r/javascript • • May 31 '18

Re: Medium.com "membership" paywall

In the context of the continued decline of medium.com as a publishing platform: if your blog on Medium utilizes the 'membership' program, it will not be allowed here.

Per our guidelines:

Posts must be inclusive to all -- e.g. no beta invites, "PM me for access", "free for first N users", etc.

We've already added one author to the spam list, and we ask that you report any further Medium posts that also fall into this category.

693 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

70

u/phpdevster May 31 '18

Too bad about Medium. I love how clean and simple it is to write articles using that platform.

52

u/kenman May 31 '18

We're not outright banning the platform, unless they go 100% membership-based. As far as I can tell, the membership thing is opt-in on a per-author basis currently.

3

u/loser-two-point-o May 31 '18

Can you please explain why asking for money is banned here? I mean they gotta make profit too right?

PS: I am not being sarcastic, I am genuinely interested to know

188

u/kenman May 31 '18

I'll tell you for $5.

1

u/_3psilon_ Aug 11 '18

I hate paywalls, too. Actually a technical workaround is linking to the Google cached version of the page. (Or Wayback machine etc.)

-42

u/loser-two-point-o May 31 '18 edited Jun 01 '18

:/

Medium is letting me publish something and some more, thus they charging something. if a user like it, they will buy it.

I do not understand what service you are offering here for 5$. We are just discussing here. You are the MOD, you can take any decision you want(like Medium). As a user I was just asking the rationale.

67

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

Paywalled articles don't work for an open forum like reddit as only a few people will be able to read and discuss it

-44

u/loser-two-point-o May 31 '18

so ... only people who are paying will be able to read? oh!

53

u/redhedinsanity May 31 '18 edited Jun 30 '23

fuck /u/spez

6

u/loser-two-point-o Jun 01 '18

Did not know that. I thought it was only for publishers not for the readers. My bad.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

Yes, and that's fine if the discussion happens on medium itself as everyone reading the article will have already paid. Here on reddit only a small part of the community will be able to read the article so it won't add much to this forum.

25

u/bart2019 Jun 01 '18

if a user like it, they will buy it.

No. It's "pay first, see what you bought later".

5

u/Soulflare3 Jun 01 '18

Loot boxes all over again

2

u/Private_Bool Jun 01 '18

Newspapers are loot boxes confirmed! /s

2

u/jsprogrammer Jun 01 '18

In most places you can look at the newspaper before buying.

-11

u/TheCarnalStatist Jun 01 '18

Folks would rather get pig headed about accessibility(and also hate ads) than admit content isn't cheap to create, curate or maintain.

7

u/Soulflare3 Jun 01 '18

I wouldn't hate ads, if they were not:

  • Obtrustive (popups, etc)

  • Distracting (Flashing, autoplaying video & sound, etc)

  • Malicious (actually had an ad install malware in the background via javascript back in 2010... heavily blocked ads ever since)

  • Spyware

2

u/monsto Jun 03 '18

In the beginning, google created unobtrusive ads. And it was good. These little 2 line text ads sat in between paragraphs in an article, a block of them off to the side, and on and on. Adblockers didn't exist.

Then people had to go and fuck it up with flash, strobes, giant billboard panels the size of a dinner plate... death and annoyance tore the web asunder, and it was not good.

I don't have a problem with unobtrusive ads. I'll leave them unblocked.

But annoy me and I'll strike down upon thee with great vengeance and furious anger... either that or ublock origin.

Want to get paid for your content? No problem. Don't annoy your users.

1

u/TheCarnalStatist Jun 03 '18

Sites that don't annoy their users get adblocked too. Meaning, they too will soon be wrapping their content around a paywall.

The end result of all this is that folks that can't afford content get second rate garbage instead of decent news. The whole open access for everyone idea dies in a post ads world.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

1

u/loser-two-point-o Jun 01 '18

Yeah, that makes sense. I thought it's for publisher's only not for readers.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

The main issue is that they don't allow reading for non paying visitors. If its some premium subscription or even something like Reddit Gold does, its fine.

I also don't get why Medium is doing it like this, because this will hurt their views for certain articles. I'd rather have them go harder on people who use adblock than completely blocking views altogether

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

I thought you got a few free premium articles in a certain timeframe as a non premium user?

I could be remembering wrong though.

