r/juresanguinis • • Jul 18 '25

Recognition Success! I got my passport!

Post image
454 Upvotes

It was a 3 year journey. We weren’t allowed to be included in my aunt’s application, but since she was recognized first at the same consulate, it was a much simpler process for my father, my siblings, and nephew.

The three years was mainly waiting. Asuncion has a lista d’attessa and no turns, so you just deliver the documents and wait. We delivered the docs on 3 June 2022z My turn arrived at the end of May 2025, and received a confirmation from the Comune in mid-June!

My next obstacle was changing consulates because I had moved to the Netherlands before recognition. There was some struggle getting my original consulate to enable my FastIT account but everything else was quick. My Comune was super responsive in providing my birth certificate extract, and my new consulate approved the move very quickly. I got a passport turn 2 weeks in advance, and today I finally have my passport with me! Drove to the consulate early and came out with my passport in hand! And my CIE will arrive in a few weeks.


r/juresanguinis • • Jul 27 '26 Bravo

Judicial News The “minor issue” is no more — the Court of Cassation rules that the descendants of a child who held dual citizenship from birth cannot lose Italian citizenship if the parents of that child naturalized while they were still a minor.

431 Upvotes

The Court of Cassation has upheld the arguments put forward by Avv. Restanio that critizised the incorrect interpretation of Articles 7 and 12 of Law No. 555 of 1912 that gave rise to the so-called “minor issue”. This interpretation prevented countless Italian citizens from obtaining recognition after the Italian administration, through Circular No. 43347 of 2024, unfairly and unexpectedly applied flawed and isolated case law that contradicted the interpretation of these two articles consistently followed for over a century, which established no such preclusion, de facto stripping them of their citizenship.

The United Sections have clearly established that Article 7 protected any minor who was an Italian citizen iure sanguinis and a foreign citizen iure soli from birth against the loss of Italian citizenship due to subsequent changes in the citizenship of either parent, returning to the original — and only — interpretation of these provisions since their enactment. Given the authority of this ruling, the “minor issue” can be considered over, at least before the courts.

The Court has also confirmed again, as we had already argued in this forum, that the reform does NOT apply to judicial cases that started before March 27, 2025 at 23:59.

Many issues and unresolved questions remain, of course, regarding the decisions that administrative authorities will take following this ruling, as well as the interaction between the unfair preclusions arising from the “minor issue” and the broader reform of Italian citizenship introduced by the Tajani Decree, which the Constitutional Court has recently referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

For the full ruling: https://files.catbox.moe/u30arl.pdf


r/juresanguinis • • Aug 21 '26

Post-Recognition Took 6 years; got it today

Post image
415 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • Aug 02 '25

Recognition Success! After 4 years I finally got it

Post image
402 Upvotes

After four years of mounting the family tree, finding and translating documents, hiring a lawyer, and a some money 😅, I’m the first in my family to get the passport. My siblings and mother are still trying to schedule their appointment, but apparently in Brazil, where they are, is more competitive than in the US. Anyways, this is such a great moment to recognize the effort we had, and also to remember my ancestors and to thank them to this heritage.


r/juresanguinis • • Apr 01 '25 Helpful

Community Updates What's happening in Rome

394 Upvotes

I am one of you, an Italian 🇮🇹 citizen by descent who obtained my JS recognition in 2023.

Today I attended the hearing today at the Courte di Cassazione concerning the 'minor issue', I was the only non-native born Italian in attendance. All indications are positive, the prosecution changed their stance and it's all but certain: The minor issue will not stand, expect a ruling in the next few months.

While this case is not directly related to Friday's decree or 1948 cases I was able to talk directly to all the leading attorneys in this space. I won't name drop, you all know exactly who they are.

They all had the exact same advice: "Fight for your Rights 💪".

They all believe:

  1. This decree and the new rules contained within it violate both the Italian Constitution and EU law.

  2. Many consulates have closed their appointment pages opens a unique opportunity to file court cases as you absolutely can not get an appointment in any way.

