r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/needachickensandwich • Feb 16 '21
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Thewickedworm • Oct 07 '20
My band just got added to Rock Band’s DLC!!
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/vulp_is_back • Jun 23 '21
Rules + Bot Info :: Why your track was removed
Provide Quality Feedback to 5 Songs Before Posting
Commenting on other peoples music is extremely important to the thread, it will inspire others as well as increase your own chances of getting feedback.
Feedback Rules:
You must give 5 high quality feedback to other members before you post your work. Comments need to be made on songs from the last few days. Going back weeks or months will not count.
When providing feedback, be constructive and acknowledge subjectivity by offering detailed insights that reflect your personal taste. If you believe the song is perfect, share what moved you and highlight the elements you loved; this not only reinforces the positive aspects of the artist's work but also helps them recognize their strengths and what resonates with listeners. If there are elements that didn't quite work for you, express your feelings clearly and subjectively while providing constructive suggestions for improvement; for instance, instead of saying, “The dry vocals are terrible,” say, “I generally prefer vocals with more reverb to add depth.” By framing your feedback as personal opinion, you foster a constructive dialogue that supports artistic growth and encourages the artist to explore diverse perspectives without compromising their own creative vision. Using AI to generate feedback will result in a ban. We ask that all feedback is written by you.
Criticism is acceptable only if it's constructive and helps the person improve their work. It should not be used for attacking or trash talking a persons work.
Do not get defensive when receiving feedback. Music is subjective and everyone has their own likes/dislikes. The person giving you feedback is trying to help you and deserves to be treated with respect.
If you post a song that isn't yours, let us know in the title. Sharing non-original music is allowed here, but let us know in the title, so that the community can respond accordingly.
Do not promo your music in the comment section of another user's post. Promoting your music in the comment section of another user's post is not allowed. Linking your music is allowed if requested or part of the discussion. Example of what not to do: "Hey this is really good, I would love it if you would check my music out too (link to music)."
Basic Civility -- Remain polite and respectful. Know the difference between constructive, and destructive feedback. If you can not think of anything to say that is helpful, move onto another song. Destructive criticism isn’t helpful, is discouraging, and hurtful.
Post One Song At A Time. Playlists go against the 1 song - 5 comment system.
AI generated music is not allowed If AI generated any significant part of the music, including the instrumental, melody, arrangement, or vocals, the submission is not allowed. Examples:
If you wrote the lyrics but generated the music, it is not allowed.
If you generated the vocals but produced the music, it is not allowed. Tools like a Vocaloid or other vocal synthesis programs are still allowed if you wrote the lyrics and melody yourself.
WARNING: If you post a spotify link that has the word "album" in it, it will be removed by the bot. You must right click the song you want to share and select the option "copy song link". This will give you a link with the word "track" instead of "album".
The Bot:
When you comment on somebody else's track, the bot gives you a hidden point. When you post your own track, it costs 5 points. You can know your score at anytime by Direct Messaging u/IndieFeedbackBot (the bot) with the word "Score" as the subject.
Note: If you send a ‘chat’ message to the bot, you will not receive a reply; You can find the message option by first going to u/IndieFeedbackBot‘s profile, and clicking the “more options” link under the chat button. Make sure to title the subject as Score; you can put anything in the message’s body. Hit send, and soon you should receive your score as a message from the bot. You can also click the following link to directly open a DM with bot: https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=IndieFeedbackBot
Questions or issues?
Feel free to message me at u/vulp_is_back with any questions or issues that you have.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Pax_Libertas_ • Mar 15 '26
Other AI generated music is no longer permitted in this community.
This community exists to support people who are actively creating music themselves and to encourage the development of human expression and musical skill. Using AI to generate music is closer to commissioning music rather than creating it yourself. It’s created for you, not by you.
If AI generated any significant part of the music, including the instrumental, melody, arrangement, or vocals, the submission is not allowed.
Examples:
If you wrote the lyrics but generated the music, it is not allowed.
If you generated the vocals but produced the music, it is not allowed.
Tools like a Vocaloid or other vocal synthesis programs are still allowed if you wrote the lyrics and melody yourself.
When AI generated music was previously allowed, the expectation was that those posting it would participate in the community by providing thoughtful feedback to other artists. Instead, we have increasingly found that many users generating songs are also using AI to generate their feedback. This results in generic, low quality comments that could apply to almost any track and do little to help artists improve.
We recognize this change is long overdue, and we appreciate the patience of the artists who make this community worthwhile.
If you see AI generated music or AI generated comments, please report them to our team. Posts suspected of containing AI generated music may be removed at moderator discretion.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/rkven9aj • Nov 11 '20
Considering it's not promoted anywhere but this sub, and averaged less than 10 listens a day, this makes me nervous...
