r/karate • u/omarfarouk_ab • Jan 05 '23
r/karate • u/Field_Jager • Feb 04 '24
Discussion I fucking hate karate, it’s ruined my life Spoiler
I’ve been in karate for 5 years, from age 9 to 14, and it was worst experience in my life.
I had to train for 2 hours straight 6 days a week all year round, without ANY breaks… Our sensei made us work to our limits, to the point that some of us (literal kids! Most of us were from 7-16) passed out from exhaustion.
I remember how he hit us with the stick so we would do exercises properly, and he literally broke it when he hit one of the students (the kid was 11!!! years old)
He practically forced us to participate in tournaments, even if we didn’t wanted or just couldn’t. He made us loose weight so we could fit into lower weight classes.
Because of all this now I have to deal with literal PTSD caused by it. I have panic attacks, body image issues, unbelievable low self esteem, depression, anxiety, and who knows what.
So yeah, I hate karate. Sorry for this rant, but I just can’t keep it in myself…
Also, just in case, I understand that this is my personal experience and it doesn’t represent all people, I know some people who benefited from it and were happy with their choices, but I’m talking about my experience.
r/karate • u/Sussy_looks • Apr 17 '24
Sport karate ruining the name?
I like watching videos of different styles fighting each other, I just find it interesting. I am an orange belt in shorin-ryu so I have some experience but still a novice. But I’ve noticed in every video where karate fights another art they are still really tappy with their strikes like in point or “sport” karate style.
We are taught how to fight tough and light so why aren’t they switching stances or hand positions? The real difference between real karate and kickboxing (other than specific techniques) is that we learn how to tap and how to hit while having the same speed. So why are these guys fighting in a full bladed stance instead of an orthodox or front stance? My school teaches how to fight in both for different types of fighting.
My theory is that people stopped teaching multiple ways to fight, they instead focus on sport karate and they get their black belt when in reality they only know one way to fight. Which is a questionable style for full contact or a streetlight.
I am not saying you can’t be a strong hitter from a bladed stance I am just confused on why that’s the go-to in a real fight when it doesn’t normally end well. Are schools that don’t teach anything but sport karate Mcdojos? And what happened to karate and its name since sport karate became more popular than the rougher, more street-practical karate?
Karate has become a joke of a name (no matter how good of a practitioner you really are) because on this jumpy, tappy sport style. If traditional, hard hitting karate was more popularized then it would be taken much more seriously.
I guess my main point is why do schools only teach one style of karate (sport) fighting instead of both? And is it fair that dojos that teach both still get the karate mockery when it’s not them?
(Props to anyone who read all that even if you don’t agree lol)
Disclaimer I am not trying to say sport karate is dumb or useless or for pussies or anything my question is why is that the only way some schools teach?
r/karate • u/Dward_77 • Sep 25 '25
Question/advice Please answer my survey on karate! Need it for black belt!
Responses are anonymous and confidential.
r/karate • u/[deleted] • Sep 28 '25
Debate: Shotokan doesn’t have a gender based advantage
I feel like if everyone starts at white with the same amount of literacy while learning from the ground up, then no one has an advantage.
(I can only speak for shotokan because thats my sport.) Its a common claim that men are better at sports that women because of muscle mass and strength, but this sport mainly requires agility, stamina and strategy.
Acknowledging that people compete in their class of skill level, its about who has better training
Thoughts?
r/karate • u/Massive_One4227 • Aug 05 '23
My heretical view on Kata
Okay, I'm going to "out" myself as the heretical Karate Black Belt that I am. I am NOT a fan of Kata as a crucial training method. I see Kata as a means to an end, NOT an end in itself. Karate is Kata, Kihan, and Kumite. In my heretical opinion, Kihan is the "stuff" of Karate, and and Kumite is "practice in using the stuff." I say Kihan and Kumite can be perfected via means OTHER than Kata. Yes, Kata DOES work as part of training. But there are other ways. More effective ways, in my opinion. Martial Arts are no longer banned across parts of the Eastern world as they were centuries ago, so I SEVERELY question over-reliance on Kata in modern times. I give "truth in advertising" when I teach Martial Arts. I tell those I train that I teach "Karate Kihan and Kumite." As far as the valuable time which would otherwise be spent learning Katas, I instead spend that time having them practice significant chunks of the basics of Kung Fu, Taekwondo, Krav Maga, and Muay Thai Kickboxing. The end result is better and faster skill improvement and development as fighters and self-defense artists. I am NOT denying that Kata can be effective in training. And Blessed Be to those of you who love, learn, and practice Kata. But I, personally, am so OVER the continued emphasis on Kata. I'm a proud Karate Black Belt, but I am not ashamed of my heretical views on Kata. I know I will catch hell for posting this. Domo Arigato for the presence of this forum.