1

u/curiousdannii Jun 02 '18

I think it's on the order of five free articles a month, and you don't know if what you're reading is one until it's already been subtracted from your free quota. Would be slightly less obnoxious if it asked you whether you wanted to redeem one of your free quota articles first.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

Syntax highlighting though.

307

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

Here here! I hate paywall sites that discuss open-source projects.

60

u/cgijoe_jhuckaby NaN Jun 01 '18

I think it's actually "hear hear". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hear,_hear

62

u/MrMZa May 31 '18

Paywall on its own is not a bad idea. I'm not using it as an author but remember, you're not paying someone for using open source but his time to come up with the article. Still, I think Brave with BAT token is a better model, yet unpopular among readers.

That said, it makes no sense to promote such content on reddit if reddit users can't see it for free.

22

u/fatgirlstakingdumps May 31 '18

Brave with BAT token

Please explain

16

u/HaykoKoryun eval May 31 '18

85

u/darthcoder May 31 '18

Oh god, more blockchain...

2

u/stuntycunty Jun 03 '18

serious question, but how old are you? just curious because anyone I know under the age of about 30~ is pretty excited about blockchain (even if its use-cases are being over-hyped). Just seems weird to me to dismiss something soley because it has blockchain tech.

blockchain isnt the new flash already, is it?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

I think it's more because blockchain has been so overhyped that everyone and everything is doing something with blockchain even when in many cases there is no reason to use blockchain there. So it's led to some people (myself included) to react with "oh God not another one" whenever I see anything with blockchain.

PS. I'm under the age of 30. Barely. Lol

2

u/darthcoder Jun 04 '18

Because blockchain tech is already almost 30 years old. Someone took it, turned it into money, and now everyone and their mother is salivating over it.

Blockchain isn't really tech, that's the problem. It's a blob, that when mathematically decoded, makes assertions about the signer, and in the case of bitcoin, about some of those blocks that came before.

Seriously, this is basically PGP. The security of the Web (TLS) is basically the fundamental basis of "blockchain". Storj is a decent technology that uses "blockchain" to provide proof of work around storage. That's cool. Ethereum is the same, but around CPU work.

Everyone else? Not so much "techology" but bandwagon riding to try and be the next Bitcoin.

1

u/stuntycunty Jun 06 '18

I think bitcoin is a better example of proof of work than storj.

11

u/avenp May 31 '18

Yeah, closed the tab as soon as I saw "blockchain" mentioned.

-26

u/andrazte May 31 '18

Funny, the creator of Javascript is part of that project and you find it uninteresting..

52

u/Canowyrms Jun 01 '18

Just because I'm interested in JavaScript doesn't mean I'm interested in literally anything else the creator of JavaScript expresses interest in.

-4

u/andrazte Jun 01 '18

How about you see the product yourself first? Ever tried Brave browser? I just find it funny that people dismiss amazing things without even checking what it is. Brave browser is really good. So much negativity in this sub all of the sudden what the hell.

7

u/Canowyrms Jun 01 '18

Actually, I use Brave on a daily basis, and its the default browser on my phone.... soo yeah.

Not really attacking you my dude, you just made a strange point, almost implying that we should be interested in whatever the creator of JavaScript is interested in. Just not how it works.

→ More replies (0)

11

u/spinlock Jun 01 '18

Eiche also contributed substantial funds to prop eight. He does lots of things that aren’t a good fit for this sub.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

14

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

My dude. That's the point

→ More replies (0)

10

u/nermid Jun 01 '18

Oh, man. So just because Eich was involved in it doesn't make it relevant to this subreddit?

It feels like somebody was just making that point...

→ More replies (0)

1

u/avenp Jun 01 '18

I don't find advertising interesting, and everyone and their mom are starting blockchain companies (blockchain Iced Tea?!). Forgive me if I'm fatigued with the clusterfuck that is cryptocurrency.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

If that is what gets them the required funding to pull it off, why not? Adding blockchain is more about getting funding these days than it providing a benefit. But its not like its a big issue to use it either.

1

u/MrMZa Jun 02 '18

You realize this is the project of Brendan Eich, right? (creator of JavaScript)

3

u/darthcoder Jun 04 '18

No I didn't.

Javascript's had a great run, sure. It's still a shitty language.

9

u/DoctorFrankz May 31 '18

That's actually very interesting!

