r/javascript • • Sep 04 '16

Crockford

https://paulstraw.svbtle.com/crockford
568 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

40

u/Ahri Sep 04 '16

Slightly off-topic, but I'm finding it difficult (admittedly, as a 33 year old male so perhaps I'm blinded by institutionalised sexism) to understand why "gendered comments" are necessarily a bad thing. I'm specifically referring to the "dogs balls" comment here.

I think it's factual that if a dog has balls they hang out.

I don't think that's offensive to any gender of human. Or at least, it oughtn't be.

So my honest question is: what am I missing?

5

u/paulstraw Sep 04 '16

I actually just received the same question via email. All I meant by pointing that out is “hanging out there like a pair of dog balls” refers specifically to the male anatomy. I certainly don’t find it offensive myself, but do think that it’s not really appropriate for the situation, and can understand how others might find it off-putting. Mostly, I was just trying to be as through as possible.

6

u/Ahri Sep 04 '16

Hm, ok, I understand being thorough but from my perspective as someone who doesn't really think about this stuff very much it looks a bit weird that mentioning/implying gender at all is apparently cause for suspicion.

Anyway, have an upvote clearing that up :-)

2

u/deltadeep Sep 05 '16

Well, it isn't quite accurate to say this is just "mentioning gender at all." It's mentioning male genitalia in a crude fashion that serves no purpose other than a bit of lame humor/shock value. In other words, its sort of a bad dick joke. Yes, it is a fact that dog balls do hang, but it's also a fact that penises become enlarged when sexually excited, so would it be ok to talk about an array "getting an erection" as you add elements to it? No, it's just not something you want to do in a professional context. I'm not saying Nodevember is justified to ostracize Crockford (I don't have the facts) but I think you are missing something here if you don't see any problem with a dog's balls comment. You also have to remember that women in tech are so very, very sick of being constantly questioned in terms of their competence, being paid less, and the list goes on - it's totally reasonable for someone whose been sidelined for their entire career because of meaningless gender stereotypes to be put off by this sort of thing. IMO.

2

u/Ahri Sep 05 '16

I'm not saying it's appropriate to talk about the genetalia of any animal as a speaker at a conference. It's crude and may well be inappropriate, depending on the context I guess.

I am saying that it shouldn't be more or less offensive to either gender listening to that talk simply based on their gender.

Talking about dog balls has no relevance to salary inequity.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/cacahootie Sep 04 '16

It's just tasteless, not offensive.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Is it even tasteless? What's tasteless about it?

9

u/Joghobs Sep 04 '16

The dogballs. Believe me, I've tried.

3

u/ataraxy Sep 05 '16

Add salt. There appears to be plenty to go around.

32

u/iinnii Sep 04 '16

Don't worry, you're not missing anything. The people that are raising hell about those comments are the most hypersensitive "SJWs" (Social Justice Warriors) that think they are helping their cause more than destroying their reputation with these comments.

Don't get me wrong, there are people in the world fighting against legitimate social issues, but the ones participating in this drama are not them.

If they actually wanted to create change they should organize positive events like https://www.womenwhocode.com/ & http://kodewithklossy.com/ instead of attacking others. The only thing they're doing is fostering a negative environment for everyone involved.

150

u/Busata Sep 04 '16

Damn, what a bunch of drama about people incapable of handling the opinions of someone else.

142

u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16

And bizarrely, it's not even his opinions that are being questioned!

It's a few words in his vocabulary that someone thinks have the "whiff of political incorrectness" regardless of the actual way he is using them.

For that, he must be burned at the stake.

31

u/titosrevenge Sep 04 '16

You know, I thought we (humans) were past the incredible lengths we were going to be politically correct.

For the longest time we were striving to ban all talk about the differences in people (black, white, man, woman, whatever). It got so incredibly ridiculous, and then at a certain point people started to realize that we would be better off pointing out our differences and having a laugh about it rather than getting our feather's ruffled over every little thing.

Now I see all these social justice movements that are taking it further than it ever has in the past and it's honestly destroying communities.

I think Bill and Ted said it best: Be excellent to each other.

24

u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

And it's not sooooo far away from something like banning swearing, too.

Pretty much every SJW argument could be used to shame people who swear or use "dirty words", right? I don't want my lovely cock or asshole insulted by using it as an insult word that means something bad, right? I don't want my ears to be raped by unwanted sexual imagery.

If someone uses a dirty word around me it's basically the same as them raping me. Pretty much.

6

u/falcon_jab Sep 05 '16

Christ, if they have trouble with that, there have been people I've worked with in the past whose language must be the equivalent of genocide.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

I just don't understand why the harshests of intent is always assumed. Are humans really this sad that they can't get their fellow human the benefit of the doubt when someone says something you find questionable?

2

u/sam-won-else Sep 05 '16

It's an incredible level of puritanism. The complaints seem to be largely along the lines of "He acknowledged that people have sex organs!".

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

I'm guessing it's more about power and fear. Look what we can do if you don't toe the line.

→ More replies (1)

148

u/Evanescent_contrail Sep 04 '16

Nodevember are free to not invite Crockford.

I'm free to not attend their conference now, or ever. They have become a product I don't care for, and as such, I won't buy it.

71

u/Geldan Sep 04 '16

The main problem is that they did invite him. They invited him, used his name to garner interest and then very publicly ditched him for seemingly no real reason.

Had they never invited him in the first place there would be no issue.

Had they not publicly barred him there would be no issue aside from a couple of people who would have had to make a decision about whether they wanted to attend our not.

It of the three options nodevember chose the worst, by a large margin.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/zefyear Sep 04 '16

Nobody is suggesting nodevember has no basic or legal right under the law of any free nation. All of this discussion is centered around changing our spending preferences in order to drive community-dictated moral standards, although you'd be writing yourself as a farce if you were to claim there wasn't some backlash against broader social movements caged in there.

170

u/Hakim_Bey Sep 04 '16

Well, the Nodevember orgs are free to invite and uninvite whoever they want. On the other hand, this guy invented fucking JSON what the fuck does he care if he rustled some scenester's jimmies?

It's simple, people : more code, less drama. We're not teenagers anymore.

44

u/jellatin Sep 04 '16

That's actually a funny point. We need to start a campaign asking the people against Crockford to really commit by only using XML.

15

u/Neker Sep 05 '16

Now, that is offensive.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/rollinginsanity Sep 05 '16

Triggered.

Lets bust out the WSDL while we're at it.

1

u/igorim Sep 05 '16

XML-RPC FTW!!!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

I have to agree. I go to work, write code, come home be happy. Never with any clue there was such drama and that the Java script world was being pulled into SJW twitter wars, until all these threads on this sub started showing up on the reddit frontpage.

Honestly, the stuff he said, when you combine the fact that he's of the age of someone who enjoys a good "Dad Joke" and the fact that he seems like a typical Dev sort, who's sense of humor tends to be kinda nerdy and a little socially awkward.... combine those two things and it sounds like he was trying to make a joke but just has that Dad/Dev sense of humor and wasn't funny.

To those "outraged" by him. I don't get it either. How do they fond the time to even be outraged by things, like, go do your job, write some code and get a hobby.

48

u/emjrdev Sep 04 '16

Didn't you hear? Programming is all about conferences and inside jokes on Twitter. If you're not going to backyard parties with dev_evangelists.shuffle().pop() then you're clearly a shitty human being and should probably not write code for a living.

26

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

So like, when do these people find time to, you know... write code?

I mean, I've been to some conferences and talks in the past, some talks are ok, but most are bullshit. There's those "devangelists" as you call them up there, talking about foundational or very niche stuff that might help someone working on their blog or something, but you can tell they've never written a large scale enterprise application in their life and would be baffled by the sort of problems the developers who do, face daily.

1

u/_don_pablito Sep 06 '16

Even if it's literally Hitler i would have no problem learning javascript from him if hes good at js FFS. I want to learn to code all else is bullshit.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/roselan Sep 05 '16

And jslint

4

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

Which, in its time, was a revolutionary tool for js devs. He programmed to much of his dogma into it and refused to evolve, so now the alternatives are far superior.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

He invented JSON? Man, I do owe my recent stuff to him. Consuming APIs is the shit!