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Pax_Libertas_ • Jun 04 '20
We believe there is no place for racism. Our differences fuel our strengths! IMF stands behind the fight against racism.
"There comes a time when silence is betrayal." "Our lives begin to end the day we become silent about things that matter." "In the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends." "Only in the darkness can you see the stars." - Martin Luther King Jr
Today and every day, Black Lives Matter.
Want to help protesters? Donate to one or more community bail funds
Donate to Black Lives Matter: You can find the main donation page here.
Get involved with your local BLM chapter: The full list is here.
Or start your own: More info here.
Donate to a bail fund: Some Twitter users are crowdsourcing lists of local organizations that help bail out protesters who get arrested. Thread here.
Or another bail fund: This crowdsourced Google Doc of bail funds keeps getting bigger.
Support the National Police Accountability Project: This group, a project of the National Lawyers Guild, helps people find legal counsel. More info here.
Support Campaign Zero, a police reform group that has been working on policy solutions “informed by data and human rights principles.” More info here.
Sign a petition: Civil rights group Color of Change launched a petition asking that all the officers involved in Floyd’s death are brought to justice. Find it here.
Or another petition: The “Justice for George Floyd” petition on Change.org already has 8.5 million supporters. That sends a big message. Find it here.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Kittens_R_Jerks • Feb 06 '20
Today marks 1 year of amazing music and community, to celebrate we are holding our first Annual 2020 Indie Music Feedback Birthday Grammy Awards!
2020 Indie Music Feedback Grammy Awards!
Song of the Year: Tomer Krail - Quadropede
Female Vocalist of the Year: Brianna Barnhart in Sun Might Set
Male Vocalist of the Year: Luke Chiang - Used to Me
Music Video of the Year: Isla - Kids Like Me
Best Rock Song: Sherwood Forest - Glow
Best Pop Song: C.HAOS - Y.ou
Best Metal Song: Zaru - Eye Of The Storm
Best Singer-songwriter Song: Aaron Lindsay - Hide & Seek
Best Indie Song: Tyler Quehl - Connection pt. 1, Limitless
Best Folk Song: River roots - Bare Feet
Best Jazz Song: Fuzen, Kate Burns - Dystopia
Best Lofi Song: Soran Leif - Wistful Nostalgia
Best Dubstep Song: BLCK WLF - Sea of Glass
Best Drum & Bass Song: Aethereal Assassin - V.H.S.
Best EDM Song: Pete Barta - Mega
Best House Song: BobaBoi - Open On Acid
Best Techno Song: Sharp Sevens - Moonshine
Best Future Bass Song: hann - Midnight
Best R&B Song: Luke Chiang - Used to Me
Best Rap Song: C’eon - Mazes
Best Trap Song: Scriptz - Nightcrawler
Best Reggae Song: Wicked Penmann - Struggle
Best Punk Song: Pelison Jetty - Pelison Jetty
Best Synthwave Song: Cru Kza - Softwaves
Best Chiptune Song: Esmajin - Electric Journey
Best Glitch Hop Song: Max Exodu$ - Don’t U Wanna?
Best Experimental Song: Thick Planet - Up With the Larks
Best Classical Song: Daniel Diaz - Pi
Best Ambient Song: Juan Maria Solare - Has the Rain a Father? (ambient guitar)
Best World Song: David M. Goncalves - SpaceErhu - V3
Best Piano Instrumental Song: Lisztlovers - Olya’s Night
Best Acoustic Guitar Instrumental Song: Lunng Fern - Chant
Sub Genre Categories