-25

u/PurpleIcy May 31 '18

Communism on it's own is not a bad idea either.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

[deleted]

-21

u/PurpleIcy May 31 '18

Well have fun with paywalls on your shitty hobby, which will nobody pay for.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

Honestly, which economic system are you advocating for if you're against communism and capitalism?

1

u/stuntycunty Jun 06 '18

Neither is an answer.

-8

u/PurpleIcy May 31 '18

TIL saying that you won't earn money from blogging means that you're against capitalism.

84

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

Time to move to github pages and publish there

3

u/rotharius Jun 01 '18

Or GitLab pages and use their built-in CI runner.

55

u/Dedecekk May 31 '18

Unrelated, but why is there such a fuss about medium.com? All I can see there are clickbait articles or stealthly promoting author's products.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

[deleted]

32

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

15

u/tunisia3507 May 31 '18

What I like about it is that it broke the expectation that everyone's blog has to be either heavily customised and flashy or be really obviously tied to the host's template.

I mainly do backend and data analysis, with a little bit of frontend, and I really can't be bothered to dive into jekyll and theming and so on to host on github pages, but also I feel like I'll get judged hard for using an off-the-rack theme. And I don't trust my own hardware/ sysadmin skills to run my own ghost instance.

4

u/HaykoKoryun eval May 31 '18

The worst I've seen is premium articles which are official reposts from official sites like The Atlantic. I think Medium.com decided to make it premium but no-one checked to make sure that it's actually exclusive to them.

3

u/techsin101 May 31 '18

what about hackernoon?

8

u/kenman May 31 '18

Are they also paywalling?

1

u/captain-keyes Jun 01 '18

They technically are Medium blog hosted on a custom domain.

If the sub decides to go total non medium in the future, that'd have to go as well.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

3

u/techsin101 Jun 01 '18

yea, sometimes i go to developer tools delete that banner first

13

u/ECrispy Jun 01 '18

Clap clap.

This was bound to happen. Any platform which promises free content without ads is guaranteed to do a bait and switch once they have enough users. This is what medium did, they got popular and now more and more content is behind paywalls.

5

u/jdickey Jun 01 '18

…and most of what isn't behind the paywall is "20 Top Lifestyle Hacks You Must Do Before 8 AM To Become Rich In Two Weeks".

I've been on Medium since December, 2014. For the first two or three years, it was a fantastic place: incredibly dynamic; open to all sorts of writing and writers; appearing to walk the talk of "a different, more open publishing platform".

And then the Twitter roots became more and more blatantly obvious. The once-thriving poetry and literary-criticism communities were the first to be shoved under the bus, followed by the addition of "mainstream" publications (The Atlantic, The New York Times, The Washington Post), the paywall with its utterly ridiculous three-stories-a-month limit and, finally, the degeneration into a den of self-promotion and "lifestyle hacks".

It's become the 1970s UHF TV of the Web, with a paywall that lets you watch VHF as well.

What absolutely cemented my decision not to subscribe, however, was the practice of sending iOS/Android notifications for articles published by authors you follow, or simply "popular" authors — with nine out of ten of those links leading behind the paywall, and thus counting against your three "free" views.

Jack Dorsey and crew obviously intend the paywall to annoy people into putting their $5 a month in. It may have brought them a few new members. But I'm quite certain that it's driven many more, even those of us who were originally rooting for Medium, to say "no way in hell".

Good that paywalled articles are on the spam list. There are good writers that will be affected; they deserve a more ethical platform.

1

u/_3psilon_ Aug 11 '18

Exactly. I think like: "it's a blog post that I'm supposed to pay for". I can find 10.000 blog posts on the same topic on the internet for free, mostly of the same quality. It's already overcrowded without Medium. Why pay then?

3

u/edzillion Jun 01 '18

Thanks for doing this mods.

1

u/Honno Jun 01 '18

Has the paywall declined the free-side of publishing things on Medium?

-16

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

I disagree with this notion. I am admittedly a Medium member, but only because I want to support the experiment of rewarding the content creator for the value they provide me, and not their ability to attract advertisers (i.e. clickbait). I understand the desire to have content on this subreddit be accessible to all, but if all subreddits had this rule we are locking ourselves into the clickbait and advertisement dependent approach to content creation. I think that would be a shame.