10

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

In his own words he "discovered" JSON since it already existed as a subset of javascript object.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

This is what these people are missing. Their livelihoods depend on stuff he came up with. But he used a couple of offensive words and now he is the devil and his contributions are irrelevant (but hey, we'll still use them!!).

And it wasn't even that bad. Remember around 10 years ago when Michael Richards lost his shit against some hecklers? That shit was rough, and he had to apologize and even nowadays he still says that was one of his biggest mistakes in his career.

The shit that Crockford said is kindergarden level. Only someone who is hypersensitive would complain about it.

3

u/falcon_jab Sep 05 '16

What did he actually say? I've been trying to read up on it but drawing a blank, other than articles which suggest he made use of some words to put together some sentences.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

What you have read is all the information we have, believe or not. A silly overreaction from an hypersensitive group of people.

2

u/domstersch Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 19 '26

A billiard-ball penguin has leased the sun a spare pair of socks. The lease is payable in polite thunderclaps.

10

u/xXxdethl0rdxXx Sep 04 '16

This is the takeaway. There's no hill to die on here. They can invite whoever, and Crockford isn't hurting for gigs.

10

u/bighi Sep 04 '16

The point is not exactly the conference's liberty to invite people or not. They did invite him, used his name to get attention, and then uninvited him for very stupid reasons.

3

u/sugar_free_haribo Sep 05 '16

They are essentially defaming this guy for attention. It's ridiculous and deserves to be criticized. Something tells me your outlook would be different if you were the one being publicly targeted like this.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Sinistralis Sep 05 '16

I'm with you on this one too. Why does any of this matter? All I care about is how to make apps quicker, more bug free, and more maintainable. I don't care if I am taught this by a white male, an african woman, or a dog with glasses or some other combination of race, gender, or whatever.

I just want a discussion of our craft. What the fuck is going on with people.

3

u/RagingAnemone Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

What's with "Mx. Perch"? What's Mx? If we really want to go after the inconsistencies and the biases of the English language, why don't they present it that way? I would also vote for Ms for everything. Get rid of Mrs. Mx is weird. I hope that's not just a typo :-).

Edit: After Paul Straw's response, I googled it (which I should have started with). Apparently, it's not a marriage neutral honorific for women, but a gender neutral honorific for everybody. TIL.

5

u/paulstraw Sep 04 '16

"Mx" appears to be their preferred honorific, based on their Twitter username, so I used it. I did the same for Mr. Crockford.

1

u/lewisje Sep 05 '16

This is the only other person I know to have used that honorific, and maybe that's what inspired Mx. Perch: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justin_Vivian_Bond

37

u/kowdermesiter Sep 04 '16

Nodevember slack pastebin: http://pastebin.com/3mQc7DfG

Decide for yourself if they just want to build a "safe place" :) Poor guys, they will learn it in the hard way that supporting specific groups does not mean to shut the windows to protect them from the sunlight.

( I actually lost it at the line where someone says that two people's opinion is representative :D )

28

u/Martin_Ehrental Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

[9:56] Nodevember doesn't owe anyone anything

They invited the guy and he accepted.

Even if they feel they had to uninvite him, they should have shown some respect. Uninviting him like that on twitter was really disgusting.

10

u/kowdermesiter Sep 04 '16

Definitely. If someone doesn't want to speak with him on the same day then pick another event to speak and don't agitate the organizers to oust somebody :)

Even inviting a friend over to a house party then later announcing on Facebook that the can't come would be very disgusting, but this Nodevember crew takes this an order of magnitude further.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

I see nothing in this conversation that detracts from their intent to create safe spaces.

I do see someone near the end start acting like an asshole and get removed from the conversation for violating the code of conduct, thereby protecting the safe space of the discussion. That seems perfectly inline with their goals.

13

u/kowdermesiter Sep 04 '16

The whole point is this "safe space" thing. It's unreal, unnecessary and creates a bubble they are fighting against.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/elmigranto Sep 04 '16

Opening a dictionary is at least twice as hard as yelling on twitter.

Promiscuous

  1. …

  2. consisting of parts, elements, or individuals of different kinds brought together without order.

  3. indiscriminate; without discrimination.

  4. casual; irregular; haphazard.

16

u/schm0 Sep 04 '16

Seems to me everyone is acting promiscuous here.

4

u/zumu Sep 04 '16

Promiscuous

The first definition isn't inherently sexual either.

  1. characterized by or involving indiscriminate mingling or association, especially having sexual relations with a number of partners on a casual basis.

I think the sexual connotation of the word has overtaken the actual semantic meaning of the word in recent years. Meanwhile, Crockford is over 60 and might not have the same experience of the word.

Now to digress*, I think an overlooked facet of this conversation, is the implicit ageism. Crockford is of a different generation, and his attitude and choice of words reflect that.

Is age/generation not another type of diversity? Are there any other speakers over 60? 50?

*NOTE: My apologies in advance, as this isn't even relevant to your post. I just couldn't stop myself.

1

u/lewisje Sep 05 '16

I think the sexual connotation of the word has overtaken the actual semantic meaning of the word in recent years.

It's like what happened to "intercourse" a couple generations back; I was surprised to learn in high school that it wasn't just the Latinate term for the sex act (that word is the still-uncommon "coitus" BTW).

→ More replies (1)

3

u/quiI Sep 04 '16

Triggered

116

u/EelingSoGood Sep 04 '16

This article takes and evaluates the claims against crockford at their face value motives to see if there's any merit to them. And that's good. We need articles that do that.

But I also think its important to consider possible ulterior motives that explain how people have continued to glom onto the campaign despite its lack of substance: Crockford is powerful and well-liked and his slight is trivial, and if he can be made an example of over that, doing so sends a powerful message throughout the javascript world: toe the line or you're next.

He's a big fish, so catching him would be a big win for them - whether he deserves it looks to be irrelevant in their minds, his reputation and happiness and possible future contributions to the community looks to be irrelevant in their minds.

30

u/PotaToss Sep 04 '16

I think that might be looking too deep, and it's probably just people being lazy. Paul Straw had to do hours of research to get to the point where he could kind of shrug his shoulders, and that's too much work for slacktivists.

As social animals, it's easier to just take people's words for it when they say they're being victimized or whatever. If you see some guy grabbing a bag from someone and they call him a thief, it's easy to want to slug the guy and consider yourself a hero, but you really have no idea. The person who cried thief could be the actual thief, and now you've got assault charges on some hapless dude.

For my popcorn, I'd love to see some libel suits come out of this nonsense, and some people learning to chill out with their pitchfork trigger words. Context matters. Talking about dog balls awkwardly hanging out in plain view doesn't even have anything to do with gender.

7

u/EelingSoGood Sep 04 '16

I think that's a fair criticism, and I'd definitely agree it probably applies to a lot of the hanger-ons: they don't necessarily have bad intentions, they're just suckered into doing a bad thing.

But by who? If they're not to blame because they are being fooled, then there has to be someone doing the fooling. So I don't think I'm looking too deep, but I do think I should narrow my scope. I would agree that it is a bad-apples-rotting-good-ones situation, but there are bad apples.

And, given how often these mountain-out-of-molehills "scandals" come up in tech, there are plenty of them.

3

u/PotaToss Sep 04 '16

I also don't know if there's any kind of intentional fooling going on. Seems like it started with some people having kneejerk reactions to some trigger words that came out of his mouth, while they ignored context, and then that just snowballed when people hopped on without knowing what the actual situation was.

It's like parsing HTML with regular expressions. You probably mean well, but you're doing more harm than good by not being context-sensitive.

11

u/EelingSoGood Sep 04 '16

Having a kneejerk reaction could be unintentional. Persisting in your calls for someone to be pushed out from conferences, even after you know the full context of their remarks, is definitely intentional.

That is what the people still leading the charge against Crockford are doing. This wasn't a case of someone accidentally starting a fire that is now out of their control to stop. This was a case of people calling for, and persisting in that call for, Crockford to be tarred and feathered based on at first a few poor wording choices, a speaker projecting hostility into Crockford's opinion on a conference, and now that those have been examined and disregarded they and the conference organizers are telling us Crockford should be excommunicated for what is effectively hearsay.

