I was talking to a lady I met on the Tinder and she asked me "what's your favourite movie?" it's the type of small talk I usually find myself too intelectually advanced for but I was trying to get some so I played along. Of course my answer was Joker (2019) starring my favourite actor Joaquin "The Joaq Man" Phoenix. So I start talking about how to me, it's more than a movie but a Mission Statement, about society and how it taught me I'm better than society. Anyway, she then asks me "what's your favourite thing about Joaquin "The Joaq Man" Phoenix's performance and I said "It's difficult to assess because he's not in the movie" and she looks at me like I'm a stupid and says "yes he is, he's the plays the lead role" and I stand my ground and say "no, Joaquin Phoenix stops existing as soon as the movie starts. There's no Joaquin Phoenix in that movie, only Arthur Fleck. He BECOMES Arthur Fleck so hard that isn't possible to even know that The Joaq Man is in the movie" at this point she rudely rolls her eyes and says "well I thought it was a good performance, he acted it well" and I say "well you weren't thinking that during the movie because you forgot what actor you were watching and she says "no I didn't, I watched that movie thinking "Joaquin Phoenix is really good in this" - when I call her out on her obvious lies she hurls some insults about this being the worst date ever and walked out of there (her loss). But I sat there with the biggest grin on my face, thinking about the profoundness of my words and my incredible analysis of Joaquin's acting becoming performance in Joker (2019).
If I'm being honest, I didn't even know he was in Joker (2019) until he trode upon the Oscar stage to accept the infamous statue, despite having already seen the movie at least 5 times at that point. That's how good he was. And that's why us Joker fans respect him so much. Now you might be thinking "well that's not THAT impressive, that's what good actors do" but the fact is most of them don't and most of those who do are unknown character actors. Joaquin Phoenix is one of only 4 "bug time" actors who does it every time, the others being Gary "The Gazzler" Oldman, Christian "The Balester" Bale and of course Daniel "THE DAY IS LONG" Day-Lewis. That's why I sometimes refer to them collectively as THE FOUR HORSEMEN OF THE ACTING but I'll also call them "The Great becomers" because they don't actt by pretending to be a character - they'll "become" the character. And Unfortunately too many actors don't do that. That's why I respect "THE GREAT BECOMERS" so much more than your others so-called movie stars.
But nobody did that as hard as Joaquin Phoenix in Joker (2019) - which is what makes it the greatest screen performance of all time. It's not about line delivery or "emotional resonance" - none of that is truly what makes a "real actor" - it's about BECOMING. He BECAME Arthur Fleck and that's why I RESPECT his performance and why we all should.