r/icfpcontest • • Apr 25 '19

2019 ICFP Programming contest announced

Thumbnail
twitter.com
17 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 03 '22

ICFP Contest 2022 will take place 2-5 September

Thumbnail
twitter.com
16 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 20 '20

ICFPC 2020 writeup (warning, long rant)

16 Upvotes

This contest had a lot of great ideas and the organizers made a huge amount of really engaging content for it. Unfortunately, it was poorly executed and this was my least favorite contest of the 16 or 17 I've participated in.

The contest roughly divided into four phases:

  1. First 4.5 hours: more teaser material was released

  2. Next 20 hours: "galaxy" was released, and teams score points by completing the tutorial levels. Only four teams passed the first level of the tutorial (which involved waiting until two ships meet and then clicking a button), and only two teams passed the second level. Points earned in this round are only for the lightning round and do not contribute to final standings.

  3. Next 19.5 hours: 45 minutes after the lightning round was over, the organizers reveal that the main contest will be a tournament held between contestant's submissions. Details remain hazy except the occasional teaser picture continued to be tweeted out.

  4. Final 28 hours: organizers release an outline for the protocol for participating in the contest. Because of the scoring rules, that's less than 10 hours between between revealing how to participate and when points begin to accumulate.

The problem I had with the contest is that the different stages were mostly independent of each other. There was no way to hasten stage 1: the discord chat collectively blew through the teaser material in about an hour of work and 3.5 hours of waiting for the organizers to keep up with chat. With the release of the "galaxy" code, teams started working on writing interpreters to execute it, and only four teams got far enough to even score any points in the lightning round.

But the only value of working on stages 2 and 3 was to get a head start on stage 4 if you managed to finish the earlier stages in time. As for me, it was around T+50 hours I had a working interpreter (including gui and communicating with server, both of which are non-optional). Then when I started work on the contest itself, I threw out everything I had done and started from scratch. I would have actually done better in the contest if I had joined at the beginning of stage 4 and not wasted the first six hours of stage 4 completing my interpreter.

After finishing the interpreter, I beat the first 10 or so tutorial levels so that I had some idea what the contest was about and worked on making a dummy submission. By the time I had gotten a minimal valid submission, there were 13 hours left in the contest (including a minimum of 5 hours of sleep). Since I still have little idea of what the combat mechanics were, or even what many of the mysterious aspects of the server protocol did, it would be a waste of time to try to come up with any kind of a strategy. At that point I quit work, which was the first time I enjoyed this year's contest.

My noop submission made it to place 66 in the ranking, although by the time of the leaderboard freeze I had fallen to 79. The only way it can ever win a combat is if the opponent falls into the sun faster than it does, which presumably only happens against the other noop submissions, of which I surmise there must have been a lot.

The easiest thing to improve for this contest would have been making it plainly clear before the contest started that there was a minimum effective team size (probably 3, realistically). I would have preferred working with 2 strangers if it meant actually getting to see the content as it was meant to be seen. I bet this contest was a lot of fun for large teams that were able to make timely progress, and there was a lot of content to explore and discover for such teams.

Alternatively, just ditching stages 1 - 3 would have been a massive improvement. I still don't know why "galaxy" was delayed by 4.5 hours -- I don't think the organizers were just stalling for time because they weren't ready.

Overall, my main issue was lack of communication from the organizers. A lot of that was deliberate -- having to reverse engineer the combat mechanics was a poor decision, but not a big deal. Reverse engineering the communication protocol was just a waste of our time. Spreading relevant information out across 3 or 4 websites (which initially didn't even link to each other!) was aggravating. They had a mailing list, but never sent any emails to it. It would have been nice if they had identified themselves in discord chat from the beginning as organizers, and made it clear from the start that they would only be providing technical support instead of keeping up the faux "we're astronomers getting messages from aliens" facade. The tenor of the contest was set from hour 0 when, instead of releasing a contest spec like in most years, they released a blog post which linked to another blog post which linked to a partially completed documentation page.

I just don't get why the organizers didn't release a spec. Were they worried that the combat game wasn't interesting enough to withstand 72 hours of teams strategizing it?

The main thing I liked about this contest was that they made the submission system testable before the contest started. The submission system was solid (really, the whole contest seemed mostly technically sound) and I hope future organizers are similarly responsive about submission validation.

I think if you just forget the competitive aspects and make a personal goal of exploring the "galaxy" object, that would be a pretty feasible and fun task for a solo team taking around 48-72 hours.

Cheers to solo team Crashing Drives for helping me out in the discord chat.


r/icfpcontest • • Apr 04 '15

ICFP 2015 contest dates announced: Aug 7 1200 UTC to Aug 10 1200 UTC

Thumbnail
icfpconference.org
16 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Mar 26 '25

FYI: ICFPC 2025 Dates Have Been Announced (05-08 Sep)

Thumbnail icfpcontest2025.github.io
15 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Apr 17 '23

ICFP Programming Contest 2023

15 Upvotes

ICFP Programming Contest 2023 will be held between 7th to 9th of July, 2023. Contest chair is Aymeric Fromherz, and I(Alperen Keles) will be acting as the co-chair. Follow https://twitter.com/icfpcontest2023  and https://icfpcontest2023.github.io for announcements.


r/icfpcontest • • May 09 '21

ICFP Contest 2021 Announced

Thumbnail icfpcontest2021.github.io
15 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Aug 12 '13

cashto's 2013 ICFP contest writeup (final score: 1303)

Thumbnail dl.dropboxusercontent.com
15 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 12 '21

cashto ICFP 2021 write up, source code, and link to solver UI

Thumbnail
github.com
14 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 25 '18

Frictionless Bananas 2018 ICFP Programming Contest writeup

Thumbnail sawicki.us
14 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Mar 03 '17

2017 ICFP Contest announced, 4-7 Aug.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
14 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jun 08 '16

ICFP Contest 2016 Dates Announced

Thumbnail
twitter.com
14 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 27 '26

cashto ICFP 2026 contest writeup

Thumbnail
github.com
13 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 25 '22

ICFP contest 2022 webpage is up!

Thumbnail icfpcontest2022.github.io
13 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jun 25 '19

cashto's 2019 ICFP contest solution and writeup

Thumbnail
github.com
13 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Aug 08 '17

Frictionless Bananas 2017 ICFP Programming Contest writeup

Thumbnail sawicki.us
13 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Aug 08 '17

cashto's ICFP 2017 solution and writeup

Thumbnail
github.com
13 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • May 20 '14

2014 ICFP Contest Dates Announced!

Thumbnail
icfpcontest.org
13 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 11 '23

Frictionless Bananas 2023 ICFP Programming Contest writeup

Thumbnail sawicki.us
12 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • May 22 '22

Looking for organizers for the 2022 contest

Thumbnail
twitter.com
12 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 24 '20

ICFPC-2020, team Just No Pathfinding, part 3 (final)

Thumbnail
dastapov.dreamwidth.org
12 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • May 20 '20

ICFP Contest 2020 is announced ٩(◕‿◕)۶

Thumbnail
twitter.com
12 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jun 29 '19

Frictionless Bananas 2019 ICFP Programming Contest writeup

Thumbnail sawicki.us
12 Upvotes

r/icfpcontest • • Jul 17 '18

ICFP contest 2018: Are you ready?

12 Upvotes

The contest starts this weekend! Who from reddit is participating? Tell me about your team, and why you're going to win this year!


r/icfpcontest • • Jun 20 '11

atomically $ save Madoka's submission (2011)

Thumbnail
github.com
12 Upvotes