r/keto • u/LloydIrving • Aug 13 '13
Keto can be unhealthy. Why not just restrict carbohydrates for weight loss/blood sugar control?
I am in my fourth year studying nutrition biochemistry and dietetics (yes I know many of you hate dietitians but hear me out!). First of all I want to clear up a few misconceptions about dietitians.
We are not allowed to be as flexible and "cutting edge" with our nutrition advice as say, a fitness or keto forum is, because simply we have more liability by working directly with patients and thus HAVE to have solid research behind everything we recommend. I feel like many people do not understand this and quickly disregard dietitians for preaching "old school nutrition".
Having said that, I do believe that we are in the middle of a "nutrition revolution" of sorts where the long taught high carb low fat diet will be slowly (and already are) replaced with recommendations of low carb diets. This is because there is solid research that controlling blood sugar levels and therefore controlling insulin production can kickstart fat burning and weight loss. The evidence is becoming so strong that even the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (the largest dietitian organization who has sponsors that include big processed food companies) is reluctantly recommending such a strategy http://andevidencelibrary.com/topic.cfm?cat=3014&auth=1.
However, I do believe that self inducing ketosis is not an ideal diet because eating plans should serve two goals: induce healthy weight loss and promote healthy eating practices for life, I believe that /r/keto is only accomplishing the weight loss part of the equation and I will explain in the next few bullets.
Fruit is healthy. Fruits contain many cancer fighting properties, nutrients, slow down the aging process and contain a lot of fiber which can improve cholesterol, blood sugar, colon cancer risk, constipation, etc. Do I need to post studies for this one?
A high fat diet can lead to bad food choices. The jury is still not out on saturated fats correlation to heart disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat_and_cardiovascular_disease_controversy, cured meats like bacon are heavily processed and contain harmful additives. Here is one review on the matter: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18444144. Cured meats also contain a lot of sodium which is still strongly linked to hypertension http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23558163
The brain prefers carbohydrates. Although a ketogenic diet has been shown to be an effective therapy against various brain diseases, there is currently not enough research to determine if the brain suffers in function by relying on ketone bodies, with decreased concentration being a frequently cited effect.
Contrary to the faq, protein based foods (eggs/meat/fish/tofu/cheese) will NOT raise your blood sugar to any significant degree. In fact, understanding this principle is paramount to controlling diabetes.
Again, I think a lot of information on this board is great and it is resassuring that people are becoming skeptical on current dietary recommendations (food company lobbying anyone?). However I believe that simply restricting carbohydrates to about <45 grams per meal is sufficient to see great weight loss while not comprising your health and will power.
TL;DR: Based on available research, I believe a low carb diet is better for long term health than a keto diet
Edit: Well that was interesting, thanks for everyone who participated in the debate. I hope you all felt that sometimes debating something you are passionate about can be healthy. I stand by my words but also learned a lot about the culture and benefits surrounding the ketogenic diet. Thank you.