r/juststart • u/brandhacker • 2d ago
I tracked which of my own pages AI assistants cite for over a year. Most of the GEO checklist did nothing for me
I run a small consultant site in a non-English market (France), and I've been watching which pages get cited by AI answers since mid 2025. Not a study, just one site and what I could measure.
Short version: the pages that get cited are the pages that already rank. The tricks barely mattered.
What I could actually measure
Bing Webmaster Tools has an AI Performance report. Over 30 days in February it counted about 830 citations for the whole site. One page, my "best freelance GEO" page, took close to 400 of them. It's also one of the pages that ranks best on regular search.
What I tried and what came out
A page written only for AI answers. I built a "find a freelance SEO" page from scratch with AI answers in mind. It does get cited. But it's also a normal page that ranks, so I can't say the AI angle did anything.
FAQ blocks by context (one for tradespeople, one for small businesses, one for WordPress sites). Added in July 2025. Two weeks later I'd moved them to my "not sure this does anything" pile and nothing since has changed my mind.
Ranking first on Google. One page sits at #1 for its query, and it's the exact page Google's AI Overview cites for that query. That's the cleanest result I have.
Being named on other sites. ChatGPT started naming me among the top consultants in my country after I appeared in a couple of other people's "best consultants" lists (we listed each other). No link needed for that, the mention was enough.
Doing nothing. I relaunched an old affiliate site as a side project in October. No GEO work at all. It still got a lead that came from ChatGPT.
What I'd actually do
Rank on regular search first. AI answers mostly read from there.
Get your name into lists and threads on other sites, with or without a link.
Write the page for the question people type, answer it early.
Then, if you still have time, the polish.
What I skip now: llms.txt, and building pages "for the AIs" that wouldn't deserve to rank anyway.
One site, one market, so take it as a data point, not a rule. Anyone seeing different numbers in Bing's AI report?