  3. Political pressure has been building very quickly. Contact the Italian Senator for North America Francesca La Marca [email protected]

Andiamo! (Let's Go!)


r/juresanguinis • • Apr 17 '26 Bravo

DL36-L74/2025 Discussion BREAKING: Bologna Court grants Italian Citizenship by descent to 4th-Generation family after Tajani Decree - no Consular appointment before March 27, 2025

381 Upvotes

Ciao a tutti, 

A major post-reform development has come out of Bologna, Italy for families pursuing Italian citizenship by descent / jure sanguinis after the Tajani Decree, the post-L74 reform, and the recent Constitutional Court developments.

On April 17, 2026, the Tribunale Ordinario di Bologna recognized Italian citizenship by descent in ruling no. 3335/26, issued by Judge Dott.ssa Natascia Gardini, in a post-reform case involving 2nd, 3rd, and 4th generation descendants - a family of 11 applicants in total. The case was filed on May 17, 2025, after the new legal framework had already come into effect.

The ruling accepted the legal strategy advanced in the case: that recognition of Italian citizenship after the reform remained justified where the applicants had clearly manifested their intention to proceed, but had been unable to secure a consular appointment for reasons beyond their control.

This ruling was issued in a case brought by our firm, based on the legal strategy developed by our attorney, Avvocato Salvatore Aprigliano.

The decision is also notable because the judge expressly refers to the Constitutional Court press release of March 12, 2026 when addressing the legal framework applicable to the case.

While noting that this ruling isn't binding for other ongoing cases and doesn't change the risk profile of anyone filing now, we hope this decision brings some real encouragement this weekend to the many families who filed after the Tajani Decree reform and are still waiting to see how the post-reform citizenship landscape will develop.

In the coming days, we will be publishing the full ruling for your reference.

Una buona giornata a tutti,

Avv. Salvatore Aprigliano


r/juresanguinis • • Feb 25 '26

Post-Recognition Does not feel real, but it's real, and it's fantasic

Post image
370 Upvotes

My sister and I had our appointments yesterday. Went very smooth, except we had to go in at seperate times as we dont live at the same address. The employee at the Toronto Consulate named Alexia was so nice, and even complimented me on my Italian (which is enough to make anyone happy, lol)

Next, getting fastit ID confirmed, getting my codice fiscale & CIE, but most importantly, getting my wife her citizenship as well. I think i need to email comune di Caltanisetta (which i believe will be my comune as it was my nonnas place of birth) and try to request mg estratto riassunto di matrimonio, but im worried my data hasn't been transcribed yet. I guess it cant hurt to ask? If anyone has any tips, let me know.

Also, i chose to wait to get my daughter her passport as she is only 19 months old, and the passport will just expire very quickly. Is this a good move?


r/juresanguinis • • Mar 28 '25

Community Updates MEGATHREAD: Italy Tightens Rules on Citizenship for Descendants Abroad

362 Upvotes

Overview:

UPDATE 3/29 12:17 AM Rome time - the law has been published in the Gazzetta Ufficiale: https://www.gazzettaufficiale.it/atto/serie_generale/caricaDettaglioAtto/originario?atto.dataPubblicazioneGazzetta=2025-03-28&atto.codiceRedazionale=25G00049&elenco30giorni=false

Here is the most relevant section, translated into English:

Article 1

Urgent Provisions Regarding Citizenship

To Law No. 91 of February 5, 1992, after Article 3, the following is inserted: “Article 3-bis. - 1. By way of exception to Articles 1, 2, 3, 14, and 20 of this law, Article 5 of Law No. 123 of April 21, 1983, Articles 1, 2, 7, 10, 12, and 19 of Law No. 555 of June 13, 1912, as well as Articles 4, 5, 7, 8, and 9 of the Civil Code approved by Royal Decree No. 2358 of June 25, 1865, it is considered that someone who was born abroad, even before the date of enactment of this article, and who holds another nationality, has never acquired Italian citizenship, unless one of the following conditions applies:

a) The person's citizenship status is recognized, in accordance with the applicable law as of March 27, 2025, following a request, accompanied by the necessary documentation, submitted to the competent consular office or mayor no later than 23:59, Rome time, on the same date;

b) The person's citizenship status is judicially verified, in accordance with the applicable law as of March 27, 2025, following a judicial request submitted no later than 23:59, Rome time, on the same date;

c) A parent or adoptive parent who is a citizen was born in Italy;

d) A parent or adoptive parent who is a citizen has been a resident in Italy for at least two continuous years before the child's birth or adoption;

e) A first-degree ascendant of the parents or adoptive parents who is a citizen was born in Italy.”

What does this mean for you?

• ⁠If you are recognized, you are unaffected. • ⁠If you submitted your consulate or comune application prior to March 27 March 28, you are unaffected. • ⁠1948 and ATQ cases: if your case has been judicially verified (i.e. you've ALREADY been given a positive ruling) OR your case has been filed, you are unaffected. • ⁠1948 and ATQ cases: if your case has not yet been FILED, you ARE affected. • ⁠This applies to all future applications, regardless of where you live, regardless of whether you file judicially or administratively.

FAQ

Is there any chance that this could be overturned?

• ⁠This must be passed by Parliament within 60 days, or else the rules revert to the old rules. However, we don't think that there is any reason that Parliament wouldn't pass this.

Is there a language requirement?

• ⁠There is no new language requirement with this legislation.

What does this mean for Bill 752 and the other bills that have been proposed?

• ⁠Those bills appear to be superseded by this legislation.

My grandparent was born in Italy, but naturalized when my parent was a minor. Am I SOL?

• ⁠We are waiting for word on this issue. We will update this FAQ as we get that information.

Is this even Constitutional?

• ⁠We don't know. The Constitution gives the legislature the power to define citizenship, but there is a lot of law around the the idea that the law in force at the time of someone's birth should be the law that guides their right to citizenship. We anticipate legal battles.

Information below this point is old. Leaving it up for history's sake.


The Italian government has introduced stricter rules for obtaining citizenship through descent (jus sanguinis), aiming to reduce abuse and reinforce a real connection to Italy.

There is a decreto legge (which is automatically valid, in force now, and remains in force unless not approved by Parliament) which changes the JS requirements. 

There is also a disegno di legge (which is not yet valid, not yet in force, and must be voted upon) which would further place restrictions on Italian citizens that were born abroad.

Text of the summary of changes (from the Ministry): https://www.governo.it/it/articolo/comunicato-stampa-del-consiglio-dei-ministri-n-121/28079

Text of the proposed law (the Ministry organization piece, not the JS piece) is here (in Italian): https://italianismo.com.br/it/conselho-de-ministros-analisa-hoje-freio-nos-pedidos-de-cidadania-italiana/

Source: https://www.youtube.com/live/03uAfJPqD5c

Ministry post: https://www.esteri.it/en/sala_stampa/archivionotizie/comunicati/2025/03/il-consiglio-dei-ministri-approva-modifiche-alla-legge-sulla-cittadinanza-ius-sanguinis/

Press Release of the Council of Ministers No. 121

March 28, 2025

The Council of Ministers met on Friday, March 28, 2025, at 11:27 AM at Palazzo Chigi, under the presidency of President Giorgia Meloni. The Secretary was the Undersecretary to the Presidency of the Council Alfredo Mantovano.

CITIZENSHIP AND SERVICES FOR ITALIAN CITIZENS AND COMPANIES ABROAD

  1. ⁠Urgent Provisions Regarding Citizenship (Decree-Law)

The Council of Ministers, upon the proposal of President Giorgia Meloni, Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Antonio Tajani, and Minister of the Interior Matteo Piantedosi, has approved a decree-law introducing urgent provisions regarding citizenship.

