

Yves - DIM

Younha - Antmill

Yena - Good Girls in the Dark

xikers - Supercalifragilistic

Xdinary Heroes - Undefined

Wendy - His Car Isn't Yours

TXT - I'll See You There Tomorrow

tripleS - 24

The Boyz - Bite Back

Taeyong - Moon Tour

Taemin - Deja Vu

Stray Kids - I Like It

STAYC - 1 Thing

Seventeen - Cheers to Youth

Seola - Let's Talk (Loneliness)

RESCENE - Pinball

P1Harmony - Last Call

ONEWE - Shoot It Out

NMIXX - Run For Roses

NMIXX - Boom

NCT Dream - Box

NCT 127 - Pricey

Loossemble - Cotton Candy

LE SSERAFIM - 1-800-hot-n-fun

Kiss of Life - Igloo

Kep1er - Flowers, Flutter, Your heart

Jin (ft. Wendy) - Heart on the Window

Jaehyun - Can't Get You

j-hope (ft. Huh Yunjin) - i don't know

IVE - Ice Queen

IVE - Blue Heart

IU (ft. Hyein and Joe Wonsun) - Shh...

ITZY - Mr. Vampire

ILLIT - Tick-Tack

Hui (ft. Jinhyuk) - Cold Killer

Fifty Fifty - Gravity

Enhypen - Moonstruck

Dreamcatcher - 2 Rings

Doyoung - Beginning

DAY6 - Happy

Cravity - C'est La Vie

Chungha - I'm Ready

Babymonster - Like That

ATEEZ - Selfish Waltz

ARTMS - Butterfly Effect

aespa - Live My Life

aespa - Flowers

&Team - Deer Hunter

(G)I-DLE - Fate


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is basically an extension of the main rate! It is a collection of host selections, as well as feedback survey favorites that couldn't quite make the main rate!

.

Xdinary Heroes - Money On My Mind

Key - Overthink

KAVE - Umm Umm Umm

Babymonster - Woke Up In Tokyo

aespa - Spark (Winter solo)

.


* Spotify Playlist

* YouTube Playlist (Audio Version)

* YouTube Playlist (Lyrics Version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Don't use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0). You can add them to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Stray Kids - I Like It: 2.1 I do not

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Google Spreadsheet you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and message it to u/KpopRates.

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


DEADLINE:

June 2nd (Monday), 11:59 Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Link to a timezone converter)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - June 7th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - June 8th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Apr 12 '25

Rate Statistics The 2024 Year in Review Stats - 'First Half + Second Half' Combined Results!

35 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Today I'm here to do something a little different: I'm here to put one final bow on 2024 in K-Pop by doing the year in review stats, combining our First Half results with our Second Half results and comparing them to the Top Ten Tuesdays results!


"All" Results:

Next, let's take a look at what would happen if we ranked the 2024 songs by average score in the rates!

RankSongScore
1aespa - Supernova8.728
2aespa - Whiplash8.566
3Red Velvet - Cosmic8.412
4NCT 127 - Walk8.053
5ITZY - Imaginary Friend7.948
6Lucy - The Knight Who Can't Die and The Silk Cradle7.939
7Kiss of Life - Midas Touch7.918
8RIIZE - Impossible7.886
9IVE - Accendio7.867
10aespa - Armageddon7.839
11ARTMS - Virtual Angel7.813
12NMIXX - Dash7.804
13fromis_9 - Supersonic7.773
14ONF - Bye My Monster7.761
15ARTMS - Butterfly Effect7.757
16Ten - Nightwalker7.746
17Kep1er - Shooting Star7.733
18IVE - Heya7.689
19ONEWE - Shoot It Out7.674
20Rescene - Love Attack7.548
21Nayeon - ABCD7.504
22KAVE - Stone7.459
23Yena - Nemonemo7.447
24Billlie - Trampoline7.444
25P1Harmony - Sad Song7.420
26Xdinary Heroes - Boy Comics7.373
27ILLIT - Magnetic7.351
28tripleS - Girls Never Die7.349
29LE SSERAFIM - Crazy7.341
30Xdinary Heroes - LOVE and FEAR7.334
31Loossemble - TTYL7.305
32ZEROBASEONE - Good So Bad7.247
33Lisa (ft. Rosalía) - New Woman7.243
34Purple Kiss - On My Bike7.205
35Cravity - Love or Die7.189
36ALL(H)OURS - Shock7.187
37Dreamcatcher - Justice7.161
38TWS - hey! hey!7.147
39Rosé (ft. Bruno Mars) - APT.7.142
40Enhypen - Brought the Heat Back7.141
41Doyoung - Little Light7.133
42Baekhyun - Pineapple Slice7.087
43XG - Howling7.077
44Twice - I Got You7.075
45Twice (ft. Megan Thee Stallion) - Strategy7.063
46ZEROBASEONE - Sweat7.053
47TXT - Deja Vu7.050
48Yves - Viola7.044
49Yuta - Off The Mask7.024
50DPR IAN - Saint7.015
51QWER - T.B.H6.996
52Stray Kids - Chk Chk Boom6.994
53WayV - She A Wolf6.973
54ICHILLIN' - Official6.963
55BOYNEXTDOOR - Earth, Wind & Fire6.912
56IU - Love wins all6.906
57P1Harmony - Killin' It6.842
58aespa (Karina solo) - UP6.841
59Irene - Like a Flower6.801
60Fifty Fifty - SOS6.746
61One Pact - Deserved6.738
62DAY6 - Welcome to the Show6.733
63STAYC - GPT6.723
64Taemin - Sexy In The Air6.719
65Jennie - Mantra6.715
66ITZY - Untouchable6.701
67TWS - Last Festival6.687
68ATEEZ - Work6.686
69Jaehyun - Smoke6.678
70The Boyz - Trigger6.675
71BIBI - Bam Yang Gang6.664
72Onew - Yay6.660
73Yves (ft. Lil Cherry) - Loop6.658
74NMIXX - See that?6.653
75ILLIT - Cherish (My Love)6.646
76Cravity - Now or Never6.644
77TXT - Over The Moon6.601
78TWS - Plot Twist6.597
79TRI.BE - Diamond6.578
80(G)I-DLE - Super Lady6.564
81VANNER - Jackpot6.541
82Kiss of Life - Sticky6.524
83VIVIZ - Shhh!6.520
84NCT Dream - When I'm With You6.492
85Twice - One Spark6.489
86Loossemble - Girls' Night6.485
87LE SSERAFIM - Smart6.450
88Mark (ft. Lee Youngji) - Fraktsiya6.442
89AB6IX - Grab Me6.386
90Young Posse - Ate That6.305
91WOOAH - Blush6.272
92ATEEZ - Ice On My Teeth6.248
93FTISLAND - Aqua (Korean Version)6.227
94Young Posse - XXL6.222
95BOYNEXTDOOR - Nice Guy6.219
96Rosé - toxic till the end6.152
97KATSEYE - Touch6.133
98NewJeans - How Sweet6.129
99RM - Lost!6.082
100LE SSERAFIM - Easy6.061
101VCHA - Girls of the Year6.057
102XG - Woke Up6.008
103RIIZE - Love 1195.990
104(G)I-DLE - Wife5.944
105G-Dragon (ft. Taeyang and Daesung) - Home Sweet Home5.924
106Zico (ft. Jennie) - Spot!5.914
107Enhypen - XO (Only If You Say Yes)5.885
108Babymonster - Drip5.824
109Wendy - Wish You Hell5.767
110STAYC - Cheeky Icy Thang5.766
111EVNNE - Ugly5.765
112Seventeen - Maestro5.710
113Chungha (ft. Hongjoong) - Eenie Meenie5.703
114Tzuyu - Run Away5.696
115BADVILLAIN - Badvillain5.683
116Jin - Running Wild5.680
117Yuqi - Freak5.665
118Lisa - Rockstar5.568
119Babymonster - Forever5.538
120Taeyong - Tap5.524
121(G)I-DLE - Klaxon5.272
122Treasure - King Kong5.103
123Yeonjun - GGUM5.103
124NCT Dream - Smoothie5.096
125Stray Kids (ft. Charlie Puth) - Lose My Breath5.033
126Stray Kids - Walkin On Water5.016
127G-Dragon - Power5.005
128Seventeen (ft. DJ Khaled) - Love, Money, Fame4.808
129ITZY - Gold4.647
130izna - IZNA4.639
131V - FRI(END)S4.636
132Jimin - Who4.615
133Babymonster - Sheesh4.313
134MEOVV - Meow4.295

Table formatting brought to you by ExcelToReddit


"Core" Results:

These results were calculated by only counting the ballots of the raters/Redditors who have submitted for BOTH the 'First Half of 2024' and 'Second Half of '2024' rates! This is the fairest way of comparing first half songs with second half songs.

