Disclaimer up front: I am a F2P developer, and specifically of a few idle games. So obviously I'm biased.
TL;DR: "Greed" is very different from making incorrect, ill-advised, or unethical decisions. So I encourage people to be careful with their word choice and instead really identify why something is "bad" instead of writing it off as simple "greedy". :)
============================================================
I know this sounds like a butt-hurt developer reacting to [ https://www.reddit.com/r/incremental_games/comments/grbmjs/wild_west_saga_forcing_players_to_watch_a/ ], but I hope you think it's worth discussing. There has been a trend to refer to F2P devs as "greedy", but it really doesn't make sense. There is nothing greedy about trying to make a living, or even trying to make a lot of money. Startup founders aren't greedy for working to have the next break out success. Bartenders and servers aren't greedy for hoping you'll tip them. Musicians aren't greedy for trying to record the next big hit. Success is a goal we all aim for, even if we measure it in different ways.
"Greed" has to do with taking more than you are due. If your startup makes millions, but you keep all the money for yourself and don't reward your employees who helped you get there, that's greedy. If there's exactly enough food for everyone to have one portion, but you decide to take two, that's greedy.
Ok ok, but why does any of this matter? Isn't it just a word? Why is this dude arguing semantics? That's another subreddit.
My problem here, outside of selfishly not wanting to be characterized as "greedy", is that it is misidentifying the problem. When you write something off as "greedy" you're ignoring the real issue, which in turn prevents productive discussion and understanding of the issue. (I could apply this to politics too, but then I'd really be in the wrong subreddit)
So if it's not greedy to force players to watch a gazillion ads to get achievements, then what is it? I'll posit it's one of two things:
A poorly-designed mechanic that provides a negative user experience.
A perfectly reasonable mechanic that looks absurd taken out of context.
Ok, let's dig in.
A poorly-designed mechanic that provides a negative user experience.
Creating a game that is dominated by ad-watching is a terrible idea. Players will hate it, they'll stop playing your game, and you'll fail. If this is the case then we shouldn't look at this as greedy, but rather as an example of a mistake in game design and then let's examine how to improve upon it or avoid it.
This subreddit is a wonderful combination of developers and dedicated players. It is the ideal place to build dialog around mechanics, including monetization, and work on optimizing them in a way that is good for players while also allowing developers to keep doing what they love doing.
A perfectly reasonable mechanic that looks absurd taken out of context.
Someone did the math in the other thread, noting that 900 ads would be around 8 hours. That does sound insane (and the image suggests the achievements go way beyond that), but context is important. The average player in these games will watch 3 - 6 ads per day. If that sounds like a lot, that's at most 3 minutes of ads. A single 30-minute TV show contains 6 - 7 minutes of ads.
The thing is, if you're really into an idle game, you could easily play it for hundreds of days and watch 1000 ads over that time. In that case, perhaps it's totally reasonable to acknowledge and reward a player for having supported the game for months by watching ads.
Now, it's true that this could be seen as "predatory" if we assume that players are so aggressively driven to collect these achievements that they would spend hours watching ads for this alone. And arguing that a mechanic is predatory is totally legitimate and I would invite exactly that type of discussion. But even predatory mechanics aren't so much "greedy" as unethical (or illegal).
If you happened to read through all of this, my point is this: let's absolutely discuss bad (and good!) designs, predatory practices, business ethics, etc. But let's try to stay focused on the real problem instead of writing it off as a character flaw of the developer. Thanks!!