r/javascript • • Dec 05 '16

Dear JavaScript

https://medium.com/@thejameskyle/dear-javascript-7e14ffcae36c
807 Upvotes

271 comments sorted by

View all comments

39

u/calsosta Dec 05 '16

I agree and maybe to recap it, the problem isn't that people are assholes, we already knew that, the problem is one that we created which is that every asshole now has a voice in the community. It is only natural that leads to politics.

Right now we are politics with zero governance, perhaps if we included some way to democratize the process of majorly impactful changes to large projects it would at least change the vent of hate to EVERYONE instead of a single person.

42

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

This won't work though. Too many CS 101 students with very vocal opinions regarding things they really don't know much about. There's only maybe five people that know enough about the babel codebase to actually make informed decisions regarding it, for example.

15

u/xaviervia Dec 05 '16

Why wouldn't it? It's not about people not being vocal anymore, is about creating channels for valuable feedback.

If there were channels with good governance available, the OS maintainers could use those for skin-in-the-game discussions about the future of the projects, without having to navigate through rants.

9

u/mcaruso Dec 05 '16

According to the author at least, there was plenty of discussion and feedback prior to the change:

Before publishing Babel 6 this was a non-controversial change that had lots of input. We communicated what the intent was months in advance and asked for community feedback.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/danman_d Dec 05 '16

There will always be people with loud opinions and little experience, no one is suggesting that they will ever disappear. The point is to give those voices less attention than levelheaded opinions by experienced contributors, rather than more - and I don't see a good reason why that can't work.

4

u/calsosta Dec 05 '16

That is true however their vote does not need to be weighted the same as that of a contributor, a board member or other key people.

7

u/jacksonmills Dec 05 '16

CS 101 Students?

I honestly would be surprised if most of the comments are coming from CS majors, or first-year ones at that. The longer I've worked in this field, the less likely its been that my co-workers or colleagues went to school for development or computer science.

I'm not saying that's the reason for the negative atmosphere, but I sincerely doubt the cause of the problem is freshman or sophomore college students.

If you rephrased it as "junior web developers", I would completely agree with you.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

junior web developers

Yeah I completely agree, probably a better choice of words. Same meaning here tho

→ More replies (6)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

Also, asshole has a wildly diverse definition. If I advocate no frameworks as a way of boosting performance and somebody else now feels threatened then I quickly become an asshole. When everybody is hyper sensitive any suggestion that is not immediately the most popular could very easily make you an asshole. Consider CrockfordGate as any example.

To me, however, an asshole is a person whose intention is to incite a negative sensation above and beyond a technical subject... typically expressed as an ad hominem. Really, any ad hominem makes a person an asshole by default.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lhorie Dec 05 '16

some way to democratize

I think that just makes it worse, especially in highly controversial issues. The thing is that "majority wins" rule is orthogonal to "what the not-small minority thinks of it". Trolls will be trolls, and criticism isn't always easy to swallow. You can't change other people, no matter how inspiring a speech you make.

The way for an OSS maintainer to cope w/ negativity, in my opinion, is to first acknowledge that it's very possible to fuck up royally, even after extensive discussions and consensus (heck, I know I've made some incredibly stupid decisions to my projects, when I look in hindsight); and second, to wholeheartedly convince yourself that toxic vitriol comes from puny worthless people (it's an arrogant attitude, I know, but it's kinda true, and I keep these thoughts to myself, and they help shrug off bullshit and maintain my mental health).

I think getting the hell away from the internet to let your brain stew on the problem for a while is actually a good coping mechanism as well. It takes some humility to acknowledge that your big achievements in the internet are actually small in the grand scheme of things, and it can feel "dirty" to waste two weeks playing some lame freemium game on your ipad, but it also helps get some perspective that your well being comes before your trophies. Getting back into the groove of things can be especially hard once you unplug, but you can use the same strategies that you would do against procrastination (tackle easy low hanging fruits, make small achievements)

At least, that's what I try to do

→ More replies (2)

7

u/DatOpenSauce Dec 05 '16

I don't think most maintainers would want to implement a democracy for their projects though. I mean, why should they? It feels like submitting to the vocal pricks.

3

u/calsosta Dec 05 '16

That's perfectly fine too.

5

u/parlezmoose Dec 05 '16

The problem is tech culture glorifies cocky know-it-all assholes. The average half-witted web dev thinks their ability to write code makes them an engineering savant, and they fashion themselves as a brave no-nonsense truth teller like Linus Torvalds or Steve Jobs. So they say their dumb opinions loudly and with angry, righteous conviction, cause that's what brave savant truth tellers do!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

Feel like the Internet could really use a system similar to some MOBAs where people that are constantly toxic are rated by the community and eventually you just don't hear or see them anymore because everyone agrees they're trolls or add nothing to the community.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/NoInkling Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16

Well yeah, feedback is always gonna be biased towards the negative, because the people who have a positive or unnotable experience (things just work how you expect them to) tend to just get on with things. This kinda sums it up:

"When you do things right, people won't be sure you've done anything at all."

Note that this doesn't imply that negative feedback means you're doing things wrong - it's impossible to make software that perfectly caters to everyone, especially when the young people entering software these days are part of the most entitled generation (on the whole, I realize it's a generalization) to reach adulthood to date and often have unreasonable and vitriolic demands.

What the internet serves to do is open communication channels that allow any negative feedback to condense into highly visible circlejerks of hate, which are the biggest problem.

9

u/logicalLove Dec 05 '16

Make JavaScript great again!

9

u/tmckeage Dec 05 '16

REPEAL AND REPLACE NODE!

4

u/so_just Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16

That kinda happened with IO.js ... and then it got merged back into node.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

everyone especially in the Javascript community.

But this isn't particular to js or /r/javascript - this is the Internet.

You should see the anger and flames happening in Python after a prominent author trashed Python 3.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16

On the other side of these anti-negativity sentiments is blind positivity, which is just as bad.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/maiam Dec 05 '16

This is unfortunatley a problem with the world in the social media age and not just the js community

5

u/calsosta Dec 05 '16

I feel like anytime there are more than 2 people you are gonna have some amount of politics.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)