I just don't understand you people's obsession with a legendary skin for Karma, when she has much more urgent matters, namely her kit desperately needing considerable work independently of playstyle, not to mention Solo Karma having been thrown under the bus by Riot and the community for years now.
In fact, a legendary skin would be bad news, because it means she won't get any type of work in a span of 5 years minimum, because they won't put in the effor to create a whole new set of animations for abilities that will have to be changed shorly. Not even visual changes, for the same reason, and it would mean no cape either.
No champion who got an overhaul (visual or gameplay-wise) got a legendary skin before the fact, unless they're oldschool champions or skins.
Objectively, a legendary skin would only get in the way for Karma to get any type of improvement.
I know we can't see it in game, but I just wanna know like... what is the reason? They made a whole new face for this skin and made it white. Y'all can't just use the base model's face?
They have literally ignored Karma for 7 years and we have friends of Developers coming on to Reddit to reason with us and be understanding of them. Over the years the Developers just want people to feel sorry for them and sympathize with their struggles. Wait, you struggled to rework Ryze three plus times? You’re purposely going out of your way to rework new champs and create 12 new champs in 2 years? You ask for feedback and data to make positive changes for your game, but you do nothing and say nothing but excuses. You have divided communities of players because of mistakes and laziness, but you don’t do anything for 7 years now.
Why are these Developers the victims? There is going to be 18 champs by the end of 2021 and we have nearly half of the champion pool that needs art updates, minor kit work and content on them. Riot just doesn’t care and would rather make excuses and play the victim. Poor Riot August! His feelings got hurt! What a joke of a Development team lol.
What do you think of this Seraphine buffs? Is it kinda unfair for Karma? Atleast riot should buff it like maybe Defiance shield stat on primary target and full Inspire shield stat on the secondary targets? Seraphine W's just works like Karma's E without the heal but why can they buff it to her and not Karma?
As the title says, whats yall's opinion about this, if she didnt have any slows in her kit which would be her Q and RQ, she could build rylais to compensate for it, but also leaving more options for items, cause I know us karma mains LOVE experimenting with builds.
Note she would be more loaded with dmg to compensate for it which gives her less safety in early but more dmg in midgame
but the removal for it, would be + more dmg faster detonation and perhaps lower cdr as an example.
Karma is weak because she doesn't contribute anything to game besides AOE shields that are either too strong or a proplay problem. Karma is weak because she technically has no identity or gameplay direction, but is allowed to be played in every role but not really succeed in them. Karma is weak because Riot has to keep her numbers low because she is a proplay problem and parts of her kit are either too strong and too much of a problem in coordinated team play.
Karma is boring because she doesn't really succeed as a support or mage, because she is a good mage early and a bad support early but transitions into a good support later but a bad mage late. What is this champion supposed to be then? Is Karma a mage or a support? Karma is boring because Riot went, deliberately, out of their way to keep AOE shields a prime staple of her "character" but that comes at the expense of everything else about Karma and the fact that they removed everything fun about the champion for the past 10 years. Karma is boring because her entire kit and the idea of Mantra, exists on item actives and other champion kits.
----------------------
Why is this champion viewed as a success just because she is "balanced" and not a problem? Karma contributes nothing compared to other mages and supports. Karma isn't unique since everything that was unique and fun about her, was removed to compensate for AOE shields. Karma has a passive that wants to promote her to play like a mage and very aggressive, but her damage numbers fall off so hard that the Karma player is doing nothing but playing a shield bot mid to late game. Karma's Mantra is a cop out and it's nothing original, since Pantheon and even Seraphine and Heimerdinger have better versions of Mantra or the same version of current Mantra. Karma has NO ULT. Karma has no identity or direction, since she doesn't succeed as a mage or a support considering there are champions that two 10 more things better than she does.
Riot is delusional and clearly focusing on new champions with new champion midscopes coming out lately, yet they use excuses that people still play Karma and they will never work on her (Riot Phlox). Riot clearly only cares about new champions and just because they announced they aren't making as many new champions going forward, they actually are still working on new champions with midscopes they are only doing on newer champions.
