So I was breaking my head over the whole issue regarding which case for my iPad Pro and finally came up with a solution that works for me, for whatever that’s worth. My iPad isn’t really a MacBook replacement, I have two other MacBooks. I do however, work in a creative field, and love being able to type in it when I suddenly get an idea, but I use it a lot as an iPad, i.e., to read, to watch videos, etc and I really don’t want the Magic Keyboard attached to it all the time.
First, I bought the Logitech case because I thought, perfect, it can detach. Big mistake. It totally sucked for me. The touchpad was so sensitive that it made it impossible for me to type. I think that it’s probably less of an issue if you use it on a desk but I’m often using it while on the couch or in bed, places a person uses an iPad instead of a laptop. So whenever I tried to type with it on my lap, it just was a disaster. I tried everything— changing the settings in all the menus, using raised ergonomic palm rests on either side of the touchpad, disabling the touchpad altogether (didn’t manage to do that)— and nothing worked for me.
So I actually gave up on typing on my iPad Pro for a while but recently came back to the idea. Looked into the ESR case but it’s so heavy and I travel all the time, I can’t be dragging that extra weight around.
I finally sprung for the Magic Keyboard, which was completely amazing. I should have bought it from the beginning. It works perfectly in every situation and doesn’t cost a whole lot more than the Logitech, and it’s light. HOWEVER, I had the same issue which had stopped me from buying the Magic Keyboard in the first place — I can’t detach the iPad and have any protection on it and I don’t want to be putting my iPad in and out of another case all the time. Also, the pencil falls off all the time when I’m putting it in and out of my bag, etc.
I’m really not okay using my iPad without any case on it whatsoever because I know I’ve cracked the screen on my iPhone multiple times and it’s only the tempered glass screen protector that’s saved me.
So I got the Mageasy case and it’s great, esp love having a place to put the Apple Pencil, but indeed, the problem is that I also have a tempered glass screen protector on my iPad. Like everyone else has said, the Magic Keyboard won’t fully close when you have anything extra on the Mageasy case but I’m not willing to take off the tempered glass.
Finally, I did this crazy thing. When I’m done using my Magic Keyboard with Mageasy case on the IPad, I put it down “upside down”, meaning that the flap that closes the Magic Keyboard with the keyboard on it is underneath the iPad itself. The weight of the iPad keeps the case closed. For me, this works. In my bag, there’s enough other stuff to keep the lid on.
When I want to use the iPad to read, etc, I pull it off and it’s protected with both the Mageasy case and a tempered glass screen. So I’m happy and hope this helps other obsessive folks like me.