r/karate • u/FuguSandwich • Apr 13 '25
Discussion Is there any footage of these "practical Karate based on secret bunkai" people sparring against a resisting opponent and using these techniques?
You know who I'm talking about. The people who insist that Karate pre-Funakoshi was a close range style of grappling with strikes, that blocks aren't blocks but instead grapples and strikes, and the true applications are hidden in the katas.
I want to see them spar and actually put this stuff to use.
Every time I see an Iain Abernethy video it's always a demo against a compliant partner where the opponent throws a slow mo punch and then stands there motionless with his arm extended while Iain blocks it and then does like 5 or 6 strikes culminating in a lock or throw while the guy just stands there.
And the techniques look totally contrived for no reason other than to look like what's in the kata.
Do any of these people spar? And if they do, are they actually pulling off these techniques or is it just devolving into either long range kickboxing or a standing clinch?
I don't mean to call out Iain, there are a whole bunch of people on YouTube posting the same stuff. That Illinois guy, the Javier guy, Even Jesse Enkamp has been making a lot of these types of videos and there is footage of him sparring, but he always looks like a traditional long range karate fighter.
r/karate • u/CuriousMartialArtist • Jul 02 '25
What is happening to karate?!
So I really need to address this because it has become a problem and honestly I am thinking of just quitting martial arts.
To begin with. I have been doing martial arts for 16 years now. My main art as you surely have guessed is karate. And I just love it. I begun with Shotokan and while in it I also visited and learned from senseis of different karate styles as well. I am just thrilled with the art. However when I noticed the full contact that Shorin Ryu and Kyokushin do, I started searching and found that for the goal of self defense etc point fighting isn't what you should be doing. So I went to my Sensei and talked to him about this. He said that we can incorporate full contact since we also sent a student to Karate Combat as well. After a few more months. Nothing. So I left. I spend a few years in MMA and combat sports to try and incorporate karate in full contact. Afterwards I spend my time in Tang Soo Do (which I also loved). And now I am in a different town because of university. And here is where my frustration is!
After I contacted and talked with a few schools. I ended up in a Kyokushin dojo. I specifically asked him if he does the more traditional techniques and stuff or if he is more focused on competition. He said that he is focused more on the traditional stuff. And that there are very few Kyokushin dojos that don't focus on pure competition nowadays. Which seemed like a red flag but I ignored it. I should have listened to my instinct because sure enough 2-3 months in and all we do is competition stuff. Not a single traditional thing. I was lied to basically. So once again (like in Shotokan). I left. If they wanted to focus more on competition that's totally fine. But I don't appreciate being lied to when I was very specific on my questions and wording that I wanted something more traditional. Which the right move would be to tell me they don't do that stuff so we can all go our way. Instead they just lied to keep me in the school. Just why?
Anyway. Then I found there are two Goju Ryu dojos. I called the first one. Asked the Sensei a few questions. Always respectfully and kindly (I don't have anything against nor do I know him to act otherwise). My 3rd question out of curiosity was if he also does full contact or purely point fighting. His answer? "NO! And I don't want anyone in my school who does full contact. Everyone who does it is an idiotic, low iq, masochistic who likes being beaten up". WOW! Then we exchanged a few more line that people typically say when the conversation is over and I hung up.