34

u/jodraws May 31 '18 edited May 31 '18

I disagree with this notion. Accessible to all doesn't mean it has to be advertisement or clickbait driven. The best content I see comes from when authors share knowledge with the community because they have a passion for the topic not because of immediate financial reward.

11

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

I agree with you that the best content is when the authors want to share something they are knowledgable and passionate about. Having a financial incentive would enable more people like this to create content (i.e. people that don't have the time/money required to write something of value) .

My argument is more about keeping that option alive. On reddit, we already have the ability to upvote/downvote content we like. We can downvote content that is behind a paywall if we want. Blocking all of this content just removes this option.

12

u/jodraws May 31 '18

It'd be great if there was a policy where articles behind a paywall weren't allowed then we wouldn't have to downvote them.

5

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

That's totally fair, but I disagree. At the very least, I wanted to communicate what this community may be missing out on if it continues this policy. I hope my argument was made clear.

8

u/PurpleIcy May 31 '18

I'll be missing out on it either way because I am not paying whatever someone wants me to pay just to read some half assed article.

Nice point.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18 edited Jun 01 '18

You're really only speaking for yourself (and I'm sure many others) there, but not everyone. I see the point the above poster is making. Why outright ban paywalled content? It should be available simply for the sake of no censorship, if nothing else. If you don't like it, don't pay for it. All it does is lower the signal-to-noise ratio for you, personally, while you browse Reddit. Add a per-user filter on said paywalled content via some browser plugin or baked-in Reddit feature - easy fix.

3

u/Klathmon Jun 01 '18

What about a compromise. Articles behind a paywall are tagged as such and all readers can easily choose to ignore them, or can even setup their Reddit to filter them out?

0

u/nermid Jun 01 '18

Isn't the Reddit redesign going to break subreddit filters? I thought I heard that somewhere, but I haven't been following that kerfuffle too closely.

2

u/Klathmon Jun 01 '18

I don't believe so. IIRC they are working with major subreddit a to make it an official feature, and not just css hacks.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

2

u/Klathmon Jun 01 '18

No... I like the community, I like the layout, I like the ability to curate.

I honestly don't think it's that big of a deal that some people have to see clearly labeled paywall articles, especially if it helps curb the constant influx of shitty blogs written as fast as possible for the ad money.

If they become so common that it's a detriment to the subreddit, then I could see limiting them to one day a week or something, but an outright ban seems less like good moderation, and more like enforcing a mods opinion on paywall on everyone in the sub.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (0)

0

u/PurpleIcy May 31 '18

If downvoting autodeleted posts nobody wants to see then it wouldn't be a problem.

But it doesn't.

8

u/NormalUserThirty May 31 '18

we don't need a two tiered system, where some people get access to resources because they can afford it and others dont because they can't. especially when I regularly see users on this sub who arent working as developer yet and are just trying to learn.

if people want to create awesome content behind a paywall, they are free to do so. those of us that want to find it and can afford it will buy it. but I think keeping paywall protected content off a sub as general as this one makes sense. in my mind this sub should be as open and accessible as possible.

3

u/lordkoba May 31 '18

look at how youtube content has degraded.

any relatively popular topic is littered with low effort 10 min videos.

it's harder to find useful information now.

3

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

I don't really know what recently changed at youtube, so I can't really respond to your point. I can say that it sounds more like an issue with youtube's search/recommendation algorithms than anything else.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

[deleted]

12

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

I agree that would be terrible, but I think it's shortsighted and naive to think that all content should be free or advertisement driven. I know this isn't a popular opinion, but I think it's important to pay for content and reward the creators of the content.

For example, a lot of the blog posts out there are written by employees of different companies to promote their products. There is nothing wrong with this (and I love those blog posts a lot of the time), but it limits the value of the content. I always think, "are they proposing this approach only to sell me on their product?".

9

u/Shaper_pmp May 31 '18

I think it's shortsighted and naive to think that all content should be free or advertisement driven

That's true, but all content posted to a free, open community full of members that only exists for the explicit purpose of those members seeing and discussing it?

Well, I'm quite happy to dictate that those articles should all be freely accessible to said members because otherwise what's the point of posting them here?

If medium wants to allow authors to restrict access to only paying members then it can absolutely do that, but then that content can only be meaningfully discussed on a forum where most/all users are paying medium members. Like, say, comments on that blog post or medium's own forums. Trying to discuss it on Reddit would be an exercise in futility, as the vast majority of the users wouldn't be able to read the content even if they wanted to, and even more users will just spam ignorant, off-topic crap based purely on the headline.

