r/javahelp • u/cherry_mxxvii • Sep 08 '19
NetBeans or Intellij IDEA
Which IDE is widely used among java developers?
19
u/Velladin Sep 08 '19
I personally like Eclipse the best but IntelliJ is also very good.
You really can’t go wrong with any of them. Just pick one that you like the most and stick with it.
9
u/jlktrl Sep 08 '19
A huge chunk or Java developers are Android devs who use Android Studio which runs on Intellij, so you can’t go wrong there.
5
u/erihel518 Sep 08 '19
I'm still a beginner, but I've used both IDE's. I really liked Netbeans, it's the one I was instructed to download for my first Java class. Later in the class I switched to Intellij and that's been my go to since.
My reasonings were because I had used Pycharm when I was learning Python and they are similar because they're both by Jetbrains. And I want to develop android and Android Studio was built off of Intellij. Also one of my next steps will be to learn Kotlin, and that language was also made by Jetbrains.
Both are fine IDEs but I feel that Intellij is more popular. I know Eclipse also is very popular. I would say try them out for a bit and see what you like better. It's more about what you are comfortable with. In the end they'll all get you to the same place.
4
u/Hoog1neer Sep 08 '19
I started out with Netbeans, used Eclipse for years, and recently converted to IntelliJ. My only complaint about IntelliJ is the use of some non-standard shortcut keys. Otherwise, it appears to be more stable than Eclipse while also offering a rich plugin ecosystem.
2
u/TunaMcFish Sep 09 '19
Btw you can change the bindings of your keymap to use Eclipse's default. Press ( CTRL + ` ) and then select "switch keymap" / "Eclipse"
4
Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Intellij is easiest to learn. Eclipse is a bit harder, steeper learning curve, but it has all the functionality of intellij ultimate for free and then some (I really miss perspectives). I think netbeans can be better than eclipse for frontend work. I would rate them as follows:
Intellij ultimate.
Eclipse.
Intellij free version.
Netbeans.
Edit: I just realised that I came to intellij after a few years of eclipse and netbeans. So I retract my easier to learn statement. Of course it'll be easier with a few years experience in other IDEs
4
u/marvk Sep 08 '19
it has all the functionality of intellij ultimate for free and then some
Nope.
Search Everywhere
Very smart Data Flow Analysis
Inline Parameter Name Hints
Scopes
Sophisticated Breakpoint options
Structural Find and Replace
Language Injection and dedicated editor for injected fragment
Just to name some.
3
u/wsppan Sep 08 '19
Use whatever everyone else at work/school uses. You will find your keybindings can go with you as you change jobs, professors etc.
9
4
u/bkushner13 Sep 08 '19
IntelliJ’s debugging is by far the best
1
Sep 08 '19
Not sure I agree with that. Why do you think so?
5
u/morhp Professional Developer Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 09 '19
I haven't used the debugging in eclipse extensively, but stuff that's great in intellij is for example stepping into compiled class files (which are automatically decompiled), custom type visualisation, conditional breakpoints, automatically breaking on exceptions (even if they're catched somewhere) and much more.
1
Sep 09 '19
Eclipse has all that. I used Eclipse from 2003 to 2016 exclusively and switched to IJ free after that. The reason why I find IJ debugger better is because it online the values of the variables in the code view itself as comments, when paused.
Adding that to an immensely superior Gradle and maven integration, native kotlin support and better Scala plugin, IJ is the only choice for me.
3
u/Ryuuji159 Sep 08 '19
if you have a student email you can get intellij ultimate
0
u/ChristianGeek Sep 08 '19
If you don’t have a student email, you can get it too. You have to pay for it, but you can get it.
1
2
2
u/Python4fun Sep 08 '19
I use Intellij among a bunch of people who use Eclipse (or spring tool suite) and I can't tell you how many times I've had them jealous of easy functionality of intellij when Eclipse makes things hard.
3
u/morhp Professional Developer Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Same. In university everyone was using eclipse because professors told them to do so, I used intellij because of previous experience on a job and very often other students using eclipse were jealous when they saw certain features. I've also used eclipse, but it always looks slow and way too modular and customizable. Sounds weird, but a lot of things in intellij feel like a core part of the application, like refactorings or version control integration, while in eclipse everything feels like a not that well integrated plug in.
Of course you can also write version control and refactoring plug-ins for intellij, but they feel more integrated, I don't know.
1
1
u/wades39 Sep 08 '19
I was first instructed to use NetBeans. However, I'm currently using Eclipse. I prefer NetBeans for stuff that requires I have a GUI, as I need to learn how to actually write the code for them myself. But I like the Eclipse editor more. I've not used Intellij, though I may try it to pin down my preferred IDE.
1
u/stevesobol Sep 08 '19
I switched away from Netbeans to Eclipse years ago because it was pure Java, no native code, and was S-L-O-W. Having reinstalled it recently, I can tell you that problem no longer exists, but I prefer the IntelliJ platform to either of those other IDEs. I just feel like Jetbrains understands the way I work.
1
u/bkushner13 Sep 08 '19
Additionally being able to see the values of variables and objects as you step through your code as well.
