r/keto • • Aug 13 '13

Keto can be unhealthy. Why not just restrict carbohydrates for weight loss/blood sugar control?

11 Upvotes

I am in my fourth year studying nutrition biochemistry and dietetics (yes I know many of you hate dietitians but hear me out!). First of all I want to clear up a few misconceptions about dietitians.

  1. We are not allowed to be as flexible and "cutting edge" with our nutrition advice as say, a fitness or keto forum is, because simply we have more liability by working directly with patients and thus HAVE to have solid research behind everything we recommend. I feel like many people do not understand this and quickly disregard dietitians for preaching "old school nutrition".

  2. Having said that, I do believe that we are in the middle of a "nutrition revolution" of sorts where the long taught high carb low fat diet will be slowly (and already are) replaced with recommendations of low carb diets. This is because there is solid research that controlling blood sugar levels and therefore controlling insulin production can kickstart fat burning and weight loss. The evidence is becoming so strong that even the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (the largest dietitian organization who has sponsors that include big processed food companies) is reluctantly recommending such a strategy http://andevidencelibrary.com/topic.cfm?cat=3014&auth=1.

  3. However, I do believe that self inducing ketosis is not an ideal diet because eating plans should serve two goals: induce healthy weight loss and promote healthy eating practices for life, I believe that /r/keto is only accomplishing the weight loss part of the equation and I will explain in the next few bullets.

  • Fruit is healthy. Fruits contain many cancer fighting properties, nutrients, slow down the aging process and contain a lot of fiber which can improve cholesterol, blood sugar, colon cancer risk, constipation, etc. Do I need to post studies for this one?

  • A high fat diet can lead to bad food choices. The jury is still not out on saturated fats correlation to heart disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat_and_cardiovascular_disease_controversy, cured meats like bacon are heavily processed and contain harmful additives. Here is one review on the matter: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18444144. Cured meats also contain a lot of sodium which is still strongly linked to hypertension http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23558163

  • The brain prefers carbohydrates. Although a ketogenic diet has been shown to be an effective therapy against various brain diseases, there is currently not enough research to determine if the brain suffers in function by relying on ketone bodies, with decreased concentration being a frequently cited effect.

  • Contrary to the faq, protein based foods (eggs/meat/fish/tofu/cheese) will NOT raise your blood sugar to any significant degree. In fact, understanding this principle is paramount to controlling diabetes.

Again, I think a lot of information on this board is great and it is resassuring that people are becoming skeptical on current dietary recommendations (food company lobbying anyone?). However I believe that simply restricting carbohydrates to about <45 grams per meal is sufficient to see great weight loss while not comprising your health and will power.

TL;DR: Based on available research, I believe a low carb diet is better for long term health than a keto diet

Edit: Well that was interesting, thanks for everyone who participated in the debate. I hope you all felt that sometimes debating something you are passionate about can be healthy. I stand by my words but also learned a lot about the culture and benefits surrounding the ketogenic diet. Thank you.


r/keto • • Jul 26 '25

Why is there virtually no keto-friendly candy? It feels like the market is designed to keep us carb-addicted

0 Upvotes

Seriously, why is it so hard to find real keto candy? Every "low carb" option either has maltitol (which spikes blood sugar) or tastes like chalk. Meanwhile, shelves are flooded with sugar-loaded garbage.

Is this just profit driven carbs are cheap and addictive or is there some weird cultural bias against fat based snacks? You’d think with the keto trend booming, companies would jump on demand for legit alternatives. Instead, we get "keto" labels on products that still kick you out of ketosis.

Also candy that is clearly labeled sugar free still has carbs, 3 grams per candy.


r/keto • • Jan 09 '13

Um...why?

12 Upvotes

Dear Mods,

Please explain why you would try and fix something that is NOT BROKEN? I have JUST convinced my mom to start this diet before her knee surgery and this sub was a BIG PART OF WHY SHE IS KEEN TO DO IT!!

...jesusfuckingchrist...of all the arrogant, holier than thou, bullshit moves...oh what you're better than the rest of us because we want to see progress pics to stay motivated rather than read science articles that confirm the research WE HAVE ALL DONE ALREADY?

I may be new to reddit, but it seems to me you have missed the basic principles of how things work around here. Is it not community driven content that is promoted to the front page of each sub BY THE PEOPLE WHO SUBSCRIBE?

Well guess what, there are more people here voting FOR progress pics than those who vote against them.

