Your comment is basically "ok but <insert reiterated point>". I don't agree and I don't think you effectively rebutted anything I said.
You think basketball players don't look at twitter? You're creating some paper thin point where you're going "oh well it's criticism but it's not visible". That's not only a bullshit refutation but it's not even true. Moreover, whether he gets paid A LOT... does that even make the analogy null and void? "Oh because he gets paid a lot, it doesn't matter". That doesn't refute any one of my points... you act as if it's EASY to play basketball (with the amount of money they make, if people could do it they PROBABLY would), or that basketball players don't get AS frustrated no matter the amount of money they're making when the fans lash out... how about you go ask Ron Artest whether the money was "sufficient enough" for him to not lash out at the fans... and I'm going to prerebut your upcoming "well that was different"... as I say often, apples and oranges but they're both fruit. Your job is to see what the analogy is based on, not the "differences" because if that were the case, using analogies would be pointless.
There will always be "this sucks, that sucks". There will also be "this is awesome, I love you". You take the good with the bad. Stop FOCUSING solely on the negative criticism. You can sit there and complain but you don't get a safe space in life. This WILL continue to happen. You can either choose to be a victim, or go "hmmm MAYBE I should just view this as impassioned people... maybe they DON'T want to hurt me... maybe people are passionate about COLORS... do I really give fucks about this?".
For 2 straight weeks, people bashed Apple when iPhone 7 dropped. I was one of the people that was like "this shit sucks, no headphone jack". Guess what? I own the iPhone 7 now. Love it. Maybe I was overreacting... that's what people DO. You can't police the world. It's much better to change your personal interpretation of reality rather than try to get everything to change. Like I said before, it's clear that a lot of you need some sort of meditation practice because you are WAY too affected by the outside world. You're essentially asking for a safe space. Get over it, it's really that simple.
Edit: and no, OSS developer doesn't give you some special "get out of criticism free" card. So what... the corollary for being OSS is for people to treat you special? Again, you can keep dishing out that "well everyone deserves to be treated with respect" platitude but your definition of respect is a personal one. Respect is earned, and I'm totally fine with someone hating on something I did... that's true respect, not pulling punches and acting as you normally do when you don't like something. I can deal with the adulation so I should be able to handle negative comments. Good with the bad.
However, I do watch basketball and if someone misses all the shots they take in the game, I can say "that person sucks".
If you meant that you are saying that person sucks on Twitter, that isn't what you said, and it is not how I read your comment.
But either way, you continue to miss the key point: OSS maintainers are volunteers. That doesn't mean they get a pass, and that doesn't mean we treat them with deference out of some moral righteousness. It means they are motivated by passion/purpose/reputation not money. In other words, your interactions with maintainers directly affects how they are "paid". It is in your interest, as a consumer of OSS, to keep its maintainers motivated. That's it.
If the precept, "When critiquing a volunteer who served you, don't be an asshole", is too difficult for you. Maybe just don't say anything at all.
I don't give a shit. I explained this to you many times before. This is not how people operate.. it's not like you are going to change people's behaviors. You're having this silly little argument with me but I'm explaining how PEOPLE operate, but yet you sit here trying to tell me to change MY actions, missing the entire point I laid out very carefully. What a waste of time.
In other words, your interactions with maintainers directly affects how they are "paid".
No. Maintainers have always had to deal with "people". You think Linus never got agitated with people? You think he sent out some "treat me better plz" message? You "do not" speak for all OSS maintainers (I LOVE when people try to attempt to speak incorrectly for a group of people). This hasn't been the reality for OSS maintainers pretty much forever, however there is still tons of benefit in OSS, and they themselves still proselytize how awesome it is. Let me ask you this: there are clearly OSS developers who love doing what they do (I'm sure I could find articles or opinions of this in very short amount of time). Do you think they never dealt with negative criticism like this? This entire time you've built this paper thing argument which goes:
OSS developers don't get paid, therefore they have to be treated nice as their only payment is if everyone treats them nice. If they are not treated nice, they will leave.