In total, there were 44 raters who did both halves (https://pastebin.com/MhLxNiei). Here are the results of the ballots from the raters who did BOTH the First Half and Second Half rates:

RankSongCore Diff. in ScoreDiff. in Rank
1aespa - Supernova8.905 0.1770
2aespa - Whiplash8.423 -0.1430
3Red Velvet - Cosmic8.395 -0.0170
4NCT 127 - Walk8.311 0.2580
5Lucy - The Knight Who Can't Die and The Silk Cradle8.152 0.2131
6ONEWE - Shoot It Out8.113 0.43913
7NMIXX - Dash8.089 0.2855
8IVE - Accendio8.036 0.1691
9ARTMS - Virtual Angel7.986 0.1732
10Kep1er - Shooting Star7.934 0.2017
11RIIZE - Impossible7.918 0.032-3
12KAVE - Stone7.873 0.41410
13ITZY - Imaginary Friend7.843 -0.105-8
14Xdinary Heroes - LOVE and FEAR7.827 0.49316
15ONF - Bye My Monster7.823 0.062-1
16Kiss of Life - Midas Touch7.795 -0.123-9
17Ten - Nightwalker7.795 0.049-1
18ARTMS - Butterfly Effect7.757 0.000-3
19fromis_9 - Supersonic7.752 -0.021-6
20aespa - Armageddon7.670 -0.169-10
21IVE - Heya7.577 -0.112-3
22Billlie - Trampoline7.534 0.0902
23Xdinary Heroes - Boy Comics7.530 0.1573
24Yena - Nemonemo7.491 0.044-1
25Lisa (ft. Rosalía) - New Woman7.480 0.2378
26Rescene - Love Attack7.430 -0.118-6
27Purple Kiss - On My Bike7.411 0.2067
28TWS - hey! hey!7.391 0.24410
29Doyoung - Little Light7.389 0.25612
30P1Harmony - Sad Song7.386 -0.034-5
31Yuta - Off The Mask7.368 0.34418
32ZEROBASEONE - Sweat7.352 0.29914
33Nayeon - ABCD7.348 -0.156-12
34ALL(H)OURS - Shock7.339 0.1522
35tripleS - Girls Never Die7.325 -0.024-7
36Cravity - Love or Die7.282 0.093-1
37ZEROBASEONE - Good So Bad7.220 -0.027-5
38Dreamcatcher - Justice7.207 0.046-1
39QWER - T.B.H7.205 0.20912
40XG - Howling7.182 0.1053
41Baekhyun - Pineapple Slice7.170 0.0831
42Loossemble - TTYL7.170 -0.135-11
43Rosé (ft. Bruno Mars) - APT.7.084 -0.058-4
44DPR IAN - Saint7.027 0.0126
45LE SSERAFIM - Crazy6.995 -0.346-16
46P1Harmony - Killin' It6.989 0.14711
47Twice (ft. Megan Thee Stallion) - Strategy6.986 -0.077-2
48Stray Kids - Chk Chk Boom6.973 -0.0214
49VANNER - Jackpot6.912 0.37132
50Yves - Viola6.911 -0.133-2
51Twice - I Got You6.900 -0.175-7
52Yves (ft. Lil Cherry) - Loop6.889 0.23121
53ICHILLIN' - Official6.886 -0.0771
54WayV - She A Wolf6.885 -0.088-1
55BOYNEXTDOOR - Earth, Wind & Fire6.884 -0.0280
56Enhypen - Brought the Heat Back6.880 -0.261-16
57Mark (ft. Lee Youngji) - Fraktsiya6.880 0.43831
58TXT - Deja Vu6.827 -0.223-11
59ILLIT - Magnetic6.816 -0.535-32
60Onew - Yay6.788 0.12812
61ITZY - Untouchable6.775 0.0745
62Jaehyun - Smoke6.766 0.0887
63Cravity - Now or Never6.750 0.10613
64Jennie - Mantra6.716 0.0011
65TWS - Plot Twist6.698 0.10113
66TWS - Last Festival6.688 0.0011
67One Pact - Deserved6.683 -0.055-6
68(G)I-DLE - Super Lady6.661 0.09712
69Loossemble - Girls' Night6.659 0.17417
70NMIXX - See that?6.593 -0.0604
71TRI.BE - Diamond6.573 -0.0058
72The Boyz - Trigger6.555 -0.120-2
73IU - Love wins all6.539 -0.367-17
74Taemin - Sexy In The Air6.536 -0.183-10
75VIVIZ - Shhh!6.523 0.0038
76ATEEZ - Work6.518 -0.168-8
77ILLIT - Cherish (My Love)6.493 -0.153-2
78BIBI - Bam Yang Gang6.477 -0.187-7
79STAYC - GPT6.473 -0.250-16
80AB6IX - Grab Me6.467 0.0819
81aespa (Karina solo) - UP6.400 -0.441-23
82FTISLAND - Aqua (Korean Version)6.393 0.16611
83DAY6 - Welcome to the Show6.389 -0.344-21
84Fifty Fifty - SOS6.388 -0.358-24
85Irene - Like a Flower6.357 -0.444-26
86Rosé - toxic till the end6.336 0.18410
87NCT Dream - When I'm With You6.266 -0.226-3
88Young Posse - XXL6.252 0.0306
89EVNNE - Ugly6.245 0.48022
90Twice - One Spark6.177 -0.312-5
91Kiss of Life - Sticky6.168 -0.356-9
92Young Posse - Ate That6.118 -0.187-2
93VCHA - Girls of the Year6.111 0.0548
94BOYNEXTDOOR - Nice Guy6.105 -0.1141
95LE SSERAFIM - Smart6.086 -0.364-8
96(G)I-DLE - Wife6.080 0.1368
97WOOAH - Blush6.073 -0.199-6
98TXT - Over The Moon6.068 -0.533-21
99NewJeans - How Sweet6.055 -0.074-1
100ATEEZ - Ice On My Teeth5.941 -0.307-8
101RM - Lost!5.907 -0.175-2
102XG - Woke Up5.807 -0.2010
103G-Dragon (ft. Taeyang and Daesung) - Home Sweet Home5.770 -0.1542
104Wendy - Wish You Hell5.732 -0.0355
105KATSEYE - Touch5.673 -0.460-8
106LE SSERAFIM - Easy5.639 -0.422-6
107Seventeen - Maestro5.575 -0.1355
108RIIZE - Love 1195.555 -0.435-5
109Yuqi - Freak5.550 -0.1158
110Lisa - Rockstar5.518 -0.0508
111Babymonster - Drip5.514 -0.310-3
112Chungha (ft. Hongjoong) - Eenie Meenie5.461 -0.2421
113Jin - Running Wild5.430 -0.2503
114BADVILLAIN - Badvillain5.384 -0.2991
115Zico (ft. Jennie) - Spot!5.370 -0.544-9
116Taeyong - Tap5.332 -0.1924
117Treasure - King Kong5.307 0.2045
118Enhypen - XO (Only If You Say Yes)5.305 -0.580-11
119NCT Dream - Smoothie5.116 0.0205
120STAYC - Cheeky Icy Thang5.064 -0.702-10
121Tzuyu - Run Away5.052 -0.644-7
122Babymonster - Forever5.041 -0.497-3
123(G)I-DLE - Klaxon4.966 -0.306-2
124G-Dragon - Power4.964 -0.0413
125Stray Kids (ft. Charlie Puth) - Lose My Breath4.686 -0.3470
126Yeonjun - GGUM4.661 -0.442-3
127Stray Kids - Walkin On Water4.380 -0.636-1
128Seventeen (ft. DJ Khaled) - Love, Money, Fame4.359 -0.4490
129ITZY - Gold4.352 -0.2950
130Jimin - Who4.166 -0.4492
131V - FRI(END)S4.145 -0.4910
132izna - IZNA3.989 -0.650-2
133Babymonster - Sheesh3.925 -0.3880
134MEOVV - Meow3.850 -0.4450

Table formatting brought to you by ExcelToReddit

Biggest Increases from Original -> "Core" Results:

.

  • Xdinary Heroes - LOVE and FEAR (+0.493 average score, 16 rank increase)

  • EVNNE - Ugly (+0.480 average score, 22 rank increase)

  • ONEWE - Shoot It Out (+0.439 average score, 13 rank increase)

  • Mark (ft. Lee Youngji) - Fraktsiya (+0.438 average score, 31 rank increase)

  • KAVE - Stone (+0.414 average score, 10 rank increase)

  • VANNER - Jackpot (+0.371 average score, 32 rank increase)

  • Yuta - Off The Mask (+0.344 average score, 18 rank increase)

.

Biggest Decreases from Original -> "Core" Results:

.

  • STAYC - Cheeky Icy Thang (-0.702 average score, 10 rank decrease)

  • izna - IZNA (-0.650 average score, 2 rank decrease)

  • Tzuyu - Run Away (-0.644 average score, 7 rank decrease)

  • Stray Kids - Walkin On Water (-0.636 average score, 1 rank decrease)

  • Enhypen - XO (Only If You Say Yes) (-0.580 average score, 11 rank decrease)

  • Zico (ft. Jennie) - Spot! (-0.544 average score, 9 rank decrease)

  • ILLIT - Magnetic (-0.535 average score, 32 rank decrease)

  • TXT - Over The Moon (-0.533 average score, 21 rank decrease)

If you weren't included in the "core" raters for this 2024 project, make sure to watch out for the First Half and Second Half of 2025 rates and submit for them so you can be a part of this project!