This legislative action allows for the immediate implementation of certain provisions from the citizenship bill simultaneously approved by the Council of Ministers, specifically concerning the limitation of the automatic transmission of citizenship through jus sanguinis. While maintaining the fundamental principle of descent from Italian citizens, the new measures emphasize the need for a genuine connection to Italy for children born abroad to Italian citizens. This is in line with other European countries' legal systems and aims to ensure the free movement within the European Union only for those who maintain a substantial link with their country of origin.

The new rules state that descendants of Italian citizens born abroad will automatically receive citizenship only for two generations. Only those with at least one parent or grandparent born in Italy will be citizens by birth. Children of Italians will automatically acquire citizenship if born in Italy or if one of their parents, before their birth, has lived in Italy for at least two continuous years.

These new limits apply only to those with another nationality (to avoid creating stateless persons) and are valid regardless of the birth date (before or after the decree-law’s enactment). Individuals previously recognized as citizens will remain so. Applications for citizenship recognition submitted by March 27, 2025, at 11:59 PM (Rome time) will be processed according to previous rules.

Additionally, the text addresses disputes related to determining statelessness and Italian citizenship, stating that:

• ⁠Oaths and testimony are not admissible as evidence. • ⁠The applicant for Italian citizenship must prove that they do not meet the conditions for the loss or non-acquisition of citizenship as outlined by law.

  1. ⁠Provisions Regarding Citizenship (Bill)

The Council of Ministers, upon the proposal of Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation Antonio Tajani and Minister of the Interior Matteo Piantedosi, has approved a bill introducing provisions concerning citizenship.

The intervention, in line with the principles established by the European Convention on Nationality of 1997 and considering the rights associated with citizenship at the European level (European Union citizen - Article 9 TUE), introduces the international principle of "genuine connection" between the individual and the state, allowing citizenship acquisition only when there is a genuine link with the granting country. This link is considered genuine when there is a requirement for "qualified residence" in Italy, characterized by a sufficiently long period (at least two continuous years). Only under such objective and enduring conditions can access to the complex bundle of rights and duties of citizens, as provided by Article 1 of the Constitution, be guaranteed.

The bill, therefore, also incorporates urgent measures from the decree-law approved by the Council of Ministers, making substantial changes to the rules for transmitting citizenship, balancing two constitutional values: maintaining ties with Italy and encouraging the return immigration of descendants of Italian emigrants, while ensuring that the acquisition and retention of Italian citizenship are anchored in a genuine link to the Republic and its territory.

Firstly, the birth certificate of descendants of Italian citizens born abroad must be registered before the age of twenty-five; otherwise, they will no longer be able to request citizenship due to presumed "lack of genuine ties with Italy" resulting from non-exercise of rights and non-fulfillment of duties.

In line with the principle of genuine connection to the country of citizenship, the bill introduces the possibility of losing citizenship for "disuse" by Italian citizens born abroad who, after the enactment of the new rules, do not maintain a genuine connection with the Republic of Italy for at least 25 years, shown by the non-exercise of rights or non-fulfillment of duties associated with Italian citizenship.

Support for return immigration is further strengthened:

• ⁠A minor child of Italian citizens (if not already a citizen) will acquire citizenship if born in Italy or if they live there for two years, with a simple declaration of intent by the parents. • ⁠It is confirmed that those who have lost citizenship can regain it, but only if they reside in Italy for two years. • ⁠Furthermore, anyone with at least one Italian grandparent (or who was once an Italian citizen) may become a citizen after residing in Italy for three years (instead of the five or ten years required for EU and non-EU foreign citizens, respectively). • ⁠Spouses of Italian citizens can continue to obtain naturalization but only if residing in Italy.

In any case, an individual who becomes of age may renounce citizenship if they hold another nationality (to avoid statelessness).

The transmission of citizenship through the mother is recognized for those born after January 1, 1927, specifically for those who were minors on January 1, 1948, when the republican Constitution came into effect, clarifying an issue that had been subject to conflicting interpretations.

