Hey y'all! I currently own a CP88, but I was tempted by the lightweight, price, and features of the CK. Since where I live, the chances of the CP and CK being stocked next to each other would be immensely slim--I haven't seen a CP in stores for years--, I thought "Screw it", and bought the CK88 from Zzounds so I could do side-by-side comparisons. I know a lot of people are asking about comparisons, so I thought I'd share my impressions and how they're stacking up for me so far. Ultimately I can only have one of or the other, so this is a battle to the death.
(TL; DR at the bottom)
First, my initial thoughts on the CK after an evening:
I LOVE the interface. Holy crap it's so good. The CP is a really minimal interface which works with its simple feature set, but in my brief YC88 days, I actually thought that the interface wasn't up to snuff with the more complex and numerous features of the board. The CK addressed just about every issue I had with the YC's interface: though it's arguably the most feature-laden of the current Yamaha Stage Trinity, almost everything is so inviting and instant to play around with, and makes sound exploration such a joy. You play a sound and think, "What if it had this on it?" Well boom, you can dial that in in seconds. I can't remember if the YC had this, but I love the screen animations depicting the parameter changes in real-time.
The Enter key, which serves as a Shift function key, is pretty inconspicuous and doesn't stand out from the other buttons both in appearance and layout, and can also be inconvenient when trying to use it as a shortcut as it obviously requires two hands to use, but it's not the biggest problem to have. I'd also like to see more features given the shortcut treatment: for example, if you hold the Part button and the Octave buttons, that either bumps up or down the octave for that part. However, you can't do the same for the transpose feature, you gotta go into the menu for that.
I was initially really bummed that the effects changed every time you changed a sound (not Live Set), but turns out there's an option in the Settings where you can have the effects stay, so all good in the hood.
Overall a truly excellent job by Yamaha.
2. If you're familiar with the CP and YC, you have a good idea of what sounds and quality to expect here, but I don't what it is...the CFX on the CK sounds better to me than on the CP? The CP CFX sounds a little dull to me, but the CK CFX sounds more clear. This week I'm gonna actually have the boards set up and powered on next to each other simultaneously so I can go back and forth and A/B them, but after playing the CK for a while, then switching to the CP for a bit after, I heard a difference for sure.
I didn't play around too much with the organ section, but I'm a little surprised by the criticism it's been getting so far. I've seen so much positive feedback for the Reface YC, so when they plop that engine in this board, the reaction is to say it sucks? Sure it doesn't stack up with some other organ offerings out there, but I'd say it's definitely useable for a lot of applications. Rotary A sounds pretty weak (apparently this is the one that was on the Reface), but Rotary B sounds a lot more lively. I didn't check to see if parameters such as acceleration and speed are customizable, but I hope so 'cause the default settings didn't really hit the mark for my preferences.
3. The talk of the town right here, probly the number one thing people ask when it comes to keyboards. The action. GHS. This action has been much maligned over the years, and I know myself and many others definitely felt the cold water thrown on them when Yamaha announced this is what the CK88 was gonna have. I myself used to gig with a P125 before COVID, and remember wanting to upgrade. Because of this, I actually wrote off the CK for a few weeks. But the features! The weight! The price! Maybe the action is an acceptable compromise? There have also been some unconfirmed rumors that the GHS has been revised since then, which wouldn't surprise me. I know Korg has been using RH3 since at least my big baby Triton, for example, but that does NOT feel like modern RH3 boards.
(Small bit of context: I'm 30 and have had arthritis in my wrists since I was 13)
So what's the deal, the low down, the nitty gritty? In a word: functional. It's more shallow than I remembered, which isn't inherently positive or negative, but I didn't feel like I could dig in the way I like before hitting the bottom. It actually feels kinda harsh! This made delicate playing trickier for me, and I did some quick adjustment in both master touch sensitivity and touch depth (something you WON'T find in P125 type boards) to try and offset that. I'll have to play around more with this. In terms of overall agility, I felt pretty comfy playing scales. I definitely noticed the difference between two and three sensors, but for my uses I don't think it'd necessarily be a dealbreaker.
All of this is regarding how I felt playing the CFX and other grand samples on here. As far as the other sounds, I think I might actually prefer it to the NW-GH of the CP and YC 88. That one feels just a little heavy for EPs etc. (not overwhelmingly so), but the GHS here actually has a nice sound-touch connection with all those sounds. I was also surprised how playable the organs felt with it: one of the eventual dealbreakers for the YC88 I uncovered was that the NW-GH just felt waaaaaay too heavy for the organs. Here, though, I felt pretty comfy with the organs. I also suspect that this might feel better as a MIDI controller, too: I've tried hooking up the CP to control software such as Pianoteq 8 and my NI Grandeur library, but even after adjusting the touch curves, it still just feels too heavy.
With all that said...
I plugged in the CP after the CK for several hours, and boy oh boy I felt so much more at home playing. It just felt so much more responsive, and I could translate my thoughts to my fingers so much better. ...I'm actually disappointed I had this reaction, because sooooo many things would work out in my favor if I could keep the CK and sell off the CP.
So ultimately, after one night, I'm left with this question: is it more important for me to be able to create the sounds I hear in my head, or is it more important for me to be able to create the music I hear in my head? Right now, I'm leaning towards the latter. Zzounds has a 45 day return policy and I'm gonna milk the hell out of that: I'm going to be spending at least the next week comparing the two, and setting them up in a way where I can immediately bounce back and forth between them.
So the bottom line: as an instrument, so far I'm having way more fun with the CK. It trumps the CP for me in many meaningful metrics. Practically everything in me says I should stick with the CK...but that sheer, basic feeling of sitting down in front of the keys and playing what came to my mind? ......I dunno if that should be THE determining factor, but I'm feeling it. If Yamaha announced a dark horse update for the CP that adds certain features, that'd be a much easier decision, but as it is now, it's a legit toss up for me.
Thanks for reading, I'll keep y'all updated and I hope this helps someone out there! Please feel free to ask any questions about either instrument either separately or in comparison with one another.