r/javascript • • Dec 05 '16

Dear JavaScript

https://medium.com/@thejameskyle/dear-javascript-7e14ffcae36c
807 Upvotes

271 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/jpflathead Dec 05 '16

Look I think the Microsoft ecosystem is terrible, and if the the devs there get butt hurt about it, I'll buy them a beer and tell them the Microsoft ecosystem is terrible.

What privileges Angular 2 from not being called terrible if certain people think it is?

And Babel 6 was a huge and shitty move, regardless of the good intentions of its developers.

Want to install Babel 6? Take this six part minicourse on Udacity to figure out which components you need.

Yeah, that was going to go over well.

The javascript community is mean to developers comes from the same folks still insisting Clinton was right to focus on identity politics.

JavaScript fatigue is not good, it's nothing to be proud of, it's not a mark of how powerful and innovative JavaScript is, it says nothing except JavaScript is built out of a rapidly pouring bucket of shit and if you want to have a chance of surviving you need to climb that enema waterfall as fast as you can.

6

u/NoInkling Dec 05 '16

It's not that negative feedback is being communicated, it's about HOW it's being communicated.

-1

u/jpflathead Dec 06 '16

People are a bell curve with more than a few black swans. Same as projects.

Some projects are shit, but sold as champagne.

How one offers feedback should have zero to do with whether some maintainer is paid or not.

JavaScript fatigue is real and brought to us by many paid and unpaid people, and often the unpaid ones still benefit via résumé and consulting etc.

So whatever, ...

2

u/NoInkling Dec 06 '16

Not sure how that justifies being a dickhead to people...

1

u/jpflathead Dec 06 '16

I'm going to have to downvote you because I have taken offense at your harsh criticism of my comment.

As a black aneurotypical lesbian trans little person, I take umbrage at your microaggression against me.

-- does that help explain?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/delventhalz Dec 06 '16

Considering that OSS maintainers are driven by passion/purpose and not money, I'd say it matters very very much whether or not they are paid. I'm talking purely selfishly. If you depend on code written by a volunteer, it is in your own self interest to keep that volunteer motivated.

Also, don't be an asshole. Is that really so hard? It's literally not doing something. It is by definition less work.

3

u/jpflathead Dec 06 '16

Considering that OSS maintainers are driven by passion/purpose and not money

That's largely debunked. For many companies OSS is just one more way to differentiate and attract users, their devs and maintainers earn the same as everyone.

And just because some gal at Google or Microsoft gets paid for their work, doesn't mean they aren't driven by passion and purpose.

Also, don't be an asshole. Is that really so hard? It's literally not doing something. It is by definition less work.

Yeah, we need to turn software into a safe space and issue participation awards and never criticize anyone's work as shitty, or bug ridden, or insecure, or hard to configure, or more trouble than its worth, or slow, even as they use their software on their resumes, or sell it to giant ecosystems or parlay it onto conferences.

God forbid, any author ever ever be told their story was boring, or had poor grammar, or was trite, or was filled with plotholes.

I mean once I had a gardener put too much fertilizer on the roses and I was going to complain but it was pointed out to me his feelings would be hurt.

Mom once made a souffle that fell but we knew we'd better eat that rock, because you know mom.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

[deleted]

1

u/delventhalz Dec 06 '16

That doesn't change a thing I said. If you demotivate them and convince them that being a maintainer is actually harming their reputation, they will stop doing the work.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

[deleted]

1

u/delventhalz Dec 06 '16

Did I say anything about altruism? Why would I care about people's inner motivations? I'm not a mind reader. I just want better software.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16

I ❤️ Babel 6. The plugin approach turned out awesome!

1

u/jpflathead Dec 08 '16

It probably IS awesome, but the day they rolled it out the website went from:

  • [download]

to:

  • [download a] [download b] [download c] [download d]

  • [download e] [download f] [download g] [download h]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

  • [download x] [download x] [download x] [download x]

And then the devs said "what? People didn't like that? Well excuse me!"

2

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '16 edited Dec 09 '16

I donno. It's just smth like npm i babel-core babel-preset-es2015.

Pretty straight forward; core/cli + preset/plugin & maybe a loader for your bundler of choice.

Seems reasonable since Babel 6 is more than just ES2015 after all.

1

u/jpflathead Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16

I donno. It's just smth like npm i babel-core babel-preset-es2015. Pretty straight forward; core/cli + preset/plugin & maybe a loader for your bundler of choice. Seems reasonable since Babel 6 is more than just ES2015 after all.

Yes, that's clearly the argument from it's just not that complex for those of us who know what we are doing crowd.

And it gives zero fucks about n00bs suffering from javascript fatigue.

That's what the whole thing is about.

I'll go one step further. I want to write in ES6 and never fucking install either that piece of shit npm or that piece of shit node on my computer.

I realize I need to.

But the simple desire of wanting to write in ES6 shouldn't require that. Ever.

But given that I do, how about a most people use this setting and a full install setting?

Instead even now, it's for each piece of shit you are forced to use, come back here to this website to learn of the new and proper way to install the additional crapola you need to get babel to work with your favorite piece of shit inflicted on you by the other asswipes in the javascript fatigue is a good thing camp.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16

But the simple desire of wanting to write in ES6 shouldn't require that. Ever.

Over time ES2015 support will increase and things will get easier. Bleeding edge language features + wide support means smth like transpiling. For now, if you want, stick to ES3 or ES5 then that's doable without it.

1

u/jpflathead Dec 09 '16

Nevertheless, this isn't year zero of programming or year zero of personal computing or year zero of plugins.

Installation of the Babel Transpiler still should not require:

  • npm

  • node

or have a zillion other additional little plugins to install every other little thing needed.

Babel 6 probably had the best of intentions when they broke things apart, but concern for noobs, beginners, and intermediate developers was not any of their evident priorities.

2

u/j_win Dec 09 '16

Maybe it's worth conceding that bleeding edge language features and transpiling aren't "noob" appropriate waters to be wading into.

1

u/jpflathead Dec 09 '16

Maybe it's worth conceding that bleeding edge language features and transpiling aren't "noob" appropriate waters to be wading into.

Sorry that's not good enough.

Here's a free 30 day javascript course that starts off by assuming es6, because that's where the language is going:

https://javascript30.com/

n00b doesn't mean never saw a do loop before, noob means new to the javascript toxic waste dump.

installing a transpiler should be a one line thing. period.

2

u/j_win Dec 09 '16

javascript toxic waste dump

FWIW - you're going to have a hard time being taken seriously when you use language like that. Especially when you're just bloviating about some 3rd party, open source thing trying to make people's lives easier. If you want it to be better, contribute to the project.

installing a transpiler should be a one line thing

brew install node && npm i babel-core babel-preset-es2015

Boom; one line. I'm not sure what that actually proves, though.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/acemarke Dec 09 '16

So should installation of, say, Ant, not require installation of the JRE or JDK as well? You gotta have a runtime available in order to run a program written in a language like Javascript, or Java, or Python, or C#, or...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheMockumentarist Dec 05 '16

Most Microsoft devs are paid to contribute to the Microsoft ecosystem. OSS maintainers aren't paid at all. There's no need to be rude when criticizing something developed for free.

2

u/parlezmoose Dec 06 '16

Isnt angular a google project?