How many times are game developers going to trudge down the same old path leading to the same old cliff, and fall to their death?
The fact is that game developers (as a collective group) don't learn, they just keep on making the same mistakes, over, and over, and over. Sure, it's always different faces making different games, but they all make the same mistake, and they all go through the alpha/beta/whatever phases, and they all get bored (or run into budget or family or career or whatever problems), and they all try to add some sort of mod support to keep the game alive, and it never does stay alive, and then they all die.
So, let me ask what I came here to ask:
What do you think things would have been like if Dwarf Fortress was designed as client/server; with an (extensible) open networking protocol between them?
You'd have the original "text" user interface (with a rich engine on the server side) and a lot of people complaining because they want fancy graphics; but by now someone would've written a new alternative client and provided fancy 3D graphics, and it'd be awesome.
What do you think things would have been like if both Gnomoria and Dwarf Fortress were designed as client/server; and both used the same (extensible) open networking protocol between them?
Yeah. Mix and match. Want to run Dwarf Fortress' client with Gnomoria's server? Fine. Want to run Gnomoria's client with Dwarf Fortress' client? That's fine too.
What do you think things would have been like if StoneHearth, and Rimworld, and Towns, and Gnomoria and Dwarf Fortress, were all designed as client/server; all with the same (extensible) open networking protocol between them?
Yeah, now you're getting the idea: mix-n-match all over the place. 5 clients and 5 servers would've meant 25 possibilities for gamers to drool over. One game developer decides to stop work on something, and it doesn't matter too much because there's more game developers still working on newer/different servers, and newer/different clients; and building on what their predecessors provided, and being awesome.
The thing is, writing a game is hard; and writing a game by yourself is much harder; and actually making profit is almost impossible. Some people are really good at things like path finding algorithms, and some people are really good at graphics, and some people are really good at creating artwork, and some are good at marketing; but "almost nobody" is good at everything.
With an open networking protocol; developers don't need to write a whole game. One developer (or one team) can write a new client (and not write a server at all). One developer (or team) can write a server (and not write a client at all). Some of the clients would have mods (with different textures, meshes, shaders, whatever). Some of the servers would have mods (with different races and items and workshops).
It'd become a big swirling, throbbing and thriving mix-n-match orgy of awesome.