r/InformedTankie • • Jul 28 '20

PR China [URGENT, HELP NEEDED] Debunking John Oliver's Video on China & Uighurs With Video Rebuttal on My Channel

15 Upvotes

Hey, everyone, its BayArea415, and I want to make a video rebuttal against John Oliver's segment on China & Uighurs

It is no secret by now that John Oliver publish an incredibly inaccurate portrayal of Uighurs in China, that is filled with already debunked Westernize propaganda

ENOUGH IS ENOUGH. I slogged my way through this and want to create a debunking/reaction video to shut this Liberal Western lapdog up. To do this, however, I need this community's help.

I have made a list of points from John's video that must be debunked and I know there is information out there that shuts down each and every point made. I want to publish this video in 24 hours, so if anyone can provide any sources to debunk these points PLEASE COMMENT OR MESSAGE ME BELOW.

Point 1: 1,000,000 Uighurs are rounded up and forcibly detained, the largest detainment of religious minorities since the holocaust.

Point 2: Uighurs are being forced to work and make masks for China to ship to Western countries

Point 3: Uighurs had an uncomfortable relationship with leadership in Beijing, particularly because of some "Han Supremcy complex" (particularly that 2008 video of that one woman calling them "robbers")

Point 4: Chinese state TV "censored" burqas using cartoons

Point 5: The "riots" in the capital that killed 200 people in 2014

Point 6: Using terrorism as an excuse to surveil Uighurs

Point 7: Background on Dr. Adrian Zenz

Point 8: Background on Sophie Richardson, China Director of Human Rights Watch

Point 9: China's "predictive policing system"

Point 10: Throwing Uighurs in "camps" for "growing a beard"

Point 11: "Classified documents for the Chinese Government"

Point 12: "Former detainee interviews"

Point 13: Forced abortions and sterilizations of Uighurs

Point 14: Banning religious practices like going to Mosque, banning baby names, etc.

Point 15: Destroying Uighurs cemeteries

Point 16: Mass labor transfers of Uighurs

Point 17: Australian Think Tank ASPI (Australian Strategic Policy Institute)

Point 18: Woman being separated from her family.

For streamline sake, I would like to ask those to comment in the following format: "For Point X, see [link, article, source, etc.] and provide brief description." For instance:

Point 4: [Link to show] Episode of show in question actually shows several clips without cartoon, and is only being playful, funny, etc.; also here are other clips in Chinese media with women wearing burqua.

If there is any more points that you would like to add, please do so, and thanks comrades for your help. I will be writing and filming as I write and review all your response!

Edit: Thanks so much everyone for these sources. I think this may take a bit longer than 24 hours, but I will produce this rebuttal this week so stay tuned!


r/InformedTankie • • Jul 28 '20

PR China In light of the John Oliver Segment on China and Uighurs, Here is My Megapost Debunking Western Propaganda Towards China!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 22 '21

discussion CPB and CPUSA Voice Support for Western Occupation of Afghanistan

Thumbnail ia601501.us.archive.org
1 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Oct 06 '24

News The government of Burkina Faso is **not** socialist. Many seem to think so:

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Nov 04 '21

Time to reclaim the CPUSA for the people, the party is the heritage of the workers.

Thumbnail
zscruggs.substack.com
1 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 06 '21

Question Im new to the left wing, is Stalin considered a bi*got and fascist or what? I still support seizing the means of production, gonna age like milk.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Mar 12 '22

Question Why do ML's support Bashar?

0 Upvotes

Never understood why so many MLs support Bashar Alassad. For the most part him and his father have been authoritarians of Syria which isnt based. Also was the Syrian Civil war not a civil war, and did he not gas people? Genuinely asking and would very much appreciate futher reading on the topic


r/InformedTankie • • Jun 23 '21

The EU trample their own Charter of Fundamental Rights in their attack on Hungary.

Thumbnail self.europeansocialists
0 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Mar 14 '21

Megathread A list of communist parties by how LGBT-friendly they are (will be updated over time)

4 Upvotes

Hey comrades, it's been a while but I am back! Being a young LGBT+ comrade myself, it is obviously very important to me to join a party that doesn't just recognise but very much supports my struggle, and unfortunately there are still many ML parties out there that are either dismissive or outright hostile to LGBT+ rights. So today, I will be creating a table of all the ML parties I can find and their official/basic stances towards the LGBT+ struggle. Since there are obviously tons of ML parties out there I can't do it all in one go, but if enough people want more then I will continue to expand it. If you're an LGBT+ comrade yourself, hopefully you will find this informative!