Finally. I called the other Goju Ryu school to set up a day to meet. Like the previous guy she wanted to talk through the phone instead. So we did that. The conversation was going smoothly and she was indeed very kind. Until...she wasn't. She asked me my martial arts background. I told her. She asked if I went to other schools while permanently attending one (the Shotokan one I mentioned) and then also switched completely and not staying put because I haven't found what I want. I told her no and that it was because I just enjoyed karate and wanted to learn as much as possible and that I left because it has been proven that point fighting doesn't work. She asked if I wanted to do full contact now. I said no. Although it would be a bonus. I went through that for quite a few years and I am confident I can defend myself (and I have). Now I just want to continue my studies in karate (she said she also did the more traditional stuff I want before that part of the conversation). And she says: (in that sort of ironic/cocky tone) "Oh. Because you know. I am in contact with other senseis (she means the ones that do point fighting like the Shotokan Sensei). So I can easily learn who you are and all that". She basically threatened that she can learn who I am just because I also visited other styles while in Shotokan, and because I quit it since the Sensei did point fighting (and lied about the full contact part, but I didn't say that to her) and went to other arts. Like WTF??!!!
Those are not the only times senseis talked in that tone to me or other people I know. Those two are just the main ones that stuck with me and are recent. So like I say in the title. What is happening to karate?! Since when has it become a thing for sensei's to lie in order to keep you coming, call you names when you did something different threaten you?
And yeah. I am very disappointed with all this. I am discourage in continuing and I am actually thinking of quitting martial arts as a whole. Anyway. I just wanted to get all that out of my chest. Thanks everyone for reading!
r/karate • u/Ok-Egg-3539 • Sep 25 '24
Is kata actually beneficial?
Half the moves are incredibly unrealistic I just dotn see why anyone would use it in a real fight.
r/karate • u/luke_fowl • Aug 24 '26
Discussion Style Cannot be Separated from Training
Disclaimer: Another long and controversial post from me, so hold on to your handrails. Please don't just dump a knee-jerk comment on me.
The most common excuse I hear whenever a "traditional martial artist" loses a fight against a "modern sports fighter" is that it's not the style that matters but the individual person. What's interesting to me is that it always comes from the "traditional" side when they lose, almost reflexively, and especially with karate (and wing chun frankly).
Here's a hypothetical: we take 30 untrained Average Joes of the same size and have 10 of them train aikido, 10 of them train karate, and 10 of them train kickboxing for an equal amount of time. Then we have them go on a free fight against each other on the proverbial streets, or even UFC 1 rules, which set would you bet will remain standing? Let's be honest, as much as we want the karate guys to win, most of us would place our money on the kickboxers, and barely anyone will place it on the aikido guys.
Or in a ruder awakening, who would you rather not have trying to beat you up: a karateka with 5 years of training or a boxer with 1 year of training?
Now don't get me wrong, I'm not a karate hater. I have a deep love for kata and I have written quite a bit around them here. But if it really is just about the individual person and not the style, the above hypothetical wouldn't be the case. A great example of this is the kyokushin vs muay thai fight in the 60s. Karateka love to talk about how the karate won 2/3 of the fights, despite the fact that Oyama brought 3 of his best students to go against literal nobodies in muay thai (despite muay thai being in their Silver Age). Even worse, or better (depending how you see it), Oyama and his students changed Kyokushin after that match, whereas muay thai stayed the same. If karate was indeed better than, or even equal to, muay thai, why would they even adapt, and why wouldn't muay thai adapt too? Even before this fight, Kyokushin was already famous for being the toughest style of karate, if we were to send fighters from literally any other style (including Shito-ryu, so that no one can accuse me of being biased), do we really think we would get even one win?
What really differentiated muay thai from kyokushin? Or an even better question, what differentiated kyokushin from other karate styles? With very minor exceptions, like rolling thunder, almost all our techniques are the same. Or as someone pointed out to me, Shotokan and Goju-ryu are more similar than Ali and Frazier. We have 2 arms and 2 legs, can't really be that big of a difference.
So that brings me to another historic occasion in martial arts: koryu jujutsu's extinction in the hands of Kano jujutsu. Kano made it very clear that judo was based on Tenjin Shinyo-ryu and Kito-ryu which, like all other jacket grappling styles, have similar technique sets. But what allowed the Four Guardians and his other students wipe the floor with other jujutsuka to the point where almost every jujutsuka jumped ship into the Kodokan? The main change he made was removing dangerous techniques and focusing on randori.
With all that said, we see that even with a relatively same technique set, you can still have a more dominant style. But to use judo as an example, if we remove randori from it, would it still be judo or would it "devolve" into koryu jujutsu? If we removed the judogi from judo, would it still be judo?