6

u/PotaToss Sep 04 '16

I mean, some of the linked stuff was oversensitive people being genuinely offended, thinking people were being slut shamed, because he said a word that was 100% sensible in context. They see a pattern of bad behavior by Crockford, which might really be a pattern of ignoring context by a community, but it makes it that much easier for them to believe next time they hear he said something terrible.

But, again, being social animals, once you've rallied support, even if you look back and are like, "Oh, I guess I overreacted," it's really hard to take it back because you make your supporters look foolish as well.

Once you get people excited and call for someone else to be tarred and feathered, admitting your fault is asking to be tarred and feathered yourself.

And once you have support, you're also just not that likely to think you overreacted. You've been validated.

I hate all of this, but I don't think it's like some insidious plot to take Crockford down for their personal status gain.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/lbrtrl Sep 04 '16

The word "witch-hunt" is thrown around a lot, but I think it applies here. Instead of property though, people are after influence.

→ More replies (6)

29

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16 edited Feb 17 '17

fmkn+>e&R*b xP.qc5(kt]XsPGM1!CevQ5Ss inzoTr#lB1wTtUmhUOb$8;v+OrTDp3SBsd9DT>6n1,OS8th+ogVo62

11

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

Now if you're so sensitive that you become uncomfortable when someone calls your idea stupid, boy is life going to be rough for you.

It makes an impression on me that a lot of those folks who are very sensitive are transgender. It's understandable they've been through a lot in their life, but there's a line they tend to cross where they see attackers everywhere.

Those are usually good, dedicated specialists, but with paranoid opinions like these, they essentially select themselves out of the community one way or another. Either they refuse to speak, because they find almost anybody offensive, or they manage to exclude most everyone else so they find themselves speaking at niche events that most host other people like them, who are mostly pre-occupied with discussing "social issues", no matter what the event is actually about.

It's sad either way. There's simply no correct solution here. I actually think the stress they've been through has brought them to a point where they should seek professional help in order to not see the world through such distorted lenses.

17

u/doobyrocks Sep 04 '16

Your first mistake is applying logic here.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16 edited Feb 17 '17

503VN(2%E9d 3n7S5El5Lm:Ww$5M,hIclDb7 4H<QhNyHEbW106KP[uniFRWl1uX4sZ1B9bn&$5quRn,R!U(1Vyf.+.M

5

u/SuperFLEB Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

to what extent are we willing to go to make sure everyone is comfortable?

The problem as I see it is that there seems to be far too much stock paid (among certain circles and mindsets) to the idea that any pain or discomfort whatsoever is inherently a bad thing, that all manner of mountains should moved whenever anyone expresses pain or discomfort, and any damage done or cost borne in doing so is acceptable, as it's done in the service of a noble cause.

However, by the very nature of the fact that there are more than one person on this earth, one person's comfort is liable to infringe on another person's no matter what side of a decision is chosen. So choices must be made.

The problem is that these choices are being guided by broad and inflexible principles that don't seek to solve problems through compromise or minimal disappointment. Instead, they favor decisive, total, and often visible action, led by categorization, prioritization, and simplistic rules, which is rarely the proper solution to anything but the most egregious behavior.

Without nuance or flexibility, you're pretty much left with few options, all based on prioritization: Prioritize an "in crowd", prioritize the freedom of the offender, or prioritize the comfort of the offendee. The first of these is right out, the second risks devolution into the sort of anti-professional free-for-all that legitimately excludes anyone with sensibilities, and the third is what we have here, a situation where the first, loudest, or most saintly wheel to squeak gets mountains moved into whatever configuration they wish, while others who can manage to hold back their tears over trivialities continue to do so while having their experience chipped away.

And decrying the third option may sound callous on its face-- surely those who can manage to hold back their tears can continue to do so, so that none need suffer! But tears are not necessarily indicative of pain, pain is not necessarily indicative of damage, and damage is not necessarily indicative of harm. When a person cries out at monsters, the first response should be to check for harmless shadows, not to immediately smash what turns out to be a coat rack.

And if there is a seed of negativity there, the whole forest need not be levelled in response. They could have just as easily said, "We've had concerns with your topics of [...] and [...], and being as we wish to retain the utmost professionalism, we'd ask that you refrain from such topics or approaches in your talk.", tell the offendee it's been dealt with, and let them stay or go as they wish.

→ More replies (1)

63

u/benihana react, node Sep 04 '16

People (especially those who grew up in different times), often don’t think about these problems in the same way younger folks do.

this is what it seems like to me. A bunch of young, immature people are upset that the world isn't the way they expected it would be and this is their attempt at coping with it. they disguise it like they're committing some act of justice, but it's all just about stroking their own egos, trying to convince themselves they have some kind of control over things.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Could the cause be that these are the kids that grew up in the generation of "Everyone is a winner!" and "there are no losers!" ? They are so used to have nothing about themselves questioned, so when someone says something that they where taught is bad, their social programming causes them to cry out against it? Anyone not following the "norm" will be shammed back in line or be expelled from society?

29

u/dodeca_negative Sep 04 '16

It wasn't millennials who decided that everyone gets a trophy. It was their parents and grandparents. The kids were not fooled.

33

u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

Whatever your take is on the "everyone gets a trophy" angle I don't think this is the same thing.

"Pointing out social injustice" has been something that has been put up on a pedestal in the last decades (rightfully so). So .. if you engage in it, you present yourself as "morally elevated". You are "advanced". You are always "on the right side". You don't even need to think about it.

Just point out something that could make someone else feel bad. How could that possibly not be a good thing? How could you possibly not be a noble person for doing that? (Regardless of the fact that you might have stolen money out of grandma's wallet last week.)

So .. for people who don't really have anything else that they can hook their identity on, they can just jump on that "social justice" boat. They can put themselves in the same lineage as Ghandi and MLK.

They are not just some "nobody". They are a champion. The world is better because they exist. And you .. if you don't agree with them and think like them .. are part of what makes the world bad. Obviously.

And it's kind of an untouchable position, they way they have it set up. After all .. nobody can ever be "standing up too much for the little guy", right? Nobody can ever be "too much on the side of the underdog". You can never be accused of "wanting fairness too much".

And sure there is an element of bullying in it. And that's exactly what draws some people to it. Because these are, you know, not the kind of people who normally get to feel what it is like to be "over" someone else. They don't normally get to feel "powerful".

But here is a weapon they now have that can hurt people. They can get other people in trouble. They can turn other people into "outcasts". Now they can feel what it is like to be powerful.

8

u/dodeca_negative Sep 04 '16

No, I think you're spot on here. From the outside looking in, I'm aware of at least some people involved in social justice who've argued against the name and shame, let's get people fired extremism, and found that they could do nothing but just walk away. Righteousness is always armor against criticism, but it has a particularly effective Teflon coating for some social justice people.

3

u/RiskyShift Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

And sure there is an element of bullying in it. And that's exactly what draws some people to it. Because these are, you know, not the kind of people who normally get to feel what it is like to be "over" someone else. They don't normally get to feel "powerful".

But here is a weapon they now have that can hurt people. They can get other people in trouble. They can turn other people into "outcasts". Now they can feel what it is like to be powerful.

Jon Ronson writes about this in his great book, So You've Been Publicly Shamed.

He writes how it felt great to "take down" transgressors on social media, before he realized they weren't just the little people punching up at the powerful anymore, but they were an internet mob attacking largely powerless individuals for minor transgressions.

It's a great book and it was very cathartic for me personally after my ex whipped up an angry mob against me on Tumblr for breaking up with her (she was very active and had a lot of followers) by turning it into a racial thing because I'm a white man and she was Latina woman.

It's crazy that you can convince random people on the internet to harass someone they have never met - trying to get someone fired or sending them death threats - but it happened to me. That's the power of mob mentality. The fact they wrap themselves in the flag of a righteous cause makes it hard to criticize, because you will often be labelled a bigot or apologist if you come out against their tactics.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

My favorite version is using the phrase "being on the right side of history." Um, isn't it always premature to declare yourself on the right side of something that can only be determined with many years of hindsight?

