r/java • u/[deleted] • May 24 '22
IntelliJ will soon look like Visual Studio Code
https://blog.jetbrains.com/idea/2022/05/take-part-in-the-new-ui-preview-for-your-jetbrains-ide/114
u/aclinical May 24 '22
"Many of our new users tell us that the UI appears heavyweight and dated."
Interesting. I'd bet most students are using vscode. JetBrains wants to attract them with a more familiar experience. <\PM>
41
u/eloc49 May 24 '22
The 2022 UI is actually a good balance between the flat, clean look of VS code yet I still feel like I'm using a powerful piece of software and not a text editor.
8
u/HellfireDreadnought May 26 '22
We live in the ashes of civilization.
5
1
u/SpiritualLeave Sep 22 '22
I understand functionality over aesthetics, but implying aesthetics don't matter is ridiculous
10
u/lechatsportif May 24 '22
They're all using 8 inch mac mini air ultras and need the screen real estate.
1
-17
u/MrDeagle80 May 24 '22 edited May 24 '22
I am java developer since 10 years and i like this new UI.
Many of our new users tell us that the UI appears heavyweight and dated."
I personally agree with this and this is one of the reasons I switched from idea to vim 2 years ago.
In intellij there are just too much informations on the ui that you don't really need.
Of course this is not the only reason i switched to vim.
Edit: I don't know why im getting downvoted for just telling my own experience and opinion lol. Typical reddit I guess ¯_(ツ)_/¯
28
6
u/kiteboarderni May 25 '22
Because you're chatting shit. If the ui was too busy you can unpin the tabs. Learn to use a tool properly, and realise your own lack of knowledge before assuming the tooling is the problem.
→ More replies (3)1
May 24 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/aclinical May 25 '22
Some schools are using web based vscode. Similar to https://vscode.dev/ but integrated with SharePoint. It actually sounds like a great way to get started without overwhelming students with tooling.
2
u/recycle4science Jul 17 '22
I feel like overwhelming students with tooling might actually be a good idea to get them used to what it's like to onboard at a new job lol
103
u/detroitsongbird May 24 '22
That’s a downgrade. The bottom is now a file path vs a bunch of icons for very useful features? Why?
20
u/hypothid May 24 '22
If they’re going to make IntelliJ look like VSCode, why not just add a download button to VSCode? Would have saved them millions of dollars in R&D and saved them so much time and effort
5
u/vytah May 24 '22
The bottom icons are moved to the bottom left. The old bottom left icons are gone, the side panels are no longer able to contain two subpanels.
The navigation bar can be moved to the top.
https://youtrack.jetbrains.com/articles/IDEA-A-156/Main-changes-and-known-issues
22
4
u/meotau May 27 '22
Alina Mishina needed to stay busy and fucking up menus and icons was not enough.
47
u/berry120 May 24 '22
If they want to move away from professional users and towards new users & students then sure - this is probably a slightly easier introduction. But in reality all I can see this doing is alienating their core customer base of professional devs.
"Looks a bit more like VSCode" is irritating, but I can live with it. Increasing the font size of the panels & buttons so I have less space for code, hiding previously one-click options behind additional buttons and icons, removing information from the main window, etc. - not so much, and I don't see how that's going to work without removing useful functionality. I have more panel options along the bottom currently (Terminal, Run, Spring, Services, etc.) than they can fit buttons to show them on the left with that current view. If they start removing useful customisation options as well - I'm out.
4
1
u/gyraciops May 27 '22
I feel exactly the same, however the problem is... what's the alternative? I think there's none, sadly.
1
271
u/cshrp-sucks May 24 '22
I hope they just don't make it work the same.
I hate that everything is a second class citizen in VSCode. Want to do anything? try searching for a command and pray that it actually works. Every single time. Want to use some language/technology? Here's a set of extensions that might or might not work. 10 of them do the same thing, just try each. Want to change a setting? Here's a json file with no comments and no schema. You want to know what are possible values here? Go fuck yourself.
119
u/-NewK- May 24 '22 edited May 24 '22
I never knew exactly how to describe my experience with VSCode, but I believe you nailed it. Everything in VSCode is a second class citizen indeed.