Get off your high horses, please.


r/keto • • Apr 19 '12

Dear keto, thanks for your help. I am unsubscribing.

0 Upvotes

So I have dropped 10-15 pounds switching to keto over the past three months. I life heavy and have started to see cuts and muscles I didnt have before. These were my goals not dropping pounds.

I can no longer stand this influx of new, impatient people who seem to be the most vocal. My guess is all you newbs who get frustrated after a plateau of 1 week after your initial water drop will probably quit and go back to your old habits soon enough.

I enjoy keto food more than the standard American diet, and it makes a lot of sense to me.

And the food porn is getting pretty low quality. Oh you made bacon and have been on keto three days? Please, share your experience with me.


r/keto • • Apr 16 '13

For the "cheating is fine, do what works for you" crowd:

2 Upvotes

Take your comments elsewhere, because they are not helpful for the typical reader and they go against the philosophy of this community.

There are dietitians who believe a high-carb, low-fat menu is the best way to lose weight. That's fine for them...but those kinds of menus do not belong in /r/keto.

There are people who believe that everyone deserves to make their own choices, and do whatever makes them feel good. If they are willing to live with the consequences of their choices, and think the benefits outweigh the costs, then eating whatever they want and embracing the resulting obesity is fine. That kind of message also does not belong in /r/keto.

Ultimately, you wouldn't go to an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting and preach that "one drink won't hurt you," and "red wine is healthy," and "all things in moderation." That message may be COMPLETELY appropriate for some settings and some people, but it simply doesn't belong at AA. Similarly, you wouldn't go to /r/atheism and talk about how God is love and we need to put Christ back into Christmas and whatnot. The message's truth or untruth is irrelevant; it's simply an inappropriate venue for it.

Ultimately, the people in /r/keto are here for support in sticking to the keto lifestyle. If you personally find that 90 carbs a day isn't a problem, and you can cheat two meals a week, and you can slip in and out of ketosis easily with no consequences, and you lose weight despite it all, that's fantastic for you. However, just as a light drinker shouldn't preach moderation to a zero-tolerance group like Alcoholics Anonymous, someone who is NOT following the keto lifestyle should not come to the /r/keto subreddit and advocate for abandoning the core philosophy of the keto eating habits.

The people who need this subreddit the most are ones who are struggling. Many of them cheat -- consciously or unconsciously -- and it sabotages them. The last thing in the world that they need is non-addicts saying, "I'm not hooked on carbs; go ahead and splurge once in a while!" You're harming people with your message, and while your words may or may not be true for the general public, you're sabotaging vulnerable people more often than you're helping them.


r/keto • • Jan 09 '13

If you were intent on killing it, why not just finish the job?

22 Upvotes

Oh and this quote from epaka was nice

"I want to ban every one of these stupid fucks."

Not much to be banned from any more unfortunately.


r/keto • • Sep 09 '24

Keto Theory

0 Upvotes

I want to pose a theory. Been on Keto for almost a week and I feel amazing.l, mostly for the keto haters who say that Keto isn't healthy because it puts you into starvation mode etc etc or whatever they say...

For the keto side: Keto puts you in a stage where you are ready to hunt, you're ready to take action and WANT to take action, your testosterone goes up (I can tell mine is already bc I get dark blue rings around my pupils), you speak more intelligently, you lose weight, etc could go on forever.

Against the anti-keto'ers: i live in Pennsylvania and i was driving around today and was looking... there was not a single fruit tree for hundreds of miles, just man made grocery stores or gas stations. But there were plenty of trees and bushes and animals, so if I lived in PA as a mammal before manufactured food processing, I'd be eating what I saw, leaves and animals right?

It appears that carbs are putting you in a place of "I'm good". I can hibernate. I can take a rest whereas keto is doing the opposite. It puts is in an animal instinct mode....

I was just thinking as meditating and I was thinking damn like keto just seems our natural way.... I get that carbs are primary/preferred source but it stops the fight... do we want to fight in our lives each day or do we want to hibernate?? Haha this may be a little exaggerated but who knows


r/keto • • Mar 22 '25

Help I just noticed i’m eating too much protein by eating mainly ribeyes. What should I do to make sure I eat 70-80% fat?