In the same way that you think authors should be paid for their work, why should they be rewarded with free publicity in open, free communities like reddit? If they want to get paid for writing, they can pay for advertising too, no?

3

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

That's a great point. Thanks for sharing.

You're right that discussions would be a lot more fruitful for free articles than thoes behind a paywall. However, reddit is more than just a place to discuss content. It's also a place to discover content.

The majority of authors are being paid for their work, either through advertisements or employment. If the content is good, we should be free to share it regardless of how the author chooses to monetize it.

3

u/Shaper_pmp May 31 '18 edited May 31 '18

However, reddit is more than just a place to discuss content. It's also a place to discover content.

Absolutely. Only as a member of a community predicated on discovering freely-available content...

... why would I want to "discover" content that I can't access?

There's nothing wrong with starting a subreddit dedicated to great Medium articles on JS that you can only access with a paid subscription, but I would respectfully suggest that the main JS subreddit for the entire site (where 99.999% of users aren't Medium members, making such submissions nothing but annoying spam) isn't it. ;-)

If the content is good, we should be free to share it regardless of how the author chooses to monetize it.

Not really - reddit isn't a place where self-publicists (or others) have a god-given moral right to advertise their for-pay offerings. It's a place designed and intended for people to find interesting content... and no matter how great the article, if 99.999% of people can't see it, then the submission is nothing but annoying spam.

3

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

It's a place designed and intended for people to find interesting content... and no matter how great the article, if 99.999% of people can't see it, then the submission is nothing but annoying spam.

I agree with you, but I also think this is self regulating. Why would people upvote content that they can't view?

I'd rather know that good content existed, and have the option to pay for it, than not know it exists at all.**

Couldn't we have labels like 'Behind a Paywall' like other subreddits?

**I understand that reddit is not the only content aggregator out there, and this is not the only javascript related subreddit, so I don't have too much skin in this game.

0

u/PurpleIcy May 31 '18

Blogging is a hobby, not a job, if you don't like sharing information you can become a janitor, will still earn more.

3

u/TheCarnalStatist Jun 01 '18

There are a lot of folks whose livelihood is blogging....

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '18

[deleted]

2

u/IkKanLaz May 31 '18

Fair point. I agree that it's up to the author/platform to build a bit of trust with the reader that the content will be worth paying for up front. That is something that they will have to work on.

For that reason, there will always be free content. What I don't like is good content being blocked because of how the author chooses to monetize it.

1

u/Fullstack_Questions Jun 01 '18

Medium spammers are the bane of all discussion and knowledge sharing of programming on the internet. Thank you, MODS.

0

u/emostafa Jun 01 '18

What if we can create a platform, with ads, inside blog posts, anf authors earn money for clicks on ads on their page, you know youtube/adsense but for blogs ? This would pay authors and keep all the content free.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

2

u/emostafa Jun 01 '18

Yeah sorry, totally forgot about that, but i read here people like medium because its simple and neat, one design, not have to woory about theing like blogger. Plus blogger is all about separate blogs, I believe medium is better because tou can just go to the homepage and have fees of posts you might like, or interested in based on categories.

-23

u/OzziePeck May 31 '18

Just ban all medium posts.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

[deleted]

5

u/Htch Jun 01 '18

I couldn’t agree more. People need to make money, maybe they do that by writing fantastic content and charging for it. This sub shouldn’t take a stance on this, but focus on building a community around great ideas and projects, no matter where they come from.

7

u/kenman Jun 01 '18

People need to make money

You and /u/Klathmon have convinced me that we should look into a paywall for /r/javascript. Us mods put in hundreds of hours per year maintaining this sub, so we should definitely be entitled to some compensation; agree/disagree?

And the same goes for the FOSS authors & maintainers -- maybe they should go commercial, seeing as they collectively put in orders of magnitude more time than any of us, all for zero compensation.

15

u/Klathmon Jun 01 '18

Come on man, you are a moderator of this subreddit. Can we have a discussion about this without dropping to silly straw man arguments?

If you want to make a paywalled subreddit, I'd fully support your decision! make /r/Curated_Javascript, require a subscription, hell if the content that is posted is good, i'd probably subscribe! Let this sub get run by others if you want, that's okay. You don't owe us anything, as like you said you are an unpaid volunteer.