Best Alternative Rock: Tunnel Traffic - Another Story
Best Heavy Rock: King Ibex - Ballot
Best Pop Rock: Arcanum - Family Man
Best Indie Rock: Shasta Gilmore - They’re Airborne
Best Soft Rock: Jericho - Moonlit Dancer
Best Surf Rock: Beach Bomb - Dunkelheit
Best Psychedelic Rock: Sam Kruger - All Sick Again
Best Blues Rock: Crooked Fix -Troubled Eyes
Best Folk Rock: Tony Appleseed - Entropy
Best Synth Rock: CitizenEarth - Catfish Burial
Best Funk Rock: Tomer Krail - Quadropede
Best Post Grunge Rock: Phantom Noise - Shut Down
Best Experimental Rock: The Anthropophobia Project - In My Room
Best Space Rock: Cosmic Carpool - Necrophage
Best Emo: Agnes Pine - Flakes
Best Emo Rock: I Feel Better When I’m Sad - Upon Your Dead Body
Best Emo Metal: Between the Heart - You Wouldn’t Want to Drink With Me at Sea Level
Best EDM Rock: SXVR - Here Again
Best Electronic Rock: Mymodulatingheart - Fyresyde
Best Progressive Rock: A Perennial Daydream - Cerebral Surf
Best Instrumental Progressive Rock: Calm Like Rye - Restorer
Symphonic Rock: Teun Segers - Blind Faith
Best Math Rock: Lybra - Mazes
Post-punk Rock: Moonglow - Hurts Like Hell
Best Noise Rock: Flynn’s Ego - When You Grow Up
Best Punk rock: Junko Daydream - Bad
Best Electropunk: RubberDollies - Good Faith
Best Pop Punk: Harold’s Last Chance - Hit The Lights
Best Ska: Sally and the Monkeys - Liar Liar
Best Reggae Fusion: Bi Harcourt - Make Believe
Best NuMetal: Sable - Zoomers
Best Thrash Metal: Tragic Forms - Caldera
Best Death Metal: In Silent Agony - Scandalous
Best Symphonic Metal: Scarlet Desire - Cry For Your Name
Best Black Metal: Rymrgand - Broken
Best Metal Instrumental: Stefan Wenger - Dualism
Best Djent: Altered Animal - A New Place
Best Industrial Metal: Rookie - Blind Is
Best Progressive Metal: Kaiber Koi - Archaic Wave
Best Instrumental Progressive Metal: Stefan Wenger - Dualism
Post-Metal Instrumental: Darkfield Xxxviii
Best Industrial: PomBo - Defeatism
Best Folktronica: Aadams - Forever on the Fence
Best Folk Singer-Songwriter: Tomber Krail - Saturday Morning
Best Instrumental Dubstep: Freakyt - Ready for Takeoff
Best Chipstep: Merlinsyoshi - Deep Breath
Best Indie Pop: Matt Dubrow & The Captives - Waste My Time
Best Electronic Pop: Somewhat Incognito - Night Light Appetite
Best Bedroom Pop: Kahika - What You Want
Best Alternative Pop: Tom Oro - Nothing More
Best Synthpop: Kantama - Dance Music
Best Darkpop: Bae Wolf - Online
Best Drunkpop: SEB - CUTE
Best Baroque Pop: Sebastian and the Deep Blue - It’s Not the Same
Best Dream Pop: Slacker 2 - Drifting Away
Best EDM Instrumental: Char.s - Pace
Best Electro House: Harvester - Halcyon Dreams
Best Progressive House Song: Kuchi - Falling
Best Oldschool House: Rasart Records - Aftermath
Best French House: Micromusic - Friday Night...Again!
Best Tech House: Reyska - Next Door
Best Deep House: Aveiro X Liam Zeno - Guilty Tabs
Best Acid Techno:Gregory Cook - Corrosive
Best Future Bass Remix: Tankk - Sweet Disposition
Best Future Bass Chiptune: Good Doggo Licks - Your Dream
Best WestCoast HipHop: Sam Ruckus - You Aint Doin Nothin
Best EastCoast Rap: Scriptz - Golden Age
LoFi HipHop: No Legs - 100
Experimental HipHop: Aeons Elevator - HuckleBerry Smokewagon
Best Nerdcore: Deadloser - Blue
Best Instrumental Trap: Add Pattern - Virtual Reality
Best Dream Trap: PetenMusic - Vanilla Sky
Best Trip Hop: J00lz - Miles
Best Nu Disco: Chrylo - Superstar!
