Picking out vehicles was incredibly easy for me: I'd get some opinions, take a test ride, transfer the funds, and voilΓ , I'd be riding it home. Iβve never second-guessed a vehicle purchase.
I'll be brief; I'm in the market for an adventure motorcycle. The requirement was pretty simple; I want a 40 bhp motorcycle that could basically do everything, but I do not want something too committed. A jack of all trades, but doesn't need to be a master of anything.
It needs 40 bhp at least. This was a powerband I'm immensely familiar with.
It has to be an ADV.
It should be able to comfortably hold triple-digit speeds for hours on end.
India has bad roads; I want something that can tackle them with ease. That being said, I do not plan to go hunting for it. So no Enduro Trails for me.
Pillion only for city circuits and commutes.
Naturally, I have shortlisted the following.
KTM Adventure 390 (350)
KTM Adventure 390 X
Royal Enfield Himalayan 450
Confusion 1 - No Replacement for Displacement?
In my region, the 390X is about 90k above the 390. I have taken extensive test rides on both (thanks to the dealer), and the motorcycle is pretty much identical in how it behaves, except for a noticeable mid-range punch that too fades rather quickly. It even shares the same gearbox and gear ratios. 398cc variant also has a bit more vibration at higher RPM, which was a huge letdown for me.
I'm paying 90k more for a bit more oomph and a lot more vibes. Is that a good deal? I'm not so sure. To me, if you want the 398cc, you'd need the Adventure R or S.
Is that the consensus? Am I truly missing out on the 398cc unit?
Confusion 2 - Addressing the Elephant in the Room
I consciously placed the Royal Enfield Himalayan 450 at the bottom of the list because it's an obvious, default choice for someone with my requirements. It's so obvious that I'm getting bombarded with reels on Instagram about it, and as I'm writing, I saw a YT recommendation of Richard Hammond riding a Himalayan 450 when introducing his daughter to motorcycles.
It's about 15k higher than the 390; it roughly makes the same power, but provides plenty of torque. It is heavier, and it does not attempt to hide it. The suspension, I think I have never come across a better one. Fantastic.
It felt like: tamed and forgiving. It's not exciting. While the KTM has an ocean full of electronics, this one does have a beautiful TFT console, and that's about it. In the end, it all came down to the characteristics; even with a downsized engine, riding KTM did put a smile on my face.
How badly am I going to miss this suspension setup if I chose the 390?
Confusion 3 - Lesser of two Evils.
I never had a good experience owning Enfields. The Classic 350 (UCE) was always plagued with issues. I got it because I had a peculiar hunger for a retro cruiser. The Himalayan 411 also left a bad impression. Super poor tyre life, magnetic coil issues and braking issues all made it a very unreliable riding partner.
My KTM 390 ownership was also not uneventful. The coolant got mixed with engine oil about two times, and it required a complete engine overhaul at only 20k kms. But it never had a problem after that. The service centre team was incredibly helpful, and I never thought twice before taking it up for a ride after that incident.
This experience has definitely affected how I'm thinking about investing in another Royal Enfield. But is this fair? Considering how much Royal Enfield has evolved since then?
TLDR;
Looking for a ~40 bhp all-rounder ADV that can cruise comfortably at triple-digit speeds and handle bad Indian roads (no hardcore off-roading). Shortlisted the KTM Adventure 390 (350cc), Adventure 390 X (398cc), and RE Himalayan 450.