→ More replies (3)

-1

u/postmodest Sep 04 '16

But every generation try to change the world. Without this, we'd still be chemically castrating gay men and beating up women who wear pants.

Having said that, I will cede that when young people reach maturity in an age of increased competition for resources, you get things like ISIS and the IRA, and these days the competition for mindshare among the New Media leads to the shrillest voices being the only ones heard clearly over the din.

...But, to be frank, Crockford's a pretty shrill voice himself. Has he contributed? Yes, we've got JSON, thanks. Does JSON have comments? No. Well, fuck you, Crockford.

Again, I'm a bit surprised that suddenly everyone's pro-Crockford when before these tweets, they were sick of Crockford's orthodoxies. Add to that reddit's general whiff of sexism (/r/all clearly shows the gender bias in reddit's userbase), and I'm more sympathetic to nodevember's organizers. Do I agree with them? ...no? But then perhaps my opinion of The Node Ecosystem colors my view, as someone a whole generation older than the people organizing it, that Node and NPM really show how [to set the wayback machine to 1997] ESR's "Bazaar" gets blown away in the storm, while the planned-economy Cathedral stands. I think they're all nuts, but I also think the nodevember folk have a right to decide what that means to them.

19

u/Shaper_pmp Sep 04 '16

I'm a bit surprised that suddenly everyone's pro-Crockford when before these tweets, they were sick of Crockford's orthodoxies.

I can disapprove of someone because he's an over-opinionated curmudgeon, but I'll defend him to the death against someone who wants to hang him out to dry and make him a pariah in his own industry for not being quite kind and patient enough for their personal preferences, let alone on entirely trumped-up charges.

3

u/RiskyShift Sep 05 '16

I don't particularly like Crockford, but I hate public shaming with a passion. They could have just said that Crockford would no longer be speaking at the conference, they didn't have to include an attack on his character in the announcement.

→ More replies (6)

103

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

I joined twitter about two years ago hoping to gain access to new programming ideas and trends.

I left twitter last month because what I found was witch hunts and cyber bullying.

Today, even after deleting my Twitter account I find myself annoyed by the silly ongoings of people on there.

Crockford is simply a victim of a self righteous social justice movement. Whether he did something to wrong someone or not, it is now irrelevant. It is irrelevant because an attempt was made to dehumanise and silence him, and that is wrong.

40

u/munificent Sep 04 '16

Twitter isn't a single place, it's just a tool for managing a list of followers. Your specific set of followers entirely determines what your Twitter experience is like. If you're not having a good one, it just means you should try to find different people to follow.

(Personally, I follow lots of pixel artists and programming language nerds, and Twitter is pretty delightful for me.)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Nasa, SpaceX and ULC always have great content. I was getting daily photographs from the space-station taken by one of the astronauts a couple of years back (and still get some from NASA directly).

11

u/JeefyPants Sep 04 '16

I don't have a Twitter account and I see tons of garbage from it by following Reddit links

15

u/munificent Sep 04 '16

Well sure. People only link to tweets that are newsworthy. In other words, drama. By that same token, according to local news, every road is a deathtrap filled with nonstop car accidents, every trial a miscarriage of justice, every celebrity and politician a criminal, etc.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

This is true. I just had to cleanse my account. I now only follow people I find either funny or insightful. Any bad vibes or drama is an unfollow.

2

u/dodeca_negative Sep 04 '16

Yep. Mute is also a great tool.

4

u/SustainedSuspense Sep 04 '16

Different platforms enable different types of discussions. Twitter by design does not foster intelligent debates but encourages singular and often sensational, provocative statements.

3

u/Shaper_pmp Sep 05 '16

Twitter isn't a single place, it's just a tool for managing a list of followers.

It's also a way to have your every utterance indexed for the rest of time, to be queried, dug up, taken out of context, re-presented and used to have you randomly lynched and your life dismantled at any point in the future. And not even by someone you've necessarily pissed off - it can just be a single bored dipshit and their followers who want to make themselves feel important.

I really can't fault anyone for bailing out of Twitter - frankly it's terrifying these days.

1

u/Spoor Sep 05 '16

Until the day one of your pixel artists paints a pixel the wrong color, and mobs of sociopaths try to ruin your life because you're following that person and are therefore worse than Hitler.

4

u/patrickfatrick Sep 04 '16

I wouldn’t conflate the technology with the people who use the technology. Twitter is just a platform, your problem is with the people you see on Twitter. It’s easy to have a great time with Twitter, but like there is inane drama in real life so too there is inane drama on Twitter, constantly.

76

u/epiris Sep 04 '16

I am speechless with how absurd this is. From what I see a single woman named Emily Rose[1] was able to have someone excluded from the event.. in the name of inclusion and diversity[2]. There was no concrete evidence just a woman who's upset and clearly has an extremely militant set of beliefs. She makes post after post about "cis males".. and how entitled they are. How they oppress her and make her upset. I didn't even know what a cis male was until I googled it and it's simply another term for a man.. who identifies as a man. Have a look at her tweets.

That's not a coincidence. It's rainbow-flavored oppression. They don't accept us. They want us to assimilate. That is what they're saying.

"I'm quite livid at the sheer audacity of @MarkRuffalo and @MattBomer. I'm tired of the intellectual dishonesty of cis men. Disgusting."

Without fail, every time I talk about my experiences as a trans person interacting with cisfolk: "Oh, that totally happens to us too!"

The impression I get is that cisfolk are desperate to invalidate the experiences I share as someone who remembers what it was like before.

Her tweets seem much more hostile than a comment from Crawford about dog balls, don't they?

Finally:

The reaction that we're seeing to the Nodevember Un-Invitation Incident™ is one born of fear for repercussions of toxic behavior. Full stop.

Man- what about his behavior is so toxic? Of everyone she could be angry about.. all the people on earth who openly express contempt for transgender people.. Douglas Crawford? I've only seen one person with toxicity here and that is Emily Rose. I'm not attempting to "shame her" and I would fight to my last breath for her rights the same as anyone else's if it came down to it. I get why she is hurting and I know a lot of the society isn't doing well at accepting transgender people. But attacking those who have not condemned her seems so counter productive to her cause. Attacking anyone.. even if Douglas Crawford claimed he is a devout Christian and believes all Transgender people are going to hell.. he has a right to those beliefs. If you believe in something and your aim is to change the position of others.. do not be militant. Be understanding and attempt to analyze the reasons they have their positions. Attack the roots of the things you believe to cause the behavior.. not individuals.

I think "We will militantly enforce equality!" to me is a paradox. When it serves as central guidance to your behavior you quickly lose sight of the condition you intended to improve. If you want equality, stop talking so much about it. Let people know privately when their behavior is inappropriate beyond your personal subjective ideology. You won't sway someones behavior through shaming them, just reinforce that your position is foreign and hostile to them.

Just chill out, man.. I mean men, women, men who identify as woman, women who identify as men, those whom have ephemeral shifts of sexual identity, those whom have change their identity in the past and resumed their original identity and of course my sincere apologies if I left out anyone making me a hateful asshole.

[1] https://twitter.com/nexxylove [2] https://twitter.com/nexxylove/status/771503406716334080

37

u/Otroletravaladna Sep 04 '16

I'm sick and tired of this recent uprise of hypersensitive, self-righteous SJWs who see offence, bigotry and sexism everywhere, then proceed to throw tantrums on social media, looking for uproar, praise and approval, when most of the times others end up obliging to their "demands" for fear of being called offensive, bigots or sexists themselves.

I'm all-in for diversity and inclusion, but these two ladies' actions and demands do a very weak favour to the cause they are supposedly standing for.

It's like this idiotic vocal-fry girl who was made famous last week for shaming a Lyft driver (while filming it) for having a Hawaiian bobble-head in his dashboard: It just reeks of attention-whoring and self-righteousness.