54
May 24 '22
Yeah, using it really makes you appreciate the "I" in IDE. VS Code is a smart text editor which can approximate an IDE with enough work. I recall reading one of their change logs where a major new feature was "you can now move your Typescript files and it will automatically update imports" - I'd have assumed my install was broken if it couldn't do that!
5
u/Sirttas May 24 '22
The I is the hard part. And vs code is bunch of plugins sloped together period. It's good looking, has great plugins for specific cases it no more.
53
May 24 '22 edited May 24 '22
Yeah, I'm a java dev using Idea Community on a daily basis and can't understand the people trying to convince me to use vs code.
I mean, just nope.
I had first hand experience on what you mentioned with XML pretty printing. There are tens if not hundreds of plugins to do that, how TF am I supposed to know which one does it best?
I mean, that's the kind of stuff I expect to be available natively, or at least via ONE official plugin.
12
u/franzwong May 24 '22
I use VS Code to read the code cloned from GitHub, e.g. JDK, guava, because I know that I won't modify or compile it. It takes time to load in IntelliJ if the codebase is huge. This is my only use case to use VS code for Java.
34
u/bingchillingx3 May 24 '22
Downgrade to a glorified text editor with 50,000 plugins from a smart as FUCK fully packed out IDE? No thanks.
7
u/Joram2 May 24 '22
I can't imagine programmers trying to convince each other which editor to use... Sometimes it's fun to hear a suggestion, but I imagine most conversation beyond that is counterproductive. It's best left as personal opinion + preference.
1
u/Objective_Baby_5875 May 24 '22
So java dev complaining that too many extensions in vs code for the same feature yet there are a gazillion json and XML parsers in Java..and there the ecosystem is seen as a strength.
11
u/Worth_Trust_3825 May 24 '22
Second. I told my teammates that I configure my database access via ultimate's datagrip plugin, which permits to use databases as if they were somewhat like trees of folders. One of the teammates tried to find similar plugin for vscode only to stumble on a database specific plugin that would accept one input line per parameter to connect to that database. After configuring the database access, the plugin disappeared not to be seen ever again.
At least now our text editors are browsers too.
8
u/lechatsportif May 24 '22
Everything in VSCode is a second class citizen
My favorite part is when it fails to open, complains my shell dying, and then forces a reboot of my work mbp. "There you have it lechatsportif, too many scripts"
7
u/Trio_tawern_i_tkwisz May 24 '22
Honest question, how is that different with IntelliJ? I mean, how is that different in any platform that allows community extensions (like IntelliJ or VSCode, or probably any other)?
I get why so many devs hate what JetBrains just introduced. Likewise, I'm really concerned myself, mostly because I doubt the target audience for Java IDE should be now beginners and students, not experts with years of experience.
But what I'm reading here is just poorly justified aversion. There are VSCode third party plugins that work great with VSCode and there are elements of Java core ecosystem that are terribly supported in IntelliJ (Rust in VSCode vs Maven projects in IntelliJ). You really never saw outdated, lacking documentation plugins for IntelliJ, or core IntelliJ functions that just don't work without any communicated reasons?
I think that if they won't get quality criticism now, then later it will never be taken under consideration. What I'm trying to say is that if that's the level of criticism they are gonna receive, then forcing more such minimalism into UI is granted. I for myself wouldn't take seriously your criticism…
2
u/NoMoreWordz May 24 '22
I have been using vscose for java spring, python development for a year now and haven't missed anything, your experience recent?
1
u/KTibow May 27 '22
This comment upsets me.
Want to do anything? try searching for a command and pray that it actually works. Every single time.
Could you elaborate?
Here's a set of extensions that might or might not work. 10 of them do the same thing, just try each.
Most of the time, you just need the top one. Keep in mind these are community created, and Intellij also has extensions. (Although I can say in my experience Java in VS Code isn't very well implemented...)
Want to change a setting? Here's a json file with no comments and no schema. You want to know what are possible values here? Go fuck yourself.
How... How did you come up with this? There's a settings page with descriptions and everything, and the
settings.jsonfile has a schema built in.1
0
May 24 '22
[deleted]
6
u/metalhead-001 May 25 '22
They are removing the ability to do left placed, vertically stacked tabs. There is no replacement...they are just removing the feature.
