r/javascript • u/TheLarkInn • Apr 08 '19
Microsoft releases new Microsoft Edge based on Chromium
https://twitter.com/MSEdgeDev/status/1115283353731600384?s=19189
u/kindall Apr 08 '19
Well that was a lot quicker than I expected.
83
u/codinghermit Apr 08 '19
Throw out almost all of the Microsoft code, use a common standard and you end up with a pretty decent product! Who would've guessed...
44
u/rawriclark Apr 08 '19
so chromioum is standard now lulz xd?
27
u/codinghermit Apr 08 '19
More standard than not honestly. It's open-source and has many flavors of browser built on it. I'm gonna feel safe considering the chromium-based edge to be following at least "a" standard if not "the" standard compared to how it was built originally.
Complaints about the fragmented browser ecosystem aside, you have to at least admit chromium is pretty decent about trying to follow agreed upon standards for new technologies. Microsoft developed browsers have never been accused of that in any shape or form.
8
u/rangeDSP Apr 09 '19
I would disagree on one point: even though Edge lacked support for newer HTML5 features, I don't recall any incidence where they decide to go against the standards.
2
u/codinghermit Apr 09 '19
Fair point. I personally consider supporting those features as part of conforming to the standard simply because the end result of not doing so is similar. It ends in painful headaches for web developers and slow adoption of extremely useful tools. Having to worry about which new feature is supported where should not be a thing in 2019. The browser vendors needs to at least stay mostly in step with each other to keep consistancy
6
u/rangeDSP Apr 09 '19
Good point, though funnily enough they currently sit higher than Firefox in terms of standards compliance: https://html5test.com/results/desktop.html
Pretty impressive feat considering they made it from scratch 4 years ago. Though the fact that they decided to throw away all that work shows how much time and money goes into maintaining a browser.
Unless that company's entire business model is tied to the browser there's not much incentive for them to invest.
13
u/rawriclark Apr 08 '19
I agree that Chromium has been good with standards and its very performant but to say its standard is just too much :), hell without google spying code I would use it 100% :)
Standard = Specs
Browser = Implementation
24
u/IHeartMustard WILL CODE FOR CAFFEINE Apr 08 '19
I've started using Firefox recently just to put my tiny statistically-insignificant weight on their side of the scales. I'm surprised I've actually stuck with it, even though there are features I miss (omnibar search stuff for one), FF finally is at a point where it really puts up a damn strong fight against Chrome.
12
u/notNullOrVoid Apr 08 '19
Firefox has omni bar search, just type in your search into the url bar works just the same as Chrome. What else are you missing?
10
u/IHeartMustard WILL CODE FOR CAFFEINE Apr 09 '19
Ah, I should have specified. In chrome, I am able to, for example, type in
github.comand hit tab, and I can do a search using githubs open search integration. Same with any other website that supports opensearch. I don't know the finer details behind how it works, but that's what I mean. I had no idea how much I used this feature until I lost it.6
u/cottonycloud Apr 09 '19
You can control this in settings. Add it as a search engine and put a keyword. For example, I have runescape.wiki set to the keyword rs.
5
u/IHeartMustard WILL CODE FOR CAFFEINE Apr 09 '19
Ah, so I can add them in myself? That's handy. I do hope that FF gets the same kind of automatic hooks for opensearch in the omnibar when you visit a site that Chrome has, but it's good to know that I can create a search keyword myself for now. I'll give that a try, thank you!
5
u/justpurple_ Apr 09 '19
You guys all miss the point of him (no offense, just hinting at it):
He doesn‘t want the function where you can add a search shortcut and then you can type „shortcut search term“ in the adresss bar, although that is a valid workaround, even if it‘s not the same thing.
In Chrome, this behaviour works automatically on every website as long as that website has supports the Opensearch format/meta-information (http://www.opensearch.org/Home). Firefox does not support that, sadly.
1
3
u/notNullOrVoid Apr 09 '19
Interesting I must have switched to FF before that became a thing in Chrome. I use duckduckgo as my search engine anyway so searching github is simple as typing "!gh hello world"
2
6
u/PRiMEFiL Apr 08 '19
Firefox was big, until chrome came along, but I stuck with Firefox most of the way.