Procedural timelines for citizenship recognition are set at 48 months.

Increased Application Fees

• ⁠Citizenship application fees: ⁠• ⁠Were €300 ⁠• ⁠Increased to €600 (from Jan 1, 2025) ⁠• ⁠Will rise to €700 under the new proposal

No Retroactive Stripping, but No Amnesties

• ⁠Those who already have citizenship or applied before March 27 are unaffected. • ⁠No “amnesties” will be granted under the new system.

Focus on Preventing Abuse

• ⁠Reforms aim to stop “citizenship shopping,” fake connections, and use of citizenship to access business or medical services in Italy. • ⁠Tajani stressed: “Being an Italian citizen must be a serious matter.”

Why was this done?

• ⁠The reform aims to crack down on abuses and "passport tourism" (people applying for Italian citizenship for convenience, benefits, or fraud). • ⁠The goal is to ensure only those with a real, ongoing connection to Italy can become or remain Italian citizens. • ⁠Massive growth in citizenship recognitions: ⁠• ⁠4.6M Italians abroad in 2014 → 6.4M in 2024 (+40%) ⁠• ⁠Argentina, Brazil, and Venezuela have seen large increases in applications • ⁠Over 60,000 pending citizenship cases in Italian courts • ⁠Up to 60–80 million people worldwide could potentially qualify under the old law • ⁠Some obtained passports only to take advantage of Italian healthcare or EU mobility


r/juresanguinis • • Jun 22 '26

Humor or Off-Topic Found in the Onion - hits way too hard 😫

Post image
350 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • 24d ago

Recognition Success! A dream that came true

Post image
333 Upvotes

I started the whole process on April 25’
Got recognized on December 25’
And finally obtained the Passaporto!!


r/juresanguinis • • Jan 09 '26

Post-Recognition Finally recognized. It took 20 freakin’ years.

Post image
322 Upvotes

Yes, 20 years. My grandfather never naturalized and it was far more difficult to prove a negative than it would have been had we had naturalization docs. One clerk in 1950 made a mistake on the census and it took me five years to get that overlooked. It was a very difficult road but all roads lead to Rome!


r/juresanguinis • • Mar 30 '25

Community Updates Bans, bans, and more bans

315 Upvotes

We've tried to be nice, and all that's happened is that we've been completely overwhelmed.

We understand this issue and these times are emotional for a lot of people.

If you come to our sub to shit on Italy or Italians, you will be banned. Rule 1.

If you come to our sub to rejoice in the misery of people whose hopes have been crushed, you will be banned. Rule 7. And 1.

If you are brigading from another sub, you will not only be banned, but your activity will reported to Reddit for possible IP ban.

BASTA!!! ENOUGH!!!

To the vast majority of people who have processed this and responded with maturity, thank you.

Please report posts and comments, we will be working to keep our community functioning with decorum.

ETA: We have noticed several examples of excellent discussion happening, particularly between the varying points of view, that is happening without name-calling, flaming, just good civil discussion. That is absolutely fine! Please continue to do that.


r/juresanguinis • • Apr 22 '25 Take My Energy

Apply in Italy Help Here’s one loophole Tajani didn’t consider… I might be able to live in Italy after all!

Post image
312 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • Jun 22 '26 Heartwarming

Recognition Success! 🎉 OFFICIALLY RECOGNIZED AS AN ITALIAN CITIZEN! 🇮🇹🇪🇺

306 Upvotes

🎉 OFFICIALLY RECOGNIZED AS AN ITALIAN CITIZEN! 🇮🇹🇪🇺

Started process: February 2024
Applied: December 2024
Court date: Changed from 2028 to May 25 2026
Ruling: June 22nd

After a long journey I received the email today that my Italian citizenship has officially been recognized!

I honestly can’t thank this community enough. These Facebook groups and Reddit forums were where I first learned about the jure sanguinis process what documents I needed and ultimately where I found my attorney Aprigliano International Law Firm. Without all of the shared experiences and advice here I wouldn’t have even known where to begin.

