r/InformedTankie • • Apr 28 '21

Don’t carry water for fascists

Post image
897 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Sep 07 '20

Debunking Thought this was a good infographic on some of the common misinformation surrounding China

Thumbnail
gallery
820 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Oct 05 '21

MEME Reddit in a nutshell

Post image
725 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Dec 29 '20

Eastern Bloc based

Post image
713 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Apr 03 '21

MEME Based Russian TV?

Thumbnail
gallery
656 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 28 '21

the West NO I DON"T THINK I WILL

Post image
640 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Nov 23 '22

the West Mask off moment from White supremacists

Post image
594 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jun 17 '20

It Took...

Post image
561 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • May 28 '23

MEME tankies

Post image
553 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 14 '21

Statistics on Gulags

Post image
526 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 13 '20

Bolivia No title. Just a solid take.

Post image
517 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 19 '20

Vaush is, and I can’t stress this enough, so dumb

Post image
514 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 14 '21

Memorial of the victims of capitalism in Dublin

Post image
513 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 09 '21

Debunking On Stalin's alleged sexual assault of a 13 year old girl

513 Upvotes

Have you lot heard the one about Stalin r*ping a 13 y/o girl? The Vaushites love this one. I think cause it's so obscure no one's yet debunked it.

So I looked into it out of curiosity.

But it's all apparently based on the conjecture of one 'historian' Simon Sebag Montefiore. He's what's known as a 'pop historian', a historian who makes books for middle aged white men who want to seem smarter than they are, sort of shit you see in Barnes and Noble/Waterstones or wherever.

He's also the guy who labelled Stalin the 'Red Tsar' for one of his books and a sensationalised, romanticised history of the Romanov family.

He wrote about this in a book called 'Young Stalin'. He then advertised the book in two right wing British newspapers:

https://www.standard.co.uk/hp/front/stalin-and-his-lover-aged-13-6581841.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-454291/Stalin-lover-aged-13.html

You'll notice that both articles are completely unsourced and written like prose. Its more like Montefiore's bad fan fiction than anything else.

So I read the book itself, though just the section which he calls the 'Arctic Sex Comedy'. So guy wants to condemn Stalin for rape but it's a comedy? Even more icky is the line where he talks about how girls are 'more nature's for their age in Siberia.

The book in question: go to Chapter 34

He makes more or less the same points as in the two articles. But I was more interested in a direct source and quotation.

There is direct quotation of the girl in question's later memoirs, none of which infer any rape or even romance. But from this Montefiore imagines his own story.

He cites a statement by KGB head Serov that supposedly confirms the story but there is no actual reference to this document in the bibliography, nor an image of the document in question. The only direct quote from this source is: “J. V. Stalin started living together with her.”

And we know the two were indeed living in the same house so for all we know, this is just Serov confirming what we already know and not really any romantic/sexual relationship or even one of victimhood.

Montefiore is a historian without any sense of academic integrity. He writes sensationalised books for the sake of profit. And this is the basis for this new anti-Stalin meme, based on old anti-Stalin rumours. No one should take this man seriously, ever. Hell, have you seen which publications he chose to advertise his crap in?

I don't believe in deifying or canonising Stalin. He was man, a human being. He made plenty of mistakes during his career. But he did plenty of good also. Make legitimate critiques of the guy, this tabloid-esque smearing is intellectually dishonest.

And beyond this, the reactionaries who usually don't give a fuck about r*pe charges will be more than eager to condemn me and anyone else for not believing it was r#pe, call my a hypocrite for being a vocal supporter of metoo but dismissive of baseless charges lobbied against Stalin by someone who isn't even the alleged victim. But then reactionaries do what they always do, say anything any everything they can to try and win an argument regardless of how contradictory it is. They shout the loudest, say the most inflammatory things they can and think that helps them win.

But it's important that we put this information out there to counter their misinformation. Doubt it'll ever convince Vaush and sycophantic liberal mob but it's out there, don't give them quarter to use their propaganda against us.


r/InformedTankie • • Mar 21 '21

Touch grass

Post image
503 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Apr 15 '21

PR China Free

Post image
498 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 11 '20

Photo Two cool dudes

Post image
482 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jan 04 '23

USSR A Ukrainian organizer of the Holocaust was later assassinated by the ussr by being sprayed in the face with a poison similar to the one used in the gas chambers

Post image
471 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jan 06 '23

take/opinion my comrades, we, we are based

Post image
468 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jun 25 '25

News Is Mamdani the first real major American socialist elected in decades?

Thumbnail
gallery
459 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Oct 12 '20

Comrades, sometimes it is easy to forget but no matter how infuriating people can be at times, whether they are Right-Wingers, Liberals, Anarchists and everything in-between, they are all working class and we must always remember

Post image
451 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 17 '20

Choose your adventure.

Post image
451 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Dec 05 '20

meme Mao Quote of the day, taken from "A STUDY OF PHYSICAL EDUCATION"

Post image
449 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 17 '21

UN Nation's stance on China's Xinjiang Policy 【 Spot the Muslim World 】 🌐

Post image
445 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Dec 25 '20

meme Some wishes never change

Post image
442 Upvotes