5 Upvotes

I just noticed that i’m eating too much protein because the main thing I eat is ribeyes. I don’t know why I thought every ribeye contained mostly fat. It wasn’t until today I was looking at the g’s on some ribeyes I got from the organic supermarket because they finally had the nutrition facts on them. It says 65g of protein and 32g of fat. So I was just like wait, i’ve been eating like 50/50 fat and protein that’s not good…

I can’t always get ribeyes with mostly fat so what should I do? I really don’t want to basically only eat the fatty parts of the ribeyes cause that’s a waste of money. But clearly I can’t just eat ribeyes. What an I doing wrong? Am I missing something here?


r/keto • • Jun 26 '22

[Rant] Fruit is “healthy” because it’s only “natural sugar”

132 Upvotes

I absolutely hate this debate because it seems impossible to convince certain family members that sugar is still sugar, regardless of the source. I don’t understand where this belief came from.

White sugar and corn syrup both come from natural plants, yet you don’t see people saying that those types of sugar are good for you.

What’s the so-called “necessity” of fruit? Fruit is 50/50 glucose and fructose, so why is it considered a “healthy” snack? All the vitamins/etc from fruit can be found in vegetables with a lot less carbs.

I’ve (25F) been keto as recommended by my doctor since October 2021 for mild weight loss (20lb/9kg) and physical/neurological benefits due to brain damage and cerebral palsy. I’m now at my goal weight (91lb/41kg) for my height (56in/142cm).

Every time I try a glucose test with fruit, I fail it and feel a “sugar high” until it’s out of my system. Or is that just because temporarily stopping ketosis feels bad? My family doesn’t understand.

Any help in trying to show people the facts when I’m confronted with this type of argument? Trying to open a dialogue with family and friends about why fruit doesn’t work well for me because I’m keto.

EDIT

Wow, I wasn’t expecting so many replies when I came home from work. To give some context to the situation, my parents recently bought a new blender, and now everyone is having smoothies with yogurt, fruit, and honey.

They’re trying to tell me how “healthy” fruit smoothies are, and I just needed a bit of a vent because they don’t fully understand the keto lifestyle.

I’m not looking to “convince” them in a debate since that’s not fair or helpful regarding the situation, and I’m not trying to “convert” anyone to keto because it’s not a lifestyle that everyone agrees with.

By the way, for the anonymous people who sent me crisis resources, I can assure you that I’m mentally safe and sound. This post was just a vent about well-meaning family.


r/keto • • Nov 01 '24

No longer entertained by Halloween... at all!

0 Upvotes

Been keto for 6 months, got rid of lingering anxiety, lost a bunch of weight, boosted my endurance in every aspect possible...

No more afternoon crashes where I just want to nap and die after eating carbs and sugars (without understanding anything about nutrition)

My city organized a big event BEFORE Halloween where they made "candy rain" for kids in the streets. Big companies sponsored this event, and everyone posted pictures of their kids with candies. Fat people in the streets, people looking like zombies.

I even saw photos of a kid I know just got diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes and she was there eating candy!

When you raise a hand to try to speak about the dangers of this, people say "it's just a day" but it's not!

Or they try to say all their health problems are due to "genetics"... Wow! What an explanation.

I've been a kid, and the more sugar and candy you eat, the more you crave! Immediately!

Then you feel like crap, and you can't concentrate and have anxiety. Then people give these kids pills so they listen in class! With a bunch of hand sandwiches and fruit roll-ups.

Really sad what's going on.


r/keto • • Jan 09 '13

I'm out

0 Upvotes

I've been posting here for over a year, spending an hour or more a day browsing through /new, reading and responding to those posts that don't ever make it to the front page. Simple questions, small victories, basic requests that sit at 1-0 for 11 hours and get three replies. I've rationalised putting in that much time because I believe that this diet has the potential to have massive, lifelong effects on peoples health and longevity.

To me, that's what keto is about. It's great seeing all those posts on the front page of people who've turned their lives around, but for me it's always been about the newcomer. The guy who didn't quite understand something in the FAQ, or the gal who was worried about heart palpitations and didn't realise it was a simple potassium deficiency. These are the people that I want to see get the most use out of the subreddit, the ones who are trying to get started on the path, not necessarily the ones trying to finish it.

The self-post only announcement didn't really bother me one way or another. What did was the reaction to it. There was some constructive criticism at first, but it quickly devolved into petty name calling, pitchforking, and flat out abuse. At the time of writing, the top post on the main page is an "upvote if" filled with vituperative snark and calls to unsubscribe.

No voice of reason.

No "let's give it a week or two and see how it turns out, and then talk calmly and politely about switching back if the majority still don't like it."

Just aggressive abuse, bullying, and ad hominem trash that I thought this subreddit was free from. It turns out that as soon as they don't get their way, keto-ers can be just as demeaning and cruel as the people they so frequently [rant] about.