Best Disco: Leeveye - World
Best Country: Taylor Red - Catch Me If You Can't
Best Dark Country: Bug Martin - Dharma Blues
Best Country Rock : Matt Dubrow & the Captive - Brunch
Best Country Rap: Proper Einstein
Best Jazz song: Fuzen, Kate Burns - Dystopia
Best Jazz Fusion: LittleRaineBand - Dreamwalker
Best Blues: Emmett LaFave - Sun Might Set
Best Retrowave: Lux Atomic - When Androids Dream of Sunset
Best Darkwave: Venator - Werewolf Angels From Atlanta
Best Chipwave: Baddon & Casual Boys Mastodontic Foot
Best Darksynth: Soft Neon - The Fabulous Moolah
Best Chiptune Pop: Megan Timings - Dreaming of You
Best Chiptune Rock: Decay - Blazing Steel
Best Glitch: Tropiik - Glaze
Best Contemporary Classical: Juan Maria Solare - Has the Rain a Father? (piano)
Best NeoClassical: Daniel Diaz - To the Moonlight
Best Jazz instrumental: Pat Butcher’s Beef Banquet - Nugget to Nuggetland
Best A capella: Bad Songwriting - Floating On Glass
Best Soundtrack: Farmer George - Beach Flight
Best Downtempo: Closed Loop - Empirical Evidence
Best Electronic Instrumental: Lost Rejects - Mizu
Best Electro Swing: Jordan Dube - Bisque
Best Electro Instrumental: Harvester - Tribalism
Chill-Hop Instrumental: Nhan Synthesis - Slow Finish
Best Experimental Instrumental: There by the Trees - December Diary
Music Video Category
Best Folk Music video: Isla - Kids Like Me
Best Rock Music video: Iduna - Nosedive
Best Alternative Rock music video: Green Leather - Tiny Box
Best HipHop Music video: Dayda Banks ft. Nolto - Yellow Bricks
Best emo rock Music video: Peter Hunt & the Great Outdoors - June Carter
Best Pop Music Video: Baby Brave - Blue Skies
Best Indie Music Video: Street Joy - I’ll Be Waiting
Best Singer Songwriter Music Video: Thrillhouse - One of These Days
Best Indie Rock Music Video: S.J. Smith - Dojo Daze
Best Hard Rock Music Video: Tradgedy Channel - Can’t Hold On
Best Jazz Rock Music Video: Wavery - Plain Sight
Best Metal Music Video: Puddle head - Severance
Best Progressive Metal Music Video: Dallas Stewart - Lunchtime
Best Lo-fi Indie Surf Music Video: Goon Lei Goon -Spitting Caves
Best Indie Pop Music Video: Porkboii - Junebug
Best Animated Music Video: Pea Green Boat - Penguins Holding Hands
Best Smooth Jazz Music Video: Aqua De Beber
Best Neo Soul Music Video: Forrest Del - Rock With Me - Original Song
Best Darkwave Music Video: Big Blind - Baran
Best Experimental Music Video: The Kitchen Groove - Making music only using sounds from the kitchen
Best Electronic Instrumental Music Video: Statx - Pleadings
Best Atmospheric Music Video: Fish Basket - Fatamorgana
Best Comedy Music Video: Emmit - I’m Harder Corer Than You!
Best Reggae music video: Diplazar - Getaway
Best Spaghetti Western Music Video: One Last Ride- Laser Rey
Soundcloud Playlist: https://soundcloud.com/user-772857285/sets/2020-grammy-winners
Spotify Playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0V1PScdPTX1Xe1kR6QXrKK?si=BaUyOophToGY7wUDSpv10w
Apple Music Playlist: https://music.apple.com/ch/playlist/2020-reddit-grammys/pl.u-pMyl1KlI4X25Rpl?l=en
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Pax_Libertas_ • Aug 01 '20
July Spotlight :: There were 1,000 songs that were posted to IMF this month. I listened to every one of them and picked out a few of my favorites.
Hey guys, here is my monthly spotlight! As usual I found a few hidden gems that I would love to share with anyone interested. I have them separated by platform. Each platform has artists that are unique to it, but it also has some of the same ones. I hope you guys enjoy the music, and thanks for being a part of our community here at IMF! I'd like to also give a shout out to u/Inovox who joined me in listening to every song that was posed here this month, and even spotlighted 10 songs! Wouldn't it be great if on the 1st of every month, all of us posted a spotlight of our favorite music!? I would love to see more people joining in!
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/[deleted] • Dec 15 '20
Folk & Singer-Songwriter a song I'm writing about having to sleep on the sidewalk if you decide not to sell your life away to your employer. thanks for listening <3
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/saintjhill • Mar 16 '21
RnB my ex was cheating on me but instead of admitting it she called me on the phone and broke up with the line "it's not you, it's me". I wrote a song about it the next day, and a few months later it got on BBC radio, amongst other things... she was pretty mad
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Pax_Libertas_ • Sep 01 '20
August Spotlight :: There were 1,056 songs posted to IMF this month. I listened to every one of them and picked out a few of my favorites. I’d love to share them here with you guys!
Hey guys, here is my monthly spotlight! As usual I found a few hidden gems that I would love to share with anyone interested. I have them separated by platform. Each platform has artists that are unique to it, but it also has some of the same ones. I hope you guys enjoy the music, and thanks for being a part of our community here at IMF!
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Pax_Libertas_ • Feb 06 '21
Today marks 2 years of amazing music and community, to celebrate we are holding our second Annual 2021 Indie Music Feedback Birthday Grammy Awards!
2021 Indie Music Feedback Grammy Awards!
-------------------------->>>>>>>>>>>Spotify Playlist<<<<<<<<<<<<---------------------------------
Song of the Year: Dead Rituals - When The Lights Are Out
Female Vocalist of the Year: Allison Rumley
Male Vocalist of the Year: The F-Use
Music Video of the Year: usLights - Exit Scam
Best Rock: Pultixima, Barabbas T. Jones, Bug, Lohm - Driftoff!
