r/knitting • • Aug 11 '26

Rant Should I write a pattern?

Post image

I made a top down, boat neck raglan tee with waist shaping and lace details. I already created the first draft of the pattern, wrote it as I knit. Currently trying to grade it for other sizes, already casted on another size. But I’m having doubts if I should continue. I want to sell it but don’t know if it would be worth buying. Maybe for beginners? Also what makes a pattern worth buying? I’m having a small mental breakdown and am open to suggestions. Or pep talk. If you’re willing.

0 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

35

u/marxam0d Aug 11 '26

Photos of it on a human would probably make it easier to give feedback.

-1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26

You’re right. I only have unblocked pics tho. I should add better pics once it’s done blocking.

47

u/marxam0d Aug 11 '26

Maybe wait until you can take front-on, clear, post-blocked photos?

-4

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26

I should but I’m just excited to share 😅

41

u/Minute-Meal2079 Aug 11 '26

This looks unfinished to me

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26

Should I just delete this post and post again later with more pics?

13

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 11 '26

No, you don’t need to do that. Your post is fine.

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26

It was, but it’s the only pic I have right now. Maybe I should’ve waited till it’s blocked

-30

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 11 '26

This is a very unhelpful comment, and by virtue of being unhelpful it’s rude. If you want to give constructive feedback you need to elaborate beyond “unfinished.”

19

u/legalpretzel Aug 12 '26

It’s 100% fair feedback to say it looks unfinished.

-11

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

Only if there’s a given reason for it though. Without an actionable reason it’s just criticism, not constructive criticism.

14

u/derpyxquack Aug 12 '26

I mean your own "suggestion" was to not think about it. How helpful is that, BoxFullOfSuggestions?

-10

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

It was to not “overthink” it, which is different. But you know that.

10

u/derpyxquack Aug 12 '26

Which isnt very helpful. But you know that.

-5

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

You’re not as clever as you think you are. Go away.

7

u/derpyxquack Aug 12 '26

You told me to go away 20 min ago, then posted some comment about ai and downvotes? Maybe you need to go away?

-5

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

Okay, here’s a more substantive response. My suggestion was to not overthink it, which you clearly read because you disingenuously referenced it claiming that I said not to think about it, which is not the same thing. I’m assuming you know that, but maybe you don’t. Maybe you are not capable of understanding the difference between overthinking and thinking.

Anyway, I don’t know what you think you’re accomplishing by just defending somebody who says something as basic and completely unhelpful as “this looks unfinished to me.” that may be true, but how does it help the person improve and how does it contribute to the conversation? It doesn’t. What looks unfinished? Which part specifically and how would you improve that?

If you want real people to write patterns instead of letting it be entirely overtaken by AI then you can’t be like this in spaces like this.

I’m sure you’re going to downvote me, but I really don’t care. The only thing about that that pisses me off is that down voting someone who disagrees with you is an obvious move to suppress conversation.

If you’re happy with all new patterns being AI, then go ahead and be unhelpful.

10

u/derpyxquack Aug 12 '26

What the fuck did i say that mentionned ai????? Nobody wants that, dont put these words in my mouth. We're in a community that understands what an unfinished project looks like (unweave ends, unblocked, etc). And if they dont know, someone thats ACTUALLY considering selling a pattern should know how to finish the project and mostly how to explain it to other people. Youre just telling them dont worry some will like it and some will not, which is true, but doesnt help op at all.

-3

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

Nobody said you mentioned AI. I know reading comprehension is hard.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 12 '26

Millions of people use reddit; every story and comment gets at least a few up/downvotes. Some up/downvotes are by reddit to fuzz the votes in order to confuse spammers and cheaters. For more info, see this post.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-3

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

This is not helpful either.

4

u/Minute-Meal2079 Aug 12 '26

It was literally not finished. OP clarified they added an icord edge. You are doing way too much (sorry not constructive)

6

u/Same-Key-1086 Aug 12 '26

Is the collar going to be finished?

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

I added I cord edging we’ll see if it fixes the collar

1

u/Same-Key-1086 Aug 12 '26

Thats a good idea!

4

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

Here’s the finished garment

4

u/Same-Key-1086 Aug 12 '26

I love the boat neck and the i cord edge. Totally different look. I dont get the middle stripe really but that's not super important. 

Personally, I would make the pattern. It seems like you want to! And something is going to be your very first pattern and this is certainly a worthy garment. 

-7

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 12 '26

How do you suggest they “finish” the collar?

18

u/legalpretzel Aug 12 '26

The collar/neckline looks unfinished in a way that blocking might not solve.

38

u/bi-bee-bb Aug 12 '26

That is a lovely garment you knit for yourself.

The following has nothing to do with you personally, it is my general opinion on pattern sales in 2026: I seriously think everyone should wait to sell patterns until they have like a decade of knitting experience, can grade to other sizes, can get their patterns tested by many differently sized knitters, and can afford to get the pattern tech edited. 

3

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

Thank you for your comment. 💞 A reality check never hurts.

4

u/bi-bee-bb Aug 12 '26

I meant what I said that this is a lovely garment, and that my opinion absolutely is not personal to you!! It's also not up to you to individually fix the prevalent issues in knitting pattern sales right now!

2

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

No no, I actually agree with you 😄 I shouldn’t be hasty trying to just get it done and actually try to technically perfect it

24

u/Lenauryn Aug 12 '26

I think a lot of people will find this harsh, but I'm inclined to agree. That is at least what I would wish for from designers I buy patterns from. I might be wishing for a vanished world, though.

I actually prefer to buy pattern books from the olden days because the patterns will have been properly developed, tested, and edited.

Get off my lawn!