Here is the link to the spreadsheet containing all the rankings, differences, statistics, and scores for this 2024 year in review!

That's all for now! Make sure to discuss your thoughts on the stats here! Do you prefer the Top Ten Tuesday results, the original rate results, or the core rater results?


r/kpoprates • • Jul 30 '24

Rate The "First Half of 2024" Rate!

35 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to rate some of the biggest songs of the year so far with the "First Half of 2024" Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)

Deadline for this rate is Tuesday, September 3rd, by 11:59 PM Pacific (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Upcoming Monthly Releases to comb through all K-Pop releases from the second half of the year. From there, we examined multiple factors: how many upvotes the MV received on r/kpop, how many Spotify streams a song has, how popular the artist is overall and on Reddit, overall balance, and several other factors.

Once a tentative songlist was decided, we also hosted a songlist feedback thread on /r/kpoprates, and we used the feedback from the thread/survey to decide the last songs of the rate.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (and the 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by release date:

.

January:

RIIZE - Love 119

ITZY - Untouchable

NMIXX - Dash

(G)I-DLE - Wife

EVNNE - Ugly

TWS - Plot Twist

IU - Love wins all

VCHA - Girls of the Year

(G)I-DLE - Super Lady

February:

Twice - I Got You

P1Harmony - Killin' It

BIBI - Bam Yang Gang

Ten - Nightwalker

LE SSERAFIM - Easy

TRI.BE - Diamond

Twice - One Spark

Cravity - Love or Die

Taeyong - Tap

March:

LE SSERAFIM - Smart

Chungha (ft. Hongjoong) - Eenie Meenie

Wendy - Wish You Hell

V - FRI(END)S

DAY6 - Welcome to the Show

Lucy - The Knight Who Can't Die and The Silk Cradle

Young Posse - XXL

ILLIT - Magnetic

NCT Dream - Smoothie

April:

Babymonster - Sheesh

QWER - T.B.H

TXT - Deja Vu

Kiss of Life - Midas Touch

ONF - Bye My Monster

WOOAH - Blush

BOYNEXTDOOR - Earth, Wind & Fire

Loossemble - Girls' Night

RIIZE - Impossible

Doyoung - Little Light

Yuqi - Freak

ZEROBASEONE - Sweat

Zico (ft. Jennie) - Spot!

IVE - Heya

Seventeen - Maestro

May:

tripleS - Girls Never Die

Stray Kids (ft. Charlie Puth) - Lose My Breath

aespa - Supernova

IVE - Accendio

XG - Woke Up

NewJeans - How Sweet

RM - Lost!

aespa - Armageddon

Treasure - King Kong

Yves (ft. Lil Cherry) - Loop

ARTMS - Virtual Angel

ATEEZ - Work

June:

BADVILLAIN - Badvillain

Kep1er - Shooting Star

TWS - hey! hey!

Nayeon - ABCD

Red Velvet - Cosmic

Lisa - Rockstar

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is a selection of host picks! We wanted to represent some of the lesser-popular gems from 2024 so far, and we hope that it will be a fun dive!

.

AB6IX - Grab Me

VANNER - Jackpot

ONEWE - Shoot It Out

ARTMS - Butterfly Effect

WayV - She A Wolf

Xdinary Heroes - Boy Comics

DPR IAN - Saint

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)

YouTube playlist (Lyrics version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Lisa - Rockstar: 7.4 When is she gonna teach me Japanese though, I'm waiting

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).


DUE DATE:

Tuesday, September 3rd, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/4YY2ksBbT6)

Day 1 - September 7th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - September 8th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing Survival Show Songs Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Feb 17 '25

Rate The "Second Half of 2024" Rate!

34 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to continue after the First Half of 2024 rate with the next rate, the "Second Half of 2024" Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links (for the rate veterans):

Deadline: Monday, March 24th, by 11:59 PM Pacific (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Upcoming Monthly Releases to comb through all K-Pop releases from the second half of the year. From there, we examined multiple factors: how many upvotes the MV received on r/kpop, how many Spotify streams a song has, how popular the artist is overall and on Reddit, overall balance, and several other factors. We also used the r/kpop "Best of 2024" TTT results to gauge what songs Reddit preferred in 2024.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 60 songs (and the 7 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by release date:

.

July:

Babymonster - Forever

Kiss of Life - Sticky

STAYC - Cheeky Icy Thang

ALL(H)OURS - Shock

(G)I-DLE - Klaxon

Xdinary Heroes - LOVE and FEAR

Dreamcatcher - Justice

Enhypen - XO (Only If You Say Yes)

NCT 127 - Walk

Jimin - Who

Stray Kids - Chk Chk Boom

Katseye - Touch

August:

Enhypen - Brought the Heat Back

fromis_9 - Supersonic

Lisa - New Woman (ft. Rosalía)

NMIXX - See that?

Taemin - Sexy In The Air

Young Posse - Ate That

ZEROBASEONE - Good So Bad

Jaehyun - Smoke

Rescene - Love Attack

LE SSERAFIM - Crazy

September:

Loossemble - TTYL

Baekhyun - Pineapple Slice

MEOVV - Meow

Tzuyu - Run Away

BOYNEXTDOOR - Nice Guy

Yeonjun - GGUM

P1Harmony - Sad Song

Yena - Nemonemo

October:

Yuta - Off The Mask

aespa - UP (Karina solo)

Jennie - Mantra

Billlie - Trampoline

Seventeen - Love, Money, Fame (ft. DJ Khaled)

ITZY - Gold

Rosé (ft. Bruno Mars) - APT.

aespa - Whiplash

ILLIT - Cherish (My Love)

Purple Kiss - On My Bike

ITZY - Imaginary Friend

The Boyz - Trigger

STAYC - GPT

G-Dragon - Power

November:

Babymonster - Drip

TXT - Over The Moon

VIVIZ - Shhh!

XG - Howling

NCT Dream - When I'm With You

Yves - Viola

ATEEZ - Ice On My Teeth

Jin - Running Wild

G-Dragon - Home Sweet Home (ft. Taeyang and Daesung)

ICHILLIN' - Official

izna - IZNA

Irene - Like a Flower

December:

Rosé - Toxic Till The End

Twice - Strategy (ft. Megan Thee Stallion)

Stray Kids - Walkin On Water

Mark - Fraktsiya (ft. Lee Youngji)

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is basically an extension of the main rate! It is a mixture of 'songs that came close to making the main rate' as well as some host selections!

.

F.T.ISLAND - Aqua (Korean Version)

Fifty Fifty - SOS

One Pact - Deserved

KAVE - Stone

TWS - Last Festival

Cravity - Now or Never

Onew - Yay

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


* Spotify playlist

* YouTube playlist (MV version)

* YouTube playlist (Audio version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Cheeky Icy Thang: 9.6 Okay boomer

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Google Spreadsheet you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


DUE DATE:

Monday, March 24th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - March 29th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - March 30th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Dec 31 '24

Rate The 1st K-Pop Soloists Rate!

34 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We are excited to take a trip back in time to dive into the founders of K-Pop, with the 1st K-Pop Soloists Rate! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


How the songs were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Top Ten Tuesdays results to grab the most adored songs from each of the artists on Reddit, and we also had a songlist feedback survey on /r/kpoprates to help decide the songlist!


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 42 songs (& 6 bonus songs) that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically for each artist:

.

BoA:

No.1

Atlantis Princess

Girls On Top

Hurricane Venus

Only One

Kiss My Lips

One Shot, Two Shot

Woman

Better

PSY:

Gangnam Style

Gentleman

Hangover (ft. Snoop Dogg)

Daddy (ft. CL)

Napal Baji

New Face

That That (ft. Suga)

Younha:

Password 486

Winter Flower (ft. RM)

Dark Cloud

Oort Cloud

Event Horizon

c/2022YH

J.Y. Park:

Swing Baby

Who's your mama?

Fever (ft. Superbee, BIBI)

Lee Hyori:

10 Minutes

U-Go-Girl (ft. Nassun)

Miss Korea

Taeyang:

Wedding Dress

Ringa Linga

Eyes, Nose, Lips

Jessi:

Nunu Nana

What Type of X

Zoom

Uhm Jung Hwa:

Poison

Invitation

Rain:

Rainism

La Song

Miscellaneous Artists:

So Chan Whee - Tears

Park Ji Yoon - Adult Ceremony

Baek Z Young (ft. Taecyeon) - Candy In My Ear

K.Will - Please don't...

.


Bonus Rate:

The bonus rate is basically an extension of the main rate! We wanted to give people a chance to explore even more artists that spearheaded the foundation of K-Pop, and we also included some fun wildcards into the mix!

.

Kim Jong Kook - Loveable

Son Dambi - Saturday Night

Outsider - Loner

Psy - It's Art

Park Hyo Shin - Wild Flower

Younha - Antmill

.

