r/javascript • u/brokentyro • Oct 24 '17
VS Code Switching Back to Blue Icon After Community Complaints
https://code.visualstudio.com/blogs/2017/10/24/theicon58
Oct 25 '17
That's funny. I didn't like it, but it wouldn't have occurred to me to bitch about it.
5
u/SamSlate Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
bitching was literally my first reaction.
edit: please everyone get the fuck over yourself.
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
11
u/breath-of-the-smile Oct 25 '17
"Adults aren't ever allowed to complain."
See how dumb that sounds even when you take the personal insult out of it? That's the hallmark of saying something dumb.
25
u/Tioo Oct 24 '17
I don't mind the colour but I hate the black rectangle in the background. Is there a way to use the old icon on the dock icon?
5
u/occz Oct 24 '17
I know you can on mac - if you search through the issue referenced in the post you can find the method easily.
1
1
u/Jsn7821 Oct 25 '17
What in the world is the tilted black rectangle all about? Is it some kind of Microsoft design thing?
1
77
u/HomemadeBananas Oct 24 '17
I didn’t even realize the color changed. Don’t people complaining about something so trivial have work to get done?
26
u/JayV30 Oct 25 '17
I realized it. I didn't care.
13
5
Oct 25 '17
I was looking for vs code for 10 minutes on the dock. I thought a bug hid it while the app was still working.
That orange icon was new and surprising, but did not bother me. I got used to the blue though. The team needs to focus on the importance of branding
86
15
Oct 25 '17
I actually wondered where the fuck Visual Studio Code icon had gone.
I had the same complaint with VS2012 when they turned all the icons in Solution Explorer Sidebar grey. I've used VS since 2013 and most of the icons for files in explorer hadn't changed significantly since there i.e. colours and shapes mostly the same.
So when a company makes a change that large when you are that familiar with the UI you are "visually" lost. I actively kept using VS2010 until fairly recently (most of my clients haven't upgraded server infrastructure in about 10 years so .NET 4 was the latest version they could run anyway).
5
u/asdf7890 Oct 25 '17
This must have been a boost for the VSCode team. People are invested enough to notice and care when something is wrong in their eyes and there isn't something more serious for them to complain about than an icon. That many people getting vocal about something so small on its own rather than as an "and another thing" complain means they they must be doing a lot of stuff right.
4
Oct 25 '17
Programmers have also free time, and to many of them aesthetic matters.
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
3
Oct 25 '17
seems like plenty of them
are children who overreact to trivial shithave opinions different from mineReally, why this hostility?
1
u/breath-of-the-smile Oct 25 '17
Apparently they really believe that people are not allowed to complain about or dislike anything. If their comments on this thread are anything to go off.
9
u/fogbasket Oct 25 '17
Here's what I don't get. Why do we care what the icon is? Why on earth would you ever click on that nonsense? You hit Windows and type VS Code and it comes up first. I assume Mac has an applicable launcher, and surely Linux does as well.
18
u/FriesWithThat Oct 25 '17
$ code .3
u/fogbasket Oct 25 '17
This needs to be upvoted more. In truth, this is how I open projects in VS Code.
1
1
Oct 26 '17
True, but switching back to it, either on the dock/taskbar or alt-tab switcher benefits from the icon.
1
u/fogbasket Oct 26 '17
Maybe it does if you keep open a lot of windows for whatever project you're working on.
3
5
u/Pyrolistical Oct 25 '17
It was important to change this for colorblind people. Orange vs green is no good for me
2
Oct 25 '17
Honestly, this is the most valid reason. I'm not colorblind, but in design you need to keep this sort of thing in mind.
2
2
Oct 25 '17
I don’t really mind it on Mac. I prefer the blue but it’s an icon after all. The orange does not sit with the other parts of the editor but eh it’s fine.
What I would like is an icon selection. Having it rebrand without my prior permission annoyed me more than the colour.
Also bad timing with sublime changing theirs.
2
2
4
u/phpdevster Oct 25 '17
Ughh, I liked the new orange icon. I have both VS Code and Visual Studio open when I work, and I kept mixing the two up because they're so similar :/
3
2
u/d4rkst4rw4r Oct 24 '17
Looks like a blue fish instead of an orange one now. Like a vector of the bluefish editor icon.
9
2
u/mxmo Oct 25 '17
It's like anything popular, once you see it enough it grows on you. Pepsi could change its logo to the most god awful thing, but after exposure to a few hundred commercials, it will grow on you. Being as the software is more important to us than the logo, we will keep using it and see the logo day-in and day-out, whatever they choose would grow on us. After awhile, we'll be used to it, and anything different will be cause for comment...for a bit, till we get used to it.
2
1
1
Oct 25 '17
I never minded the orange. But I love they used a Monty Python reference in their apology.
1
1
Oct 25 '17
Wait.... What is this all about? I have never heard anything about this? Can someone explain? My VS program icon is purple?
1
1
0
u/mycall Oct 25 '17
Lame, the blue icon isn't as good imho.
How hard is it to dynamically generate the color?
0
-2
u/daven26 Oct 24 '17
Can we as a community get sublime to do the same? I'm not a big fan of their new icon.
-3
u/Serializedrequests Oct 25 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
I deeply enjoyed the backlash from a folly of humanity wasting outrage on trivia standpoint, and also from the standpoint of much preferring the original icon, or at least the color blue and its elegant simplicity. I don't know what the new one is supposed to be.