15

u/epiris Sep 04 '16

Dude.. what. in. the. actual. fuck. I googled that bobble head situation after I read your comment. Cringe as fuck.. people drawn to this type of behavior have deep rooted psychological problems and need to seek professional help. She would have found just about anything he said or did to take a position against him before the end of that ride. She is not a feminist nor interested in equality.. just wields it as a tool to victimize herself to be more comfortable in her misery. Sickening.

If she was offended and had the intent to change his position on the matter of "Bobble Head's".. what good would such an approach do? You don't change someones position with an onslaught of negative stimulation. Calling them names, attempting to shame them.. so ignorant.

If something bothers you in this world and you want to make a difference than do that, but this "SJW" shit, fuck the crap out of you.. go get help. Medical help. You are not a victim, you just lack depth. You have deep rooted issues and you are a cancer to society. Period.

2

u/mureni Sep 05 '16

It's a national pandemic that's getting fueled on both sides by the political scene (which should not be ignored this time, btw, but carefully watched, neutrally minded, until Nov 8th). I think there's something much deeper causing this behavior but I can't quite decide if it's a backlash at their prosperous parents or an institutional sinister doublethink indoctrination. Either way, it's deeply concerning for our future when 99.6% of the country is bullied by the 0.4% of otherkin.

When it gets down to the level of COMPUTER PROGRAMMING, an area usually so far removed from this bullshit by its very nature, well... time to pay attention to why.

I personally don't think it's because of oppression, but I'm open to debate.

5

u/flying-sheep Sep 05 '16

Emily rose doesn't even hide it:

[A community, just like a garden, needs] soil, adequate water, correct amounts of sunlight, and—not least of all—proper pruning

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

[deleted]

1

u/epiris Sep 05 '16

Absolutely! Just to make sure, you are referring to a transgender attacking a "cis male" and not something I said in this post right? Cause FYI just in case anything came across that way because it wasn't my intent.

15

u/nodevember Sep 05 '16

From the mouth of @nexxylove:

mx emily a rose ‏@nexxylove Sep 1 A JavaScript conference with all-male keynotes at private Christian university. What a stellar show of inclusivity.

mx emily a rose ‏@nexxylove Sep 1 If you value a community where diversity and inclusivity are top priorities, please boycott @nodevember. This is unacceptable.

mx emily a rose ‏@nexxylove Sep 1 I'd like to hear a statement from @egdelwonk, @jasonamyers, and @kevinold on concrete steps they plan to take to make their event inclusive.

This is immediately followed by the response that they would be kick Crockford to the curb. Incredible cave.

11

u/_HlTLER_ Stackoverflow searcher Sep 04 '16

I don't understand why Nodevember even had to disclose why they removed Crockford. Just say he won't be speaking and leave it at that. I worked at the Hollywood Bowl for a summer and one of the artists set to perform was too paranoid to perform after dropping some acid. We just said that the person was unable to make it and moved on. No need to air private shit in public.

9

u/nerdy_glasses Sep 04 '16

I would so love to see a tripping Crockford give a talk about JavaScript.

5

u/SuperFLEB Sep 05 '16

It's a single annual event, he's a keynote, and he's a pretty big name. It'd leave a significant hole full of rumor if they just edited him out of the program. Hell, look at the amount of rumor flying around from their inadequate explanation.

3

u/rabinito Sep 04 '16

That moment when even HITLER makes more sense than your childish approach to the world.

22

u/internet_badass_here Sep 04 '16

Really it's the SJW's that are being sexist and "slut-shaming" by arguing that promiscuity has negative connotations. If promiscuity is okay then there should be no problem using it in a talk.

20

u/joequin Sep 04 '16

He wasn't even using it negatively in the the context of tech. He wasn't saying that promiscuity was bad. He outlined a lot of its positives as well as it's security concerns. The whole thing just shows how stupid people are. They don't even understand context, just keywords. Or they're liars. I don't know which it is.

5

u/notTheAggressorHere Sep 04 '16

This is why I find the term "slut-shaming" so confusing. Shouldn't the term actually be "woman-shaming"? I mean, the term "slut" is pretty unambiguous. The intent of using the term "slut" is to denigrate someone who is promiscuous (strictly speaking in a sexual context here). If it's decided that promiscuity is OK, then drop the word "slut" altogether. Or, is this one of those "we're going to take the word back so we can feel more empowered" things?

I also find it hard to take "slut-walks" seriously either. I mean, using professional language as apposed to unsavory colloquialisms will go a lot further towards winning people over to your cause.

7

u/SuperFLEB Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

Or, is this one of those "we're going to take the word back so we can feel more empowered" things?

In one sense. In another (IMHO), it's using "slut shaming" as a single pejorative term, and "slut" is a part of the pejorative, not the subject. If you hyphenate "slut" into the act being described, the term could just as well mean "shaming [a promiscuous person] by calling them a slut", instead of "shaming [someone who is] a slut".

It's similar to "witch-hunting" (in the metaphorical sense). Decrying "witch-hunting" is not decrying hunting people who are admittedly witches, it's decrying both the act of branding and hunting, as they are done in tandem. "Slut shaming" can refer to both the shaming and the branding, as they are tightly related.

OTOH, "slut walk", I don't see how that can be anything other than counter-appropriation.

3

u/internet_badass_here Sep 05 '16

I guess a "promiscuity walk" would have too much negative connotation.

10

u/original_evanator Sep 04 '16

If I were Crockford I would put together a last-minute anticonference at the same time and near the same place as nodevember.

I bet it would be well attended.

21

u/toiletjs Sep 04 '16

We'll call it... Crocktober.

3

u/ataraxy Sep 05 '16

Rock out with your crock out...wait a minute...

3

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

It would probably be crashed by hypersensitive "SJWs" (Social Justice Warriors).. We'd need to screen them somehow. Like maybe say "Dog balls" at the gate and see how they respond..

5

u/jpflathead Sep 04 '16

Yikes! I hadn't realized svtble and their idiot kudos system was still around. Assumed it had died the ignominious death it deserved.

19

u/brockisawesome Sep 04 '16

This is absolutely ridiculous, thank god i'm not part of this bullshit SJW generation.

16

u/Throwaway_bicycling Sep 04 '16

But neither is Crockford.

5

u/its_never_lupus Sep 04 '16

Sadly they can't always just be ignored.

18

u/againstmethod Sep 04 '16

I have little time or money to attend such events, and I'm certainly not going to invest those resources in supporting such arbitrary nonsense.

Call me when you get serious, nodevember.

25

u/markdesign Sep 04 '16

Triggered SJW's strike again. Really sad to see nodevember bullied into submission.

Reminds me of Brendan Eich fired as CEO of Firefox. Extremist really love censorship at any cost if it goes against their ideology.

9

u/cacahootie Sep 04 '16

The case of Brendan Eich and Crockford are not comparable. Speaking at a conference for an hour and representing and leading an organization for years are clearly not in the same league of consideration.

25

u/Lhaer Sep 04 '16

What is Nodevember anyways? Bunch of mediocre SJWs, they'll never get to the level of Crockford

→ More replies (6)

17

u/parker_fly Sep 04 '16

This is why adults hate working with millenials.

17

u/jtredact Sep 04 '16

Can confirm. I'm an adult and a millenial and I hate working with myself.

1

u/ccricers Sep 05 '16

lol I get the idea of what you're saying. I'm born in the early 80s and feel like at the cusp between two different generations.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16

Same here, they call us millennials, but we are not, not really. We are a transition generation of about.... 80 to .... 85 / 86. Most of us where brought up and attended school without a lot of computers and tech, only seeing it enter the school system in high school. I classify millennials as the group of people who grew up online, connected when they started school. We might have had cell phones in middle school, but txt messages where too expensive to actually be used as a valid chat system.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

Millennial here. My classmates, my ex-coworkers, my current coworkers, most of them millennials, could not give a bigger shit about this SJW bullshit. The few I've met who do, would never bring this shit to the workplace, and would certainly never politicize a tech we use every day.

But yeah, it sucks that a lot of this crazy SWJs happen to be millennial. I don't want to be identified with some idiot who creates pull requests because some variable names are gendered or whatever the fuck.