Africa

PartyCountryOfficial stance
Socialist Revolutionary Workers' PartySouth AfricaSupportive - supports equal rights for LGBT+ people in its official party manifesto

Asia

PartyCountryOfficial stance
Communist Party of India (Marxist)IndiaSupportive - released an article in 2018 supporting the legalisation of homosexuality in India and the general liberation of LGBT+ people
MakiIsraelSupportive - officially supports LGBT+ rights and has a very LGBT-friendly youth wing

Europe

PartyCountryOfficial stance
Communist Party of Albania (1991)AlbaniaPassively hostile - vehemently upholds Hoxhaism, whose founder Enver Hoxha was known to be a staunch homophobe
Communist Workers' Party - For Peace and SocialismFinlandPassively hostile - not officially opposed to LGBT+ rights but dismisses discussion of them as liberal identity politics
German Communist PartyGermanyVery supportive - officially supports LGBT+ rights and liberation and even runs an exclusive magazine, DKP Queer, on LGBT+ figures and events in the communist movement
Communist Party of GreeceGreeceHostile - famously opposed to same-sex marriages and the general advancement of LGBT+ rights, viewing them as products of the bourgeoisie
Communist Party of IrelandIrelandSupportive - supports LGBT+ rights, particularly in its allied organisation, the Progressive Film Club
Communist Party of PolandPolandUnknown - no official stance on LGBT+ rights
Communist Party of the Russian FederationRussiaExtremely hostile - literally tried to pass a bill that would ban the discussion of LGBT+ topics in any public space; is also in general a very conservative party, opposing abortion, supporting creationism and having an anti-Semitic leader
Communist Party of TurkeyTurkeySupportive - officially supports LGBT+ rights and has published articles celebrating pride month
Communist Party of UkraineUkrainePassively hostile - unquestioningly defends every aspect of the USSR and Stalinism, making no attempt to challenge the homophobia that existed during the Soviet era
Communist Party of BritainUnited KingdomMostly supportive - officially supports LGBT+ rights though there are apparent issues with TERFs among their ranks
Communist Party of Great Britain (Marxist-Leninist)United KingdomHostile - vehemently opposes trans rights and LGBT+ rights in general, viewing them as a "reactionary nightmare", and bans anyone from the party who supports "LGBT ideology"

North America

PartyCountryOfficial stance
Communist Party of CanadaCanadaVery supportive - has published numerous articles and webinars by both the party itself and the youth wing declaring support for LGBT+ liberation; supports LGBT-inclusive sex education and Bill C-16.
Communist Party of Canada (Marxist-Leninist)CanadaUnknown, probably hostile - has no official stance on LGBT+ rights, but considering their extreme anti-revisionism it probably is not positive.
Communist Party of MexicoMexicoUnknown - no official stance on LGBT+ rights
Communist Party USAUnited StatesSupportive - has officially supported LGBT+ rights and equality since 2005
Party of Communists USAUnited StatesSupportive - recognises the need for LGBT+ equality in its official program

Oceania

PartyCountryOfficial stance
Communist Party of AustraliaAustraliaSupportive - officially supports the full emancipation of LGBT+ people in its list of policies as well as public funding for pro-LGBT+ organisations
Communist LeagueNew ZealandUnknown - no official stance regarding LGBT+ rights

South America

PartyCountryOfficial stance
Communist Party of BrazilBrazilSupportive - has a particularly LGBT-friendly youth wing

r/InformedTankie • • Feb 22 '21

As farmers expand their agitation, Indian government intensifies repression

Thumbnail
wsws.org
1 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Dec 14 '22

Debunking Reactionary Chapo Trap House Origins Debated

0 Upvotes

Major publishing industry networks and reactionary indie darlings like Taibbi and Greenwald, with their own suspicious origins, gave Chapo its popularity

Chapo friend Rob Skvarla runs cover:
https://twitter.com/PolitsturmInter/status/1603119985093709832?s=20&t=WK1UglLiUPecy6VuPSP51Q


r/InformedTankie • • Feb 21 '23

discussion My (a moron who has very little theory knowledge) thoughts on one of the roadblocks on protecting a socialist society from reemerging capitalist tendencies.

