r/iOSProgramming • • Jul 05 '21

Discussion Tired of Xcode.

I don’t know about you, but I’m starting to get sick of it.

First, it’s terribly slow.

  • Opening a storyboard with a single ViewController can take over a minute, and any file I try to open will be a blank screen until it’s done loading the storyboard.

  • But then, just opening a project can take quite a bit of time.

  • Yes, SwiftUI is supposed to be better. But, personally, SwiftUI previews have only ever worked for tiny brand new projects. Then they just start failing.

Second, it’s unreliable.

  • One day it’ll open a project. The next, it’ll (take a long time and) crash trying. But opening said project via right-clicking on Xcode’s Dock icon will work. Go figure.

  • Then, suddenly, at some point while programming, all syntax highlighting will be gone, and auto completion will just stop working, plain and simple.

  • Edit 2: Also, @IBDesignable. It’s a neat idea. If only it worked reliably instead of randomly failing to render.

Third, I find it’s build time errors can be ridiculous.

  • The worst of course, is when using things like RxSwift. But I find the Combine ones pretty hilarious too, sometimes.

Fourth, it’s "refactoring" capabilities are meh.

  • When it does work, and doesn’t just take ages playing it’s accordion animation only to fail cryptically, the renaming refactoring feature will often behave like a simple search and replace, renaming properties from other classes and structures.

Last, weird bugs with more or less helpful logs:

  • Why do we have to wipe the DerivedData so often? It was almost nice and fine until we started adding SPM packages into the mix and they too were stored there. Now, after wiping those, we also have to redownload our dependencies. Yay

  • Did you know there were other folders you could clean up when stuff stops working? There’s xcuserdata in the xcworkspace, also ~/Library/Caches/com.apple.dt.Xcode.

  • And sometimes you have to reboot your Mac because somehow XCode suddenly lost the rights to write into one of it’s build folders. Don’t ask me how; I have no idea

  • Crashes / hanging forever because a device is plugged in / connected "over the network" ? Seems it’s been fixed since. But that was pretty annoying.

Anyway, sorry for the rant. It just gets tiring over time, and sharing with other people who might know that pain makes it feel better.

If anyone has solutions, you are more than welcome.

And if I’ve forgotten anything this godforsaken tool does wrong, you absolutely are welcome to chime in.

Edit: fixed format

170 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/egrimo Jul 05 '21

I think I'm a minority who absolutely loves Xcode as an IDE. I did programming with Java(Eclipse,Netbeans,ImtelliJ), Web(Webstorm,phpstorm,VScode, Brackets), Android(Android Studio)... coming all of these I still use some Web development but I LOVE Xcode. The design is my taste, storyboards(with using Storyboard References) does not take me longer than 1 minutes on my (2018 13" 8GB/512GB) MacBook Pro and it was like that on my 2015 MacBook Air 8GB/256GB model too. I'm not expert at programming but Xcode is the reason I love programming. VScode is my second choice and while I used Jetbrains tool on my school account, I don't like them that much.

4

u/ReadWriteHexecute Jul 05 '21

Honestly yeah I’m in the same court. I’ve been going back and forth between an M1 MacBook Pro and mid 2012 rMBP and even the retina doesn’t have most of these issues. I also wipe my laptops once a year before each macOS major update so maybe there’s something to be said about that? A worse experience for me was using Android studio and building out the iOS side of things and having nothing working until I rebuilt or restarted my Mac and rebuilt the cocoapods or bash/zsh bs. Maybe I need to try larger projects.