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.


Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

YouTube playlist (Audio version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0).

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

La Song: 8.1 I didn't realize Rain had a premonition for tripleS's discography

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give comments for individual artists! Just write your comment after the :, such as the following:

PSY: Everyone, it's time to bow down to the king of K-Pop

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).


DUE DATE:

Monday, February 3rd, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/4YY2ksBbT6)

Day 1 - February 8th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - February 9th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Jun 30 '26

Rate The 2nd All-Stars Rate!

32 Upvotes

Hello everyone! It's that time once again to have the battle of the titans by pitting the most acclaimed songs of the past few rates against in each other in our 2nd All-Stars Rate!

If you haven’t already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to stay tuned for future rate-related posts!


Quick Links:

Ballot submission: Reddit // Ballot template: Google Docs // Ballot template (Pastebin)

Playlists: Spotify // Apple Music // Youtube (MV ver.) // Youtube (Audio ver.) // Youtube (Lyrics ver.)

Deadline: August 2nd, Sunday, 11:59 PM Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

Only top-ranking songs from each rate from "Japanese Songs Rate --> 2025 in B-sides" were considered for the rate, by nature of the theme. Summer Rate entries will be eligible for next All-Stars rate.

New to AS2 is the addition of Wildcards! These are top-ranking songs from rates from the AS1 phase that couldn't make AS1, so we gave them a chance to be in AS2.

Songs were helped decided by the songlist feedback survey we had on /r/KpopRates.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 70 songs that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by rate date and their placement on said rate:

.

Rate: Japanese Songs:

Yuta - Prisoner (#1)

Chen - Free World (#1.5)

Girls’ Generation - Paparazzi (#2)

LOONA - Hula Hoop (#4)

Rate: Second Half of 2024:

aespa - Whiplash (#1)

ITZY - Imaginary Friend (#3)

Rescene - Love Attack (#5)

KAVE - Stone (#5.5)

Rate: NCT:

NCT 127 - Superhuman (#1)

NCT 127 - Walk (#2)

WayV - Moonwalk (#3)

Rate: 2024 in B-sides:

aespa - Spark (Winter Solo) (#1)

Chungha - I’m Ready (#1)

ONEWE - Shoot It Out (#2)

Rate: Early Gen 3 Girl Groups:

GFriend - Rough (#1)

AOA - Miniskirt (#3)

EXID - Up & Down (#5)

Ladies’ Code - The Rain (#8)

Rate: Grab Bag 2:

WOODZ - Busted (#1)

BoA - L.O.V.E (#2)

Infinite - Man In Love (#3)

TAN - Heartbeat (#5)

Rate: Early Gen 3 Boy Groups:

VIXX - Error (#1)

GOT7 - If You Do (#2)

VIXX - On and On (#3)

MONSTA X - Beautiful Liar (#4)

Rate: First Half of 2025:

CIX - Thunder (#1)

NMIXX - High Horse (#2)

Yeji - Air (#4)

Saja Boys - Your Idol (#5)

Rate: Dreamcatcher:

Dreamcatcher - Odd Eye (#2)

Dreamcatcher - Scream (#4)

Rate: 2022 in K-Pop:

IVE - Love Dive (#1)

Taeyeon - INVU (#2)

ATEEZ - Halazia (#3)

NewJeans - Ditto (#4)

Rate: Late Gen 3 Girl Groups:

Momoland - BBoom BBoom (#1)

Oh My Girl - Closer (#4)

April - Oh! My Mistake (#6)

WJSN - As You Wish (#8)

Rate: Soloists 2:

Ailee - I Will Show You (#1)

Ailee - U & I (#2)

IU - Twenty-three (#3)

Gain - Paradise Lost (#6)

Rate: 2023 in B-sides:

fromis_9 - Attitude (#1)

Billlie - nevertheless (#2)

WOODZ - Drowning (#3)

VIVIZ - Untie (#7)

Rate: Late Gen 3 Boy Groups:

Wanna One - Energetic (#1)

KNK - Sunset (#2)

SF9 - Now or Never (#3)

A.C.E - Goblin (Favorite Boys) (#4)

Rate: Female Soloists Albums:

Taeyeon - Spark (#1)

LeeHi (ft. Yoonmirae) - Red Lipstick (#2)

Heize - Happen (#3)

Rate: Second Half of 2025:

NMIXX - Blue Valentine (#1)

Cravity - Lemonade Fever (#2)

Close Your Eyes - X (#4)

XG - Gala (#5)

Rate: 2018 in K-Pop:

fromis_9 - Love Bomb (#1)

Red Velvet - Bad Boy (#2)

K/DA - Pop/Stars (#4)

Twice - What is Love? (#7)

Rate: 2025 in B-sides:

NMIXX - Spinnin’ On It (#1)

LE SSERAFIM - Ash (#2)

The Boyz - Miss Demeanor (#6)

Rate: Wildcards:

Girls’ Generation - Into the New World

Red Velvet - Cosmic

SHINee - Lucifer

Twice - Feel Special

.


* Spotify playlist

* Apple Music playlist

* Youtube MV Ver.

* Youtube Audio Ver.

* Youtube Lyrics Ver.


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Don't use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0). You can add them to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Saja Boys - Your Idol: 8.3 My favorite K-Pop group, hypnotize me all day long daddies

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give a comment for each rate, like so:

Rate: NCT: Open your eyes NC deez nuts

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Ballot submission: Reddit // Ballot template: Google Docs // Ballot template (Pastebin)

If this does not work, or your ballot exceeds the character limit, you can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates above, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/KpopRates. Make sure, if doing this, that your document has sharing permissions enabled. You may also DM the ballot to u/Zypker125 (@Zypker124), u/ke1per (@joseambuervo), and u/CheesesPriced (@sudointalexual) on Discord! Please message all three hosts, not just one. You can amend your ballot at any time in the lead up to the rate deadline, just let the hosts know and they'll update it in the file.

Google Spreadsheet you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


DUE DATE:

Sunday, August 2nd, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - August 8th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - August 9th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing 3rd Grab Bag Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Mar 10 '25

Rate The 1st All-Stars Rate!

31 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Happy 25th rate to us! What's a better way to celebrate it than to pit some of our most iconic and highest rated songs against each other in our first ever All-Stars Rate! (if you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to stay tuned for the future rate-related posts!)


Quick Links:

Deadline: April 14th, 11:59 Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

Only top-ranking songs from each rate (outside of Best Of and Music Videos Rate) were considered for the rate, by nature of the theme. Japanese Songs Rate entries will be eligible for next All-Stars rate.

We have decided that artists can only get a max of 2 songs on one All-Stars Rate, to increase artist variety and diversity. Also every rate here will have a minimum of 3 songs in All-Stars (except for Pre-Debut LOONA due to artist limit), and a maximum of 4 songs.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 70 songs that were selected for this rate, ordered chronologically by rate date and their placement on said rate:


.

B-side Battles

EXO - The Eve (#1)

Red Velvet - Kingdom Come (#3)

ATEEZ - Cyberpunk (#4)

STAYC - Young Luv (#6)

.

First Half of 2023

IVE - I AM (#1)

Purple Kiss - Sweet Juice (#2)

LE SSERAFIM - Eve, Psyche & The Bluebeard's Wife (#4)

Seventeen BSS ft. Lee Youngji - Fighting (#7)

.

EXO, BTS, & Seventeen

EXO - Monster (#1)

Seventeen - Very Nice (#2)

BTS - Blood, Sweat & Tears (#3)

.

2020 in K-Pop

GFriend - Mago (#1)

Taemin - Criminal (#2)

Everglow - La Di Da (#3)

Twice - I Can't Stop Me (#5)

.

Underappreciated Artists

Youha - Abittipsy (#1)

ONEUS - Luna (#2)

WOODZ - Waiting (#3)

.

Red Velvet, Twice, & Blackpink

Red Velvet - Russian Roulette (#1)

Twice - Fancy (#2)

Blackpink - As If It's Your Last (#12)

.

Second Half of 2023

Kiss of Life - Sugarcoat (Natty Solo) (#1)

Jungkook - Standing Next To You (#1)

VIVIZ - Maniac (#2)

Kim Sejeong - Top or Cliff (#7)

.

Pre-Debut LOONA

LOONA/Chuu - Heart Attack (#1)

LOONA/OEC - Girl Front (#2)

.

"Bridge of Gen 2 & 3" Boy Groups

Infinite - The Chaser (#1)

Beast - Fiction (#2)

Infinite - Bad (#3)

Block B - Her (#7)

.

2021 in K-Pop

WJSN - Unnatural (#1)

Enhypen - Drunk-Dazed (#2)

(G)I-DLE - HWAA (#7)

TXT ft. Seori - 0x1=Lovesong (I Know I Love You) (#9)

.

The "Late Gen 2" Girl Groups

f(x) - 4 Walls (#1)

miss A - Hush (#2)

Stellar - Vibrato (#4)

Rainbow - A (#7)

.