I personally have no played much at all lately and I love the new Karma skin. Unfortunately, I don't think the current Dev team cares about champs like Karma and it's been 10 years now. It's ridiculous to see Kench, Yuumi, Xeri, Neeko, Rell, Xin, Rammus, Ryze, Lux and so many other champs constantly getting midscope updates or kit changing buffs, but Riot is proud of the fact that Karma mains are still not happy with the direction and laziness they did to Karma. I really hope some of these Devs just lose their jobs because they are not working on the champs that need the work. They are literally still working on new champsions, but just in a different way.
Base stats are good buffs for Top, some mid matchups and support
Passive change, albeit having no idea how exactly it'll work now, seems like a big buff
Other new passive is irrelevant or a nice change to have for Top/Mid, good for Support
Q is a buff to (mage) Karma
W is a buff to (mage) Karma
E is a bit of a nerf but that's fine, her shield is already spammable as is, mostly hits Support anyway
All in all seems like hefty buffs across the board, especially for mage Karma. More upfront damage and generally better output with W being buffed and made more useful for AP building? Hell yes
Let the changes get to PBE first, then you can complain about them, thanks
The title says it all and I know I will get flack for saying this. Every single Dev that touches Karma says the same thing: “she needs further work like a rework or small midscope to fix problems like being too tied to proplay and not having an actual identity outside of Mantra E in the backline.
Current Karma is just another front at overbuffing something in her kit to try and hide problems and not actually work on the real problems. I’m frankly sick at tired of Devs that say one thing every single time, but they overbuff the most annoying parts of her kit that is a problem and play it off as if they are care and doing, at least, something. She shouldn’t be getting half arse work every single time, because it always leads to harsher nerfs, inconsistent design directions they say they wanna do, or they continue to remove parts of her kit that are actually fun. I’m tired of having a champ that has problems and a lazy Dev team constantly says and know she needs a rework/midscope, but they overbuff something that leads to her being in the same spot or worse.
Phreak cares less than all the other Devs that prefer to work on new champs and make excuses to continue working on new champs. Why is Karma getting nerfs when they’ve already done this experiment of overbuffing something in her kit? Like stop it and do your job at this point, cuz you clearly are not looking at the history of every single time she is worked on where they’ve done this and it hasnt worked out.
Imagine a world where your shield could do damage. I actually doesn't care about the damage, could be 1 damage, i dont really care. But in this world where shields could explode and with karma unique and legendary passive, if a shieldbomb procs at least one time in a 5x5 teamfight... the whole world would explode. In this world I would garantee perma shield and perma damage to everyone, i'm saying EVERYONE FOREVER.(until my mana goes down).
The shieldbomb karma is a myth, stop believing in it.
How is Karma ruined when she destroyed Viegos crown and shadows? Love how every popular champion is Sentinel and the "irrelevant" are ruined like plsss- and why they bring this theme AFTER 6 MONTHS.
I unlocked her and went straight into a ranked match (silver), I know you shouldn't do this but I play many similar supports so I went for it.
I maxed Q first and went mandate, in lane she felt solid with good poking and "get out of jail" shield, she feels very good in all ins or ganks because a W and RQ is deadly to ADC, and you have both slow and MS buff.
My previous match I played as Janna which was one of my mains last year, and the lack of damage made me feel really useless, this meta is all about damage even for supports.
I read often this thread even tho I didn't play her, and I saw a lot of you complaining about the Q AP scaling, but damn the unpowered Q has a low cooldown pretty quickly, and mid/late game it did like 1600dmg which was doing wonders.
I basically carried my whole team with Q and W on big targets and shield spam, I finished 7/2/19 which is pretty good since with supports usually you die a lot and get few kills. At the end I had 3000 money and no more available slots
So this was a good match and in other occasions I am sure it's harder, but she didn't feel weak to me. I would rather say she is difficult, because you have to think quickly and decide what to empower and on who, and never miss the RQ, but if you have a good awareness of what is going on I feel like she can work fine.
Her W is definitely lacking, I never empowered it, but still it can be useful in many scenarios. Maybe making the root quicker when it is empowered would be better.
I've been playing Karma before her rework and I gotta say, seeing her win rate shoot up after the last balance adjustment made me super hype. But playing her by just spamming RQ (especially with the 5 second passive buff) isn't really a healthy playstyle. It's gonna be nerfed easily by pure AP ratio changes, and it kinda goes against Phreak's idea of battlemage Karma (feels more like a burst mage, if you ask me).