0 Upvotes

I would say argue much like Mao, from my limited understanding of Mao, that the return to capitalist tendencies is due to mainly due to an inconsistency between the cultural superstructure, political superstructure and the economic superstructure. Now don't take what i say as a fact because a lot of this is my own analysis from the limited amount of theory i know. To understand more read more theory. So here is my understanding

Society is mainly divided into 3 superstructures: Economic, Political and Cultural. Economic and Political are rather easy to define. Economic is how the means of production are organised and political are the class interests represented at the legislative realm. Cultural would the mindset of the masses like traditions, societal norms, religion etc. For an example, let's look at the US and China. Economically in the U.S, the means of production is controlled by the bourgeois and Politically the legislative powers represent the interests of the bourgeois. Culturally, the U.S has a large capitalist oriented consumer culture. So on all three fronts the U.S is capitalist and favouring the bourgeois. Meanwhile, in China, Politically China is controlled by the CPC, a communist party representing the interests of the working class with the intention of forming a socialist state and Economically, the means of production is officially in the hands of the bourgeois but with strict control from the state. I would argue China has advanced state control more in the more recent years but i would place that judgement on people smarter than me. Culturally, the idea of communism has great importance in China but once again i cannot say how that affects the values and traditions of people on a day to day basis, so i would put in a midway point as well. Basically if the cultural of the masses is not changed to a more socialistic form then there will be more reactionary tendency within the masses which inturn will cause it to affect the political and economic superstructure reverting it to a more capitalist system. Hence the success of a socialisation would be to transform the collective mindset of the people into on that is receptive to socialist ideology, at a deeper level than one derived from personal benefits. I believe education is the most effective way to achieve that i.e is teaching basic Marxist theories, perhaps in a simplified manner from a young age. But my question is that a country like the USSR despite giving the relevant education still collapsed from capitalist tendencies that emerged from the inside(agreed that external force did fuel the sparks but still). There was an emergence of capitalist tendencies arose from the the time of Khrushchev. Was the Marxist education of the USSR not sufficient or am I missing something?

Again, I am prefacing this "analysis" by saying I am a moron who understands nothing. Please go easy on me and correct me if i have made any misstatements.


r/InformedTankie • • Jun 17 '21

Cotler led Anti-Semitism Summit seeks to deflect criticism of Israeli apartheid

Thumbnail
thecanadafiles.com
0 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jun 13 '22

USA As U.S. contradictions mount, uniting the proletariat & lumpen is vital for carrying out revolution

Thumbnail
rainershea.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 13 '22

take/opinion Why free healthcare in America is a pipe dream

5 Upvotes

Let me explain it in the most simple and thorough way possible, because I am getting a lot of downvotes from neckbeards for some reason. It undermines American financial hegemony. How? Well, the trade deficit would balloon so much that it would cripple it economically by ballooning the trade deficit and reducing domestic savings, which partly finances the government and capital investment in America. Spending more on healthcare also diverts resources from other more important industries, which help reduce the trade deficit, and increases the trade deficit since the U.S. doesn't invest as much to augment its productive output to not be reliant on exports and is heavily reliant on foreign capital from abroad. Let me explain this part a little better. Let's say the government spends money, the government cannot efficiently do that at least less so than the market itself. So by spending money, it's allocating fund for the health care sector more than it would have gained, so capital and other resources allocated by this increase in capital would reduce the productive output of other sectors. We can easily see this already in America as America allocates a lot of money into its military. This is why America is significantly more dominant in military technology than civilian technology. It will also make other companies less attractive as the money and other resources misallocated by the government would have a negative impact on the attractiveness of other companies reducing foreign capital inflows. Not to mention that because of the weakening of the dollar, financing in the bond market will cost more. Also, by forcing private healthcare companies to make less profits, their ability to attract foreign capital also diminishes. The trade deficit is primarily due to manufacturing and the reason why companies don't invest a lot in manufacturing is because the profit margin is too low, but if more capital is being injected that money would fight against each other and settle for lower returns and higher risk, which means manufacturing will become more attractive and more money would be invested in manufacturing thereby reducing the trade deficit. Also, the healthcare system in America is designed to cripple Americans. By costing so much, the money that would have otherwise been spent in goods that would have led to a bigger trade deficit is spent on services that will generate little to no deficit as most of the services come from domestic sources. Doing so, forces Americans to save up more, and literally exterminate people who aren't productive enough to generate the required wealth and contribute more to the trade deficit. So a bigger public deficit, less attractive capital market for foreign capital, and a crippling trade deficit will ultimately kill American financial hegemony. This is why you should buy every dip when stocks like UNH dips 30% because of talks about bringing free healthcare to America, because it will never happen.