6
u/IHeartMustard WILL CODE FOR CAFFEINE Apr 09 '19
I know :) I was there, and was using Firefox when Chrome first came out. I was very skeptical (As everyone was) of Google ever making any sort of impact in the browser wars of the time, but eventually down the line I did infact move to Chrome. Chrome (in my opinion) overtook Firefox and everyone else in terms of functionality very quickly, and for the last few years I had tried a few times to go back to FF, but each time I found myself going back to Chrome, until about 6 months ago when it's finally stuck (I was using FF on my android phone already, FF is easily the best mobile browser I know of). So it's starting to make a comeback, and it's amazing to see it rise yet again like a phoenix that just won't die.
1
2
u/rawriclark Apr 09 '19
oh boy 8 remember whem peolple wouldnt use firefox 1.0 cause it was the.new thing , it was ie6-7 days hahah
3
Apr 09 '19
FF used to be THE browser outside of IE before Chrome came around. It was Chrome that came and wiped away FF's browser share which is what makes their current positioning kinda ironic. I still remember when Chrome first came out and how reluctant I was to give up FF but how quick and lightweight Chrome was.
5
u/TheRealNetroxen Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
Don't forget guys, Chromium and Chrome are two different things... Chrome is a flavour of Chromium using features and utilities developed by Google. You can still download a standalone version of Chromium here: https://chromium.woolyss.com/download/en/
11
u/Poltras Apr 08 '19
Build Chromium then. Don’t use chrome. Chromium doesn’t have any assets trademarked by google and you can easily disable usage reporting functions.
3
u/SahinK Apr 08 '19
Chrome implements most web standards before any other browser, and have been following the specs much better than IE / Edge.
-1
Apr 08 '19
Considering that most people use chrome to browse it safe to say that it is the standard atm.
0
-1
1
u/YasZedOP Apr 08 '19
Remove a 50+ services while you're at it from chromium, most of which belong to Google
4
1
1
u/wherinkelly Apr 09 '19
How close do you think the teams were to completion when the initial announcement was made?
-8
u/bartturner Apr 08 '19
They are using Chrommium. Why should it take much time?
18
u/kindall Apr 08 '19
Adapting an existng browser shell and debug tools to a completely different engine, when their existing engine was specifically built to enable those functions... probably will take some time.
11
u/Eirenarch Apr 08 '19
They are not using their existing browser shell or debug tools.
10
u/kindall Apr 08 '19
Oh. Well, then it's hardly Edge anymore.
4
-7
1
-2
u/bartturner Apr 08 '19
Majority of the browser comes from Google.
Also we have no idea when they started.
Do think this is a hail marry. Highly doubtful will do better than existing Edge.
Most people have no idea they are going to use Chromium. They have already been programmed to use Chrome.
Personally hate seeing Microsoft just give up.
1
u/troglo-dyke Apr 08 '19
I don't see this as giving up, it's combining efforts. There's a benefit to having competing implementations but with Microsoft and Google contributing towards chromium it might increase innovation
2
u/bartturner Apr 08 '19
Actually smart. Gets them out of doing a browser without looking like it.
Not going to help them slow the bleeding. For browser and Bing.
I am more curious when they will pull the plug on Bing. Specially mobile which is now done below 1% share.
1
u/troglo-dyke Apr 08 '19
Possibly, now that I think about the amount they've sunk into Bing, and Edge compared to the success they've had with Azure - it would make sense to cut some projects.
1
u/bartturner Apr 08 '19
Definitely. They are killing it with Azure and a ton of business to win where edge and Bing they loss and little chance to change. Even harder now search is more of ML application.
10
u/01123581321AhFuckIt Apr 08 '19
Downloaded it. It's much snappier than normal Edge. I have to explore it more to see if I like it more than chrome's UI though. I'd also be hesitant to use it if it doesn't have the extensions availalble in chrome.
5
u/alleycat5 Apr 08 '19
You can go to the normal Chrome Extensions store (just Google/Bing it), and download chrome extensions like normal.
4
23
u/cinnapear Apr 08 '19
Is this a welcome end of an era?
48
u/SteiniDJ Apr 08 '19
Well, they're supporting IE11 until 2025. :(
23
Apr 08 '19
Clarification: they're keeping it patched with security updates. They are not implementing anything new into IE11. So yes, we're stuck with their horrendous implementation of Grid for a while.