And again and again I've laid out my points very carefully to say that this is an argument that could be applied to life and it would be incorrect there and it is incorrect here. Ignoring that, there are many OSS maintainers that have continued on for YEARS having received the same type of negative feedback. Whether you like it or not, people will continue to contribute to OSS REGARDLESS of the small vocal minority of negative comments. So you can continue to dance around the point, make platitudes but OSS will continue on regardless of your opinion of people's attitudes and opinions, which is off base to begin with.
Regardless of the badass students teachers run into, the joy of teaching for the sake of teaching will ALWAYS be present. The great teachers don't let criticism, bad students, or bad apples override the pleasure they get from the adulation, from the thanks, from the joy of helping people, and is an obstacle that is generally UNDERSTOOD before the journey starts. Your point is 100% invalid and not based in reality in any way whatsoever. Have a great day.
Edit: I used to teach for practically pennies, hence the context I'm giving you. I enjoyed it greatly. There were bad apples, there were hard heads, there were negative people there. However if you "volunteer" or give help for free, you understand that it's not all roses... this is something that every "volunteer" understands... you're going to be encountered with nastiness and sometimes the person even HAS a reason to be nasty... part of contributing to greater good is acknowledging this type of behavior but not focusing in on it... otherwise you become consumed by it. So again... you are not correct. There are volunteers that cannot take those negative aspects... those volunteers either do not last long, or they become bitter.
I take issue with the claim that you have laid out your points carefully. Your posts are like rhetorical shotgun blasts. Scattered and loud.
Your intended target this time seems to be that assholes won't stop all OSS developers, so there is no point in encouraging people to be more constructive. This is analogous to saying that seatbelts don't prevent all traffic fatalities, so there is no point in encouraging people to wear them.
If assholes cost us some OSS developers (they do), and we can encourage some of our community to be more constructive with their criticism (we can), then it is worth doing.
0
u/p0tent1al Dec 06 '16 edited Dec 06 '16
Your comment is basically "ok but <insert reiterated point>". I don't agree and I don't think you effectively rebutted anything I said.
You think basketball players don't look at twitter? You're creating some paper thin point where you're going "oh well it's criticism but it's not visible". That's not only a bullshit refutation but it's not even true. Moreover, whether he gets paid A LOT... does that even make the analogy null and void? "Oh because he gets paid a lot, it doesn't matter". That doesn't refute any one of my points... you act as if it's EASY to play basketball (with the amount of money they make, if people could do it they PROBABLY would), or that basketball players don't get AS frustrated no matter the amount of money they're making when the fans lash out... how about you go ask Ron Artest whether the money was "sufficient enough" for him to not lash out at the fans... and I'm going to prerebut your upcoming "well that was different"... as I say often, apples and oranges but they're both fruit. Your job is to see what the analogy is based on, not the "differences" because if that were the case, using analogies would be pointless.
There will always be "this sucks, that sucks". There will also be "this is awesome, I love you". You take the good with the bad. Stop FOCUSING solely on the negative criticism. You can sit there and complain but you don't get a safe space in life. This WILL continue to happen. You can either choose to be a victim, or go "hmmm MAYBE I should just view this as impassioned people... maybe they DON'T want to hurt me... maybe people are passionate about COLORS... do I really give fucks about this?".
For 2 straight weeks, people bashed Apple when iPhone 7 dropped. I was one of the people that was like "this shit sucks, no headphone jack". Guess what? I own the iPhone 7 now. Love it. Maybe I was overreacting... that's what people DO. You can't police the world. It's much better to change your personal interpretation of reality rather than try to get everything to change. Like I said before, it's clear that a lot of you need some sort of meditation practice because you are WAY too affected by the outside world. You're essentially asking for a safe space. Get over it, it's really that simple.
Edit: and no, OSS developer doesn't give you some special "get out of criticism free" card. So what... the corollary for being OSS is for people to treat you special? Again, you can keep dishing out that "well everyone deserves to be treated with respect" platitude but your definition of respect is a personal one. Respect is earned, and I'm totally fine with someone hating on something I did... that's true respect, not pulling punches and acting as you normally do when you don't like something. I can deal with the adulation so I should be able to handle negative comments. Good with the bad.