Plus, with Renewal's healing and RE's group shields, Karma is still a viable pick for top lane tank or becoming a late-game shield bot as support (which Riot's not really a fan of). So, there's still a need for a full-on rework,or a mid-scope, in my opinion.
Now, the thing is, even though Riot sees her as a battle mage (which I don't totally agree with because Karma was originally more of a burst mage), her current kit just doesn't match up with the sustained fighting style battle mages are supposed to have (considering her not so reliable damage output). Comparing to other battle mages, they usually have sustained damage abilities, with bursts under certain conditions (like Anivia E, Taliyah E, or Vlad Q blood rush, etc.), and they've got speed / AOE control skills to keep up the fight and dish out consistent damage, meanwhile Karma only has one main skill shot damaging skill and got no effective CCs. And talking 'bout enchanters, they usually have some reliable crowd control. So, after looking into it, I think the Karma we've got in Wild Rift is kinda the best idea of a battle mage / enchanter fantasy. So, the goal of my Karma rework idea is to make her more like a battle mage and fix stuff that League players aren't too happy about, like not being able to choose which skill to empower with Mantra. Please notice that the skill values are tentative and subject to further adjustment. :)
Passive - Mantra
Innate – Mantra
Karma can empower her next basic ability by pressing R once within 8 seconds for an additional effect. This effect has a 36 / 32 / 28 / 24 second cooldown at levels 1, 6, 11, and 16 respectively. (Does not affected by ability haste.)
Karma begins the game with one rank in (R) Transcendent Embrace. Her empowered abilities scale based on (R) Transcendent Embrace’s rank.
Innate - Gathering Fire
(P) Mantra’s current cooldown is reduced by 6 seconds for each basic ability cast.
Goal: Transfer the passive from the Wild Rift version while retaining Karma's flexibility to freely choose which basic skill to empower (I believe we can achieve this through Hwei's technology). Additionally, change the cooldown reduction from damaging enemies to casting skills (which cannot be reduced by AH) to better fit the fighting style of battle mages, addressing the issue of late-game AP Karma primarily spamming RQ, making the choice of Mantra meaningful. Also, slightly increase the cooldown of Mantra (have to cast 4 abilities to proc), and of basic skills to balance out the addition of a new ultimate also encourage her to buy ability haste items while playing her mid.
Q - Inner Flame
COST: 40 / 50 / 60 / 70 / 80 Mana
COOLDOWN: 8 / 7 / 6 / 5 / 4 sec
CAST TIME: 0.4 ~ 0.15 s (reduced with higher ability haste, capped at 100 AH)
Active: Karma fires a bolt in the target direction that explodes on the first enemy hit, dealing magic damage to nearby enemies and slowing them by 35%, decaying over 2 seconds.
The explosion creates a field for 2 seconds that slows enemies within by 30 / 40 / 50 / 60%, which then ruptures to deal magic damage. If an enemy champion on the field is immobilized, the field immediately detonates.
Soulflare scales with (R) TranscendentEmbrace’s rank.
Goal: Sync Inner Flame's cooldown and mana cost with primary dmg output abilities of other battle mages, and encourage players to invest in ability haste and mana items by reducing its cast time. In order to better fit the "burst damage under certain conditions" concept, decrease the damage of RQ upon hitting, and increase the damage and detonation time of the field that is difficult to land, while adding an instant detonation mechanism to complement the new W and R for effective damage output. Slightly increase missile speed to compensate support Karma's lost. Kinda OP considering she has only one damaging skill, and the second explosion is hard to land.
W - Focused Resolve
COST: 80 / 85 / 90 / 95 / 100 Mana
COOLDOWN: 18 / 16 / 14 / 12 / 10 s
CAST TIME: 0.25 s
TARGET RANGE: 675 TETHER RADIUS: 850 (increase 25 in compensation of tether changes)
Active: Karma deals magic damage to a target enemy champion, monster or an enemy large minion and forms up to 2 tethers between her and them for 2 seconds, during which they are revealed.
Magic Damage: 40 / 60 / 80 / 100 / 120 (+ 50% AP)
If the tethers are not broken by the end of its duration, each target are dealt the same magic damage again and are rooted for a duration, during which they are revealed.
Mantra Bonus: A new tether will be formed between tethered targets. If there is only one tethered target in range of Karma, the new tether will spread from that target to a nearby enemy champion, enemy large minion or monster. If a target fails to break all their tethers, they are dealt the same magic damage and are rooted for a longer duration.