Best Pop: Ok Feather, Flora Lin - Summer of Young Love
Best Metal: Tragic Forms - All Bridges Burned
Best Singer-Songwriter: Carlo Villa - Happy to Forget
Best Indie: Mariana Blue - I’ve Got Music on My Mind
Best Folk: Ezra Briggs - A Useless Good
Best Jazz: Daniel Diaz - Lost in the Car Radio
Best Lofi: OnlyM - Out of Time
Best Dubstep: Drumboii - Get Better
Best Breakbeat: Slick Gato - State of Zen
Best EDM: Mannech - Snazz
Best House: Vosakiz - Rave Your Soul
Best Techno: Machine PNG - Whirlwind
Best Trance: JMesa - New April
Best Future Bass: Matfroninja - Ruin Us
Best RnB: Junejam - tired eyes
Best Rap: Moon Crab - Elevate It
Best Trap: Fried Monk - Welcome
Best Reggae: Jake Mare - Teach Yourself to Love
Best Punk: Fuck yeah, Dinosaurs! - (I Don’t Wanna Go) in the Museum
Best Synthwave: The Mad Prophet - Fallen Angels(intro)
Best IDM: Murr - Eversleep
Best Chiptune: Mitch Werth - Adventure Island
Best Funk: Ryan Laluna - Vibes
Best Experimental: Chris Laguna - Tree Line
Best Instrumental: Felknia - Angel of Dance
Best Country: Matt Dubrow & the Captives - Travel Lite
Best Downtempo: Deadpanned - Ginseng
Best Trip Hop: Latch - The End
Best Alternative: Toby Bradner - Melancholy
Sub Genre Categories
Best Lofi Folk: Venus in Ferns - Ghost
Best Folktronica: Savera - Landfill
Best Folk Singer-Songwriter: The Slow Defeat - Water
Best Indietronica:Le1 - The First Sunlight
Best Indie Folk: Emma Guzman - Strawberries
Best Jazz Fusion: Sam Rowan - Sun
Best Alternative RnB Oceya - Mud in My Shoes
Best Experimental Jazz: Fax Bot - Devious Steve
Best Acid Jazz Tag Lee - Power Over
Best Chillhop: JW NoT3s - The Journey
Best Chill: Nado - Lost In The Clouds
Best Deep Techno: JMesa - Back View
Best Future Beats: Murr - Jammed and Stuffed
Best Electro: Teddy Girl, Latch - Electro Veins
Best Melodic Dubstep: Matfroninja - Keep On Running
Best Drum & Bass Song: Aphire - Altair
Best Big Band: Big Beat Jazz - I Wanna Talk with You
Best Glitch Hop: Baaz - Diary Of A Cephalopod In Crisis
Best Pop Punk Song: Dead End Job - Autumn Tree
Best Indie Pop: JYLDA - Serene
Best Synth Pop: Nodotmad - Wrong Things
Best Experimental Pop: Becomestrange - Hearts in the Right Place
Best Dance Pop: Kami - New Things To Love
Best Electronic Pop: Andrew M - Moments
Best Folk Pop: Lisa Akuah - Dancing Trees
Best Bedroom Pop: Longhairedjoe - What I Want
Best Alternative Pop: LOHM & Flora Lin - Unforgettable
Best Acoustic Pop: Watluxid - Universe
Best Dream Pop: Dead Rituals - When The Lights Are Out
Best Future Pop: Aiden - Change
Best Psychedelic Pop: Sympathy Wizard - In the Morning
Best Bitpop: Neko Vader - Playing My Phone Games
Best Hyperpop: Gutter Punk - Up2Me
Best Dark Pop: Sintia - In Cold Blood
Best Baroque Pop: Somewhat Incognito - Hey There Lurker
Best Synth Rock: DHXP - Solitary
Best Alternative Rock: The F-Use - For the Love of God
Best Electronic Rock: PomBo - Mannequins
Best Soft Rock: Pultixima - Pot of Frogs
Best Heavy Rock: The Modern Flowers - Methanol Poisoning
Best Surf Rock: Sunsurfer - Tye Dye Sky
Best Progressive Rock: Ray of Creation - Synagogue of Satan : Rev 2:9
Best Industrial Rock: Vas Provatakis - Defective
Best Post Rock:The Anthropophobia Project - My Wall
Best Pop Rock: BEES! - Life Coach
Best Indie Rock: Dispirited Spirits - Negatives of the Moon
Best Acoustic Rock: Dan Barracuda - Web
Best Acoustic Fingerstyle: Herder of Mammoths - By The Window
Best Grunge: Fawner - Melt
Best Alt Grunge: yeah, sure - hot brains
Best Post-Hardcore: Pinton - Prehabilitation
Best Industrial: Boy Deluxe - Bait
Best Progressive Metal: Framing Skeletons - The Beggar and the Leech
Best Death Metal Song: LÝSIS - Hollow Screams
Best Symphonic Metal:Antediluvian Projekt, Flora Lin - Highjump
Best Symphonic Metal Instrumental: Sonic Catalyst - Creatures
Best Darkwave: Drone Fields. - The Waters Above