13
Apr 08 '19
I work for a company that arranges special contracts between Microsoft and gov agencies to support their installations of Windows XP because upgrading is difficult and expensive.
You guys are fucked.
8
5
u/smeijer87 Apr 08 '19
Upgrading is expensive? Makes me curious about the bill that Microsoft is sending for the support. I'm sure that ain't cheap either.
1
Apr 09 '19
It’s only gotta be cheaper, not cheap. Don’t condone it myself but have witnessed enough of it to make me sick and a lot of times it ain’t the organization or whatever government agency just not wanting to deal with it but rather some 3rd party vendor who developed a system they depend on, won’t support windows next and has them by the balls.
1
u/asdf7890 Apr 09 '19
It’s only gotta be cheaper, not cheap.
It doesn't even have to be cheaper. A company with a sufficiently risk averse culture may resist change even if staying put costs more.
1
u/asdf7890 Apr 09 '19
It isn't just the cost of the OS upgrade and the infrastructure project to make sure it is properly rolled out to hundreds/thousands/tens-of-000s/... users spread over many sites. There is also replacement hardware as old kit might not have usable drivers for newer OSs, and all that custom legacy software the large old companies tend to have which might not work as-is and would need to be (expensively) replaced because literally no one will work on upgrading it (perhaps the company or internal individuals that made it is long gone and the source in escrow is found to be something so bad that they can't pay enough to make anyone they'd trust be willing to touch it).
On top of all that there is a large amount of less specific risk aversion that resists change. Even if staying put costs more, it might be the preferred option because the current risks are known & mitigated but change might throw up new ones.
I don't like it, I certainly don't agree with it (by sticking with the bad situation because of legacy, your legacy problems will only get worse), but I understand the position.
I'm just glad we've (only recently) got to the point of no longer having to support IE8 at all for our client base...
5
u/greymalik Apr 08 '19
And if history is any guide, some companies will continue to use it well beyond when MS ends support.
2
u/christophocles Apr 08 '19
Where I work, there are some computers that still run Windows 2000. These computers aren't connected to the internet and they're used to operate special equipment. To upgrade the OS we would have to buy new versions of the software/drivers that runs this equipment for tens of thousands of $$$. As long as we can keep these old ass computers running, that ain't happening.
5
u/Mabenue Apr 08 '19
If they're air-gapped it's really not that much of an issue. Still vulnerable to stuxnet style attacks but for most that shouldn't be so much of a problem and can be avoided by good process.
5
u/christophocles Apr 08 '19
Edge doesn't support ActiveX or Java so it's useless in a business environment that relies on applications that were made 5-10 years ago.
We run Windows 10 on most of our desktops but Edge isn't even allowed to run because it would create confusion because everything we need to do our jobs requires IE11.
For general web browsing needs we have Chrome which has a colorful icon and doesn't try as hard to usurp the default browser position.
20
u/mypetocean Apr 08 '19
No. It means the end of the browser wars — which was, on the whole, a very positive thing for the Internet — with Chrome + Google having been awarded far, far too much power.
The AMP Project, for example, will likely now continue unabated, barring government intervention.
3
Apr 08 '19
Which is mostly unrelated to Chromium's dominance. To be crystal clear, Google's dominance and the entire reason why people should be worried is because of their overwhelming majority control of web traffic thanks to Google Search. This is how AMP is even a thing, all outlets jumped on board because effectively google said add it or die into page 2 irrelevancy. Chrome's popularity, again, is because of Google Search every single person guaranteed first heard about it on the google search home page or some popup on a google page.
Microsoft using Chromium now, or heck, even if Firefox started using Chromium, ultimately means nothing due to the license. They can still implement their own standards (likely won't, most browser devs by now are tired of that mess), and change things to their liking.
-1
4
23
u/zeddotes Apr 08 '19
Thanks for all the memories, IE. You won't be missed.
32
1
u/SecretAnteater Apr 08 '19
IE has been gone for years. Edge replaced it with Windows 10, although IE11 is still bundled with it.
5
u/StuffMaster Apr 09 '19
Gone? It's on my computer.
1
u/SecretAnteater Apr 09 '19
yea, I went on to say "Edge replaced it with Windows 10, although IE11 is still bundled with it."