If you are talking about taking the current sub dark and charging for access to what was once free, I can't say I agree. That's a shitty move, a bait and switch, and I don't support that idea.

Those feelings apply to articles posted on reddit as well. If someone takes all their medium.com articles that were once free and puts them behind a paywall, I feel they should be removed and have to be resubmitted fresh tagged as "paywall". But posting new appropriately tagged articles behind a paywall is okay in my book.

And nobody here is saying that content creators are entitled to compensation, but that they should have the freedom to choose which method they want to use, and not be banned from subreddits because of that choice. If an author posts something and puts it behind a paywall, the entire sub is more than free to downvote and ignore it. And the author probably knows that, which is a tradeoff they need to make. Do they go for a large amount of readers that pay next to nothing, or a small amount of readers that pay a lot?

And as you said, the same goes for FOSS authors and maintainers. Many of them do go commercial. Dual licensing is relatively common, and many will charge for support to be able to afford to maintain the project. But nobody is requiring that, and nobody is disallowing that. Each author is free to choose how they want to monetize (or not monetize) their projects , and I don't feel they should be entirely banned from a platform because of the strategy they choose.

I used to moderate a few small-ish subs, and I know all too well how shitty of a job even that was, so I don't envy you at all, but in the end it's clear you've made up your mind, and i'm in the minority here. I'm just super disappointed because of all of the subreddits I frequent, I honestly felt that /r/javascript was one of the better run subs. But if even my favorite sub's moderators aren't open to discussions, then i'm pretty sure I don't want to be an active part of the community.

I deleted and retyped this like 4 times now, so i'm just going to send it at this point. I genuinely hope this decision works out well for you and this sub as a whole.

2

u/Htch Jun 01 '18

I cannot upvote this enough

2

u/nikolasleblanc Jun 04 '18

Yeah your response here and the "continued decline of medium.com" mentioned in your post just sounds super jaded. Paywall tags seem like they'd do the trick just fine. It sounds like you just don't like medium.

18

u/ftfymf Jun 01 '18

I have to say I agree, although the quality of the content on medium is often questionable (a lot of self promoting, or very poorly written opinion/advice posts) overall there is some very good quality content there. I hope Medium focuses on making sure the content quality increases and content creators are properly rewarded without having to bow to advertisers demands, which is a good thing.

I also think the impact of the GDPR and decline of online advertising except for the big boys (fb/google) means we're going to be seeing a lot more paywalls.

5

u/1-800-BICYCLE Jun 01 '18 edited Jul 05 '19

743999745c19

1

u/Klathmon Jun 01 '18

We already have rules and limits about self promotion, and like it or not many people are already profiting off platforms like reddit by showing ads and monetizing data.

I'm hoping that the widespread usage of ads and data tracking can be reduced by allowing people to pay content creators directly.

Also, why do people keep bringing up that reddit is an "open platform". Reddit isn't open sourced, it's absolutely not free (you paying either for gold, or with your information for advertising), it does quite frequently block and ban people that don't follow their rules, and it's run by a corporation which is profiting from it. I find it extremely ironic that people are upset by a push for content creators to get paid for their work on a platform which is profiting from that comment being made.

3

u/Singularity42 Jun 01 '18

Agree completely. If we don't like ads, and we don't like paywalls, how do we expect to get any good content if there is no way for sites to get money. We can't just have everything for free.

To me, the best thing about reddit is that it is a democracy. If people don't like a post, or don't want to pay. They will downvote. Why is this something mods need to decide for us?

1

u/bunnyholder Jun 03 '18

I think its distribution problem. If it's a tutorial, you could make some code examples payable.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '18

I second this. In the post-GDPR world we need to consider that not everything can be free. That shouldn't mean we can't discuss about it on more general platforms like reddit.

1

u/Fullstack_Questions Jun 01 '18

Copy pasting from a module's docs and titling "How to use X with React" is not "funding" anyone.

4

u/Klathmon Jun 01 '18

God this is so disheartening. I like this community, and I really feel like it's rocketing downhill in front of me...

I didn't say that, you know it. I don't like shitty articles any more than most of you, and I try to downvote them and comment why I feel they are shitty articles when I see them.

But there are articles which do pay the author, and there are articles which are well written that would not have been made if the author would have been banned from this subreddit.

Man I don't even know why i'm still typing...