A huge thank you to the entire team at Aprigliano especially Sarka for her communication support and guidance throughout this process. This is a milestone I’ll remember for the rest of my life.

I also wanted to share something that may help others:

If you filed before the law changed and only had NARA records without a USCIS CoNE my case was successful. I know that’s something many people worry about so I hope this gives someone else a little reassurance.

Thank you to everyone who answered questions shared timelines and offered encouragement along the way.

We did it! 🇮🇹❤️


r/juresanguinis • • Oct 01 '26

Recognition Success! After 4 years finals

Post image
297 Upvotes

After 4 years and a 1948 case glad to add this one to the collection with my Uruguayan and American passport. My gggf was Italian.

Felt quite surreal waiting for this but it was totally worth it. Houston consulate today was quite quick in under an hour got the appointment done and passport.

Family comes from Piemonte near Alessandria as is common in South America. Did most of the work through the Italian embassy in Uruguay since my parents and whole extended family are Uruguayan. Good luck to those others on the same journey!


r/juresanguinis • • Jul 25 '25

Recognition Success! Received my Passport!!

Post image
297 Upvotes

I started this journey 5 years and 9 months ago. I did the research and document requests myself. It was a lot of fun and I learned so much along the way.

I'm ecstatic to have made it to this point! Yet, I'm sad my family members and others who were starting the application process no longer qualify.

I am hoping things will change in the future, or new precedents will be set that don't cut so many people out of the process. Time will tell and I won't stop hoping.

Still, a big thank you to everyone on this sub that has helped me along the way!!


r/juresanguinis • • 28d ago

Recognition Success! Unreal

Post image
283 Upvotes

Today, I had something happen that I once thought was going to be procedural and take some time, but then spiraled into uncertainty and doubt, then hope, then something undeniable, but all of those still feel unreal. My journey in pursuit of recognition has been long and fraught with turmoil. The email feels unreal to see. I cried as I read it.

I started this endeavor in 2020 as a COVID project. It took 6 frustrating months to book an appointment, one with a 2 year wait. Then the appointment was in Boston in 2022. I was in Germany at the time, so i flew home just for it. Then we waited and waited. Then the law changed and the minor issue came. It was struck down. We sent a letter with an attorney and another one last week. Finally the acceptance has come.

My mother and I are so ecstatic. Thank you to everyone who has helped here throughout the years. To the others still waiting: good things are coming!


r/juresanguinis • • Oct 17 '26

Post-Recognition Putting this under my pillow tonight

Post image
268 Upvotes

Previous post: https://www.reddit.com/r/juresanguinis/s/sHf4Qst07L

Welp… here it is! Turnaround time was 3 weeks.

Still not sure how to feel about finally having this in my hands. The anxiety the whole process gives you doesn’t just go away, especially after waiting a full 8 years for this moment.

Now to figure out how I’ll celebrate this weekend!

Saluti.


r/juresanguinis • • Jun 25 '25

Community Updates Turin court accepts motion to raise the question of constitutional legitimacy of Law no. 74 of 2025

Post image
262 Upvotes

This was shared on the 1948 Facebook group. Marking as speculation until confirmed by mods. Thought you all might be interested!


r/juresanguinis • • May 27 '25 Helpful

Community Updates Corte di Cassazione, 27 May 2025

Post image
256 Upvotes

Today I attended the hearing regarding two of Marco Mellone’s cases at the Corte di Cassazione (18354/2024 and 18357/2024, which seemed to be heard as one). Unfortunately, due to poor microphone placement it was very hard to hear everyone except the Public Prosecutor (a legal expert and counsel to the court who recommends a course of action). The takeaway is that Marco feels good about the outcome, which likely won’t be known until after the Constitutional Court hearing on June 24 (which I plan to attend). As with the April 1 hearings, the Public Prosecutor sided with Marco. (Note: this was a different Public Prosecutor, so that makes at least two who are firmly in our camp.)