The idiots at JetBrains think that removing features that people pay for and use will make the IDE better?
5
167
91
u/HeadSignal3 May 24 '22
I use to use Borland, then I switched MSVS, then Forte, then Eclipse, then Netbeans, then Eclipse after they rewrote it, then Netbeans after they rewrote it, then finally Intellij in 2012. Each switch was because the previous IDE became bogged down and unusable, not because it looked bad.
13
u/benjtay May 24 '22
Netbeans is underappreciated -- such a good IDE.
5
u/RandomName8 May 24 '22
The problem with NB is that IDEs don't age well, they need constant maintenance and improvements just to stay afloat. And once the actual commits flow in NB died due to Oracle the IDE also sorta died. Sure it does great the things it used to do in 2008, but we expect so much more these days, and also for bugs to be fixed quickly.
3
u/Comfortable-Big7765 May 24 '22
Yes! I am still using netbeans for my hobby projects. And I really appreciate it.
2
u/HeadSignal3 May 24 '22
It is or was in my opinion. The Swing support was great if that's your thing.
6
u/lechatsportif May 24 '22
My Eclipse was always fast actually, but everytime I tried to upgrade packages, it would explode and end up corrupted. I finally got tired of it and explored Intellij.
9
u/kuporific May 24 '22
Then you'll be happy to hear about this https://www.jetbrains.com/fleet
18
u/JustADirtyLurker May 24 '22
I'm in the beta preview of Fleet. To be honest, it's a disappointment.
9
u/Wmorgan33 May 24 '22
I too have been underwhelmed by Fleet. In my view right now, its currently used best as a VSCode replacement (with much fewer extensions). I haven't been able to get the auto-complete to work well either.
6
u/JustADirtyLurker May 24 '22
To me Vscode is 10x better. Fleet is fast only when used in dumb editor mode, but when you enable the smart IDE features it takes more time to bootstrap than even the full IntelliJ, for java/python/other platforms.
→ More replies (1)
54
u/Sirttas May 24 '22
Why moved the file to the bottom, why using icons for tabs that are 3 times wider than the old ones? The run button isn't the only one in the Taskbar we are using.
29
74
45
u/developer_how_do_i May 24 '22
Somehow I like intellij more than vscode..
Hope there's a switch button to go back to classic view... Similar to the ones shown in Salesforce UI
5
u/berry120 May 24 '22
Not according to current plans. They say they'll support both for a year, then that's it.
4
3
u/Atulin May 24 '22
Could you link to where they said it?
11
u/berry120 May 24 '22
Oh sorry, misread that. They said "we plan to keep both the old and new UI for at least a year after the new UI becomes the default."
So hopefully longer than a year, but definitely no guarantees, and certainly sounds like they're not keeping it around for long.
62
May 24 '22
My reaction be like: NOOOOOOOOO! GOD! NOOOOOOOOO! GOD PLEASE NO! NO! NO! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
94
u/dethswatch May 24 '22
"Our goals were to reduce visual complexity, provide easy access to essential features, and progressively disclose complex functionality as needed – resulting in a look-and-feel that we believe is clean, modern, and powerful."
This ux trend really needs to die. It looks great to the designer because they don't code, it also looks great to everyone until you start using and you wonder wheretf they put that thing you needed.
It worked fine in Code because Code didn't offer you much... I don't do anything serious in Code...
58
u/pronuntiator May 24 '22
The Windows 11 explorer is a good example. The right click context menu has a "show more" button to bring up the real context menu, because too many options may scare users. So Git, SVN etc. integration is now one more click away.
Everything is becoming a freaking mobile app with huge buttons. Docker Desktop UI is a joke with its stop buttons that only appear when hovering over a container because OH NO TOO CLUTTERED
31
u/redwall_hp May 24 '22
Yeah...it's fallacious thinking to entertain the idea that you can make a complex problem less complex by simply hiding the complexity. The UI isn't complex for the sake of it, but because it's expressing tasks that have complexity.
