r/iitmadras • • 29d ago

Gossip/Confession/Rant Basic question!

Why is basic etiquette and mutual respect slowly disappearing from IITs? People walk into class whenever they want, cross in front of professors without even acknowledging them, disturb others while finding seats, and dont even bother greeting seniors or faculty. Is this really the new normal?
Since when did being intellectually smart become an excuse for lacking basic manners? Education without manners is just information without character. Surely, basic courtesy, humility and respect should be the bare minimum, even in the best institutions of the country.
A genuine question to seniors who graduated 10-15 years ago, was it the same during your time, or has the campus culture really changed this much? Would love to hear your perspective.

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

17

u/Stunning_Ad_2936 29d ago

HaHaHa... Such a flawed methodology of measuring courtesy...

-12

u/gainstsz 29d ago

Questioning the methodology is fair, but does that invalidate the concern itself?

8

u/Any-Profession-5509 29d ago

Until and unless they're making a thing out of it what's the problem, we're not kid anymore to ask permission for basic things pls groww up. Also i don't think randomly greeting seniors or prof is right like that's cringe, if you're in class or you're close it make sense otherwise why the unnecessary respect. Moreover many prof asks us to leave or come to the class or even cross them without saying anything and that's fine for them. Aren't we suppose to save our energy for imp stuff instead of unnecessary respect and greetings??

2

u/Stunning_Ad_2936 29d ago edited 29d ago

In ancient Egypt, it was mandatory to kiss hands, feet or hem to show courtesy to someone. For us, centuries later, it makes no sense, right? There are no 'truths' or fixed ways to be respectful; people make up their own meanings based on their preconceived ideas. That's why what you think is an expression of courtesy others find too much. And neither is 'The Truth' but simply 'human errors', as Nietzsche used to say, LoL. You are simply being a bully if you think that your way is the correct one, but being a bully is not a bad deal unless and until you get thrashed by another bully...

4

u/BathIndividual6660 29d ago

Huh, it's an IIT not a boarding school..

0

u/gainstsz 29d ago

Right!

2

u/Reasonable-Photo2850 29d ago

Professor come from real account

1

u/gainstsz 29d ago

Meet me at GC. All i can say is this

1

u/gainstsz 29d ago

Can dm

34

u/CallReaper 29d ago

Been to this and one more IIT, in both of them professor explicitly told not to stand while they come, not to ask to come in, not to ask if you want to go.

You're an adult paying fee to learn, not a schiok kid forced to learn something.

I personally also hate when a person is late and he start to ask for permission to come, ruins the whole momentum.

22

u/NailTop5767 29d ago

I don't understand OP here.

People walk into class when they reach the class. If they are late by 10 mins due to whatever reason, they can either skip the whole class or just silently enter without disrupting. People do the latter which makes more sense to me.

100s of professors in campus, do you want us to say good morning or nod head for all of them. If we go to talk to them, we greet and start the discussion.

I studied their for 5 years and never saw anybody disturbing others while finding seat if class is going on.

Greetings seniors? This looks like a 10 year old mentality. If I know a senior, I would greet him like a friend, if I don't know him personally, I won't say 'good morning sir' just because he got admitted to insti one year before me.

I don't think any of the above is lack of basic manners. I graduated last year btw.

17

u/[deleted] 29d ago • Popcorn Mindblown

Damn a prof using reddit!

2

u/Worldly-Nose-8714 29d ago

Exactly πŸ’―πŸ€£

10

u/Worldly-Nose-8714 29d ago

Take my downvote πŸ« πŸ« πŸ™ŒπŸΌπŸ™ŒπŸΌ

10

u/notsaneatall_ Student-Verified 29d ago

The profs themselves will get annoyed if you do any of this "hello/good morning" sir crap when you enter a classroom. They're trying to teach and you should have more sense than to break their train of thought.

I've personally not seen people disturb anyone to find seats, I'm not convinced that it's a widespread thing.

Wdym not even greeting seniors and faculty? In what sense? In entering classrooms? There's a class going on, they shouldn't be. Outside the classrooms? You probably don't even notice each other

2

u/chrisdutchman 29d ago

it was getting bad around the time i was there, this was 2015 ish. There are always students who are absolute pricks and super arrogant. It's always been that way and now with media hyping up IITians like theres no tomorrow its become even worse. I personally blame excessive media hype post 2008. JEE is a fucking exam for christ sake, not life. Acing that doesn't mean you are god.

1

u/BraveKnowledge04 Alumni-Verified 29d ago

Prof. themselves told not to greet them with good morning at the starting of the class, not ask may I come in, while entering. When I uses to meet prof. outside class, I used to say Hi sir, or good morning if I know he/she. Most of them are chill. About the seniors, isn't they are our friends?

1

u/ApprehensiveStay8052 Student-Verified 28d ago

Ok Boomer

-5

u/Royal-Fig-6670 29d ago

Its not a IITM problem, it is a society problem.

-5

u/gainstsz 29d ago

Expected comments! Validates. Thanks guys for the opinion.

2

u/NailTop5767 29d ago

No pun intended. Are you a PhD scholar or UG student or a professor?

1

u/gainstsz 29d ago

Beyond that.

1

u/NailTop5767 29d ago

A retired prof? An old alumni?

I must say that times have changed things a lot, specially what is normal behavior around campus. Freshers have different hostels. Senior interaction is limited in first year unless they really want to interact via fresher nights or other club events.
In fact the faculty strongly discourage even questions like saying 'I am nameless and shameless', etc.

Profs also behave around students like what modern corporate companies or startups do.
Casual attitude, friendly behavior, etc.

1

u/BathIndividual6660 29d ago

He's a prof ig πŸ’€πŸ₯€

1

u/gainstsz 29d ago

I am a student. But beyond that