The 1st K-Pop Grab Bag

Max Changmin - Maniac (#1)

&Team - Firework (#2)

Vincent - That Day (#6)

.

The Survival Show Songs

Boys Planet - Jelly Pop (#1)

Produce 48 - Rumor (#3)

Produce 101 S2 - It's Me (Pick Me) (#5)

.

First Half of 2024

aespa - Supernova (#1)

Lucy - The Knight Who Can't Die and The Silk Cradle (#3)

RIIZE - Impossible (#5)

.

"Early Gen 2" Boy Groups

TVXQ - Mirotic (#1)

SHINee - Sherlock (Clue + Note) (#2)

SHINee - View (#3)

FTISLAND - Take Me Now (#4)

.

Halloween Rate

Max Changmin - Devil (#1)

Ahn Yeeun - Changgwi (#2)

BewhY - GOTTASADAE (#9)

.

"Early Gen 2" Girl Groups

Brown Eyed Girls - Abracadabra (#1)

Girls' Generation - Genie (#2)

Orange Caramel - Catallena (#3)

KARA - Step (#4)

.

2019 in K-Pop

Taemin - Want (#2)

Dreamcatcher - Deja Vu (#4)

DAY6 - Sweet Chaos (#4.5)

SuperM - Jopping (#7)

.

SHINee Solo Albums

Onew - O (Circle) (#1)

Key - Killer (#2)

Jonghyun - Moon (#4)

.

K-Pop Soloists #1

K.Will - Please don’t… (#1)

BoA - Better (#2)

Psy - Gangnam Style (#3)

Younha - Oort Cloud (#4)

.


* Spotify Playlist (missing Vincent - That Day)

* YouTube Playlist (MV Version)

* YouTube Playlist (Audio Version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Don't use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0). You can add them to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Sugarcoat (Natty Solo): 9.8 I won't sugarcoat it, she deserves her rightful crown

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give a comment for each rate, like so:

Rate: 2019 in K-Pop: yeah, but where is the best song of 2019, Superhuman?

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

Google Spreadsheet you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


DEADLINE:

April 14th, 11:59PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Link to a timezone converter)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - April 19th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - April 20th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


r/kpoprates • • Jan 25 '26

Rate The "Female Soloists Album" Rate!

30 Upvotes

Hello friends! We are back with another album rate, this time focusing on standout albums from some of K-Pop's most renowned female solo artists.

Welcome to the Female Soloists Album Rate, in which we will be rating albums from IU, Taeyeon, HA:TFELT, Heize, and LeeHi!

If you haven’t already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to stay tuned for future rate-related posts!


Quick Links:

Deadline: March 8th (Sunday), 11:59 Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

We used a number of stats to decide which albums would be featured in this rate, including previous TTT results and the responses to the album rates feedback survey held on the subreddit, as well as taking into account which songs would appear on future rates. The hosts also held multiple discussions in order to decide on a cohesive combination of albums that were released relatively close to one another.


IU - Palette [2017]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

Write up by u/snowswinters

From the bright and 2000s style of her first studio album, Growing Up, to the whimsical nature of Last Fantasy, and the exploration of jazz and bossa nova in Modern Times, IU has never been one to stray from trying out new themes in her work. And with Palette, the singer's fourth full-length album, she sought to continue this trend, this time forgoing a specific style or genre for the album to follow. Even the name of the album, Palette, is an indication of this concept, as the singer wanted to draw on the idea of how a painting palette holds a variety of colors.

While the album holds notes reminiscent of her pre-Palette discography, such as the brightness of the album opener's "dlwlrma" and a handful of slow ballads like "Through the Night", her fourth studio album features new sounds for the singer as well, like the disco-inspired "Jam Jam" and electro-pop in the title track, "Palette". What brings this collection of songs together, though, igniting interest in critics and the general public, is the personal lyrical content. Following in the footsteps of her 2015 EP Chat-Shire, IU continued to exert control in her music, writing every song on Palette except for one. The album follows her feelings about life and adulthood, delving into the gritty and personal. Unlike in her 2015 release "Twenty-three", which highlights her anxiety regarding adulthood, the title track "Palette" is all about acceptance and maturity at 25. From self-realization to contentment to longing, IU emphasizes her own experiences in Palette, creating an introspective album that serves as one of the most impactful works in her career.

The title Palette doesn't only reflect the variety of sound. Much like how the colors on a painting palette come together to make up the final artwork, the stories presented on the album can be seen as both the colors of IU's journey through life and the human experience.

Tracklist:

  1. dlwlrma

  2. Palette

  3. Ending Scene

  4. Can't Love You Anymore (ft. Ohhyuk)

  5. Jam Jam

  6. Black Out

  7. Full Stop

  8. Through the Night

  9. Love Alone

  10. Dear Name


Taeyeon - Purpose The 2nd Album Repackage [2020]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

Write up by u/kawaii_mokona

The leader of Girls’ Generation Taeyeon herself needs no introduction. And by 2020 neither does her already well-established solo career.

How do you follow up your extremely successful full length album debut which showcases every single side of you as a performer? From pop-rock numbers to soft ballads to Bond-esque anti-drops, My Voice (Deluxe) is a masterful showcase of Taeyeon’s range, shining in all the rainbow colors. 3 years has passed and we find ourselves with her long-awaited follow-up: Purpose (Deluxe).

It is the only album on the rate where the performer has not been involved with writing and producing the songs, instead allowing the SM camp of songwriters craft the album experience where her strengths can shine. While the album’s centerpiece “Spark” draws heavy inspiration from Adele and Emeli Sandé’s works of the mid-2010s, the critics and listeners alike have been quick to note that Purpose is still Taeyeon. And Taeyeon at her most cohesive. The tightly woven dark late autumn soundscape, allowing her to perfectly glide between warm like a hug (“Dear Me”, “Do You Love Me?”), raw and determined (“My Tragedy”, “Here I Am”), sultry and confident (“LOL”, “Better Babe”, “Love You Like Crazy”).

Despite INVU later eclipsing this album on the sheer popularity of its title track, we still hope that the Purpose and its maroon-tinted maturity will get a couple of good swirls and that we’ll be able to shine a spotlight on one of Taeyeon’s most formative bodies of work.

Tracklist:

  1. Dear Me

  2. My Tragedy

  3. Here I Am

  4. Spark

  5. Find Me

  6. Love You Like Crazy

  7. LOL

  8. Better Babe

  9. Wine

  10. Do You Love Me?

  11. City Love

  12. Gravity

  13. Drawing Our Moments


HA:TFELT - 1719 [2020]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

Write up by u/snowswinters

At age 17 in 2007, Park Ye-eun debuted as a member of Wonder Girls, later debuting as a soloist with the stage name HA:TFELT in 2014. However, it wasn't until 2020, 3 years after HA:TFELT left JYP Entertainment, that she released her first full-length album, 1719. The title of the album references multiple ideas, such as the ages from 17 to 19 and the time when the sun sets, 17:00 to 19:00.

Perhaps the most prominent idea though, is the period of 2017 to 2019 in HA:TFELT's life, a time in which the singer struggled with career changes, self-doubt, and depression. HA:TFELT describes the album, as well as the storybook that accompanied the album, as works that cover both the events of the darkest period of her life and her process of acceptance and healing. By releasing the album, the singer hoped to share her stories with others who had experienced similar issues, encouraging herself and others not to give up.

The album starts on its most personal note with "Life Sucks", an upbeat yet dark track that features honest lyrics discussing HA:TFELT's relationship with her estranged father. In 2018, the singer was investigated for being connected to her father's fraud case, and although she was proven innocent, the event and relationship with her father at the time were some of the most significant stressors in her life. HA:TFELT was praised for her willingness to explore such a dark and personal topic, with the track becoming one of the most popular songs on the album. Compared to "Life Sucks", the album's lead tracks, "Satellite" and "Sweet Sensation", are dazzling and interwoven with encouragement, HA:TFELT deliberately choosing these two as the lead singles, perhaps due to their inspiring messages. "Satellite" reminds its singer and audience to keep shining even during self-doubt, while "Sweet Sensation" serves as a call to move past previous worries and greet the next day with positivity.

Outside of its lead tracks, the album continues to highlight concepts like self-discovery, loneliness, romantic love, and hope placed atop dreamy, comforting instrumentals. HA:TFELT carefully blends struggle and perseverance in the stories of 1719, producing a candid work that resonated with its audience.

Tracklist:

  1. Life Sucks

  2. Piercing (ft. Thama)

  3. I Wander (ft. Gaeko)

  4. Pluhmm

  5. Read Me (Guitar ver.)

  6. Cigar

  7. Make Love

  8. Satellite (ft. Ash Island)

  9. Sweet Sensation (ft. Sole)

  10. Solitude

  11. 3mins (ft. Choiza)

  12. Bluebird

  13. Sky Gray

  14. How to love


Heize - HAPPEN [2021]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

Write up by u/pollutedrain

Renowned Unpretty Rapstar alumni Heize (Jang Da-hye) made her debut in early 2014 with her self-titled EP Heize. She would go on to cement herself as a formidable force within the industry: her 2016 song "Star" achieved an all-kill after reaching number one in all Korean music charts, with many of her later tracks also finding similar levels of success.