Modern UI design is simply bad. It's crazy, if you look at design guidelines from something like early Mac OS X or Windows 98, how well thought out and discoverable things are. Buttons look like buttons to give the user a clue that they're clickable. Functions are in discoverable menus that can be visually explored. Now we have hidden functionality that only appears on mouseover or when you flail around and make random touch gestures that have zero indication of whether they'll do anything at all.
1
u/neutronbob May 25 '22
So true. However, one of the UI features that the 90s gave us that was completely pointless was the "About" box, which would just show you a list of license verbiage and/or copyright notices. Unfortunately, as the years have clicked by, that one UI feature has remained unchanged.
10
10
u/hippydipster May 24 '22
...modern...
I hate so-called "modern" UIs. All they are is different. And we didn't need different for the sake of different.
3
u/nlisker May 24 '22
This is one reason why I like Eclipse, everything is easily accessible and customizable. An IDE is a professional environment, it's good for it to cater to a professional audience who doesn't have a problem with complexity. The IntelliJ trend is going towards an end-user mobile app.
Not that everything should be as complex as possible, or that Eclipse gets it all right, but the direction is much better.
4
u/dethswatch May 25 '22
going towards an end-user mobile app.
that's an excellent way to expressing it
2
u/Wugliwu May 24 '22 edited May 26 '22
Actually that's against UX. A UXler needs a deep understanding of their users and one part of this is to understand what they are used to. You don't change a system from one day to another because you disrupt the mental model your users developed over years. Sometimes it's much smarter to build a system around the habits your users developed even if this leads to a worse usability on paper.
The problem is you end up on something like Photoshop if you don't rework. This will make your product less attractive to new users. So the smart way would be a slow transition. Change a menu. Let your user become comfortable with the changes. Do another change. And so on...
4
u/dethswatch May 25 '22
agreed on all of this, and I actually had photoshop in mind- the existing stuff hasn't changed at all, as far as I can tell since the 90's or possibly before.
I fear the issue with UX people is that they tend to be designers more than anything else- and it's way easier than understanding how the users use the thing.
1
u/OZLperez11 May 25 '22
Maybe the problem is that we are at a point in tech history where there are significantly more new users than veteran coders, especially those familiar with VS Code and it's cousins. Using JetBrains IDEs might be a turn off for them because there's too much going on in the UI. From a business perspective, it's possible that JetBrains sales either plateaued or are declining and they wanted to know why. Maybe because not enough new users want to conform to a cluttered UI.
-3
u/keosen May 24 '22
I don't do anything serious in Code...
Chad programmer being too good to code in vscode
4
u/dethswatch May 24 '22
my side projects tend to be in code, and I've got a ton of hours in it, but those projects still aren't serious compared to my day work.
If they were, I wouldn't bother with it.
0
May 24 '22
[deleted]
4
u/dethswatch May 24 '22
I trust them so far, we'll see how it goes.
3
u/Ilookouttrainwindow May 24 '22
I trust them, but I feel like we're on a downward spiral here. It's just becoming more and more intrusive. Rider just started doing word autocompletion; didn't realize this before, but typing comments has just become harder due to constant visual garbage popping up.
40
u/morhp May 24 '22 edited May 24 '22
This is terrible. I was already irritated by them redesigning the run configuration dialog and the toolbars (which are now much more complicated to use IMO and require way more clicking). But that's too much.
3
u/vqrs May 24 '22
I find the keyboard integration for run configuration editing to be rather well designed.
It now mirrors the CLI, I think it's quite a good take on fitting a lot of information into little space.
2
u/morhp May 25 '22
It now mirrors the CLI, I think it's quite a good take on fitting a lot of information into little space.
I appreciate the order of the entries mirroring the CLI. It's a nice idea.
But: There's enough space in the dialog, no need to cram it into little text boxes that share lines. I often use several bulky JVM and program arguments, and my package/main class names are also plenty layers deep. And the texts are cut off in that dialog while the bottom of the dialog is a huge gray empty area. Doesn't make sense to me.
Another huge problem is that the textboxes aren't labeled. I'm often contemplating on what is what.
Something like
Java executable: [zulu-17/java v] JVM arguments: [.............. ...] Main Class: [................ v] Program Arguments: [.............. ...] Environment: [.............. ...] ...would also mirror the cli and be much more usable. Especially as you could just resize the dialog if you have particularly long package names and arguments and so on to get everything visible. With their current design, making the dialog larger often reduces the size of the textboxes because they merge more into the same line.
