Am I the only one here who was really disappointed with Mercury - Act 1? While I can agree that it is one of the most personal albums for Dan for sure, for me many of the songs sound bland, like very stripped back. I've always thought Origins was forever going to be my least favorite album but now Mercury - Act 1 has taken it over.
My biggest criticism for me is that in this new album, the instrumentals feel like a compliment to the vocals rather than having a standalone value in itself.
While most of the songs are pretty good, the instrumentals really let it down IMO. S+M had some of the most beautiful sounds and instrumentals to the point where the singing was not even necessary for it to be amazing, whereas in Mercury - Act 1 the instrumentals feel very basic, with heavy use of fake computer drums, guitar, and bass (yes in interviews Dan said they sometimes used computer generated guitars and bass). This leaves a lot of the songs feeling very empty to me, except for My Life. In S+M they did not seem afraid to have long periods of instrumentals, and produced angelic sounds in songs like Smoke and Mirrors, The Fall, It Comes Back to You. In Mercury - Act 1, I feel there is a real absence of the beautiful sounds they once had.
Lyrically, it has both positives and negatives. Dan's honesty really hits hard and is a breath of fresh air for the band when a lot of times songs did not feel like they had a meaning. On the contrary however, this does make for some basic wording and lyricism. Personally, I loved the metaphors and unfamiliar lyrics in S+M, especially in songs like Hopeless Opus, but I could understand somebody preferring the more upfront lyrics.
Critics often say that Imagine Dragons overproduce and that their songs had too much going on, but I feel that that gave it such a great sense of personality. The bird chirping in The Unknown, or the waves crashing subtly as the whistles ring in Gold, or the choir in the background of I Bet My Life, were all the band's personality ringing through their music. Mercury - Act 1 feels the exact opposite, almost like it's trying to be as stripped back as possible.
Although I still think Mercury - Act 1 is a good album, and a lot better than most other bands out there. But for me personally, it feels like a far cry from their first two albums which are the two best albums I have ever heard.