Following her 2020 move to P Nation, an entertainment company founded by industry legend Psy, Heize released her seventh EP Happen in May of 2021. She is credited as a lyricist on all of the songs bar the final one, and the album boasts a repertoire of famous names, with Tablo and Giriboy contributing towards the production of the album, and Gary, Changmo, Kim Feel, and Ahn Ye Eun appearing as features across four of the tracks. Heize herself has gone on record to say she holds Happen in very high regard, as she credits it with helping free her from a creative rut she'd fallen into after the release of her previous work, Lyricist.

Thematically, Happen focuses on love, and all of its trials and tribulations. The title track, bearing the same name, opens the album with Heize's wistful voice atop a soft guitar, before the bassline swiftly kicks in to whisk us off to a disco-esque chorus that's very much a surprise, but not an unwelcome one. Aside from the previously mentioned diverse array of features, other standouts include "Why" with its city-pop vibes and crooning vocals, and the final track "Destiny, It's just a tiny dot.", a dreamy instrumental piece that acts as a perfect outro for the album.

Tracklist:

  1. Happen

  2. Like the first time (ft. Gary)

  3. Flu (ft. Changmo)

  4. Why

  5. The Walking Dead (ft. Kim Feel)

  6. From the Rain (ft. Ahn Ye Eun)

  7. Hi, hello?

  8. Destiny, it's just a tiny dot.


LeeHi - 4 ONLY [2021]

Spotify / Youtube Music / Apple Music

Write up by u/pollutedrain

Debuting under YG Entertainment in late 2012 with her first single "1, 2, 3, 4", Lee Ha-yi (LeeHi) took the K-Pop world by storm with her powerful and soulful voice. She was rewarded with immediate success - claiming her first music show win just over a week later through Mnet's M Countdown, soon followed by the accolade of Song of the Year - November at the Gaon Chart K-Pop Awards.

Years later, following her departure from YG Entertainment and consequent move to AOMG, LeeHi would go on to release her third Korean studio album: 4 Only. It marks her most hands-on project to date - in her own words, she would previously “get a good song, sing it well, put on a good performance” before moving on. This time, however, she reached out to the featuring artists herself, and is credited for her involvement in either the lyrics, music, or arrangement of 7 of the album's 10 tracks.

Described as a series of encounters with different kinds of love, the tracks of 4 Only are intended to reflect different emotions, ranging from sorrow, anger and regret, to desperation, excitement, and the purity of love. The lead single "Red Lipstick" is a fun call-back to LeeHi's retro roots, and it draws inspiration from South Korean R&B and hip-hip duo Tashannie, with Yoon Mirae herself featuring on the song. Other notable tracks include "Savior" with its jazz-inspired instrumental and poetic lyrics, as well as LeeHi's third collaboration with fellow YG Entertainment alumni B.I; "H.S.K.T.", a playful twist on a childhood rhyme with a feature from Wonstein; and streaming titan that is "Only", which rounds out the experience of the album with a heartfelt plea for love.

Tracklist:

  1. Savior (ft. B.I)

  2. Intentions

  3. Waterride

  4. Bye

  5. Red Lipstick (ft. Yoonmirae)

  6. H.S.K.T. (ft. Wonstein)

  7. Safety Zone

  8. What is Love?

  9. Darling

  10. Only


* Spotify Playlist

* Apple Music Playlist

* Youtube Playlist (MV/Visuals Version)

* YouTube Playlist (Audio Version)

* YouTube Playlist (Lyrics Version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Don't use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0). You can add them to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Jam Jam: 4 seventeen outsold

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • You can also give comments for each individual album! Just write your comment after the :, such as the following:

Album: Purpose: call Taeyeon mother the way she gave birth to this masterpiece

  • For this rate we have a ballot average minimum of 3.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

* Link to Reddit Chat with u/kpoprates to send in scores

As Reddit is (unfortunately) moving away from the private messaging system in favor of utilizing the Reddit chat system, we are forced to also adopt the Reddit chat system for messaging. You can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates below, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates.

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

  • If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).

Alternatively, if you have Discord, you can message the link to your ballot to all of the rate hosts, @_melizard (u/pollutedrain), @kawaii_mokona (u/kawaii_mokona), and @yureves (u/snowswinters) (please message all of the rate hosts, not just one).

Google Spreadsheet you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


DEADLINE:

March 8th (Sunday), 11:59 Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Link to a timezone converter)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on r/kpoprates as well as the KpopRates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - March 14th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - March 15th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing Late Gen 3 Boy Groups Rate, due February 9th! Thanks! ❤


r/kpoprates • • Feb 20 '24

Rate The Pre-Debut LOONA Rate

30 Upvotes

Hello everyone! It's u/rickikardashian, I have participated in a few rates, but this is going to be my first time hosting over here, and I'm extremely excited for this idea. I present you...

The Pre-Debut LOONA Rate

Who is LOONA? Why are they getting a whole rate to themselves?

LOONA is a 12 member girl group under Evil Company Entertainment. Domestically known as "Girl of the Month, they stood out from the sea of other K-Pop groups by their unusual pre-debut rollout, as instead of going the usual route of announcing the lineup and releasing group content to build up hype, each member was revealed one by one and alongside their first public appearance they would get a single album with a physical release, photoshoot, music video and choreography. Not only did each girl get their own solo, but there were also sub-units, all distinct in concept and sound, so by the time they had their official debut in 2018 with Hi High, they already had a long and varied discography under their name. These pre-debut era is unlike anything else done in K-Pop and was the foundation for LOONA to build their notoriously rabid fanbase.

We'll be rating all 12 of the solo single albums, and the 3 sub-unit minis. The list of all 45 songs included in the main rate are below.

Heejin

ViViD | MV

ViViD (Acoustic Mix Version) | MV

Hyunjin

I'll Be There (with Heejin)

Around You | Film Ver.

Haseul

The Carol (with Heejin & Hyunjin) | MV

Let Me In | MV

Yeojin

Kiss Later | MV

My Sunday (Heejin, Hyunjin) | MV

My Melody(Haseul, Yeojin) | MV

Vivi

Everyday I Love You (with Haseul) | MV

Everyday I Need You (with Jinsoul) | MV

Kim Lip

Eclipse | MV

Twilight

Jinsoul

Singing In The Rain | MV

Love Letter (with Kim Lip)

Choerry

Love Cherry Motion | MV

Puzzle (with Jinsoul)

Yves

new | MV

D-1

Chuu

Heart Attack | MV

Girl's Talk (with Yves)

Go Won

One & Only | MV

See Saw (with Chuu & Kim Lip)

Olivia Hye

Egoist | MV

Rosy (with Go Won)

LOONA 1/3 - Love & Evil

Love & Evil

Sonatine | MV

Rain 51db | MV

Love & Live | MV

You and Me Together

Fairy Tale

Valentine Girl

LOONA / ODD EYE CIRCLE - Max & Match

ADD

Sweet Crazy Love | MV

Uncover

Girl Front | MV

LOONATIC

Chaotic

Starlight

ODD Front

LOONA / yyxy - beauty&thebeat

dal segno

love4eva (feat. Grimes) | MV

frozen

one way

rendezvous 18.6y

Bonus Rate

Through all their pre-debut era, LOONA would go on to release various alternate versions to many of their songs, some released officially across all streaming platforms, others only found in physical copies of certain projects, so I decided to take the most noteworthy ones (in my opinion) and add them to an optional bonus rate.

Love & Live 2.0 (with Choerry)

You and Me Together (Remix)

LOONATIC (English Version)

Again, it's optional to rate these 3 bonus songs, and you may only use scores between 1 to 10. You're not allowed to use your 11 or 0 in these songs.

Girl the boycott...

In case you aren't aware, orbits (LOONA's fandom) have been on war against Evil Company Entertainment for their predatory contracts and mistreatment of not only the group members, but all of their staff, so many of them refuse to consume any LOONA media via official channels or services that would generate some revenue to Evil Company Entertainment. If this is a cause important to you or you simply would like to support it but would still like to participate in the rate, I've made a separate Spotify playlist where the songs are all in podcast format, and for non-Spotify users, here's a list of links to all the audios and music videos


Rules

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill the missing scores in.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.5 is fine, 6.55 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favourite and most favourite song respectively. These are optional but encouraged if you feel some type of way about a given song! Comments are also very encouraged but not required for such scores.

  • Please be sure to submit your scores using the prepared message format linked here, this makes it infinitely easier for me to record your scores using the rate machine program.

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated! (but not required) and can be added to any song by simply typing after inserting your score, like so:

Heart Attack: 10 Where were you when Chuu invented lesbians?