4

u/kilroy123 Sep 04 '16

Hey there are many of us who aren't into all this BS. We just want to go to work, do our job the best we can, and go home.

28

u/ghostfacedcoder Sep 04 '16

I'm a "social justice warrior": I do not believe we live in an equal society, and I believe we should do more to fix that.

I also can't stand Crockford.: that man presents his opinions as facts and has set back the Javascript community time and time again (he's the reason we can't have comments in a package.json file, the reason JSLint convinced millions of developers to adopt anti-patterns, the reason YUI looked more like Java than Javascript, etc.)

... but all that being said, even though I believe he's the bane of all that is good in the JS community, I'm with Crockford on this one.

19

u/adipisicing Sep 04 '16

Your point is well-made but

he's the reason we can't have comments in a package.json file

stuck out because he's the reason we have JSON in the first place too. It seems like a net benefit even if I disagree with the removal of comments.

It's kind of like how I'm disappointed with John Gruber for refusing to accept a formal Markdown standard, but I still appreciate more that he created Markdown.

2

u/Throwaway_bicycling Sep 04 '16

My "huh?" moment here was not the refusal to have a standard, but the refusal plus the irritation that other people are doing it wrong. But it's a really mild "huh?".

2

u/adipisicing Sep 04 '16

Right, that was what I meant by "accept". It's slightly more than irritation for me, because the inevitable result is fragmentation.

2

u/sugar_free_haribo Sep 05 '16

even though I believe he's the bane of all that is good in the JS community

That's a ridiculous position. All those things you listed that are bad are what got JS moving in a better direction, even if they weren't perfect.

3

u/KhalilRavanna Sep 04 '16

Sounds like you're not a SJW at all but just a reasonable person with differing opinions-- which so far from my experience is the antithesis to the SJW's ethos

4

u/flying-sheep Sep 04 '16

He/she meant in the literal/original sense: somebody who is willing to fight for social justice.

SJW has mutated to mean “somebody who whines about irrelevant shit and uses it to bully others”. Make up many arbitrary rules, know them better than others, and you can get away with anything

7

u/SuperFLEB Sep 05 '16

I'd always understood the inclusion of "warrior" to imply an over-the-top, thoughtless attitude more interested in the fighting than the things being fought for, that would sacrifice the cause to win the fight.

Was there an earlier use of the term without that sarcastic/pejorative use?

3

u/flying-sheep Sep 05 '16

I think so, but I'm not sure

3

u/mollydotcom Sep 07 '16 edited Sep 08 '16

Having worked as both a speaker and organizer of conferences and events in Web technologies since 1997, I have had almost two decades of observing and working to diversify not only events but our industry at large. In that time I had opportunity to interact with Douglas Crockford on more occasions than I can remember.

What I do remember clearly is how much Douglas Crockford impressed me with his work on JSON, his well-known talk(s) on "Quality" and innumerable positive actions to the Javascript language and its varied communities.

Did I ever feel him to give off odd vibes? Without question. But not in any way that was negative or threatening. Socially different. Awkward, fish out of water, as if he were uncomfortable in his own skin. As this is not atypical in our industry, I chalked it up to social awkwardness all around.

Stepping back to examine the panoramic view of that near 20 years of observation, what I see and the conclusion I've arrived at is that Douglas Crockford is an extremely diverse human being.

Specifically? Neurodiverse. Anyone who absorbs and processes information at high speeds (and almost everyone reading this likely falls into this category) is bound to have some form of what we're now calling "spectrum disorders." Personally, I don't think they are disorders, preferring the term "difference."

Diversity means variety. More plainly? Difference!

Did someone break the law? If so, we must report the crime or we leave others vulnerable. If no law was broken and we are just of a different opinion, how about we use the power of choice and not attend the conference? Even better, we can choose cooperative behavior by not attending that talk or ensuring we are with other companions at social gatherings, leaving others who do not feel the same discomfort to gain from the experience.

Open web is Open. Backchanneling is bullshit. Covert operations are an especially heinous form of social engineering in an environment where cooperation and communication are key factors. Let's not make the mistake of thinking the Web is not a social creation. We need only refer to its inventor Tim Berners-Lee for the precise truth about the core ideals of the web. Given that, we have as much responsibility to ensure our society is celebrated and not degraded as well as keeping our technology pursuits to a standard of quality.

Let's ask ourselves again: WHAT IS DIVERSITY?

Variety. Difference.

The world is an uncomfortable place. It behooves all humanity to learn to deal with that discomfort more effectively than resorting to our childhood temper tantrums. Let's lift it up a bit - be better than our last stable build and realize that diversity includes the people who might be our polar opposites in the way he, she, they, it, etc. approach the world.

My personal beliefs conflict with Brendan Eich's but does that for a moment make me not capable of accepting that his work has changed the very course of my career? Douglas Crockford is the same for me.

Not everyone is going to come in the color, shape, gender, size, religion, clothes, fashion, approach or what have you that is going to please us all of the time. It's a mathematical improbability that one person will ever please all people.

Let's learn how to receive information and learning that is incredibly valuable from a world of differences, many which will make us uncomfortable.

Let's take that gift and not bite the hand who gives it. If we want to change the world, we can do that too - and the path to that isn't by committing an act of attempted professional homicide. Quite the opposite.

Diversity means difference. Check ourselves, please. These ridiculous controversies are points of FAIL and we don't need them, they get in the way of efficiency and quality.

Broken laws go to the authorities. Social behavior is OURS to manage. So let's manage ours more kindly, please?

Molly

Molly E. Holzschlag

author * speaker * webdev

Developer Relations, Vivaldi Browser

With a sincere thank you to Paul Straw for the informative article.

10

u/max_renlo Sep 04 '16

SJWs have infiltrated the JS community and have for some while. It reminds me of the irc #javascript channel on freenode.net where saying 'hey guys' to the room is forbidden because it's not 'gender inclusive'. Instead you must use the greeting of 'Hello women, men, transgendered and non-gendered people (or entities)' /s.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Jesus, every time I pop into #rubyonrails there is a fight about someone who said "hey guys" or "thanks guys", ending in some poor coder being ganged up against until they fade away in forced apology, probably never to return.

My wife calls her friends "guys" all the time (could be a Hawaiian thing), and if you suggested she wasn't for gender rights or feminism she'd slap you into next week. Then again, she's not a Millennial...

1

u/rocketpastsix Sep 05 '16

Slack does the stupid fucking hand thing when you say guys. So stupid

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ccricers Sep 05 '16

In programmer's terms, SJW's like to make unnecessary optimizations for extreme edge cases.

11

u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16

Many of the greatest thinkers in history have been really unpleasant people personally and have held all kinds of strange ideas and prejudices. (Though I don't think Crockford comes even remotely close to that.)

But imagine if they had all been "shouted down"?

6

u/Tiquortoo Sep 04 '16

It takes personal time and resources to do anything. Figuring out the social aspects of language to appeal to modern sensibilities is more taxing on that personal time than it has ever been before. The current climate will make the very bright reluctant to participate in public because they will almost always lag behind the popular/populist mindset.

4

u/ClockCat Sep 04 '16

Who would want to risk everything just to share with the community?

There is no small chilling effect here.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

He isn't even unpleasant. I watched the videos that they seem to be complaining about.

7

u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16

I know right? Of all the people! The whole thing does seem very witch-hunty.

And it's not even like they said "Hey you were using some language that maybe is a little problematic. You should watch out for that." They just went right for the jugular. Scary.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

There is nothing Crockford can say that would diminish my desire to hear his honest thoughts about javascript and its upcoming features. I feel the same way about Brendan Eich. I wish we lived in a world where people didn't cater so much to the easily offended. I'm glad when easily offended people don't get their way. I like "people who don't offend", but I like "people who do offend" more than I like "the easily offended".

6

u/apiBACKSLASH Sep 04 '16

This is an outrage!

Crockford should take JavaScript back from the community!

17

u/j1330 Sep 04 '16

Crockford should just record an hour video and put it on youtube and i'd take that over the entire conference.

4

u/SuperFLEB Sep 05 '16

How about kind of an MST3K thing? Sync up a stream of him commenting on the conference realtime.

