r/jenkinsci • u/mani1soni • Nov 03 '20
r/jenkinsci • u/kamilchm • Jul 10 '25
After 20 years in CI/CD Engineering, I've started documenting my approach to CI/CD pipeline architecture. What do you think?
Hey r/jenkinsci,
I've been building and managing CI/CD pipelines for a long time, and I've seen countless teams struggle with the same architectural issues: a patchwork of CI/CD tools that don't integrate well, inconsistent workflows, and a general lack of a unified strategy that leads to reinventing the wheel.
To bring some order to the chaos, I've started formalizing my own methodology, which I call the "CI/CD Pipeline Architecture Framework." I wanted to share the core concepts here to get your thoughts and feedback.
It's built on two main ideas:
1. The Golden Path: This is the non-negotiable, 6-step foundation that every solid pipeline needs. It's the core workflow: commit → build → test → staging → production → monitoring
2. The 7 Pipeline Pillars: These are the strategic capabilities you can build on top of the Golden Path. They aren't sequential; you implement them based on your team's biggest pain points.
Here are the pillars:
Multiple Environments & Promotion: Beyond just
stagingandprod. How do you handledev,qa,uat?Progressive Delivery Strategies: Decoupling deployment from release to reduce risk, using techniques like canary releases, blue-green deployments, and feature flags.
Metrics & Observability: The foundation for safe progressive delivery. This pillar moves beyond simple pass/fail to answer critical questions: Are our builds getting slower? How much developer time is wasted on flaky tests vs. real bugs? Can we see the performance impact of a new release by grouping metrics by version?
Advanced Testing Strategies: Going beyond basic unit/integration tests (e.g., contract testing, mutation testing).
Pipeline Control & Orchestration: Giving developers safe, self-service control over their pipelines.
Multi-Platform & Multi-Cloud Support: Building pipelines that aren't locked into a single vendor.
Access Control & Security Architecture: Integrating security into every step of the pipeline (DevSecOps).
I'm particularly interested in which of these pillars you've found most challenging or rewarding to implement. In my experience as a Platform Engineer, getting Metrics & Observability right is a total game-changer. It's crucial for having the confidence that changes to the pipeline won't break anything.
What are your experiences? Does this framework resonate with the challenges you face?
r/jenkinsci • u/tjayy1234 • Jul 29 '20
r/jenkinsci is back
Hi
We're pleased to announce that r/jenkinsci is back,
We have a new moderator team /u/tjayy1234 and /u/oleg_nenashev
Posting restriction has been lifted.
r/jenkinsci • u/wololock • Apr 19 '20
Jenkins Pipeline Environment Variables explained
r/jenkinsci • u/recampbell_cb • Mar 26 '19
Jenkins and Jenkins X Experts AMA
We’re here for the Ask Me Anything today on Jenkins and Jenkins X. Thank you for joining today. We have a crew of us from CloudBees here today to help cover any questions you may have. By way of introduction, today we have:
Ryan Campbell (recampbell_cb): I'm a Jenkins committer and author of the Google Login plugin. I'm a CloudBees cofounder and serve as the Director of Global Support.
Jenn Briden (jennbriden), Product Management Director and PM lead for the Jenkins team (Jenkins, Jenkins X and Pipeline) at CloudBees. I am working on UX improvements and on things like Jenkins Config at Code and Java 11.
Ryan Smith (ryansmith_cloudbees). I'm a JVM Performance Tuning Nerd, Squad Lead for the North America West Coast team, and serve as a Sr. Development Support Engineer for CloudBees. Today is my 1 year Cakeday with CloudBees.
Dennis Newel (dnewel) Sr. Product Manager working on Jenkins X
Javier Ráez (jraezrus) a Development Support Engineer team member at CloudBees.
Ray Kivisto (ray_kivisto), I love using Jenkins and automating all the things, and I’m the squad lead for the North America Central squad of the Development Support Engineer team at CloudBees.
Parker Ennis (pkthunda), Product Marketing Manager for the Jenkins team. I work closely with Jenn Briden, Product Manager for Jenkins, and the Jenkins, Jenkins X and Pipeline teams at CloudBees to find ways to improve our favorite automation tool and market it effectively
Alyssa Tong (SpiritWater13), events officer for the Jenkins project
Please ask us anything about Jenkins and Jenkins X ;-)
r/jenkinsci • u/weighanchore • Sep 22 '17
The jenkins community has deprecated the library/jenkins image. Make sure you use jenkins/jenkins image
r/jenkinsci • u/noodles80 • May 27 '16
Introducing Blue Ocean: a new user experience for Jenkins
r/jenkinsci • u/akitsu111 • Jun 12 '24
A very accurate illustration of how it feels to troubleshoot obscure side effects of specific plugin combinations
r/jenkinsci • u/dovholuknf • May 25 '22
We stopped exposing our Jenkins server to the internet. You can too.
r/jenkinsci • u/ZaiHighTech • Feb 08 '25
Why Choose GitHub Actions Over Jenkins When Jenkins is Open Source?
In a recent interview, I was asked why I prefer GitHub Actions over Jenkins, given that Jenkins is open-source and widely used. I responded that security concerns make me lean away from Jenkins, but the interviewer didn’t seem fully convinced.