1
u/vqrs May 25 '22
Try keeping ALT pressed next time you use it, it'll label everything. You can also expand all of the small inputs using shift-enter I believe or the arrow icon on the right hand side of the input.
But yeah, if expanding the window crams even more onto one line, I'd report that in their issue tracker. That does sound rather inconvenient.
0
u/vxab May 24 '22
The change to the run configuration dialog is not that bad IMO. It is a bit more clicky but how often are you going to customise it?
9
u/morhp May 24 '22
but how often are you going to customise it?
I'm relatively often messing around with JVM settings or command line arguments. So pretty often, I'd say. But even if I'd use it only rarely, that no excuse to make the UI worse.
1
u/Worth_Trust_3825 May 24 '22
Always. I have custom runtimes and must define remote debugger configurations every time I need to interact with that custom runtime.
18
17
84
u/BlueGoliath May 24 '22 edited May 24 '22
Fixing bugs, improving build system integration, and allowing multiple projects being open in the same window: no
Making intelliJ look like Visual Studio Code: yes
FFS, what is up with tech companies pulling low effort marketing bullshit instead of fixing the product? Who do you people think you are, Microsoft? Are you going to start introducing 5 different UI styles next?
I want to switch from the buggy broken mess that is Netbeans but when your product is so lacking in basic UX features it blows my mind and makes switching not possible.
23
u/kubelke May 24 '22
At least they fixed the problem with indexing. I’m not even updating my IntelliJ to not let it break again.
14
u/BlueGoliath May 24 '22
Progress!
But that reminds me: my understanding is that all the premium features of IntelliJ are in addition to. Imagine being a paying customer, still having all of these technical issues, and then seeing this announcement. I'd be pissed and wouldn't be inclined to buy any of their other products.
12
u/kubelke May 24 '22
I’m a paying customer since ~2014, I’m pissed every time when I see such announcements. I even started contacting support via email just to let them know that I have problems and I don’t know what to do.
1
u/yawkat May 24 '22
Did they fix it recently? The status quo for me is about five minutes of indexing for every project I open, every morning
→ More replies (3)17
u/DualWieldMage May 24 '22
It's still not possible to exit presentation mode without fonts being wrong size in various places that requires a restart to fix. Still some projects break when compiling, saying stuff like package not found that deleting the .idea folder and reimporting fixes.
They got real comfortable after passing eclipse market share and the product has degraded rapidly. Lots of new features that i don't want to use somehow affect the things i do want, such as kotlin plugin doing extra stuff with the debugger and slowing it down (and debugger in kotlin itself is utterly broken, i never use kotlin language snippets in evaluate expression as a result).
2
u/Regis_DeVallis May 24 '22
I love intellij but man the entire thing needs a rewrite. I have a moderately beefy desktop and the fans go crazy when I boot up an IDE. Hopefully fleet works nicely.
12
u/Marcdro May 24 '22
you can actually open multiple projects in diferent tabs. In a single window.
7
u/kozeljko May 24 '22
In IDEA?
2
u/renatoathaydes May 24 '22
Not sure if that is good enough, but I often use the import "modules" feature... I guess them calling it "modules" makes this feature undiscoverable, but it means you can basically import another project into the same "workspace" (to use the Eclipse terminology), or whatever your main project is, by using "import modules from existing sources".
EDIT: it's in the "File > New > Module from existing sources" menu!
→ More replies (1)1
4
u/vprise May 24 '22
They fix a lot of bugs and provide amazing support. Multiple projects can be opened in one Window which is what I do all the time.
It's not like NetBeans but it will never be. They are very different beasts.This improves the design which is currently very old. A company with MANY employees can do more than one thing in parallel.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Trio_tawern_i_tkwisz May 24 '22
Yeah… I would like not to be afraid of updating to a new version without a risk of features I use stopping working. Or have Maven support that is less buggy :(
15
u/SpaceToaster May 24 '22
Hopefully they are dogfooding it and forcing their devs to use it as they work on the new release.
2
u/meotau May 27 '22
Lose the hope, they will release it like that. Just like the gray icons years back.