-2
23
Apr 08 '19
More power to Google, just what we needed.
1
u/kidno Apr 09 '19
Let’s not forget to thank Apple, who took KHTML and made WebKit, which Google used for Chrominium (and then forked to Blink).
0
Apr 09 '19
[deleted]
1
u/kidno Apr 09 '19
Oh I thought we were being mad at people, not praising them. Apple let Google take WebKit and then take control of the browser market.
0
Apr 08 '19
[deleted]
21
u/TheRedGerund Apr 08 '19
Doesn't it affect standards somehow? Chrome has a lot of control over standards right?
13
u/_GoT Apr 08 '19
Since chromium is open source Microsoft can implement their own standards without any interference from google. Although we could all benefit if all browsers implemented the same compatibility standards.
7
u/Ajedi32 Apr 08 '19
They could implement their own standards. The problem is, they're not going to. The whole point of this move was so that they wouln't have to maintain a separate browser engine, so unless they decide to go back on that move and fork Chromium/Blink, the standards that Edge implements will be almost entirely decided by Google.
→ More replies (1)15
u/Candyvanmanstan Apr 08 '19
You need to differentiate between Chromium and Chrome.
One is open source, the other is Google's browser.
11
u/Ajedi32 Apr 08 '19
That's kinda irrelevant for the purpose of this discussion though. Microsoft isn't forking Chromium, just using it. Google controls the upstream Chromium project, therefore they also control what web standard features Edge supports.
6
u/Candyvanmanstan Apr 08 '19
That would only be true if Microsoft just wrapped chromium in an edge package and called it a day. MS is free to add on whatever standards they want in Edge. (Although I suspect part of the point is not needing to handle standards on their own)
This is a discussion I don't really see the point of, though. I was originally just pointing out that chrome and chromium are not the same thing. And they aren't.
2
u/Ajedi32 Apr 08 '19
Unfortunately, "wrap[ing] chromium in an edge package" is pretty much exactly what they're doing. Since they're not forking, they have rather limited influence over what web standards features Edge supports.
They can contribute new features back to Chromium (just like anyone else can), but it's entirely up to Google whether or not those changes actually make it into the codebase.
Yes, Chrome and Chromium are technically different, I'm just saying that in terms of how this move "affect[s] standards" it's kinda an irrelevant distinction.
5
u/Candyvanmanstan Apr 08 '19
Yeah, you're probably right. I'm just going to say again that this isn't a discussion I want to have, as per previous post.
I was just being pedantic about the name, because it DOES matter.
Chromium by default comes without all the extra tracking and other shit Chrome comes with. If you're going to discuss it, you need to name the right piece of software. Otherwise it'll get confusing fast.
0
Apr 09 '19
[deleted]
1
u/Ajedi32 Apr 09 '19
The reason they switched to Chromium/Blink in the first place was to avoid having to maintain their own seperate browser engine. Forking Chromium (rather than just using it) would negate that advantage.
Also, the link in the OP specifically says:
Our plan is to continue working in Chromium rather than creating a parallel project.
So not a fork.
→ More replies (3)1
Apr 09 '19
I guarantee you that Microsoft engineers will be making significant contributions to the Chromium project if it is shipping with as major a product as their default internet browser. Do you mean to say that this is in some way distinct from Google’s contribution to the Chromium project?
1
u/Ajedi32 Apr 09 '19
Google doesn't just contribute to Chromium, they own it. Any contributions Microsoft makes are subject to Google's review and approval.
4
u/ared38 Apr 08 '19
Not really -- Chromium contains the rendering engine and JS engine, and Google controls Chromium. Sure you're free to fork it, but MS did this so they wouldn't have to maintain that stuff.
2
u/Candyvanmanstan Apr 08 '19
So.. you're saying exactly what I said?
Chrome and Chromium is two different things.
Chrome is based on chromium the same way the new edge is now based on chromium.
1
u/sharlos Apr 08 '19
Yes and it's chromium that controls the implementation of standards, and Google controls chromium.
→ More replies (1)2
u/PicturElements Apr 08 '19
Go to caniuse.com and you'll see some APIs that only Firefox supports, and some that only Chromium supports. The support of significant features is pretty level, and actually I think the two can spur each other to implement more features. If one releases one feature, the other should probably implement it as well. Mozilla is still more driven by standards, though; sometimes even too far.