1
0
u/Soreasan Sep 08 '19
As a professional Java Developer I recommend IntelliJ. It has amazing debugging features!
Netbeans is very good when you're getting started though because it installs Java and everything for you. (Video with Netbeans)
-1
u/Nix-X Sep 08 '19
NetBeans feels ancient. Feel like it should be extinct already.
2
u/HBK05 Sep 08 '19
It was taken over by Apache in 2016, and it's been modernized (I think?) a lot. I can't remember what it used to look like, but it feels very modern/normal to me, certainly not ancient. The old version might of been, and don't get me wrong, it's not as sleek as intellij, but it's at least eclipse or better.
0
u/raja777m Sep 08 '19
For some reasons companies don't get the license for intelliJ, and people tend to stick to the IDEs. I'm used to Eclipse.
0
0
-2
u/zultdush Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 20 '25
no thanks
3
Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
...fucking what? That is the last thing anyone in the world cares about because only idiots write their code in notepad++ and fixing compile time errors are at most 0.1% of what you do in any given day, even if you write it with runes on a stone tablet.
You're still gonna get the feedback, you just get it faster if the IDE tells you than if the compiler tells you. You're still writing the same code and getting the same errors.
Runtime errors are just as likely to happen even if you use two IDE:s to write one set of code, but actually probably more likely because again, only an idiot would do that.
This is probably the dumbest thing I've heard in a long time.
-1
u/zultdush Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 20 '25
no thanks
2
Sep 09 '19
I just thought it was shockingly bad advice to give to someone starting out and I wanted to make sure no one follows it. It was rude but it's better to be rude than to sabotage peoples careers by giving them terrible advice.
I've never seen anyone as incompetent as what you're describing but if they exist surely that's not an issue with using an IDE because most people learn using IDEs and most people turn out fine. That's an issue with a certain portion of the population just being idiots, and that can't be helped even if you code in notepad. A normally gifted person can write on a whiteboard if they're used to syntax highlighting.
It must just be the case that your recruiting process is terrible and so you end up recruiting morons which has given your company a bad reputation which means good candidates stay away. I guarantee it's not because they write their code in a program meant for writing code. Your analysis is wrong.
-1
u/zultdush Sep 09 '19 edited Sep 20 '25
no thanks
2
Sep 09 '19
I'm sorry but this argument is retarded. Using an IDE isn't a crutch, it's a productivity enhancer. An IDE won't help with shit to make you a better programmer. It saves you some time remembering obscure method names and stuff like whether the way to check size of an array is .length or .size.
That stuff has jack shit to do with good programming though, and if you'd turn down a candidate for using the wrong method to check array size while writing pseudo-code on a whiteboard then you're an idiot and you're valuing all the wrong things. That's not where you look for quality in a programmer, it's completely inconsequential. What's it matter if they don't know which package the Scanner class in when the IDE is gonna help them with that in real life anyway?
Programming is about logic and problem solving, not memorizing magic spells and incantations and what special words you have to write in what order. I think you've got it confused with witchcraft or something. You're not making any sense at all to me. Describing the most basic programming tool as a crutch is just delusional, you seem like one of those autistic purists who thinks everything was better back when you programmed on punch cards. Why don't you go program a web server in assembly or something.
0
Sep 08 '19
[deleted]
5
u/nutrecht Lead Software Engineer / EU / 20+ YXP Sep 08 '19
Eclipse is still the most popular
It's not, IntelliJ has had the largest market share for a while now.
4
u/shiba009933 Sep 08 '19 edited Sep 08 '19
Curious, where do you see eclipse as being the most popular?
I know this isn't conclusive at all, but I've not seen many surveys that aren't biased and show otherwise (for example, JetBrains survey likely has some bias in the results)
SO's Dev survey 2019: IJ-25.4%, Eclipse-14.4%, Netbeans-5.9%
SO's Dev Survey 2018: IJ-24.9%, Eclipse-18.9%, Netbeans-8.2%
2
u/morhp Professional Developer Sep 08 '19
Eclipse definitely is more popular in university and so on. Maybe because they don't want to teach using the free version of a commercial product. Or because they want to do java ee stuff for which you need to get the ultimate edition from intellij. Which is free for students, but they probably still don't want to teach using something the students can't use after university.
On my job though everyone uses intellij.
1
u/shiba009933 Sep 08 '19
I'd love to see some numbers to back this up - not disputing it, just would like to see numbers instead of presumptions.
something the students can't use after university.
This doesn't make sense to me. Students can still use it after university. And even still, CE just doesn't have the features for EE, but you can still write the code. Once a student turns into a full time employee, they should have the funds to purchase, and likely be able to expense it to their company/write it off as a business expense.
10
u/HBK05 Sep 08 '19
Big 3 and my personal opinions:
Intellij (free or paid): Intellij IDEA is my top pick for a java IDE. It's simple yet complex, with so many options and an easy to use UI that I fell in love. It looks better and is integrated better with gradle & maven vs others of what I've seen. Not to mention they have VERY similar IDEs for c#/python/php/js/c++ etc.
Eclipse: Very Popular, decently easy to use but personally I think it's ugly as satan.
Netbeans: Obscure, but it works well and I've used it a small amount for some personal projects. it's not bad by any means.