The Public Prosecutor spoke first, stating that the new law has no bearing on these cases. She said whether the Bologna case behind the upcoming CC hearing is relevant remains to be seen. She then reviewed the history of maternal lineage as regards citizenship by descent and emphasized that denying women the ability to pass down citizenship was not justifiable. (I think she referenced decisions in 1965, 1983, and 2012, but I’d have to look them up.) Regarding the infamous articles 7 and 12, she urged the Court to consider the negation of a maternal lineage unfair, and emphasized that minors lost their Italian citizenship without their consent or knowledge.

Marco was then asked to clarify a few things. Though the minor issue was one factor in these cases, he described the day’s theme as “involuntary loss,” meaning that the children of a mother who naturalized (pre-1012, I believe) didn’t know they lost Italian citizenship when she naturalized (involuntarily), therefore how could they request to have reinstated something they didn’t know they had lost?

The Public Prosecutor nodded a lot while Marco spoke (yay!). Also significant was the absence of opposing counsel.

I didn’t hear anything new or groundbreaking at this hearing, but it’s encouraging to have the Public Prosecutors’ opinions support our cases (both have spoken at length and made multiple arguments in support of recognition of the plaintiffs in 1948 minor issue cases).

So, that’s the gist of today’s hearings. Sorry not to post sooner; it’s been a nonstop day. Marco said he was grateful for my presence and to tell you all that he is fighting hard for us. I reiterated that this sub appreciates his efforts so, so much.

And now we keep on waiting …

FORZA!


r/juresanguinis • • Apr 18 '25

Humor or Off-Topic "How come he don't want me, man?"

Post image
251 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • Aug 12 '26 Bravo

Consulate News [BREAKING] Italian Ministry of Interior Issues New Circular (Prot. 0065050 - Aug 10, 2026) Formally Overturning Circular 43347/2024 ("Minor Issue")

249 Upvotes

by Avv. Michele Vitale - Italyget.com

UPDATE (Aug 15, 2026):
I have updated the AVITAL Interactive Assessment Tool (v2.4) to fully incorporate Circular 65050/2026 and the Supreme Court doctrine:

  • Consular Re-examination Triage: Direct guidance on requesting an administrative review (riesame) for applications/appointments which have been rejected (no new fee, no starting over).

  • Law 74/2025 Safeguard Filter: Differentiates between applicants protected by Article 3-bis exceptions (1st/2nd generation or parental residency) and 3rd/4th generation descendants requiring judicial action under the CJEU referral and/or other legal strategies.

  • Historical Age Verifier: Automated check of the 21 vs 18-year majority cutoff before March 10, 1975.

You can run your specific timeline through the updated engine here: AVITAL Minor Issue Assessment Tool (v2.4).

EDIT Aug 13 — I’ve deepened the analysis on the consulate’s room for manoeuvre after a re‑examination request and added a new FAQ section on whether a “minor‑issue‑only” denial binds the consulate to that single ground.

Cari amici,

Following the Italian Supreme Court's United Sections (Sezioni Unite) landmark ruling (Judgment No. 24045 of July 26, 2026), the Ministry of the Interior has officially issued Circular Prot. No. 0065050 on August 10, 2026.

This document formally instructs all Italian Prefectures, Consulates, and Municipalities (Comuni) that Circular No. 43347 of October 3, 2024 is officially superseded.

Key Takeaways from the New Circular:

  1. Dual Citizenship by Birth Preserved: In accordance with Article 7 of Law 555/1912, children born abroad who acquired foreign citizenship iure soli at birth are dual citizens by operation of law. The subsequent naturalization of the parent while the child was a minor does not interrupt the line of transmission.

  2. Scope of Application: Applies to cases governed by Law 555/1912 (naturalizations between July 1, 1912 and August 15, 1992).