7
u/ared38 Apr 08 '19
Competitors using the same underlying open source framework explicitly means that they do not outpower each other.
You're acting like Microsoft and Google have equal power over the Chromium project. Google has absolute control over what goes in to Chromium, and all derived browsers either fork or follow. And as fewer people use anything else, the standards effectively become whatever Chromium does, just like it was with IE back in the day.
Best case scenario Google's services are always a step ahead because the engineers know exactly what future browsers will support and have the power to create new technologies like AMP or QUIC that competitors have to catch up to. Worst case Chromium engineers only worry about supporting Google services and Google services only worry about working in Chromium, and it's hard to use anything else. I'm already noticing more and more problems with Youtube and gmail as a Firefox user, while Firefox itself has become much snappier on other pages.
1
Apr 09 '19
However the other side of the coin is edge can and likely will be included with the OS as it is today so enterprise customers will likely standardize on it and less inclined home users who give 2 shits about a chrome, Firefox, blink, gecko, WebKit etc... will use what is in front of them and the largest part of the windows user base probably fits that demographic. Going on that it is very much in googles interest to also appease Microsoft because chrome, despite its privacy flaws, is a damn good browser so Microsoft is out the door basing this on a pretty damn good foundation. Never mind Microsoft offers a counterpart to nearly all of googles services they can flash in front of those same less inclined demographic. Googling is synonymous to searching the Internet for a lot of these same users so it makes sense if google’s search is the first thing that comes to mind for them when they need to search and google push’s chrome hard on their own sites so sure Chrome can still maintain a foothold I guess but nothing is stopping Microsoft from doing the same shit people think google will do regarding standards and their own agendas. I mean no one is gonna say “dunno man have you tried binging that shit” anytime soon if ever but there are plenty of other areas Microsoft can compete and they have the advantage of bundling a good browser with the OS which is not insignificant in itself.
-2
u/rawriclark Apr 08 '19
I dont understand why Microsoft would have less power than google, you really need to understand what open source means lmfao.
its literally take code and do whatever you fucking want with it
2
u/tinydonuts Apr 08 '19
I dont understand why Microsoft would have less power than google
The project is controlled by Google. The code is open and you are free to read and use their code however you want. But if you want to change Chromium (and by extension, Chrome) you have to submit a pull request and hope Google accepts it. Open source does not mean everyone has an equal seat at the table. You really should go learn what opens source means yourself.
Chrome is the IE of our time. If Chrome doesn't support it, it doesn't matter if it's a W3C standard at this point. Web standards now belong to Google.
1
u/aztracker1 Apr 08 '19
There's a few bits that aren't open-source (the portions for Netflix etc). Beyond that, it's mostly true, and MS could very well fork, like Google did with Blink already. I'm not sure we're all at that point yet though. Running it for about an hour, it's decent enough, and I like the look slightly more, when they have a Mac and Linux release, and get account sync working on Android and iOS versions, I'll then be impressed.
2
u/brokenURL Apr 08 '19
I seem to remember a story about google's plans to integrate features that effectively render ad blocking useless into Chromium. That seems like a bad time.
1
u/aztracker1 Apr 08 '19
Funny considering the Edge store has a plugin to enhance Youtube, that I think is blocked from google's store. ublock origin is available and lastpass as well... there's a few others, haven't tried the dev extensions from chrome store, authy didn't work.
7
u/FleraAnkor Apr 08 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
I really don’t understand this. After pouring a boatload of time and money i. Internet explorer / edge people still would not use it. It would make so much sense for microsoft to just kill it off and package windows with firefox. But nope. A few months ago they told the world they were working on another chromium based web browser. Meaning they are no depending on a competitor’s product which they still have to maintain.
3
u/peex Apr 09 '19
They could've made Edge open source and available to other operating systems. People could've fixed some of the underlying issues Edge had. Such a shame.
6
2
2
u/doitstuart Apr 09 '19
Interesting. Edge was never available for Windows 7. MS says the new Edge will be and that version is coming soon.
I guess that's a function of using Chromium. Can't hurt.