I still prefer Sublime, but it is a bummer how little activity there seems to be with it these days and how the linter plugins have really poor display of output.
0
-3
u/veydar_ Oct 25 '17
Time was wasted. Magnanimous refrigerator, vociferous and succulent. Praise the verisimilitude.
2
u/DinglebellRock Oct 25 '17
Your reply is more valuable than that blog post and as a bonus took me much less time to read and parse!
-4
u/T-Dot1992 Oct 25 '17
Still doesn’t change the fact that VS Code sucks.
drops mic
-1
u/breath-of-the-smile Oct 25 '17
I swear, it's like the VS Code version of every extension I also use in Atom has a bug that makes the extension almost useless. ES6 import autocompletion doesn't work, Parinfer... only kinda works, the list goes on. But my work laptop isn't super beefy and can't handle running Atom for long. Bleh.
At least it's faster?
No problem using Atom at home, though.
-13
u/pichfl Oct 24 '17
I don’t care for the color, but it is cringe worthy to see Microsoft once more going back on a strong design decision instead of embracing it. First fanfares than a big excuse than back to how it was before because that’s what a loud part of the community has demanded. A perfect recipe for a Microsoft branded way of improvement and innovation. Meh.
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
-1
u/ianpaschal Oct 25 '17
It's not about that. This topic indicates that a lot of people liked it or didn't give a shit. But a few very vocal people gave the impression that the community wanted something and the designers, rather than stand firm by their expertise and decisions, completely caved. Laaaaaaame.
5
-2
u/malcor88 Oct 25 '17
Why switch back, how about make it a setting. Then let users choose. In all honesty I'd prefer they work through bugs that affect the error.
0
Oct 24 '17
[deleted]
41
Oct 24 '17
Not gonna lie, I love the orange. Blue is rates one of the most inviting UI colo(u)rs, but orange made it unique.
6
9
u/namesandfaces Oct 25 '17
I didn't have a problem with the color at all, but I did think their original icon design was more elegant and recognizable.
1
u/doomcomes Oct 25 '17
That makes sense. I hope they will keep them included, it's a small bit of data for the few people that would like to change it.
9
u/nplus Oct 24 '17
Same.. I use both VS & VS Code and orange is much easier to tell them apart (VS is purple).
1
u/nbagf Oct 25 '17
I like using the Insider version to get new features faster and the last two builds had no icon at all so it defaulted to the electron icon. The github issue for it was hilarious with a few thinking it had to do with the orange icon hate. FWIW insiders icon used to be green until it changed to match the release color.
17
u/mayhempk1 Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 24 '17
Not for me, I have Sublime right next beside it so it makes it harder to find. The blue definitely helps me out. Blue has worked for so long so why change it?
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
3
u/mayhempk1 Oct 25 '17
Yeah, I wish they gave an option for what icon you want. Since it has an open-source community behind it, perhaps there is custom VS Code icons?
0
Oct 25 '17
[deleted]
2
Nov 14 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/doomcomes Nov 15 '17
Well, I just reinstalled my os, I guess it'd be in actually changing the icon for the program and not just the taskbar icon.
2
Nov 15 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/doomcomes Nov 15 '17
cool. I might have to make the icon bigger and do this. thanks for the link.
1
5
u/fgutz Oct 24 '17
ditto, I kept clicking Photoshop at work because of the similar colors. Since they changed i've had noticed way less accidental app launching.
2
u/NuttingFerociously Oct 25 '17
Kept clicking on Photoshop when it was blue, kept clicking on Illustrator when it became orange
Should've gone with the insider build since I don't use Dreamweaver I guess
1
u/doomcomes Oct 25 '17
Luckily my photoshop is across the bar but display fusion was right next to Code so I totally know what you are talking bout, it's a pain when so many icons are around the same blue and you have to close apps you launch on accident.
2
Oct 25 '17
Agreed. My dockbar is a field of blue and purple with VS Code and Hyper being the only non-conformists.
2
u/vicarofyanks Oct 25 '17
Me too, it’d be cool if they left the assets so you can set it whichever one you like
2
u/spectre013 Oct 25 '17
don't remember the last time I clicked on Icon to launch something. On mac I use spotlight and windows the windows key and just type in what I am looking for and hit enter.
0
0
Oct 24 '17
[deleted]
6
6
u/mayhempk1 Oct 24 '17 edited Oct 25 '17
Right? I hate when companies change for no reason, it's so dumb and pointless and it ends up being worse when they change it.
Udemy's new appearance is a very rare exception to this rule. I love Udemy's new appearance minus their logo color (should have kept the new logo but colored it green again instead of red) is actually fantastic, but then again they had a good design before as well.
2
1
u/dylan_kun Oct 25 '17
The only one that pissed me off was a couple years ago when jetbrains took all their icons and turned them into a generic splash of color with two letters. I guess I'm used to it now but I still wish they would use the old icons.
1
u/kayzzer Oct 25 '17
maybe your thinking of adobe like 12 years ago
1
u/dylan_kun Oct 25 '17
Well they modelled it off the "success" of adobe's rebranding in the past, but no I'm talking about jetbrains a couple years ago.
1
0
79
u/DOG-ZILLA Oct 24 '17
This entire debacle was hilarious.
It's a good thing though. It shows the community really cares for VS Code and that the team building it do indeed listen up.
Win win all-round I say.