14
u/jamesxwhitehead May 24 '22
The syntax highlighting in their screenshot looks a bit noisy to me. Obviously highly personal and subjective and can be replaced with a theme, but I don't think that's meeting their goal of "reduce visual complexity". On that note; removing the labels from elements on the panels... I get that, that is the current trend, but I always end up mousing over the icons to remember what they are anyway. Keen to hear others thoughts on this.
13
u/wildjokers May 24 '22
No, the text on the buttons on the side needs to be there. I don't want to have to remember which icon does what. Just put some damn text on them.
28
13
u/JustCallMeFrij May 24 '22
omg the comments on the blog post itself lmao. Hopefully they listen to the overwhelming feedback. But let's be honest, they probably won't...
4
u/cjthomp May 24 '22
They did respond well to feedback during the pricing debacle, so there's hope of at least a permanent toggle.
2
u/JustCallMeFrij May 24 '22
what was the pricing debacle? I ask cus having a permanent toggle would mean having to support the new UI and the legacy UI permamently for all new UI updates, which sounds like a tech debt nightmare.
3
u/cjthomp May 24 '22
That's why I pay almost $200/yr for the right to continue using software I already purchased.
1
36
u/kurosaki1990 May 24 '22
Why every company need to redesign and reinvent the wheel for something that actually work? this is not mobile apps when you need to update your app with shitty redesign so you make yourself valuable, dam it guys just put your resources in something much useful.
2
u/tariqabdullah1 May 25 '22
Got to keep developers busy
2
u/Ciri0x5A May 25 '22
it would be a point if there was no room for performance improvements... chasing trends and hoping newcomers will join in exchange for a base of loyal experienced users...
23
20
u/Fiskepudding May 24 '22
All I see is a lot of wasted screen space and a tiny window for the code.
If you added a pane with ads, I would have thought this was a Microsoft product.
35
9
u/kyru May 24 '22
A ui redesign that looks and operates worse? Are jetbrains a social media company now, that's what they do.
9
9
u/VTHMgNPipola May 24 '22
This is certainly the most depressing news I received this week. The UI looks good already, and we aren't monkeys with 2 IQ points to need a "simpler" design which leaves a tiny area for the code because the icons are so big.
8
36
u/BanishDank May 24 '22
As someone who has worked with VScode during one semester, my response is: NOOOO!!
C’mon man, they can’t drag themselves down to the bottom with this bs. What’s next, is the IntelliSense gonna be as horrible as VS Code’s too? Omg..
→ More replies (2)
7
6
u/HR_Paperstacks_402 May 24 '22
So they are destroying their UI to go after new users while alienating their existing user base? Dumb.
1
u/Liqmadique May 25 '22
Genius level product mgmt. Fucking clowns running the show over there these days.
11
u/3rdTab May 24 '22
I usually enjoy minimalism but ffs not in my developer tools. Holy Shit I am so angry, this brought all the bitter VS Code first year memories
19
5
u/bbqburner May 24 '22
You know, the better business idea is to actually spin this off as another product in between Fleet and IDEA
4
5
5
u/Mean-Chipmunk3255 May 25 '22
There blog post is filled with people against the change, don't know for whom they are doing this change.
5
u/StoneOfTriumph May 25 '22
Well, this is one way to make me to cancel my ultimate pack subscription.
5
u/swaranga May 26 '22
This is terrible news. I do not want icons and "clean, modern minimal". I want functionality easily accessible for professionals in a professional tool and we are not scared by too many options. Who really comes up with these ideas? Don't they have developers who would say this is a bad idea?
Too bad this will eventually be the only option because no way a company is going to fund two UI efforts in parallel for too long.
4
u/gravitas-deficiency May 24 '22
Sounds like I’m going to be using the version before they release this shit for the foreseeable future…
4
4
4
4
4
u/Worth_Trust_3825 May 24 '22
Every update jetbrains shits out, I have to look for flags to restore how IDEA2018 looked like. I'm tired of fighting. Why can't you just leave it as it is right now? I genuinely hope this is another skin plugin that will get forgotten in the store and break in the next major release permanently.