  • This is the ONLY correct way to write a comment. Please do not include colons (e.g 10: Where were you…), dashes (e.g 10 - Where were you…), or anything else after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • Conversely, if you want to include comments for a specific album, you can do so by adding a colon after the "Album: [name]" line in the ballot. For example:

Album: Choerry: That's not how you spell cherry lol

  • DO NOT SABOTAGE! Hopefully this shouldn’t be a problem as we trust you guys (famous last words, right?), but if I sense that you're trying to tamper the results in bad faith, I reserve the right to reject your ballot and/or ask you to change your scores. If you really hate certain popular songs, please leave comments explaining why you hate them. Ultimately, please just rate all of the songs truthfully – this will make the whole process a lot easier and more fun for everyone involved!

  • If you want to change scores or add comments at any point, feel free to send this Reddit account (u/PreDebutLoonaRate) a message. I'm also active on Discord, so if you have Discord you can find me in Popheads Discord at @9to6.

  • You can use the message link to send your scores, or through copypasting this Pastebin here into a Reddit message to this account.


DUE DATE:

Monday, March 25

REVEAL DATES:

Saturday, March 30 and Sunday, March 31


Spotify playlist

Spotify playlist (Boycott Ver.)

Apple Music playlist

YouTube playlist

List of boycott friendly links

LINK TO SEND IN SCORES


r/kpoprates • • Jul 14 '23

Rate [RATE] "First Half of 2023" K-Pop Rate!

30 Upvotes

Hello everyone! We're excited to announce that r/KpopRates has finally returned with a new rate, the "First Half of 2023" song rate! We (u/Zypker125 and u/colourmefaded) are excited to get things started here! (If you haven't already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to ensure that you stay updated on future rate-related posts!)


How the songs for this rate were selected:

We used the /r/kpop Upcoming Monthly Releases to comb through all K-Pop releases from the first half of the year. From there, we picked the songs that received the highest upvotes on /r/kpop, as well as songs that were mentioned the most in the /r/kpop Quarterly Favorites threads. Other factors were also taken into consideration, such has how much buzz/discussion a song had, how popular the artist was overall and how popular they were on Reddit, etc..

Once a tentative songlist was decided, we also hosted a songlist feedback thread on /r/kpoprates, and we used the feedback from the playlist to make modifications to the songlist, which were noted here.


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 50 (+5) songs that were selected for this rate:

.

January:

NewJeans - OMG

Boys Planet - Here I Am

MONSTA X - Beautiful Liar

Taeyang (ft. Jimin of BTS) - Vibe

GOT the beat - Stamp On It

TWICE - Moonlight Sunrise

XG - Shooting Star

TXT - Sugar Rush Ride

NCT 127 - Ay-Yo

.

February:

The Boyz - Roar

BSS (ft. Lee Young Ji) - Fighting

KEY - Killer

tripleS - Rising

XG - Left Right

STAYC - Teddy Bear

Purple Kiss - Sweet Juice

FIFTY FIFTY - Cupid

.

March:

TWICE - Set Me Free

Kai - Rover

NMIXX - Young, Dumb, Stupid

Jimin - Set Me Free Pt.2

NMIXX - Love Me Like This

Jimin - Like Crazy

IVE - Kitsch

Billlie - EUNOIA

xikers - Tricky House

JISOO - Flower

.

April:

IVE - I AM

Kep1er - Giddy

Lee Chaeyeon - KNOCK

NCT DOJAEJUNG - Perfume

Agust D - Haegeum

SEVENTEEN - Super

.

May:

LE SSERAFIM (ft. Nile Rodgers) - Unforgiven

aespa (ft. nævis) - Welcome to MY World

aespa - Spicy

(G)I-DLE - Allergy

(G)I-DLE - Queencard

ENHYPEN - Bite Me

LE SSERAFIM - Eve, Psyche & The Bluebeard’s wife

KARD - ICKY

Dreamcatcher - BONVOYAGE

.

June:

Stray Kids - S-Class

fromis_9 - #menow

Taeyong - SHALALA

EXO - Let Me In

ATEEZ - Bouncy (K-Hot Chilli Peppers)

NCT DREAM - Broken Melodies

SHINee - HARD

Choi Yena (ft. Yuqi of (G)I-DLE) - Hate Rodrigo


Bonus Rate (Host's picks):

There were songs that we couldn't include in the main list, but wanted to see rated in some capacity!

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list if you do it: you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating.

MAVE - Pandora

Kep1er - Back to the City

Boys Planet - Jelly Pop

ONEUS - Erase Me

P1Harmony - Jump


Spotify playlist

YouTube playlist (MV version)

Youtube playlist (Lyrics-only version)

YouTube playlist (Audio-only version)


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed (in the main 50-song rate). If your ballot is missing any scores, it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not.

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song!

  • Comments are encouraged and much appreciated (but not required, except for if you give a 0) and can be added to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

NMIXX - Young, Dumb, Stupid: 5.2 Omg, I'm so excited that they finally made a song about me!

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • DO NOT SABOTAGE! Hopefully this shouldn’t be a problem as we trust you guys (famous last words) but we reserve the right to reject your ballot, and we also reserve the right to ask you to change your scores and/or leave comments, especially for scores on the low end. Ultimately, please just rate all of the songs truthfully – this will make the whole process a lot easier and more fun for everyone involved!

  • If you want to change scores or add comments at any point, don't hesitate to message this Reddit account (u/KpopRates)!

NEW Rules:

  • For this rate as well as for most future rates moving forward, we will be imposing a ballot average minimum (ie. the average score of your ballot must be above a certain threshold for us to accept it). For this rate and most rates, we will be imposing a ballot average minimum of 4.50. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.50-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average yourself, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}

  • For this rate, if you use a 0, you are required to leave a comment next to the song you gave a 0. Since a 0 is a powerful score/statement to give, we want to see why people gave songs 0s.


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Link to Private Message to send in scores

Google Docs ballot template

Pastebin ballot template

  • If the private message link is not working (or your private message exceeds the character count), please use the Google Doc template (make a copy of it to your Google Drive) or the pastebin for your ballot and DM it to u/KpopRates. (Also, please note that Old Reddit sometimes can randomly wipe/erase your message while you're working on it, so we recommend filling our your ballot on a website where your work is saved.) If you message us a link to your Google Doc, PLEASE double check your permissions so that "anyone who has the link can view the document" (since the default is otherwise).


DUE DATE:

Tuesday, August 22nd, by 11:59 PM PST - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given for this rate! Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline. (We will post reminders on r/kpoprates so that people can be reminded of submitting before the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveal posts will take place on r/kpoprates, so make sure to join the subreddit during these dates):

Day 1 - August 26th (Saturday) at 1 PM PST (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - August 27th (Sunday) at 1 PM PST (Time zone converter here)


Looking for more help!

Ideally, we would like to continue doing K-Pop rates in the future. However, K-Pop rates take a lot of effort and time to host, and we're currently a very small team. Therefore, if you all want to see rates continue to be conducted, it is important that we get more helpers & people willing to host rates! For those interested in helping out, all information can be found here on this r/kpoprates post. Additionally, feel free to send a modmail to the r/kpoprates team and/or message u/Zypker125 if you're interested in helping out on future rates! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Jun 02 '26

Rate The 3rd K-Pop Grab Bag Rate!

29 Upvotes

Hello everyone! It's once again that time of year where the r/kpoprates community comes together to create a collection of songs only they are capable of producing. Welcome to the third installment of our Grab Bag series, aptly titled The 3rd K-Pop Grab Bag Rate!

If you haven’t already, make sure to join r/kpoprates to stay tuned for future rate-related posts!


Quick Links:

Ballot submission: Reddit // Ballot template: Google Docs // Ballot template (Pastebin)

Playlists: Spotify // Apple Music // Youtube MV ver. // Youtube (Audio ver.) // Youtube (Lyrics ver.)

Please note that 2 songs are missing from both the Spotify and Apple Music playlists - please find them in the Youtube Playlists.

Deadline: Sunday 5th July, 11:59 PM Pacific (Link to a timezone converter)


How the songs were selected:

As with previous grab bags, the song list for this rate was entirely user-submitted via a Google Form on the subreddit! Priority was allocated based upon the number of rates a user had completed, both in total and also since our 2nd Grab Bag Rate last year. Additionally, for the first time ever, this Grab Bag features a bonus section - comprised of songs submitted by the most regular rate hosts/helpers as a thank you for their hard work!


Now, without further ado, let's introduce the 55 (plus 9 bonus) songs that were selected for this rate!

