So I was recently reading about when the Bullet train will finally be operational, and even though it is going to start from 15th August 2027, I learnt that it will only be operational between Surat and Bilimora, a mere 50km strech (roughly 10% of the total planned route). Rest of the route is projected to be operational by 2030 (originally it was planned to be operational from 15 Aug 2022). Now, I'm not blaming the government for delays, yes some fault can be attributed but a complex project like this takes time and budget overruns are common. But where I believe the government got it wrong was the route and funding structure. 81% of the initial funding of this project came from a soft loan by Japan at a very cheap rate. But the rest was supposed to be divided between the Central, Gujarat and Maharashtra governments in the ratio of 50:25:25 respectively. Most of the delays are happening in Maharashtra because of the challenging geography and lack of political will shown by Maharashtra Government. Further, the planned route is neither the busiest nor most profitable route in India. Add on to that the relatively difficult geography and higher cost of land acquisition, we can understand the delay. Involving State government in funding itself is not the smartest move since Railways are primarily under Centre and States through which bullet train pass not necessarily provides the State Government with significant benefit. Further, if we look at the future planned routes how the funding is supposed to be shared between Telangana, Andhra, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu?
Now, let's go back to 2014, when the project was first announced. Modi led BJP government came to power with a record mandate with Modi himself being elected from Varanasi. BJP won 72 out of 80 seats in UP and their win in the upcoming UP elections seemed imminent. Later in 2017, Shinjo Abe came to India and laid the foundation stone of the project in Ahmedabad. Fast forward to today, look at the crowd in trains to Bihar and Eastern UP for Diwali and Chhath and the ticket prices in flights to Patna. If instead of the planned route being between Ahmedabad and Mumbai, the route was planned between Delhi and Varanasi. Look at the political significance of the route as well as the demand. Firstly, Modi's constituency getting India's first Bullet Train. Secondly, the route being almost entirely in one State i.e. UP, BJP government would've faced litte political problems from the State Government. Land is also entirely flat between Delhi and Varanasi thus little engineering challenges would've been there. Additionally, the route itself is very busy and has one of the highest occupancy rates in India. I believe this route would've completed in it's entirety before the upcoming UP elections, especially after the belting received by the BJP in 2024 elections, the project would've become a big selling point before the UP elections. Also, the expansion potential is much better in this route than Ahmedabad-Mumbai as the route could've been expanded to Patna by early 2030s and till Kolkata by mid to late 2030s. Delhi-Howrah route itself is the busiest route in India and has one of the highest occupancy, even in premium segments.
Now, however, the project has become a long wait and the eventual inauguration on 15th August 2027 will be extremely underwhelming from what was originally planned. Yes, we will get a bullet train on our 80 years of Independence, and the media will potray this as the biggest achievement in the world, another masterstroke. But a Surat - Bilimora route after 5 year delay is far short from what this project meant when it was announced.
Edit: A lot of good points are made by people in the replies about the spending capacity and per capita income of the people in UP/Bihar. I agree, people in UP and Bihar will spend less on average than people in Gujarat and Maharashtra. However, to probe the aforesaid claim I looked into the average number of daily flights between Mumbai and Ahmedabad, their average price throughout the year and average occupancy rates and compared the same with Delhi-Patna route. To my own surprise, the average number of daily flights between Delhi-Patna and Mumbai-Ahmedabad is around 16. The average occupancy rate is also about the same at about 85%, but the average price between Delhi and Patna is considerably higher at around ₹6500-₹8000 as compared to Ahmedabad-Mumbai route which is at around ₹4500-₹6000. Now, neither my research is foolproof nor both the routes are same, and in the post I've mentioned Varanasi not Patna, but my first argument is simply that in Delhi-Varanasi route, expansion opportunity to Patna and then Kolkata is much better than Ahmedabad-Mumbai route. But more importantly, my second argument is that the route iself would've been cheaper and easier to build as it is in one state only and on an entirely flat land unlike the Mumbai-Ahmedabad route which faces both political as well as geographical challenges, and at the same time would've a better expansion opportunity to Patna and Kolkata as the expansion will also lie on majority flat land, compared to Mumbai-Pune expansion which will have to cross the difficult ghat section and Ahmedabad-Delhi expansion which will have to either cut across or circumvent Aravalli or Vindhya ranges and will be more expensive to build.