MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/javascript/comments/72lh17/react_16/dnjelvs/?context=3
r/javascript • u/batmansmk • Sep 26 '17
63 comments sorted by
View all comments
27
Yes! And everything wrapped in a nicer licence :)
29 u/[deleted] Sep 26 '17 And by nicer they mean "Your company can use this again without your legal dept lighting your project on fire" -8 u/fogbasket Sep 26 '17 Until FB sues you for infringing their patents. 12 u/DanielFGray Sep 27 '17 Your risk of being sued by FB is no different from using React or not, even before or after the new license. 5 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 Without a patent grant that's debatable. 5 u/Jestar342 Sep 26 '17 IANAL: Does there need to be one? What's the default when grant absentia? 1 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 There is no default grant. 1 u/Jestar342 Sep 26 '17 No, I'm not asking if there is a default grant, I am asking what is the default legal position in the absence of a grant. 3 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 edited Sep 26 '17 It means you can be sued for patent violation if FB so chooses, since they don't grant you any rights.Its for this reason that GraphQL, which does have explicit patents, was on such shaky ground - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/09/20/gitlab_suspends_graphql_project_over_facebook_license_terms/FB today announced this - https://code.facebook.com/posts/121714468491809/relicensing-the-graphql-specification/which seems to have taken care of that issue.
29
And by nicer they mean "Your company can use this again without your legal dept lighting your project on fire"
-8 u/fogbasket Sep 26 '17 Until FB sues you for infringing their patents. 12 u/DanielFGray Sep 27 '17 Your risk of being sued by FB is no different from using React or not, even before or after the new license.
-8
Until FB sues you for infringing their patents.
12 u/DanielFGray Sep 27 '17 Your risk of being sued by FB is no different from using React or not, even before or after the new license.
12
Your risk of being sued by FB is no different from using React or not, even before or after the new license.
5
Without a patent grant that's debatable.
5 u/Jestar342 Sep 26 '17 IANAL: Does there need to be one? What's the default when grant absentia? 1 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 There is no default grant. 1 u/Jestar342 Sep 26 '17 No, I'm not asking if there is a default grant, I am asking what is the default legal position in the absence of a grant. 3 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 edited Sep 26 '17 It means you can be sued for patent violation if FB so chooses, since they don't grant you any rights.Its for this reason that GraphQL, which does have explicit patents, was on such shaky ground - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/09/20/gitlab_suspends_graphql_project_over_facebook_license_terms/FB today announced this - https://code.facebook.com/posts/121714468491809/relicensing-the-graphql-specification/which seems to have taken care of that issue.
IANAL: Does there need to be one? What's the default when grant absentia?
1 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 There is no default grant. 1 u/Jestar342 Sep 26 '17 No, I'm not asking if there is a default grant, I am asking what is the default legal position in the absence of a grant. 3 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 edited Sep 26 '17 It means you can be sued for patent violation if FB so chooses, since they don't grant you any rights.Its for this reason that GraphQL, which does have explicit patents, was on such shaky ground - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/09/20/gitlab_suspends_graphql_project_over_facebook_license_terms/FB today announced this - https://code.facebook.com/posts/121714468491809/relicensing-the-graphql-specification/which seems to have taken care of that issue.
1
There is no default grant.
1 u/Jestar342 Sep 26 '17 No, I'm not asking if there is a default grant, I am asking what is the default legal position in the absence of a grant. 3 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 edited Sep 26 '17 It means you can be sued for patent violation if FB so chooses, since they don't grant you any rights.Its for this reason that GraphQL, which does have explicit patents, was on such shaky ground - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/09/20/gitlab_suspends_graphql_project_over_facebook_license_terms/FB today announced this - https://code.facebook.com/posts/121714468491809/relicensing-the-graphql-specification/which seems to have taken care of that issue.
No, I'm not asking if there is a default grant, I am asking what is the default legal position in the absence of a grant.
3 u/ECrispy Sep 26 '17 edited Sep 26 '17 It means you can be sued for patent violation if FB so chooses, since they don't grant you any rights.Its for this reason that GraphQL, which does have explicit patents, was on such shaky ground - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/09/20/gitlab_suspends_graphql_project_over_facebook_license_terms/FB today announced this - https://code.facebook.com/posts/121714468491809/relicensing-the-graphql-specification/which seems to have taken care of that issue.
3
It means you can be sued for patent violation if FB so chooses, since they don't grant you any rights.
Its for this reason that GraphQL, which does have explicit patents, was on such shaky ground - https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/09/20/gitlab_suspends_graphql_project_over_facebook_license_terms/
FB today announced this - https://code.facebook.com/posts/121714468491809/relicensing-the-graphql-specification/
which seems to have taken care of that issue.
27
u/coldlestat Sep 26 '17
Yes! And everything wrapped in a nicer licence :)