r/InformedTankie • • Sep 20 '21

PR China A Chinese student in Canada had two followers on Twitter. He still didn’t escape Beijing’s threats over online activity

Thumbnail
thestar.com
0 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Aug 16 '20

What is your opinion on the PRC being an AES

1 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of dengist advocating that here, using state owned media outlet, while denouncing the other way round propaganda by the western media. How can you justify the decollectivization in the PRC, rising inequalities and the loss of some Mao's deeds. Today it seems like he is more of a figure that is what Lenin described as a canonized revolutionary by the bourgeoisie.

I dont know why this post was shadowbanned, since I only asked a relevant question to gather knowledge


r/InformedTankie • • Mar 08 '23

Question Thoughts on the nato intervention in Yugoslavia and if it was justified?

0 Upvotes

Many say it was justified do to potential genocide. Thoughts on this argument and if you support this intervention?


r/InformedTankie • • Feb 03 '21

Imperialism is a system, it is capitalism and it's Monopoly stage where a few Banks and corporations control the global economy and keep the world poor so that they can stay rich.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Mar 21 '26

MEME The inconvenient truth

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jun 02 '23

the reasoning for a new philosophy: dialectic and eristic contradictions between the material and ideal and coralary regression, progression and digression of humanities socio-political-economic evolution toward or away from higher understanding

1 Upvotes

so marx was at least 66% right just like everyone else we like, right? lenin too more than definitely. the issue is i know they got things wrong, and i know you do too. all of them at best

now understand, I'm not one of your ivory tower elites, going about all nambly pambly, I'm a practical philosopher and scientific socialist. first thing is fixing our diagnostic tool, right? this all goes back to my and presumably your observation that historical materialism seems to be the best tool man has for discerning the motion of human history and the minds of man. it almost seemed like the most hard and scientific social, political and economic science we have.

the problem to be solved if we wanted to know what must be done would be in moving it closer too hard science then, right? that's what ive been thinking about and delving the outer edges of our shared history trying to find. thats where a hypothetical you or "youse guys" as i'm always calling youbcould could come in. could be interesting, might be useful and hey maybe it could even be fun, right? now lets get to painting this fence

the necessity for adding eristic contradicton and digressive resolutions to dialectical materialism

so, why would i feel the need to add eristic contradictions and digressive solutions to marxist dialectics? simple. its because marx didn't have a method for understanding destructive contradictions or what mao would call antagonistic contradiction, and mao didn't have a consistent theory for what made a contradiction antagonistic or not and how that could change over time. this may sound like navel gazing but it is literally not because if you're working with a flawed theory how are you going to accurately asses the problem and arrive at the correct solution reliably?

a dialectic implies coming together to solve opposing ideas or views. when he talked about the bourgeoisie being destroyed he wasn't talking about literally lining them all up and shooting them. nor did he think the bourgeoisie could or would metaphorically or otherwise line all the proletariat up and shoot them. this is how he thought.

i could go into this but he literally did believe that eventually capitalism would result in the inevitable defeat of the bourgeoisie over time. the reason was because he saw the proletariats numbers, control of the economy and increasing immiseration as only growing exponentially over time in one direction. that meant the bourgeoisie could only slow or regress the increasingly progressive nature of the proletariat in europe for so long because time only flows one way, not divert it like they eventually did. he didn't see how it was these societies whose bloody plunder he referred to as the free gifts of nature could themselves through their anihilation change the system they were being consumed by. this is actually how marx thought. why wouldn't he?

from our lofty perch in the future it seems obvious how and why they got it wrong but that is hindsight 20/20. so, what did he get wrong, why did he get it wrong and how could anyone have been able to do any differently considering when and where he was in time, space and and relative class?

I'm pretty sure it starts with his failure to realize he was looking at all these tiny european nations as mostly enclosed systems within a greater system called europe. he also seemed to believe that it was extracting but somehow not exchanging with the rest of the world. he did know where his "free gifts of nature" came from, it just never enter entered the equation for him. we should talk about that, right?

after that, we can talk about other stuff. first eristics, later other stuff.


r/InformedTankie • • Jan 21 '23

You Will Eat Ze Bug

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/InformedTankie • • Jun 30 '21

US-EU-Canada: A Shameless Admission of Punishing Venezuela

Thumbnail
thecanadafiles.com
0 Upvotes