Best Retrowave: Decay - Detected
Best Future Garage: Zsirk - Fall In Space
Best Nu Disco: Leepstick - Forever
Best Piano: Stephen Rodgers - Path Tred by Lovers
Best Urban Breaks: Soul Propane - Vagabonds of the Dancing World
Best New Wave: Landecho - Anxiety
Best Ambient: Chaloupe - Let Me Dream
Music Video Categories
Indie Pop: Dream People - People Think
Pop: Emma Halpin - On a School Night
Best Folk Pop: Lisa Akuah - Dancing Trees
Best Dark Pop: Sintia - In Cold Blood
Best Indietronica: Le1 - The First Sunlight
Best Indie: Marlon Chaplin - Weights + Feathers
Best Indie Folk: Emma Guzman - Strawberries
Best Old Time Music: A.P. Rodgers - Close Your Eyes
Best Soundtrack: Addie - le Port de la Gare
Best Claymation: Thrillhouse - One of These Days
Best Folk Singer Songwriter: Priscilla Hernandez - You Are Home
Best Pop Punk - Dubby Mac - What’s So Tough About Love?
Best Industrial: Boy Deluxe - Bait
Best Dark Pop: Marza Panther - Nite Sweats
Best Indie Rock: Sanya N’Kanta - The Hard Lesson
Best Pop Rock: Symon Marcus - Too Little Time
Best Irish Folk: Tir Nan Og - Shaun O’Malley
Best Electro: Drooling - Boyfriend
Best Alternative Rock: Tasting Colors - Home
Best Grunge: Fawner - Melt
Best Rock: Frozen Factory - Fantastically Incorporated
Best Progressive Metal - Framing Skeletons - The Beggar and the Leech
Best Progressive Rock: Ray of Creation - Synagogue of Satan
Best World: Phalgunn Maharishi - Faith Hope & Love
Best Alternative: usLights - Exit Scam
Best Jazz: Folland Music - Worlds Apart
Best Dream Pop: Same Eyes - Forever
Best Synth Pop: Dog Daze - Lost my Keys!!
Best Trip Hop: Freeda Beast - My Hometown
Best Urban Breaks: Soul Propane ft PSYCH - Vagabonds of the Dancing World
Best Art Pop: Oceya - Rêveries
Best Big Band: Big Beat Band - Sensitive Woman
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/I_enjoy_hats • Oct 04 '20
Acoustic Rock I lost my daughter three months ago. This is the first of many tracks that I’ve written for her. I know my production skills aren’t perfect but I feel like I’m improving.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '19
Don't Let Industry Ruin Music!
There are a lot of musicians out there that make amazing music!
I was searching through soundcloud, and it startles me, to hear such good music... and see that these people have very few plays on the song. In some cases I was the FIRST to listen to it ever!
There are so many promotion companies trying to actually make money off of these people! I mean soundcloud itself is trying to bring some money in on this! They approach these artists with promises of people hearing their music!
There is so much good music out there that the market has become saturated. Certain companies out there have realized that there is BIG money to be made from these artists that want to be heard.
This is a great injustice....the people that avoid that sort of stuff... go completely unnoticed.... which is a pity because their music is amazing! It comes from their heart! Not to make money, but to express themselves... all they want is for people to be interested and to listen!
Is it possible to start a community of people, that actually listen to each others music? Sure there is r/ThisIsOurMusic but check it out! There are so many posts with not a single comment or upvote.
People who promote themselves do just that! Then they leave! They have little/no interest in listening to other peoples music!
If we could change that, we could make a powerful statement!
If self promoters acted as listeners as well, we would all listen to each others music, instead of listening to the music someone paid a company to TELL us to listen to...
I created r/IndieMusicFeedback for this purpose!
Rules + Bot Info + Why Your Track Was Removed
The Rules:
---Comment on 3 posts before posting.