5

u/sittytucker Sep 05 '16

I find this extremism in sjw culture to be very unsettling, really scares the hell out of me. To scared to even type this comment for being labeled as insensitive non-inclusion guy.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '16

A few years ago I wondered why being a believer of social justice was cause for ridicule. Turns out I just had to look at my current programming language and version control system of choice to learn why.

A supposedly legitimate professional conference kowtowed to baseless claims that a speaker makes "several people uncomfortable".

GitHub's "code of conduct" literally says any hate speech against cisgendered people, white people or men does not break the code. I see this sort of lexicon in no other profession except software development.

People aren't paying to go to a conference for diversity. People aren't paying to see lesser speakers give talks because another more accomplished speaker made a joke about dog testicles. People don't care that Crockford used the word "promiscuity" to describe the connectivity of the web. It looks like Nodevember is figuring that out.

4

u/ChutneyRiggins Sep 04 '16

Can't we just try to get some work done? If you have the opportunity to mentor a programmer from a non-typical demographic, do it.

4

u/monsto Sep 05 '16

You people don't understand. Node/js is all about the cool kids.

I've dabbled in php, python, js. with php/python, principly, dev is done on mostly linux, some windows, and i've heard, rarely, of mac usage. people realize that, and I've experienced some ancillary conversation, but it's always about the comfort, what tools you like, how productive you think you are... and then you move on.

JS is the ONLY environment where I've experienced where people seem to have some sort of full on derision for anyone not using a Mac. "nobody uses pc/windows to dev anymore, everyone uses macs now" which is absolutely NOT the case. Where guys with their $1500 mac laptop sit in coffee shops in their little sisters jeans and beanie just to drink lemon water.

If you're not using a mac; if you're not worried about inclusion, even at the ironic expense of excluding people; if you're not rabid in your defense of pushing out a founder of an era because he's old and not a cool kid...

... then you don't matter, your opinion doesn't matter, and you can have your money back and just stay home. Because we don't want you here.

Has anyone in the reddit js/programming circles tried to organize a conference? I'll help.

2

u/falcon_jab Sep 05 '16

Can we organise a conference for people who develop solely on dusty old PCs they've cobbled together over the years?

Or would it get hounded into non-existence for not being inclusive?

2

u/sittytucker Sep 05 '16

or maybe we shouldn't care about such petty things. I use Mac for Dev, but I can totally relate to windows or Linux developer. I use windows too once in a while, as well as Linux.

2

u/MrBester Sep 05 '16

I've never developed using a Mac and I've been doing this shit for 20 years. And yes, I started with a PC I built myself.

1

u/ccricers Sep 05 '16

I consider myself a OS agnostic developer. Most of the time I use a Mac for production development, and I learned on a WAMP stack, but I'm comfortable in the three major operating systems. I'm not saying I'm an expert sysadmin, but I can set up a server stack of my preference with relative ease in any of the three.

But I'm trying to figure out where you're seeing this kind of inclusive culture. As an outsider seeing in, I don't have the money to afford going to these big conferences, and neither do the employers, so maybe I'm not getting where the elitist culture is coming from.

Maybe it's a geographical thing, that mostly happens in Silicon Valley, and I don't even feel much of a tech scene presence in Chicago.

5

u/enry_straker Sep 04 '16

The whole thing is, IMHO, much ado about nothing.

3

u/magnetik79 Sep 04 '16

Not handled well at all.

I've seen Crockford speak in person and watched many videos featuring his talks over the years.

I'm really only interested in his technical merits and in this area he shines with some great insight and knowledge.

Outside of that I don't really care/know how he conducts himself and can filter out the rest from my mind. So for me this is really a storm in a teacup.

4

u/hsfrey Sep 04 '16

Stupid illiterate people don't understand that 'promiscuity' is not gendered. It can be, and often is, used in reference to men.

Though it is usually used in a sexual context, it often is used to refer to any sort of indiscriminate association.

It is only through extensive reading that people become familiar with the full range of use and meaning of words.

The illiterates must not be allowed to use their ignorance to suppress full use of the language.

3

u/Tychonaut Sep 04 '16

I was just in an argument with someone who said black people can't be racist against whites because racism is the systematic cultural suppression of another race. So white people can be racist, but black people can't be. And I understand the point she was making and sure there is something to it .. but that "something" is not contained in the definition of the word "racist".

It would mean that if a black guy and a native indian guy both stood together and both said "black people are stupid and smell funny" the white guy would be being a racist, but the native guy would be being something else, since natives aren't part of the "system" that disadvantages blacks.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Neker Sep 05 '16

OK, people, it's time to abandon the IP protocol, which is promiscuous, and also version control, which want us to commit, as do all the the RDBMS in existence that carry on the trait that their forefathers the transactional monitors of yore exhibited shamelessly. Let's renounce all cables and their gendered connectors.

Don't get me started on electricity, so polarizing with its "positivity" and "negativity", and the binary numeration system.

Thinking of it, I think I'll leave programming behind as well as all things related to computers and industry and retire on a remote, unpopulated island. I shall take wows of silence, as it is the only way to remain unaffected by the trickeries of human language. While I'm there, I shall as well refrain from thinking altogether and indeed from any cerebral activity, and dedicate the remaining of my life to becoming a mindless, selfless vegetable. Doing so, I might not contribute much to the progress of humanity, but I am assured not to hurt anyone's feeling.

2

u/roselan Sep 05 '16

I can't decide if this is a publicity stunt from nodevember (nobody was coming and they needed a scapegoat, plus they don't have to pay him that way) or they are simply re-enacting their daddy issues...

2

u/z0ne66 Sep 05 '16

Not surprised something so stupid has been allowed to happen. Far too many neutron star clenching ultra liberal lefties...

1

u/md2074 Sep 05 '16

People need to get over themselves..

-15

u/Jafit Sep 04 '16

Combing over what people say, judging them by your own (frankly bizzare) set of standards, and acting as some kind of authority on what is and is not appropriate and acceptable, and even funny.

I find that completely unacceptable and offensive, and now I demand attention and sympathy for being exposed to something that I don't like, and I demand that you be subjected to a witchhunt for having offended me, and your career should be destroyed.

Was this an appropriate “joke” to make in a conference talk? Certainly not. Was it even a funny joke? Literally zero percent funny. Was it exclusionary? Yup.

I'm sure glad we have people like you to tell us what is and isn't appropriate and funny. I sure look forward to the future where nobody can say anything except in Tumblr newspeak, and we have to walk on eggshells to avoid running fowl of people like you lest you decide to ruin our careers.

Your entire ideology is utterly toxic and destroys everything it touches.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Did you even read the article? Or did you just get to that sentence so you'd have something to quote?

14

u/Jafit Sep 04 '16

Yes I read the article, it consists of this guy pointing out all the times Crockford has ever made a joke about balls, and then trying to establish whether or not he was "slut shaming" when he said that the old web was promiscuous.

Even if the conclusion of the article were different, combing over people's words trying to find something to be offended by and then deciding (based on your own personal set of values) whether that person deserves to speak at a conference or not, is a shitty perverse practice, it is destructive, stifling and unhealthy.

I can't believe we're even having this discussion. The entire situation is ridiculous.

9

u/flying-sheep Sep 04 '16

He did that to find out if there was anything substantial to find that justifies kicking or Crockford, and his conclusion was a define “no”.

His point was: even when sifting through everything he said and scrutinizing it by PC standards, there's still no reason to uninvite him.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/tresfaim Sep 04 '16

I'm pretty sure that combing over a person's words and deciding whether to be offended or not is DE FACTO in human communication.

It's necessary for people to synthesize a version of reality that they can share, because we all see it from a subjective perspective. So pulling facts, no matter where from, is necessary to build something more than a pale understanding of an occurrence.

And be more mindful of when someone is trying to exhibit a specific sort of defense - letting the facts do the 'speaking' themselves and the defender only need provide minor elaboration. This defense boils down to: 'this **** is obviously BS and all you got are dog balls on my client'

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Uberhipster Sep 05 '16

Umungus wot m8?!