4
4
u/metalhead-001 May 24 '22
They removed the ability to use left positioned vertical tabs. Total deal breaker for me as I usually have a ton of tabs open.
You'll be forced to use horizontally placed tabs at the top so you'll see many fewer open files, and because they've made the fonts bigger, even less than before if you used the horizontally placed tabs.
Taking features away that their users rely on is completely unacceptable, especially for a paid product.
I don't want the IDE that I use day in and day out to be dumbed down to be 'noob' friendly while making my life more difficult.
Don't do it Jetbrains!
2
u/wildjokers May 25 '22
Just turn off tabs then use cmd-e to switch to recent files.
1
u/metalhead-001 May 25 '22
That is not the same as a static list of files that vertical tabs gives you as the 'recent' feature only shows recently touched files. What if I want to see a couple files I don't touch often, just to keep them in mind? When you use that 'recent' feature you have to hunt around for what you're looking for. It is not a replacement for vertical placed tabs.
4
u/_INTER_ May 24 '22
Genious move, they want to make developers more efficient by forcing them to memorize all shortcuts.
12
14
3
May 24 '22
You can already configure IDEA's UI as bare and uncluttered as you want, disabling all toolbars and tool windows (and even the menu bar), with just the editor remaining (with no tabs if you wish). It's just not the default. By default it's very cluttered, but it does not need to be.
3
u/naturalizedcitizen May 24 '22
I've used Eclipse a lot but moved to Spring Tool Suite once my development was all about Spring. I'm on IntelliJ Ultimate for 3 years now. I hope they don't screw up their new version.
3
u/Professional-Key-266 May 24 '22
nooooooo give me back the build debug stop runConfiguration commit update and push buttons at the top
3
u/tonybenbrahim May 25 '22
Just from the screenshot, I am already missing the Run Configuration menu in the toolbar, and the run/debug buttons.
At work, several teams have already switched to VS Code, Jetbrains may just give me a reason to switch my team over after this UI update comes out. If I wanted VS Code, I would already be using it. This is the wrong approach Jetbrains, innovate, do not copy!
3
3
u/edmguru May 25 '22
2 things for jetbrains
functional over pretty
I want an IDE not some cloud based web dev tool
3
u/m1000 May 29 '22
You know what users (new devs, but with some experience under their belt) tell me when they see me using Rider instead of VS or VSC ?
That they think its beautiful and would like to learn that IDE. So yeah, its BS.
Must be new UI people that want to redo everything their way (well the VSC way it seems).
5
u/tim125 May 24 '22
IntelliJ is where my peace of mind is grounded to reach zen and inspire my thoughts. It’s the sword I use to express my mind…. Now you’re giving me nunchucks ?
2
u/mm1dc May 24 '22
I spend most time with vscode to figure out how get things work rather than actual coding. The only good thing is it is free, everything else is bad
2
May 24 '22
No thanks. I will just switch to VScode. Already tempting considering I need to use Intellij + Rider + Vscode with all the microservices/IaaC using different languages 😂
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/_marcioendo_ May 26 '22
Not an IntelliJ user so please correct me if I am wrong.
IntelliJ is currently a Swing app, correct?
Curious if this new version will keep using Swing.
To my knowledge IntelliJ was one of the greater Swing applications out there. Again, to my knowledge.
2
u/wildjokers May 27 '22
Yes IntelliJ uses swing. This appears to be a new swing look and feel they are creating for IntelliJ.
1
u/_marcioendo_ May 27 '22
Ah, thanks for the info. Being a new Swing look and feel I wonder if they will let the old and the new UI coexist for a little while.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/jevring May 24 '22
I think it could be interesting. I don't hate it. As long as they keep the ability to add the menu bars back, I'm game. I have signed up for the ui preview. Hopefully I'll be selected.
3
u/wildjokers May 24 '22
On mac os the menu will remain along the the top of the screen. On windows the menu can be be put back to its normal location. Linux can't yet put it back in its normal location.
https://youtrack.jetbrains.com/articles/IDEA-A-156/Main-changes-and-known-issues#Window-header
1
1
1
u/rdjack21 May 24 '22
While I'm not a fan of the new front end I will give it a chance. What I'm really wondering is if they are using Flutter for this like they are doing for Fleet, personally I would not trust Google for something like this. But in the blog post they mention that current plugins will continue to work so maybe not this may be just an updated Swing L&F.