For those with experience in both, what are the key reasons you would choose GitHub Actions over Jenkins? Is security a strong enough reason, or are there other compelling factors like ease of use, maintenance, cost, or integration with modern workflows?
Would love to hear your thoughts!
r/jenkinsci • u/AwesomeThrowaway5689 • Jan 27 '22
Came back to Devops after 10 years, so much changed but Jenkins is still the default CI/CD?!
Hi,
I'm a pretty experienced developer but new to modern Devops (used to do Devops but been out of the game for years), and I've been trying to choose a CI/CD tool. With so many other changes in the stack over the past few years, I was surprised that the default choice for CI/CD is still … Jenkins.
Several of my friends in DevOps told me that they started with Jenkins, switched to a commercial solution that seemed better, and then came back to Jenkins.
What I like about Jenkins:
Easy to get started -- has a good configuration UI, can ignore advanced features until you need them.
Powerful enough for complex projects, includes CaC.
Big community and lots of people writing good plugins.
Points against Jenkins:
You need to write your own build scripts.
You need to learn Groovy to use its CaC.
The UI just shows logs of your jobs. For example, when I build an environment using Terraform, I wish the UI showed me the results visually. (You can get this information from the Terraform logs, but it’s not seamless.)
If you've abandoned Jenkins, what made you do it?
If you've abandoned a commercial solution, what made you come back to Jenkins?
r/jenkinsci • u/goto-con • Mar 15 '19
"40 Jenkins Features & Plugins You Wished You had Known about Before!" with Joep Weijers (46min talk from GOTO Copenhagen 2018)
r/jenkinsci • u/TheRoboTombstone • Feb 08 '25
How long will Jenkins last?
is it just me or does jenkins feel ridiculously volatile sometimes? one day everything is running fine and the next, BOOM random ass plugin update breaks the entire pipeline
So how much time does Jenkins really have left in the industry? Will enterprises cling to it cuz of legacy pipelines, or are we on the verge of a complete Github Actions takeover?
r/jenkinsci • u/jequalsfive • Apr 06 '17
Say hello to Blue Ocean 1.0 jenkins.io/blog/2017/04/0…
r/jenkinsci • u/recampbell_cb • May 01 '19
Jenkins and Jenkins X Experts AMA
We’re back and here for the next hour for an Ask Me Anything on Jenkins and Jenkins X.
We’re excited to be back! We have a crew of us from CloudBees here today to help cover any questions you may have. By way of introduction, today we have:
Ryan Campbell (rcampbell_cb): I'm a Jenkins committer and author of the Google Login plugin. I'm a CloudBees cofounder and serve as the Director of Global Support.
Jenn Briden (jennbriden), Product Management Director and PM lead for the Jenkins team (Jenkins, Jenkins X and Pipeline) at CloudBees. I am working on UX improvements and on things like Jenkins Config at Code and Java 11.
Ryan Smith (ryansmith_cloudbees). I'm a JVM Performance Tuning Nerd, Squad Lead for the North America West Coast team, and serve as a Sr. Development Support Engineer for CloudBees.
Dennis Newel (dnewel) Sr. Product Manager working on Jenkins X
Ray Kivisto (ray_kivisto), I love using Jenkins and automating all the things, and I’m the squad lead for the North America Central squad of the Development Support Engineer team at CloudBees.
Alyssa Tong (SpiritWater13), events officer for the Jenkins project
Alex Taylor (egg35223), I am a Sr. Developer Support Engineer at CloudBees. I appreciate all the fun things Jenkins can do and fixing issues people are having
Please ask us anything about Jenkins and Jenkins X ;-)
r/jenkinsci • u/FraBle90 • Jun 03 '21
Slack Engineering: How a Jenkins Job Broke our Jenkins UI
r/jenkinsci • u/MaxWebro • Aug 26 '20
Free Jenkins tutorial for beginners | Learn Jenkins CI/CD tool in one video
r/jenkinsci • u/werner-dijkerman • Jun 16 '21
Jenkins as code, part 1: Setting up Jenkins in Docker
https://werner-dijkerman.nl/2021/06/14/jenkins-as-code-part-1-setting-up-jenkins-in-docker/
I published this blogpost a few days ago. Might be interesting for you as well in here.
If you do have any comments and or remarks, please let me know.
May the code be with you!
r/jenkinsci • u/qoheletal • Aug 27 '21
Why is Pipeline-Groovy so weird and how to deal with it?
I'm working with Jenkins now for around three years and I agree it's probably one of the best CI/CD products out there - but writing Pipeline-Code is always a pain.
Mostly I fail with the most primitive String-Operations (despite being a Java-Developer for 10 years).
I can't debug, there is no IDE and even if I just replace a single line of code I am afraid I rendered the whole script useless. There is no documentation or auto-completion and I have no idea how to refactor my re-usable code properly (over several pipelines).
Most Tutorials or videos show (most in a good quality) how to tweak Jenkins and get the maximum of functionalities out of it, but here it comes to the simple thing of writing just a pipeline. This is on most of the congresses not so interesting.
Please tell me someone it's just me who couldn't find a proper environment and everything is much easier than I feel.
Are there some Pipeline-Pros who are willing to put their scripts on Github or tell how they are doing it properly?
Thank you
r/jenkinsci • u/ariehkovler • Dec 18 '18
Why on earth did we choose Jenkins for 2019? A new startup's story