TLDR: KCD is interesting but some of the high praise it receives is extremely unwarranted or rose-tinted. It hinders itself by giving vague, false, unfair or zero information to the player. And a large part of the community willingly gaslights itself into accepting these flaws based on a warped view of 'realism'. I like the game but it is something I wouldn't recommend without warning.
It's my first time playing Kingdom Come. I was planning on writing a thorough review after I finished the campaign but its flaws got to me so bad I wanted to vent and express some stuff first.
Spent 100 hours so far in the game with two playlines. On my first, I got 30 hours into the game and hot a wall with the combat. I realized that for all the "HARDCORE REALISM" people praised about KCD, the combat boiled down to waiting for masterstrikes, getting bumrushed by superspeed NPCs and horrible hit detection. So I installed a few mods to rectify those issues and wham! It all felt way better. 60 hours in, I stopped before the Rovna investigation in the campaign. The reason was I felt a new playline would be better was because although the combat felt less frustrating, I was curious whether I eas missing out.
So I took out all my mods save for some quality-of-life stuff like better item labels and started the new playline. Curiously, the game actually felt good even without the No Masterstrikes mod! There were still bad animations, attacks that phase through enemies and etc. But I could actually hold my ground against enemies and figure out how they fight. It felt like I was actually engaging in combat!
Then I started training with Bernard and it all went downhill from there.
To give a little background, my second playline I actually decided to ignore the main story and see the world first. I figured if this game was truly realistic as people praised it, it could handle me stepping off the beaten path and let me make my own adventure as a Henry attempting to start a new life. So I prepped some food, a low-level sword and armor and set off to Talmberg then Sasau via Sir Divish's quest.
This was by far the BEST moment I had with the game 100 hours in. I ignored fast travel, plotted my own routes and felt like I was actually roleplaying an adventure. When I stumbled into a fight between bandits and cumans on the road, I was delighted because it meant ambushes aren't only generated by fast travel. It was really cool to see the bandit taunting the cumans and then the fight unfolded in front of me. I also got in the action too in a fight against the surviving bandits. Throughout the fight, I felt tense and awesome switching targets, blocking, feinting and whacking them down. The last one I shot down with arrows.
Then I realized something.
The entire fight had ZERO masterstrikes. I had no idea this was possible! It turns out based on research that low-level characters have lower chances of masterstriking you.
Guess what happens when you head back to Bernard? He starts the tutorials about masterstrikes by giving you contradictory information! He uses the word 'riposte' and describes how he parries into the direction if enemy strikes to hit back. When in reality, it is simply a perfect block executed on the first few frames of an enemy attack. It also gave me dread because I realized all the complex moves I had pulled off in my 10 to 20 hour adventure before I met Bernard would now be replaced by this load-bearing automatic defense mechanic he just taught me.
Now this is a long story to talk about my experience with the combat but it isn't the only point I wanted to make.
In all this time I struggled trying to understand why the combat was so weird with the game, I had to read some of the most stubborn, toxic and self-deluding types of responses from the KCD playerbase. There are threads that run for YEARS on Steam and Youtube where whenever a criticism or frustration had been raised about the combat, you're guaranteed three types of terrible responses: 1) The combat isn't bad, you're just bad so git gud!!; 2) The combat is bad because it works like this actually (proceeds to explain completely false mechanics that don't exist): or 3) It's bad but trust me, it gets good later!!!
For example in one of the longest running threads since 2018 on Steam about masterstrikes, I was looking for someone to explain the confusion I had when I realized you could simply turtle and win every fight with it. Inside, several people contradicted each other explaining that Masterstrikes were/weren't unblockable, Masterstrikes are the same thing as Perfect Blocks and Ripostes, NPCs can/can't perform unblockable attacks etc etc etc.
In another thread I found while trying to understand why stealth killing someone with ZERO witnesses (no other NPCs around, no one woke up, no one saw me enter or exit the place etc.) still reduced your reputation, several comments stubbornly insisted that it was because people thought you were suspicious. Which is such a strange way to explain things because logically, if no one knew it was you and no one even SAW you commit the crime, how could that happen? This thread also ended with comments telling the OP to return to playing Skyrim and that 'hardcore games with hardcore AI' weren't for them.
It's this crazy whirlpool of misinformation and I blame it all on the devs giving false/hidden/contradictory info when they made KCD. For a game with so much roleplaying potential, it's a huge shame that it doesn't have an equally robust community that teaches you stuff. It's also quite hard to teach about the game's combat I think when so much stuff is unclear. One of the top 'perfect duel' videos on Youtube for JCD has a pinned comment claiming the use of feints and avoiding the direction a character is guarding can reduce the chances of a masterstrike from your opponent which is never mentioned in the game lol. It COULD be a fabrication but it's been pinned on a high-view video AND one of KCD's better combat mods did change how masterstrikes can only work when you hit where an enemy guards so the values obviously exist to be tweaked that way??? It just left me so confused.
I compare it to playing STALKER where my experience has been marginally better with people sharing stories about faction interactions, build guides etc. I don't think it's an entirely fair comparison since both games have different levels of complexity but I hope my point gets across.
I believe the game has great potential. But it isn't anything as Game of the Year as its biggest fans have made it to ve imo and it has coasted greatly on both its hardcore reputation AND a demand for kore games like this.
If I have the time, I would love to pour over every single one of its mechanics one by one. If you made it this far reading what I wrote, thanks lol.