The same question then applies to any other style, especially karate. Is the reason that tradition martial arts consistently lose against modern combat sports just because of the individuals? Why can't we produce better fighters statistically speaking? And why do professional karate fighters like Lyoto Machida and Wonderboy Thompson fight nothing like how karate is "traditionally" trained, whereas boxers fight exactly like how boxing is trained?
Could it be that perhaps other than the techniques we do, another similarity within karate is how we train? Like no matter where you go in the world, 90% of karate dojo spend half their time going up and down the hall hitting air? Or how karate's sparring, i.e. kumite (crossing hands), is basically only the equivalent of judo's uchikomi (striking repetition) or muay thai's drills rather than judo's randori (free practice) or muay thai's technical sparring, and much less stuff like judo's shiai (trial/contest) and muay thai's real fight?
Why do we not fight the way we train? Why is it despite the talks of rooting and stable stances in Sanchin and Naihanchi, the two most important kata in karate, do karateka bounce around instead? Why is it that we still practice hikite, despite making it easy to get knocked out? Why are we training in a way that's contrary to how we fight? Or perhaps the better question, or the one I believe myself, is why do we fight in a way that's contrary to how we train?
Before anyone can say, "But that's not how karate was originally trained!" We have photos and videos from the pre-war era that looks very similar to what we do now. We also have photos and videos of other martial arts from the same era. But on the other hand, we know that training in a karategi was only introduced after Kano gifted Funakoshi with a judogi, so it is in fact a created tradition. And yet if we suggested that karateka ditch the karategi, that would basically be heresy.
Another example is the hojo-undo. Why do people still train using things like chi-ishi and ishi-sashi in a world where we now have kettlebells and clubs? Why do karateka not use mitts more to practice their strikes? I suppose the simple answer, and something I personally understand as well, is that because that would lose the identity of karate as a unique art.
Like it or not, the KKK (unfortunate abbreviation, I know) of karate is the foundation of our art. All 3 of them, especially kata, have been emphasized by the masters a lot, even if not in a clear defined KKK package. It could be reasonably argued that if we get rid of even one of them, we would have ceased to practice karate.
So where does that leave us? Stuck with a crappy pedagogy? I'm honestly not sure myself. What I am sure, however, is that the training is part of the style itself. A good style is more statistically likely to produce good fighters, be it by actually good pedagogy, good culture, and/or good quality control. Is karate a good style? You tell me.
Bonus: Andy Hug vs. Changpuek in kickboxing rules (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ol7uAQ22Wn8). See how Andy Hug, considered one of the heavyweight GOATs, looks nothing like how we train, whereas Changpuek, considered an average lightweight muay thai fighter, fights exactly like how nak muay train.
r/karate • u/Ogsonic • Jul 28 '24
Discussion Am I the only one that highly respects karate but absolutely detests mma and the ufc?
I am not sure if I am alone in this but I did tae kwon do and karate for periods of time years back and I respect both martial arts and find value in both of them and have a lot of respect for martial arts as a whole. Despite that I absolutely can not stand mma or ufc. I get nothing but bad vibes from famous ufc/mma fighters despite those sports being martial arts based. I think this is most likely due to that fanbase rather than the sport themselves. UFC is highly politicized to the point politics is practically intertwined with the fanbase. Lots of famous mma fighters being absolute garbage human beings does not help either. I could extend this criticism to the boxing scene as a whole.
Karate, kung fu, tae kwon do and other more authentic martial arts are not intertwined with politics at all and growing up this allowed me to really focus on becoming a good fighter and learning discipline. I also find due to the nature of martial arts like karate and the idea of this being used for self defense, learning contentment and building discipline. I find most people in this sport to be good natured and genuinely good people to be around. There's less chest pumping and desire to be super macho in martial arts compared to mma.
r/karate • u/karatebreakdown • Aug 14 '24
What Karate can learn from BJJ Classes
r/karate • u/DeadpoolAndFriends • Mar 18 '16
This is my song is my Jam. Totally gotta start class with it ;)
r/karate • u/ZeroPotato • Sep 06 '26
Discussion What is actual "correct" in karate?
Recently I thought about the definition of "correct" in karate. In other sports mostly correct means the best movement to achieve the best possible reaction. Ball sports are easy to see in this, fighting styles also. But if we look at traditional karate training or traditional taekwondo things get weird.