1

u/TellanIdiot Sep 05 '16

No-Dev-ember

-17

u/nluqo Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

I mostly agree with you. I tend to fall on the side of SJW camp most of the time, but here I'm struggling to see the problem with the majority of what he's being accused of saying.

The promiscuity thing, at least in the version of the talk I've heard, is completely innocuous. Now it could be that several earlier versions of the talk were different. Who knows.

There's also nothing to see with the "weak map" reference. Everyone hates weak shit. Weak sauce. Weak coffee.

However, the balls/gonads/chicharrones/huevos thing is pretty juvenile and yea exclusionary. Having struggled with impostor syndrome my whole life and being particularly terrified of functional programming, I can easily imagine not wanting to step anywhere near that talk if I wasn't a dude.

And I think you're being a little naive with the terminology. While "gonad" may technically reference to both kinds of organs, that's clearly not what it means in common parlance (don't stop at the first definition). Likewise with chicharrones. Even if Crockford made up this usage on the spot, it's obvious what it means. Which one even remotely makes sense: "If you have the pork belly, you can learn monads" or "If you have the balls, you can learn monads"?

4

u/randallsquared Sep 04 '16

Even if Crockford made up this usage on the spot, it's obvious what it means. Which one even remotely makes sense: "If you have the pork belly, you can learn monads" or "If you have the balls, you can learn monads"?

When you put it like that, it looks like he was trying to say "If you have the guts, you can learn monads".

3

u/nluqo Sep 04 '16

Sure, that would indeed make sense because guts/spine/balls are almost totally interchangeable in that kind of saying. But I'm doubtful it suddenly means "guts" when there are so many other testicle references in the talk (plus the word sounds a bit similar to "cojones").

→ More replies (2)

6

u/PotaToss Sep 04 '16

Malcolm Gladwell says people love weak, milky coffee, but they'll tell you otherwise.

Chicharrones doesn't even have to be belly. Maybe he meant if you had a thick skin, which clearly a lot of people don't.

Huevos (as courage exclusive to males) was the only thing that was fairly deemed exclusionary mentioned here. The dog balls quote was just a visual to imply something that looks awkward. Nothing to do with gender.

7

u/nluqo Sep 04 '16

Yea I love that anecdote from Gladwell. Point being either way that "weak" has a widely agreed upon negative connotation.

Again here, it seems to me like mental gymnastics to ignore the gonads and chicharrones references. If you poll people on the street about what they think those words mean in a sentence the way Crockford used them, I bet 9 out of 10 are going to say "balls". That's what gonads means outside of a scientific context. Having thought about it, I'm pretty sure I understand the chicharrones thing even more (it sounds close to cojones). "Thick skin"... yea, a talk with half a dozen references to testicles, and this one is just going to be about thick skin.

At best it's plausible deniability. Like when Trump makes a joke about the "2nd admendment people" and Clinton. Anybody in the room knows exactly what he's saying, but there's just enough vagueness for pundits to pretend it was something else.

Anyway, I don't think any of this qualifies Crockford for an insta-ban from conferences without an explanation, but at the same time there's no need to be dishonest about what the guy said.

3

u/autourbanbot Sep 04 '16

Here's the Urban Dictionary definition of Cojones) :


The Mexican/puerto rican/cuban/south american way to say balls


I'll rip off yo cajones


about | flag for glitch | Summon: urbanbot, what is something?

6

u/dodeca_negative Sep 04 '16

"These people can't handle the slightest disagreement!"

downvotes contrary but well-stated opinion into oblivion

2

u/nluqo Sep 05 '16

Yup. The thing that really gets me is I'm 90% in agreement with the blog post and yet I'm still Hitler for having my own nuanced position.

4

u/sugar_free_haribo Sep 05 '16

It's because you're saying you're scared of a mild reference to balls.

1

u/sugar_free_haribo Sep 05 '16

However, the balls/gonads/chicharrones/huevos thing is pretty juvenile and yea exclusionary.

What if a female speaker made a reference to ovaries? Would that send you running? MY GOD WHO THE FUCK CARES?!!

1

u/nluqo Sep 05 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

If, in an alternate reality, there was a well established and popular saying that equated the lack of ovaries to cowardice and if I knew the talk was going to be laced with that kind of thing and all other things being equal, sure, I'd probably skip that talk for something else.

It's because you're saying you're scared of a mild reference to balls.

Nope. I said it was juvenile and exclusionary, which it is. It's a great thing to say around your 12 year old friends, but seems a bit out of place at a professional conference.

Downvotes are for spam and comments not contributing to the discussion. Even if I did say I was scared of a reference to balls, why the hell would that warrant a torrent of downvotes?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

[deleted]

0

u/nluqo Sep 04 '16

You won't listen to a talk because you don't think it will appeal to you?

No, I'd listen to anything, but I don't think I would attend a talk if I thought the environment was going to be hostile to people like me. I've been in talks where speakers have, for laughs, taken a giant shit on X, Y, or Z technology choice I've made and it doesn't feel great to be in that room. I'm pretty sure it would be much worse if the jokes were about gender.

10

u/svper Sep 04 '16

Just so i'm getting this right: You will not attend a talk because you might feel bad when someone laughingly talks shit about a technology you use?

How about you grow up and aqcuire some mental toughness.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bugeats Sep 04 '16

Meritocracy is one of the best qualities of tech culture. Simply said: some tech choices are better than others. That's why we go to conferences to listen to smart people, understand their opinions, and make up our own minds.

You're never going to thrive if you're looking for a reason to be offended instead of doing the work to learn and grow as a professional.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

[deleted]

115

u/ivosaurus Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

I simply don't get how organisers take solid action on one person's claim that lots of people [who?] are uncomfortable about another person. From a slack conversation posted earlier, that seemed to be all the 'evidence' they needed. He's being witch hunted at the moment, IMHO.

64

u/MonkeyD Sep 04 '16

It's funny too... They all owe their career to him in one way or another.

3

u/sugar_free_haribo Sep 05 '16

Same with Eich, except even more so.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/tebriel Sep 04 '16

Morbidly obese people make me uncomfortable, I refuse to go to conferences with morbidly obese people. And since my comfort is the most important out of everyone's, I demand all morbidly obese people be denied entry.

14

u/ryeguy146 Sep 04 '16

Many will decline to speak if morbidly obese people are invited.

31

u/toiletjs Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 05 '16

The cyberbullying thing is what really gets me. People like @getify and @polotek are writing literally hundreds of tweets in Nodevember's defense, and absolutely steamrolling anyone who chimes in with a dissenting opinion. They're trying to twist this into an issue of race, which is totally absurd. Even when underrepresented people speak up against them, they shut them down too. It seems so closed minded for people who are building their case on inclusivity and empathy.

2

u/markcabal Sep 07 '16

@getify and @polotek are SJWs and SJWs act like a gang, backing each other up no matter what. "Inclusivity" for them means the "privileged" are fair game. "Empathy" means the "privileged" should listen to them (but not visa versa).

19

u/Aldonio Sep 04 '16 edited Sep 04 '16

The nodevember's official statement still fails to convey something meaningful, but "at least" they are allowing people to request a refund.

41

u/nerdy_glasses Sep 04 '16

I sincerely hope enough people request a refund to kill off the conference. Their behavior is poisoning the community.

27

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

Let's address the elephant in the room

I'm triggered.

we became aware that based on private feedback - not simply the dialogue on Twitter - that his presence would make some speakers uncomfortable to the point where they refused to attend or speak.

I just can't understand how can people whose only weapon seems to be excluding people then talk about "inclusiveness".

14

u/Spoor Sep 05 '16

Let's address the elephant in the room

Now it all makes sense. That person wanted Nodevember to be a PHP conference. Of course you didn't want the author of a well-known JS book at that event.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

These type of bullying really need to backfire spectacularly, so that people can stop doing it.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/lewisje Sep 05 '16

This is the first place where I've seen either TailGate or CrockfordGate; I understand what the other two are referring to, but is TailGate something about the new proposal for explicitly declared tail-recursive functions, because tail-call-eliminating all the things wreaks havoc on attempts to debug functions?