Commenting on other peoples music is extremely important to the thread, it will inspire others as well as increase your own chances of getting feedback! The most important thing is to connect with each other!! Please comment on at least 3 posts each time that you want to drop a track. If you want to post 2 tracks you will need to comment 6 times.
---Post one song at a time.
Playlists are difficult to give feedback on, and they go against the 1 song - 3 comment system.
Why Your Track Was Removed:
Tracks are removed automatically because you haven't commented 3 times, or because you tried to post a playlist/album.
The Bot:
When you comment on somebody else's track, the bot gives you a hidden point. When you post your own track, it costs 3 points. You can know your score at anytime by Direct Messaging u/IndieFeedbackBot (the bot) with the word "Score" as the subject. To receive a point, you must comment on a song that is no older than 3 days. If you comment on a post that is more than 4 days old, you will not receive a point.
Note: If you send a ‘chat’ message to the bot, you will not receive a reply; You can find the message option by first going to u/IndieFeedbackBot‘s profile, and clicking the “more options” link under the chat button. Make sure to title the subject as Score; you can put anything in the message’s body. Hit send, and soon you should receive your score as a message from the bot.
I’d like to give a BIG shout out to our new mod u/merci_nurse for taking his free time to write a bot for r/indiemusicfeedback !!
Questions or issues?
Feel free to message me at u/Pax_Libertas with any questions or issues that you have.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/caydenwww • May 08 '21
Indie Rock This is about how much my roommate’s girlfriend pisses me off
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/TorkTheKingRx • Jul 11 '20
Hip-hop & Rap I’m a pharmacy student by day and a rapper by night. This is my first official release, with more to come soon! King Rx // War on Drugs
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/ParaShift77 • Sep 27 '20
Other Mixing Engineer offering free mixing feedback on your song
I specialize in rock, singer songwriter, pop, folk, alternative, and psych. Post/message your links and let me hear what you've got! I'll be as honest as possible! And give this post a like :)
Also, I'm looking to expand my mixing/mastering portfolio. If you're interested, reach out to me and let me know what you're looking for.
Mixing portfolio: www.danbarracuda.com
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Kittens_R_Jerks • Feb 19 '20
A friendly suggestion from your mod team: When someone comes to your post, and leaves you well thought out feedback, that they clearly took a long time to write, don’t just say thanks and move on. Make a connection with that person! The most important thing is to connect with each other!!
Ask that person directly if they have music that you can listen to. Or, likewise, check that person’s profile, find the music they posted to Indie Music Feedback, and return the favor. You will still be granted your point, and you will likely make a new friend. Next time you see that person out in the wild, be sure to listen to their music. Over time, you will make many connections. But you have to give before you can take. If you just go around never caring about the people who took care of you, then you won’t ever build meaningful connections here.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/downhillparty • Nov 30 '20
Indie Untitled Song - my first upload on here, really looking to get some feedback to know if anyone would actually enjoy listening
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/needachickensandwich • Dec 31 '21
Rock The F-use - It's Not Over "Live Demo" from my house, going to work on a studio version soon :)
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/Pax_Libertas_ • Jul 20 '20
Feedback Rules Updated :: You don't have to be an industry expert to give useful feedback.
We ask that everyone here is as constructive with feedback as possible. Feedback should give detailed information on how the user can improve their work to produce a better overall song. We are a community of musicians here to help each other. If you have no intentions of participating beyond posting your music in order to get a listener count up, you will not be permitted to post in this subreddit anymore.
What did you like about a song? Why did you like it? What didn't you like? How can they improve the song overall? You don't have to be an industry expert to give useful feedback. We all are here because we love music and it started with us listening to it. We listen to it because we enjoy it. We all have likes or dislikes. The key point and what helps the most is being specific as to why we like or don't like a song. If you're just starting out, you don't need to worry as much about the specifics; that will get better over time as you practice your own work and develop your ear to be better at finding the subtleties.
Be constructive with what you post. If there is something you don't like about a song, offer a possible way to fix it. Criticizing a track without a solution is mostly unhelpful and can put the person into a negative mindset about their project. Therefore being specific is so important to giving feedback as that is what will help musicians grow and learn the most. Be supportive so they can learn and grow in their skills.
A very good article about giving feedback: https://www.krisenacomposes.com/post/art-critique
On the topic of how much feedback is acceptable, while we don't expect newer producers and musicians to write paragraphs of information on someone's work, we do expect that people go back to specifics in order to help everyone get better. If there is something you'd change about a song, how would you do it? What would you personally do differently? How would you personally accomplish this? The more you give, the better you will get and the more it will reflect in your own work as it will help you develop your ear.
Feedback Rules:
You must give 5 high quality feedbacks to other members before you post your work.