Each style does things somewhat differently, hips, deeper stance, where to start the movement of a block etc. overall someone (usually your master) defines what is correct. There can even be subliminal differences in the same style, if they came from a different master or just changed it themselves because they didn't like it.
The best example can be tournament. A kata just looks different in training compared to a tournament.
Our fighting is not even the same sport when you look at the way we train.
So in your opinion what is correct?
Is there even a 'correct' way to throw a zuki?
Edit: I think we somehow and somewhere lost the true meaning of martial arts when we look at why Bodhidharma created a martial art system just as a tool to develop character, reach mindfulness and enlightenment.
r/karate • u/Firm_Chef_2001 • Feb 25 '26
Can i say i practice karate?
Hi,i have been lurking her for awhile and this is my first post. i came here ask the afromentioned qwestion above,can i call myself a karateka?,due to circumstance i have never had the privilege to step unto a real dojo never train with a real instructor or anything of the sort,all that i have had as a resource is karate books and trusted media such as alot of training manuals from goju ryu and full contact karate manuals, my physical training mostly is me practicing stances,blocks,and executing my techniques on my own makeshift makiwara,also some bagwork and resistance traning with workout bands,i also recently started to learn a kata like naihanchi.
What i mean to say is that i enjoy doing this,and what i practice by myself could be called karate but due to the fact i have never had any real instruction i dont feel like i can say that,i feel like a larper acting out a fantasy in my room,i would love all your much wiser opinons on the this.
Thank you.
Wow thank you everyone that responded,and im glad for it. i would like to clarify certain things. I am and have been quite aware that i will never be as competent as anyone who actually pratices in a real dojo with a real instructor,and with real people,that of course sucks as i do wish to get stronger/better but i am a realist.
When i ment saying i practice karate i ment mostly a claim i would say to myself,im not so full of myself that i would make such a claim public when its clearly not(i dont think i would have the guts to be so cringe) i am simply wishing to try my best being apart of something that i look up to,of course i would like to get better at punches and kicks but i do quiet enjoy even more the philosophy. "The ultimate aim of karate lies not in victory or defeat, but in the perfection of the character of its participants" is one that realy sticks with me
And to elaborate on said circumstances i dont have much money and the closest dojo to me is far beyond what little i have left after paying for my nessesities so sadly i most likey will not be able to afford such in the near future.
Final notes: this kinda an off shoot but anyone willing to help or give me tips on how i can continue what im doing in a better way any of you would recomend.
Thank you.
r/karate • u/FizhyFishy_ • Jun 23 '25
Discussion Karate Competitions Are Watered Down Compared To Training
I’m 17 and have been training in Tang Soo Do Karate for 9 years. Lately, I’ve been frustrated with how much modern karate tournaments go against the practicality of what we’re actually taught. For example, getting warned, or even disqualified for “excessive contact” is ridiculous. I get the need for safety, especially for kids and casual practitioners, but at the end of the day, karate is a martial art. It was developed for real combat situations, even life or death ones. A hard hit should be expected. We should be conditioned to take a bit of damage, it’s part of the discipline. Then there’s the issue of banned techniques. Things like leg kicks, open hand strikes, clinching, knees, elbows, grabbing kicks, all of these are taught in karate. Yet they’re illegal in tournaments. Why? If these techniques are part of our training, why are we not allowed to use them in competition? It feels like we’re being taught one version of karate but asked to do a dumbed down version when it matters most. Lastly, I’ve never understood the very popular use of those thin satin uniforms in some competitions. Sure, they’re light and easier to move in, but you should be able to fight and move effectively in your actual gi. In real world situations where you need to defend yourself, you’re more likely to be wearing jeans, shoes, which are pretty heavy, or a jacket, not some featherweight suit. Part of karate is learning to adapt and move in less than ideal conditions, including clothing. Just needed to get that off my chest. Anyone else feel this way?
r/karate • u/Upper-Bake-9480 • Sep 27 '25
Supplementary training Difficult Drill
There are infinite things that come together when you are performing any technique.
The aim is to maximise everything and bring it together to deliver the perfect move
This drill is an excellent drill to really enhance your physical ability.
It is a challenging drill, I would definitely categorise it as "high level" but it is very much worth giving a go - there is too much to be gained from it to just ignore it.
It's all down to whether or not you are willing to put the work in to get the results.
*I would genuinely be impressed to see anyone pull it off competently.