I don't care whose fault it is, I don't care who's acting more immaturely. All I know is that seeing this subreddit drenched in such a blanket of negativity and hatred has sapped me of whatever will I had to continue trying to help people here.


r/keto • • Dec 11 '23

Plant based Keto?

0 Upvotes

Do any of you do a more plant based keto? Did you notice the usual benefits that most people claim? Anything unique?

What are your caloric staples?

EDIT: When I say plant based I mean a diet that is based around things like nuts, seeds, avocado, olives, dark chocolate, etc. All high fats foods with barely any carbs.

For example a diet of almond butter, hemp hearts, avocado, olive oil, leafy greens fish, cheese and dark chocolate. This would net around 20g of carbs.

EDIT #2: "Plant based" doesn't mean vegan or plants only. I'm thinking more Mediterranean diet style, some fish, some eggs but mostly plant fats.


r/keto • • Oct 08 '24

My seasalt has dextrose listed as one of the ingredients. What the...? I hear it is an anticaking agent. Does that mean everytime I eat salt I am also consuming sugar and spiking my glucose levels? What alternatives are there?

0 Upvotes

Both Morton and the Whole Foods Seas salt Hain contain this, which is scary. What salts should i use to avoid sugar? Who the fuck decided to sneak a high glycemic index food into SALT would be a good idea?


r/keto • • Mar 03 '13

[Rant]-if I hear calories in vs calories out is bs one more time...

29 Upvotes

It's great that we have lost a lot of weight on keto, myself included but when some folks on this sub ignorantly claim that they get "fat" on 1200 calories of a low calorie diet, it gives me chest pains. Unless you have a major thyroid disorder and don't move at all, then yeah maybe it's possible.

There are benefits of ketosis other than fat loss, which I understand. But bashing low calorie diets isn't the way to do it, they both work. We must understand the importance of calories, and eating more "fat" won't make you burn more fat either. If you any of you guys have a MFP account, see your caloric intake, I bet it's under 2,000 calories almost every time, and from experience on my list, most people eat 1200 calories and brag how much they eat.

There, keto is merely a trick to eating less, it's not magic but it is something special that improves people's lives, lets just not be ignorant about other lifestyles. I'm on a semi low calorie diet (1800 calories) and I'm consuming 100-300g of carbs so I can maintain intensity while lifting weights, and guess what, I'm not gaining all the weight back and I'm getting somewhat shredded.

Hope this helps stop this bashing of carbohydrates, they're not as evil as you think. But keto has made me lost a lot of fat and I thank the science behind that.

edit: Damn, the comments are brutal, lol. Didn't mean to come off as a prick, but oh well, my bad, sorry I made you guys feel insecure about your diet for 5 minutes, which only explains the cursing lol.


r/keto • • May 26 '17

Startup guide to the ketogenic diet

1 Upvotes

Found this a few days ago, and a friend of mine is already very happy with the information:

https://www.perfectketo.com/the-ultimate-start-up-guide-to-the-ketogenic-diet/

And sharing it directly instead of doing the explaining myself saved me time. Check it out and maybe use it for the same purpose in the future, because it's very concise.


r/keto • • Apr 15 '15

i frikkin hate this lifestyle.

1 Upvotes

at this rate, i'm going to have to change my clothes TWICE this year! :D


r/keto • • Jan 19 '13

Our friendly mod epaka is at it again. This time, he orders someone to not post memes... in the comments!

5 Upvotes

link: http://www.reddit.com/r/keto/comments/16tpsp/insane_calorie_restrictions_wtf/c7zbsrf

I mean, what the hell?

I'm sorry, but between this and the "I want to ban every one of these stupid fucks" comments, I'd really like to find a way to get rid of this guy.


r/keto • • Aug 17 '13

[Science] Ketosis may elevate the risk of Spontaneous Human Combustion

8 Upvotes

The author argues that ketosis causes increases in acetone levels that could lead to Spontaneous Human Combustion. What do you guys think? Is the added risk of dying in a fire worth the benefits of keto?