Be as constructive with feedback as possible. Feedback should give detailed information on how the user can improve their work to produce a better overall song. If you think the song is perfect as is, then be sure to describe how the song made you feel and what you loved about it.
Criticism is acceptable only if it's constructive and helps the person improve their work. It should not be used for attacking or trash talking a persons work.
If posting a song, do not take criticism personally. You're looking for advice on how to make a song better. Reacting defensively is not the proper response to people trying to help you.
If you have any suggestions on how to improve this community, please let us know in the comments below.
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/ParaShift77 • Sep 29 '20
Other Mixing Engineer, with notes after listening to your songs
Hey guys - I had a great time listening to all your songs and providing mixing feedback/adjustments. It was honestly really cool to hear such a variety of different styles & sounds, and of course to see how appreciative and receptive you were to my feedback. I love this sub!
There were some common things I noticed in many recordings, both with mixing and recording. I'll address them here. Remember that there is no RIGHT or WRONG way to do things in this art - though there are "better" practices we can use especially when recording at home:
RECORDING:
Vocals: a common thing I noticed was strong sibilance, which is the unwanted high frequency buildup when a singer sings s's and t's. We can control this by not singing too close to the mic (generally, no closer than 6 inches), and even tilting the mic slightly off axis so that we're not singing DIRECTLY to the mic. High frequencies are very directional, so we can eliminate a lot of frequencies by having the mic just slightly tilted away from center to the singer's mouth. At the same time, we can avoid LOW frequency buildup by also stepping back a bit from the mic. Also, make sure that the BACK of the mic is FACING anything that's making noise in your room: AC, fan, computer noise, things like that. This will cancel it out!
Acoustic: As a general rule of thumb I like to have this placed about 7-10 inches from the sound hole, but FACING the 12th fret. This captures nice low end, but also the highs and mids since it's not directly facing the sound hole.
Bass: My general favorite way to record bass is to blend the DI (direct input) track and an amp track. DI is responsible for a huge part of the sound, including the low/deep harmonics.
Drums: The more individual parts of the kit you mic, the more control you obviously have. If you simply don't have much to work with, I recommend mic'ing the kick, and then a condenser somewhere between the kick and the snare (look into the "Dick mic" on YouTube, it's real and it's effective!). If you have more mics to work with, make sure the distance between the snare middle is the same to each OH (this prevents phasing). Room mics can go a long way. Really take the time to test out different mic positions on the snare and hi hat. It's far better to get it right in recording as opposed to try to fix a sound in mixing
MIXING:
Parallel compression: this means simply duplicating a track (let's say, a vocal). On the duplicated track, pump up a lot compression, and then BLEND this track in with the original vocal track (but not the same volume as the original track, much lower). This does a lot to make the vocal stand out. You can also do this parallel track with distortion, dramatic EQ moves, etc. I highly recommend doing this on other things like drums, electric guitars, bass.
De-Esser: this is a plugin that helps to tame the sibilance on things like Vocals that I was talking about above. Don't be afraid to use more than 1 in a track, but just be weary because too much can start to make the vocal sound like a lisp. Can also use on things like high-frequency buildups on guitars, or cymbals.
Mix Bus: This is the AUX track that all your tracks get sent to. It's sort of like your Master Fader. I recommend doing some Mix Bus EQ and Compression. EQ in the sense of subtracting (very slightly) unwanted frequencies that are in your entire mix. Be careful not to overdo it with compression - a squashed song can really sound like crap. All of these terms you can learn a lot more effectively about in YouTube videos - I learned a TON through YouTube over the years.
Panning: I'm a big believer in panning things. It adds a lot of SPACE and DEPTH to the mix. As a general rule of thumb, I like to do this:
CENTER: Snare, Kick, Bass, Lead Vocal, Guitar Solo
100% L and R: Overheads, Room Mic, guitars, keys, synths, harmony vocals
Somewhere in between: Percussion like shaker/tambourine, toms, other vox, sound effects
HPF: This stands for High Pass Filter. Sometimes it's good to put a HPF at around 100 HZ on instruments like vocals, guitars, keys, toms, overheads, rooms. This frees up a lot of LOW frequency so that more important instruments can take them like the kick and bass. Doing this adds a whole lot to the overall clarity of your mix.
That's all I've got for now. Feel free to reach out/message me for questions. Thanks guys!
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/yetanothertyler • Aug 07 '20
Music Review Hello! I listened to all of the Spotify tracks posted here in the past week and wanted to share my favorite tracks. This is a bit out of my comfort zone, let me know how I did! I want to make this a weekly thing that I do to give back to this awesome community. Keep on making music everyone!
r/IndieMusicFeedback • u/[deleted] • May 01 '20