r/javascript • • Dec 05 '16

Dear JavaScript

https://medium.com/@thejameskyle/dear-javascript-7e14ffcae36c
807 Upvotes

271 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/NoInkling Dec 05 '16

It's not that negative feedback is being communicated, it's about HOW it's being communicated.

-1

u/jpflathead Dec 06 '16

People are a bell curve with more than a few black swans. Same as projects.

Some projects are shit, but sold as champagne.

How one offers feedback should have zero to do with whether some maintainer is paid or not.

JavaScript fatigue is real and brought to us by many paid and unpaid people, and often the unpaid ones still benefit via résumé and consulting etc.

So whatever, ...

1

u/delventhalz Dec 06 '16

Considering that OSS maintainers are driven by passion/purpose and not money, I'd say it matters very very much whether or not they are paid. I'm talking purely selfishly. If you depend on code written by a volunteer, it is in your own self interest to keep that volunteer motivated.

Also, don't be an asshole. Is that really so hard? It's literally not doing something. It is by definition less work.

3

u/jpflathead Dec 06 '16

Considering that OSS maintainers are driven by passion/purpose and not money

That's largely debunked. For many companies OSS is just one more way to differentiate and attract users, their devs and maintainers earn the same as everyone.

And just because some gal at Google or Microsoft gets paid for their work, doesn't mean they aren't driven by passion and purpose.

Also, don't be an asshole. Is that really so hard? It's literally not doing something. It is by definition less work.

Yeah, we need to turn software into a safe space and issue participation awards and never criticize anyone's work as shitty, or bug ridden, or insecure, or hard to configure, or more trouble than its worth, or slow, even as they use their software on their resumes, or sell it to giant ecosystems or parlay it onto conferences.

God forbid, any author ever ever be told their story was boring, or had poor grammar, or was trite, or was filled with plotholes.

I mean once I had a gardener put too much fertilizer on the roses and I was going to complain but it was pointed out to me his feelings would be hurt.

Mom once made a souffle that fell but we knew we'd better eat that rock, because you know mom.

→ More replies (1)