Conclusion: "For the first time a feasible cause of human combustion has been experimentally demonstrated. So does this mean that victims of ketosis are likely to spontaneously combust? Hardly – there are only about 120 cases on record throughout history, so it is vanishingly rare. On the other hand, there would be an argument against people with ketosis wearing synthetic fibres on dry days, and a new argument to give up smoking."

http://www.brianjford.com/a-1208-NSci-SHC.pdf

http://www.mcri.org/CMSuploads/Brian%20J.%20Ford%20-%20Solving%20the%20Mystery%20of%20Spontaneous%20Human%20Combustion-85047.pdf


r/keto • • Feb 24 '14

[NSV] [NSFW] [TMI] first real acknowledgement from husband that keto works NSFW

13 Upvotes

We were in the middle of having sex and decided to go doggy. Halfway through he had to comment that my arse is getting bonier and he jokingly said he wasn't sure if he liked the less cushioning. I've lost 10lbs and I haven't noticed a thing, I'm glad he's noticed and is liking it :D

EDIT: Preeeeetty sure I didn't ask for unsolicited exercise advice. Losing my arse is a good thing. I don't want to replace it with muscle.


r/keto • • Jun 07 '18

Why do people down vote every post.

3 Upvotes

I've never seen so many "0s" in any thread. Upvoting the posts I find interesting doesn't help because in a few minutes, someone will come and downvote it again. WTH?


r/keto • • Feb 25 '24

Is diet coke okay on keto?

0 Upvotes

As I have read that many sources say that diet coke or zero coke is okay on keto due to zero calories whereas some sources say it is not okay due to aspartam?

If it is okay, how many a week can work? Please assist!


r/keto • • Sep 29 '12

RTFM and STOP complicating things!!

0 Upvotes

Honestly, when you post something, do you see the big banner that says

"I swear I have actually read the FAQ and am not posting a question that may have already have been answered 400 times previously"?

It's getting annoying to see so many ill-informed questions and posts that describe how you're doing keto (incorrectly, usually not eating enough fat) and wondering what might be wrong.

Keto is the simplest fucking diet out there:

*Keep your ratio 65/30/5

*Create a calorie deficit

That's keto. Here's the complicated parts (largely common sense):

*Drink plenty of water (2L+ a day)

*If you get keto flu, increase water and electrolytes

*Track every single thing you eat

There's nothing magic about this, you still need to eat fewer calories to lose weight. Exercise is good for you, but it's not what makes you lose weight. Want to cheat? Well, that's not keto, but go for it, it's your choice. Need to know what knocks you out of ketosis - ketostix.

Think for yourself a little, if you're not maintaining the proper macronutrient ratios and/or you're not creating a calorie deficit (which you won't know if you don't track), then there's no need to post a question here.

Discussions are awesome, we can learn a lot from each other and share our experiences, but answering the same question 50 times, that is CLEARLY covered quite simply in the FAQ or overview, is a bit annoying. Also, there's this awesome new site you should check out that can answer a TON of questions about keto - give it a try.

edit: formatting.


r/keto • • Nov 06 '25

Why do you need high fat for the keto diet?

5 Upvotes

I literally don’t understand why you need to have fats in your diet for the keto diet. Isn’t the whole point that the fat that’s already in your body is what’s getting burned for energy? Why can’t I just consume nothing but chicken and vegetables all day long and lose weight?


r/keto • • May 01 '25

How much weight could a 5ft7 200lb 29y/o female lose on keto if she kept it going for a year?

0 Upvotes

If I kept to under 20g of carbs, eating 1200 a day, how much could I lose? I've been trying to do keto for over a month, but for one reason or another (not reading the ingredients, severe stress) I can't get past the first week. I lose a bunch of water weight during that first week, hitting a plateau of 200lb, and I was wondering what I could expect if I kept it up somehow for a year? Crazy question, I know, and probably impossible, but I want to hear from other people with my body info what they've lost.

To clarify, I plan on going to barr pilates three times a week and need to lose 80lbs. I know you lose less as you lose more, but I really, really need to hit my goal weight. I can settle for 135lbs.


r/keto • • Nov 15 '12

PSA: If You Over Eat On Thanksgiving and Come Here Looking For Sympathy, I Will Only Affirm How Stupid Your Actions Were.

199 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong, if you're planning in advance to eat non-keto for the holiday, I respect that, and more power to you.

However, if you make the conscious choice on the day of to gorge yourself on food you don't really need all in the name of gluttony, and then post on here expecting sympathy after...

...I'm going only going to tell you "DUH-DOY!", and "Have fun getting back into ketosis, Mr./Mrs I-Have-Poor-Judgement-And-Self-Control!"

Be smart! Make your choice ahead of time and stick with it!

Sincerely,

Grumpy Curmudgeon Uncle AreYouReadyToReddit