  3. Re-examination of Previous Denials (Istanza di Riesame): Applicants who previously received a rejection based on Circular 43347/2024 do not need to file a new application. They are entitled to request a formal re-examination of their original application with the authority that issued the denial.

  4. Protection from Law 74/2025 Restrictions: Applications originally submitted before March 27, 2025 (or filed pursuant to an appointment communicated before that date) will be evaluated under the rules in force at the time of original submission, and are exempt from the restrictions of Article 3-bis of Law 74/2025.

FAQ – Re-examination, Administrative Reconsideration (Autotutela), and "New Grounds" for Rejection

If my rejection was justified only by the "minor issue," can the consulate add other grounds during the re-examination?

It is not guaranteed that they cannot do so. The fact that the initial rejection cites only the minor issue does not definitively close the proceeding. In an eventual administrative reconsideration (autotutela—meaning at your request, without a prior court annulment), the consulate may attempt to base a new refusal on other issues that emerged during the initial investigation, making your defense more complex.

Is there a rule preventing the public administration from introducing "new grounds" after an initial rejection?

Yes, but it operates strongly primarily when there is a judicial annulment of the negative decision by an administrative judge (TAR / Council of State). In that case, Article 10-bis, paragraph 1, last sentence of Law 241/1990 establishes that, when re-exercising its authority, the administration cannot cite for the first time opposing grounds that had already emerged during the investigation of the annulled decision.

What if I only request a "re-examination" or administrative reconsideration without going to the TAR?

In this case, the restriction is weaker. The law explicitly refers to "judicial annulment"; the prevailing legal doctrine does not automatically extend this same constraint to a simple administrative re-examination or discretionary reconsideration. Therefore, in principle, the public administration can attempt to "renew" the rejection with a more detailed justification, even though this can be challenged on the grounds of procedural fairness and legitimacy.

Why is it important to be assisted by a lawyer starting right from the re-examination request?

Because a "do-it-yourself" request can turn into a procedural trap: by reopening the file, the consulate could expand the rejection with new grounds, forcing you to defend yourself on multiple fronts in future litigation. A technical, well-structured application aims to narrow the administration's room for maneuver, lock down the record of the investigation, and build a stronger defense path, reducing the risk of subsequent rejections.

If I win at the TAR, can the consulate still reject my application again on other grounds?

After an annulment by the TAR (or the Council of State), the administration is much more constrained: it cannot introduce ex novo opposing grounds that had already emerged and were not raised in the first decision, in accordance with Article 10-bis and the principle of the so-called "tempered one-shot" (one shot temperato). However, a new refusal based on different, newly arisen factors or a fresh investigation remains possible and would have to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.

Full Translation & PDF Download

I have published the complete, literal word-for-word English translation of the official Circular, along with a direct download link for the original Italian Ministry PDF:

🔗 Read the full English translation and download the official PDF here:
https://italyget.com/breaking-news-italian-ministry-issues-circular-65050-2026-overturning-minor-issue-directive/


r/juresanguinis • • Apr 01 '25

Minor Issue The fight against the minor issue is happening NOW

Post image
247 Upvotes

Marco Mellone and two other attorneys are here at the Corte di Cassazione in Rome fighting for our rights!


r/juresanguinis • • Mar 29 '25

Community Updates From Marco Mellone

Post image
239 Upvotes

r/juresanguinis • • Mar 30 '25

DL36-L74/2025 Discussion Anyone else seriously struggling with this news?

232 Upvotes

My dad died two weeks ago and my case for Italian citizenship was one of the few things still giving me hope.

I poured my heart and soul into putting together my brother and I’s 1948 case via GGM over the past 3 years. Countless calls, hours spent researching, thousands of dollars spent, stressful conversations, late night worries.

We were done. I tracked down everything we needed. I had just signed the POA two weeks ago. All of our papers are currently being apostilled and translated (I guess for nothing now)

I don’t really know what the point of this post is. I’m just not ok. This news came out of nowhere just as I was finally beginning to get past the grief of my dad passing away. I can’t even get out of bed