2
u/madcaesar Apr 09 '19
If Microsoft really wanted to win some goodwill with developers, they'd hold up on this horseshit, and provide a major fix / upgrade for IE11. A lot of us still have to support that POS browser and it's a fucking nightmare.
2
u/alphama1e Apr 08 '19
I'll board the hype train when I see them adopt modern standard across the board. I want modern css and javascript and I don't want to wait 5 years before they catch up. Every browser they've released has been a shit show in this way for years. So they're using chromium. Great. How much if it? How many adjustments? We all know they're not just gonna throw a new sign on the chrome browser so what will this be in the end? I hope they get their shit together because edge was supposed to be their comeback and it flopped hard.
2
Apr 08 '19
Good riddance. I recently had a change to my company's react app and was doing multi browser testing. It worked perfectly in every single browser, including IE, but it broke in freaking edge. Took another day and a half of work to get past this.
I know some people feel that diversity and competition is good in the browset engine space, but personally I feel it's just a pain in the ass.
2
1
Apr 09 '19
Would love to see more diversity in the rendering engine world but it's now just blink and gecko.
1
Apr 09 '19 edited Apr 09 '19
What has diversity brought us much other than compat hell. It's nice to have specs and features, but they're mostly theoretic (pointer-events for instance are useless because of just blink and gecko). Wouldn't it be great if web tech could actually work for once? The argument has always been features, but with javascript running outside the browser, frameworks dominating the view and handling cross platform UI, babel/ts/npm and the community making the standards, we're way past vendor mandated specs anyway and the browser has turned more into an implementation detail. If they could just fix an engine good enough and make it faster, i'm sure i'd value that more than 10 incompatible ones that keep us from making progress.
1
Apr 09 '19
Diversity brings us the ability for standards to not be controlled and set by one entity. The end result here is a Google controlled and dictated web standards.
I understand the compat issues but having 20 blink browsers does not remove those issues. You'll be facing compat issues between browsers who are on X version or Y.
It's not really any different. Biggest example here on the above is supporting the Samsung browser. It used random daily builds of blink/webkit and shipped it.
Hard to ignore when there is so many devices and users of this browser for your customers.
I'd rather a decentralized system that competes.
1
u/dumildekok Apr 09 '19
I wonder if they are going to push this to windows 7&8 users now. From what I understood, they couldn't push Edge because of an incomparability with the OS. There's no problems with Chrome based browsers.
1
u/doitstuart Apr 10 '19
Why wouldn't they? They have a vast number of 7/8 users, together at 40% Windows desktop share, and not exactly plummeting in the trend.
http://gs.statcounter.com/windows-version-market-share/desktop/worldwide
And that they've bothered to make a Win7 version at all suggests that will be the strategy.
1
u/RussianBot96621 Apr 09 '19
They need to bring setting tabs aside; tabs preview; the better InPrivate indicator; the gestures add on;the superior pdf reader to catch up with current Edge.. Not to mention the current UI even tho similar is far uglier than current Edge. WTF are those round edges in the tabs and url bar. Also the current home page looks much nicer.
The good Part: I can use Adnauseam again
1
1
1
u/Agentzap Apr 08 '19
It doesn't have Edge's smooth scrolling yet, which is basically the only thing keeping using Edge rather than Chrome right now
1
0
0
0
-1
u/gosh Apr 08 '19
Not good that browser code now only use code bases from two sources. We need competition
-5
Apr 08 '19
Die IE! die! you miserable piece of crap!
2
u/Stanulilic Apr 08 '19
Ha! ha! ha! you had me laughing so hard. I wonder why you got so many downvotes though?
0
-1
-1
u/drumstix42 Apr 08 '19
Preview build shared on insider, announced on twitter, reshared through reddit. Woo!
-6
u/donohutcheon Apr 08 '19
Maybe if all browsers use the same core, it'll make it easier for them to collaborate to rip out JavaScript and throw it away and start over with something that didn't evolve from a nasty hack.
1
u/aztracker1 Apr 08 '19
No need to remove JS.. you can always bootstrap a *LOT* with go + webasm, there's some decent DOM wrapper libraries and progress is definitely ongoing if you want to go that way. There's also rust, and if you like C# (blazer).
131
u/CantaloupeCamper Apr 08 '19
Really disappointed Microsoft jumped on Chromium instead of Firefox in some way.