1
May 24 '22
Is this going to go to all of the editors? I use a variety of JetBrains stuff, but if it's all gonna be VS-ified, I might as well just switch to VS.
1
u/i_pk_pjers_i May 24 '22
If this horrible UI goes through I'm cancelling my all products pack subscription. This is ridiculous.
1
1
u/Fury9999 May 25 '22
Honestly I don't really care what they do to the ui as long as I don't have to relearn my keybinds. I hardly click anymore anyway
1
u/AmoebaLogical May 27 '22
Woah. IntelliJ tryna be VS code while VS code tryna be intelliJ . (Recently vs released local history )
1
u/Zebbzz May 30 '22
I think the easiest solution to this whole problem is to keep the "old-look" accessible permanently via a theme or something like that. That way they can cater to their new users, and keep their old users on-board.
0
u/Joram2 May 24 '22
I love JetBrains IDEs, I'm looking forward to their visual refresh. I don't know if I will like it, but I presume JetBrains know what they are doing. I'm surprised by the negativity: this crowd hasn't even used the new visuals yet.
I love Visual Studio Code too. I've noticed my preference in editors/IDEs drifts every year as I work on different projects, my use cases change, and I notice different pros/cons of different tools, and I adjust accordingly.
I presume the JetBrains people know what they are doing, I presume I will like the changes they make, but I honestly haven't thought a lot about it.
5
u/metalhead-001 May 24 '22
They removed vertical tabs which is a wonderful feature. They are making the product WORSE.
0
-6
u/nimtiazm May 24 '22
As long as they make it snappy and lightweight, at least I’m in.
→ More replies (1)-1
u/preskot May 24 '22
Totally. I like how it looks, the less UI clutter, the better. Let's see what the preview brings.
-8
u/Fruloops May 24 '22
Everyone jumping the gun and throwing a tantrum after a brief screenshot. Interesting lol. At least wait until you can test it out or see a comprehensive showcase.
22
u/berry120 May 24 '22
It's absolutely right devs are making their concerns known - this is a product many of us pay for, and we're being told a change is going to be forced upon us that no-one asked for, and very few will find helpful.
→ More replies (3)5
u/hippydipster May 24 '22
A UI redesign is such a fuck-you to your current users. Especially on a big complex app where it took significant time for people to learn to use the app effectively. These redesigns are never for the benefit of current customers. It's to attract new ones. To add to marketing material and new buzzwords. Everyone that spent time learning the previous UI has that time discarded for no gain, since these differences in UI are neutral in terms of objective value.
0
u/qubedView May 24 '22
Sounds good to me. I like VSC's style, and I like IntelliJ's functionality. Go ahead and put that chocolate in my peanut butter!
1
u/Prestigious_Two_2440 Nov 17 '22
I totally agree. I like Intellij support of java ,spring boot (latter applies to ultimate edition only) and lombok functionalities. Hope that if they change it to become extension-based like VSC, they also would provide extensions to support java, spring boot and lombok in similar ways.
Don't really quite like the VSC's vscode-java, spring boot tool and lombok extensions.
0
May 24 '22
Hostile and backlash reaction is inevitable for a huge redesign of a beloved program and professional tool that has a long history. I pretty much guarantee Jetbrains 100% expected it. People will complain loudly for a while, then eventually stop and nobody will care.
6
u/istarian May 24 '22
They’ll care if and when people cut them off from the flow of $$$, but otherwise probably not.
5
u/metalhead-001 May 24 '22
When they remove features like vertical tabs, they NEED to be called out. Why would I pay for a product that they are making WORSE?
2
May 24 '22
Disable tabs and use CTRL+E.
3
u/metalhead-001 May 25 '22
That maintains files in order of most recently viewed. I want a static list and not have to hunt around constantly. It is not a replacement for vertically stacked tabs.
→ More replies (1)1
-9
-10
u/N0xxi0us May 24 '22
I disagree with almost everyone here and actually like what I'm seeing from the new design ! They streamlined the UI and it feels simpler, less cluttered
-2
154
u/Straitstan May 24 '22
No please no