Root Duration Increase: 0.5 / 0.75 / 1 / 1.25 s
Goal: Port the W from the WR version, remove the health restoration based on missing health proportion after observing champions like Vlad, Cassiopeia, and other mages who have healing abilities, they are tied to AP. Karma, however, has tank-like health restoration capabilities. To prevent abuse of top lane tank Karma, remove and enhance her crowd control abilities.
E – Inspire
COST: 60 / 65 / 70 / 75 / 80 MANA
COOLDOWN: 11 / 10 / 9 / 8 / 7 s
CAST TIME: NONE TARGET RANGE: 800
ACTIVE: Karma grants a shield to herself or the target allied champion for 2 seconds as well as 40% / 45% / 50% / 55% / 60% bonus movement speed, decaying over 2 seconds.
Mantra Bonus: Karma focuses her power, granting a stronger shield that decays over 4 seconds and 60% bonus movement speed that decays to 20% over the same duration. An additional ring is generated around the shielded target, and the first ally champion who enters the ring will be granted the same shield. If there are more than one ally champion around the shielded target while this ability is cast, ally champion with the lowest health will be granted the shield.
Bonus Shield: 40 / 100 / 160 / 220 (+ 40% AP) (increased due to AOE shield loss)
Defiance scales with (R) Transcendent Embrace's rank.
Goal: Basically removing AOE shield, preventing her becoming shield bot late game. Thought of not removing it and make shield split on ally, but once it lasts support items on her becomes too OP.
R (press once): activate (P) Mantra
ACTIVE: Karma empowers her next basic ability within 8 seconds for an additional effect.
Mantra can be used while affected by cast-inhibiting crowd control.
Only available When (P) Mantra is not on cooldown.
R (press twice) – Transcendent Embrace
COST: 100 MANA
COOLDOWN: can't be cast at rank one / 110 / 100 / 90
CAST TIME: 0.5 s EFFECT RADIUS: 700 (to center)
Only can be cast after reaching second rank of(R) Transcendent Embrace.
ACTIVE: Karma immediately enters a Mantra state.
Karma forms a ring of spirit energy at the target location. After 1 second, it detonates, dealing magic damage to all enemies inside the circle and slowing them by 35% for 1 second. If enemies are hit by the outer ring, they will be knocked back towards the center.
Magic Damage: 125 / 250 / 375 (+ 80% AP)
Goal: Giving her an actual ult which can complement her RQ field, also fits lore. Low basic dmg and high ratio to prevent support being too OP after getting a new ult.
Thank you guys for reading! I think Karma's state now is good but I'm afraid that she might get nerfed, she's been doing too well in rank and pro league, and buffing her through ratio changes leads to this situation. I tried to make her more like a battle mage rather than a burst mage now and solve her gameplay issues. Hope you all like it and feel free to join the discussion, Let me know your thoughts!
ive been trying out enchanter karma bc i a) love the new skin and b) love enchanters, but it feels like every time a lane goes south its my bad because karma is a 'trash support'. maybe my sense of viable supports is wack (i play taliyah and enchanter orianna support) but i really think karma fits quite well in the support role. should i look to play her somewhere else?
if you showed me the model for karma, ignoring skin tone, and said it was soraka, i would honestly believe it. makes me a bit disappointed? maybe im wrong and she looks nothing like soraka, but i just feel like the model looks so off.
Part of what made Shield bomb feel like an actual bomb was the crazy amount of damage it did and the fact that Mantra used to have 2 charges. In a team fight you could hit the shield bomb 3 or maybe 4 times dealing massive damage to the enemy team.
But allocating that kind of power to one ability is impossible nowadays. Karma has 3 abilities now instead of a powerful shield and a super ineffective Q and W.
The devs simply don't have the ability to make Shield Bomb powerful enough to be nearly as fun or effective as it used to be.
Let's looks at some speculative examples of what I am talking about:
A Normal Mage's Power Distribution:
Q: 25%
W:20%
E:20%
R:35%
Old Karma's Power Distribution:
Q: 15%
W:25%
E:60%
New Karma's Power Distribution
Q:40%
W:25%
E:35%
This is just a speculative example, but see here how the fact that Karma has 3 health abilities means the budget for her E is significantly less than old Karma.