If you want to read the comments submitters left for their songs, you can read them here

First, we'll go over the songs submitted by those who selected to have their names revealed alongside their songs at the start of the rate, listed in alphabetical order:

SongSubmitter
9Muses - Figarou/msargent24
Aiobahn +81 (ft. KOTOKO) - INTERNET YAMEROu/AmeZim
BIGBANG - Still Aliveu/Ganos-b-thanondorf
Blady - Blood Type B Girlu/redalert30
BTOB - Blue Moonu/kirakiranatsu
Effie - downu/WoolenDPOY
eite - Independent Womanu/SecretStoryOfThe-
Gain (ft. Minseo) - The Footsteps of My Dear Loveu/aidshha
Infinite - Moonlightu/lavendrsgreen
ITZY - Blossom (Lia)u/Randummonkey
Kai (ft. DK of Seventeen) - Die Schatten Werden Laengeru/naegerowwa
Lee Jung Hyun - Ari Ariu/DPM36
mimiirose - Flirtingu/Marsmaenschen
MUSHVENOM (ft. Dr.Lee) - Spin The Wheelu/MartialST
Pinkfong - Fun Facts About Animal Poopu/Zypker125
Purfles - 1,2,3u/ruhroh386
Red Velvet - Pushin’ N Pullin’u/snowswinters
Say My Name - UFO (ATTENT!ON)u/Goorry121
SHINee - Savioru/Jennywren2323
Song - It's Callu/necromanta_101
Sumin (ft. Slom) - Yogijogiu/kauai6
UN - Waveu/bibliomaniac15
XIA (ft. Tablo) - Floweru/keine_panik
YOON MIN (ft. sokodomo) - night owlu/ke1per
Yuta - If We Lose It All Tonightu/MurkyGalaxies
ZEROBASEONE - Now Or Neveru/lemon131nomel

Next, we have the songs submitted by those who chose to remain anonymous until reveal weekend. These are also ordered alphabetically:

Are you a r/kpoprates regular who feels like they know their fellow raters like the back of their hand, or someone who just loves guessing games? See the 'Additional Predictions' section below for a chance to show off your skills!


Bonus Rate:

As previously mentioned, this is the first installment of Grab Bag to include a bonus rate! The following 9 songs were submitted anonymously by the subreddit/server's most regular hosts/helpers:

DAY6 - Letting Go

Enhypen - Teeth

Eyedi - Caffeine

Kim Heechul, Shindong, Eunhyuk, Solar - Charm of Life

Infinite - Nothing’s Over

Lee Sang Woo - A Fading Little Smile

Little Psy - Show+Time

Min Kyunghoon, Kim Heechul (ft. BIBI) - Hanryang

Mirae - Killa

The Bonus Rate is optional and you do not have to submit a score for every song in the bonus list. If you do it, you can score none of them, all of them, or any number in between. You cannot give a 0 or 11 to any song in the bonus, as they are not part of the main rate. While it is optional, we hope you consider participating. There will also be an additional predictions activity centred around this section, details of which can be found in the 'Additional Predictions' section below!


* Spotify playlist (2 songs missing!)

* Apple Music playlist (2 songs missing!)

* Youtube MV Ver.

* Youtube Audio Ver.

* Youtube Lyrics Ver.


Rules:

  • You must listen to and assign a score to EVERY song listed. If your ballot is missing any scores it will not be eligible and you'll be sent a message asking you to fill in the missing scores.

  • Each song should be assigned a score between 1 to 10. Decimals up to one point are allowed but any further is a no-no – 6.9 is fine, but 6.99 is not. Don't use commas (i.e "8,8") to separate your decimals!

  • You can use ONE 0 and ONE 11 for the entirety of the rate, for your least favorite and most favorite song respectively - they are optional but HIGHLY encouraged if you feel some type of way about any given song! Comments are also encouraged but not required for such scores (except if you give a song a 0). You can add them to any song by simply typing after the numerical score, like so:

Little Mix - Wings (Korean Version): 10 it's been 15 years and i still think little mix unnies were robbed of the 2011 rookie of the year award at mama 😔

  • This is the ONLY correct way to format a comment. Please do not include colons (ex. 9: I stan!), dashes (ex. 3.3 - This song sucks), or any other symbol after your score/before your comment as it breaks the program.

  • For this rate and most future rates, we have a ballot average minimum of 4.00. In addition, if your ballot average is between 4.00-5.50, you must leave comments on your lower scores (which we define as any score that's a 3 or lower). {Do not worry about having to calculate your ballot average, once you submit your ballot, we will tell you if you need to make changes to your ballot for it to be accepted.}


SUBMITTING A BALLOT:

Ballot submission: Reddit // Ballot template: Google Docs // Ballot template (Pastebin)

If this does not work, or your ballot exceeds the character limit, you can make a copy of either the Google Docs or Pastebin ballot templates above, add your scores on your local copy/file, and send the link to your local copy/file in your Reddit Chat message to u/kpoprates_ghost. Make sure, if doing this, that your document has sharing permissions enabled. You may also dm the ballot to u/pollutedrain (@_melizard), u/kawaii_mokona (@kawaii_mokona), and u/kirakiranatsu (@kinakowaffle) on Discord! Please message all three hosts, not just one. You can amend your ballot at any time in the lead up to the rate deadline, just let the hosts know and they'll update it in the file.

Google Spreadsheet you can use for calculating averages/trends and making predictions

You can also submit the Top/Bottom 5 predictions form at any time!


ADDITIONAL PREDICTIONS:

Can you successfully spot all the forks in the kitchen? Flex your identification powers in the "who submitted what song" guessing contest!

The guessing contest is split up into 2 portions, one for the hosties bonus rate where you will have to match the songs with one of the 9 hosties (and other rate job havers), and one open ended one for all the anonymous songs in the main rate. These "contests" will be separate, so you may participate in one but not the other.

If you are an anonymous submitter, you are allowed and in fact encouraged to deceive your fellow raters. Claim ownership over a song you've never heard before, brazenly deny that the song you listened to 300 times in a month is yours, bluff and double bluff and triple bluff your way to victory. Trust no-one and fool everyone.

The form can be found here! There will also be a .txt file posted in the rate channel with a list of the anonymous songs and hosts who are participating in the bonus.

This contest is hosted by Murky (u/MurkyGalaxies on Reddit, @SmallDesires on Discord) and Zo (u/zo142 on reddit, @mkh.zo on Discord). If you have any questions, either @ us in the rate channel, or DM us on either Discord (preferred) or Reddit!


DUE DATE:

Sunday, July 5th, by 11:59 PM Pacific - This will be the FINAL deadline, no extensions will be given this time! (Here is a link to a time zone converter for the deadline.)

REVEAL DATES (Reveals will take place on /r/kpoprates as well as the r/kpoprates Discord: https://discord.gg/rkpoprates)

Day 1 - July 11th (Saturday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)

Day 2 - July 12th (Sunday), 8 AM Pacific (Time zone converter here)


We also encourage you to participate in the ongoing Summer Rate! Thanks!


r/kpoprates • • Jan 24 '26

Results Reveal The "2023 in B-Sides" Rate, Day 1: You know I got the rate, the rateness

28 Upvotes

Welcome to Day 1 of the "2023 in B-Sides" reveal! We will be revealing the bottom 30 songs today!

Day 1 will begin at 4 PM UTC / 8 AM Pacific, roughly 3 and a half hours from when this post goes up. For those following the song rate live during this time, we highly encourage you to follow both this post and the live chat on our community Discord, as we will be using both for chatting/communication.

If you are here after the live results-reveal watch session, we would encourage you to avoid spoilers by going through the comments section one-by-one, as the comments will be sorted by Old after the live watch session so you can simulate the ranking reveal for yourself.


STATS

Participants: 68 participants

Average score: 6.884

Average controversy score: 2.273 (Any song with a controversy score higher than this is considered to be divisive)


SONGS REMAINING:

.

aespa - Thirsty

Agust D ft. Ryuichi Sakamoto and Woosung of The Rose - Snooze

ATEEZ - This World

Billlie - nevertheless

Chuu - Aliens

EL7Z UP - Die For You

Enhypen - Chaconne

EVNNE - Role Model

EXO - Cinderella

fromis_9 - Attitude

GOT the Beat - Rose

i-dle - Eyes Roll

Infinite - Time Difference

Itzy - Kill Shot

IVE - Blue Blood

IVE - Hypnosis

Jeon Somi - The Way

Jimin - Face-off

Kep1er - Back to the City

Key - CoolAs

Kiss of Life - Sugarcoat (Natty solo)

Le Sserafim - No-Return (Into the unknown)

Lee Chaeyeon - I Don’t Wanna Know

Lucy - So What

Monsta X - Lone Ranger

NCT 127 - Space

NCT U - PADO

NewJeans - New Jeans

Odd Eye Circle - Je Ne Sais Quoi

Pixy - Falling

Purple Kiss - Autopilot

Red Velvet - Underwater

Red Velvet - Will I Ever See You Again?

Seventeen - I Don’t Understand But I Luv U

SHINee - Identity

Stray Kids ft. Tiger JK - Topline

Taemin - The Rizzness

TRI.BE - Would You Run (Original ver.)

tripleS - New Look

Twice - Wallflower

TXT - Farewell, Neverland

TXT - Tinnitus (Wanna be a rock)

Viviz - Untie

WayV - Poppin’ Love

Weeekly - Backwards

WOODZ - Drowning

Xdinary Heroes - Good Enough

XG - Left Right

Yena - Wicked Love

ZEROBASEONE - Take My Hand


Bonus Rate:

.

BTOB - Moon Ride

DPR IAN - Welcome To The Other Side

iKON - Fighting (Song solo)

Jihyo - Room

NCT U - The BAT

NiziU - Jump

Xdinary Heroes - Pluto