11

u/bi-bee-bb Aug 12 '26

Lol girlll I'm over here in the Knitty magazine archives trying to see what patterns from 2002 have come back into style 😅 

23

u/indecisivepersimmon Aug 11 '26

Why do you want to write a pattern to sell? I would personally feel upset if I did all the work to make a pattern and no one bought it, so I’d probably look for an audience first. How to do that is a different issue altogether. But if your goal is just to practice pattern writing, that might be a non issue.

Aside from interest in the design itself, I always feel clear well written patterns feel more “worth it”. Would you be planning to hire a tech editor? That would really help with the quality and make it more “worth buying” and maybe help you learn pattern writing skills too. If not, it’s ok too but it brings me back to the question of why you’re doing it and how dedicated you are to making it great which in my opinion will dictate how much you enjoy the process/actually finish the pattern.

3

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26 • Heartwarming

I do have a small audience (although quite small) and a few channels I can turn to for help. But I wouldn’t be upset even if I didn’t manage to sell any.

I really don’t have anything else I’m looking forward to other than knitting and writing patterns. Aside from my self doubting from time to time (like right now) I’m dedicated. Your comment actually help me ground myself a bit, thank you very much ☺️

4

u/indecisivepersimmon Aug 11 '26

That’s great, I’m working on being less results driven myself. It sounds to me that you’re doing it for the love/interest of the thing itself which seems sustainable

8

u/Lenauryn Aug 12 '26

I have some feedback not based on the quality of your design, which is lovely (I am curious about how you plan to finish the neck though) but based on publishing in general.

I'm a novelist and I have frequently heard the advice not to publish your first novel. Your first novel is a learning experience full of mistakes you're too much of a novice to see yet. The point of your first novel is to prove to yourself you can write one.

So go ahead and write the pattern. All the way through--grading, writing out the instructions, formatting, etc. Run it by friends or ask for some testers to try it out.

Then don't publish it (yet). Start writing your next pattern. Take what you've learned from your first pattern and apply it to the next one.

If you find pattern writing--not just creating, but writing--is something you enjoy, you can break this one out of its drawer, dust it off, and look for the mistakes you didn't know you made.

I love your enthusiasm but enthusiasm is never enough for any professional endeavor.

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

That makes so much sense, I think I’ll follow your advice and create a few more patterns before I actually publish this one. Thank you very much. And btw I finished the neckline with an icord edge 🌸 I think I should’ve added a buttonhole tho 😅

2

u/Lenauryn Aug 12 '26

Love it!

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

Tysm 💞💞

12

u/heyredditheyreddit Aug 11 '26

For me, a pattern worth buying is CLEAR. Like, the repeats all make sense, sections are clearly labeled, and it really walks me through everything. I do not want to have to guess what the designer meant.

And your top is super pretty!

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26

Thank you 😊 I will definitely try to get it as clear as possible

8

u/highlighter_yellow Aug 11 '26

Someone might think your pattern is worth buying. Who is that person and why is it worth it to them?

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 11 '26

A person who hates purling and seaming?

4

u/meeksohmeeks Aug 12 '26

I think writing your own pattern will be a fun challenge! are you open to critiques about your pattern? Not a necessary step but something to consider since you posted. Personally, I'd just make it a written one and if it's one size, just make it free on ravelry.

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

Of course, I am open to critiques

8

u/Ruuuuuuuuuby Aug 12 '26

Can you change it so the color change is under the arm? It’s very obvious in the front.

1

u/Mercury_Lemon Aug 12 '26

Here is the blocked garment for anyone wondering. Sorry if I gave you a heart attack with my unfinished edges before 💞

8

u/EvilCodeQueen Aug 12 '26

Very rarely worth it. The market is flooded and the work that goes into a well-done pattern is more than you’d think. You’ll need to math out all the sizes up to 5X or be considered “size-ist”. Test knitters are important because you’re too close to the pattern to see issues. You’ll need to be able to write it out clearly or have to answer tons of questions. And for all that, you won’t make any real money selling patterns unless you build a personal brand.

If you enjoy it, release them for free and enjoy seeing what people make.

4

u/Remarkable_Delay469 Aug 12 '26

You’ll need to math out all the sizes up to 5X or be considered “size-ist”

I'm sorry but that is ridiculous. It's perfectly reasonable to make a pattern to fit a particular size or set of sizes. Not all people who are good at writing patterns will be good at grading it to every single size, or have access to somebody 5X or bigger to test on.

13

u/EvilCodeQueen Aug 12 '26

It’s the reality of the paid pattern market. You’re strongly encouraged to be size-inclusive, but to do it right, it takes more than just adding a few inches for each size. The proportions change and in some cases is a very different pattern. .

-9

u/BoxFullOfSuggestions Aug 11 '26

I’d say don’t overthink it. Write the pattern and put it up for sale. There are so many patterns out there of such varied quality. Some may like it, others may not. It’s worth a shot.

-9

u/Successful-Grab6091 Aug 11 '26

Do it!! Looks great!

-8

u/AllinHarmony Aug 12 '26

Those clips are neat

-10

u/Nellyfant Aug 12 '26

I love it! Sell the pattern.

43

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/huulipunahilkka Aug 11 '26

This. If you have professional or other extensive experience doing pattern drafting and grading I say go for it. If not, study that first to be able to do that well. I've heard that some tech editors can also do the grading for you if you prefer that. For a simple pattern, well written instructions and grading are so important. You mentioned in some comment that the intended audience for the pattern would likely be beginners. I think this makes it even more important to really know your sizing and garment construction so that the beginners will have the best chance of getting a well fitting result when not knowing how to modify patterns.

6

u/legalpretzel Aug 12 '26

And if you charge for it then you have to anticipate providing support when purchasers reach out with questions/complaints.

If you post it as a free pattern with a disclaimer that it’s unsupported that’s not an issue.