r/iOSProgramming • • Mar 17 '21

Alas, it's too much

Post image
586 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

13

u/KarlJay001 Mar 18 '21

The thing about a $70 video game is that anyone even considering that is looking at a game that was made by a professional team. I've paid about $40 for games back in the day, but I knew I was buying a game from a company that made awesome games.

When it comes to mobile apps, anyone can make one. You have over 2 million mobile apps in an ultra flooded, race to the bottom market.

The Play store is nearly 3 millions apps with hardly any rules.

The vast, vast, majority of apps will never be opened twice.

Think about that... that's your customer base telling you something. Almost every app wasn't worth a 2nd open.

Most never earn enough to pay for the $99/year costs. The app could be made by a team that spent 5 years developing it, or it could be a 10 year old in North Korea that downloaded the code from a tutorial and compiled it.

It's like a box of chocolates that has over 2 million choices made by random people from all over the globe...

2

u/MonkAndCanatella Mar 18 '21

Yeah this is pretty much my rationale for not buying apps.

1

u/Roadrunner571 Mar 18 '21

Maybe they wouldn’t be so crappy if people would pay for a decent mobile game.

1

u/KarlJay001 Mar 18 '21

Here's the deal, at this point in the history of video games, a "decent" game isn't good enough. Look at the history of video games and you see you go from 8bit, stickman games, to 1st gen AI/shooters, to games that require powerful machines.

A "decent" game isn't going to give the dopamine hit that gammers pay for. Gaming and other things are all about the dopamine hit that you get from playing. It's like a race car driver getting into kiddy car ride, it's just not the same.

There's a bit of a stand off between customers and devs... devs might need $1M to make a great product but the people aren't going to pay until the product is completed and proven... so it goes nowhere.

This is why the game market, and app market in general, is all about a very, very small percentage of shops that make almost all the money. After it's been this way for a bit, other devs just get locked out because the barriers to entry are just too high and they can't compete.

This is why the app store has millions of apps and almost nobody cares about any but a few hundred of them.

Just like the web, you could remove 1/2 the web pages on the web and hardly nobody would even know.

If I told you that 1/2 the apps on the app store were missing, how would you prove me wrong? They could ghost 1/2 of them and nobody would know the difference.

It's just the way markets work as the tech ages. Mobile is over a decade old now.

1

u/Roadrunner571 Mar 18 '21

A decent game on a mobile platform is already more than good enough. You don’t play AAA games while waiting for the bus. There are a lots of casual games that are really good, like Blek. Mini Metro or Hook are fun to play and worth the money.

1

u/KarlJay001 Mar 18 '21

IDK, it's really up to the customers. The big boys don't seem to have a problem getting people to pay, so it's not really anyone else's opinion that matters, it's the customers that are shelling out the money or not. In this case, it's pretty clear what the customers think about apps that don't come from the big boys.

1

u/Roadrunner571 Mar 18 '21

The big boys are often using evil tricks to squeeze money out of people. They get people to buy in-game currency for hundreds or even thousands of dollars and the game is often not better than some indie title selling at three bucks.

1

u/KarlJay001 Mar 18 '21

It's still the customer's choice. The indie can do the same "evil tricks" if they want to.

The market is all about competition, if the customer wanted to pay more to the indie devs, they could.

You said the games are "decent", if the customer wanted a "decent" game to play while waiting for the bus, they'd pay for it. They don't.

The customers are telling you how they feel about things based on who gets their money.

You're opinion about what the customer SHOULD do, doesn't matter, it's about what the customer DOES do that matters. and the big boys found a way to make it work.

1

u/Roadrunner571 Mar 18 '21

There is ethics. Many developers don’t want to use evil mechanics because they are not assholes.

Markets are not always perfect and games with addictive mechanics that use mainly IAP are essentially disturbing the markets. Because they suggest that games have no value. Why pay $0,99 when that other cool game is free? So they don’t buy the one time purchase game and often go to pay-to-win titles where they often will pay more in the end for shit content. Because that content will always make you want to buy IAPs and not enjoy the game.

Having said that, there are now at least some good on-time payment titles in the App Store. And then there is Apple Arcade. Which is good for mobile gaming.

1

u/KarlJay001 Mar 19 '21

This has nothing to do with ethics. People buy whatever they want, there's no force involved, it's a free market.

So they don’t buy the one time purchase game and often go to pay-to-win titles where they often will pay more in the end for shit content.

What you say is "shit content" others are willing to pay money for. It's THEIR choice, it's THEIR money, your opinion of the content doesn't matter, even if the content is "shit", they have the right to buy that, they buy that for a reason under a free market.

Because that content will always make you want to buy IAPs and not enjoy the game.

This is how they get a return on their investment of making a game that people clearly WANT to buy. Again, simple free market, the consumer has the choice, it's the consumer's money.

This is just the way economics works. The big boys end up with a HUGE share of the money, they can use this to hire more devs and buy more marketings. We saw this with King's Candy Crush, they got a HUGE share of the market.

This is just the way economics works, it's why Amazon has the growth it has and it's hard for people to compete against Amazon.

People have the choice to shop Amazon, people have the choice to buy things on Candy Crush and Candy Crush has the choice what to do with that money in terms of marketing an better products.

35

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '21 edited Jun 28 '24

escape shy offer arrest jobless capable divide dazzling icky price

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

7

u/techfreak23 Mar 18 '21

That's because the two markets are completely different. The people playing mobile games are likely not the ones also paying $70 for pc/console games. Therein lies the problem...

1

u/slowthedataleak Mar 18 '21

On top of that, there's so much "free" out there that the overall market isn't trained that spending money on mobile is the same as a $70 game. You might even say the opposite, I'm a young guy and grew up with the boom of smart phones, my parents and most peoples parents would laugh or think you were crazy for wanting to spend $0.99 on a cellphone item.

Over time this is going to change and people will become trained to spend money on their phone on software.

It's honestly a shame that I fit this "not trained" mold. I have an app that's asking customers to pay $8+tax a month...

7

u/SudoPoke Mar 18 '21

When people write an email in to complain about the 99c app not meeting his standards despite spending hours using it.

"Well I'm sorry you didn't feel you received your 99c worth of entertainment, but..."

4

u/sanchower23 Mar 18 '21

A 0.99$ mobile app with tons of ads that can not be turned off. Nah

18

u/my2kchild Mar 18 '21

Why can’t people figure out where the dollar sign goes?

20

u/BedtimeWithTheBear Mar 18 '21

On one level I agree with you, but there are many languages where the currency symbol goes after the digits.

When you think about it, for a non-native speaker, it makes complete sense - you say seventy dollars, so it’s obvious that you write 70$.

18

u/dahbaron Mar 18 '21

Blows mind how Americans will argue to the death about the month-day-year date format “because that’s how you say the date out loud”, but can’t expect the $ after the number

2

u/himzo_polovina Mar 18 '21

Never heard someone say date out loud like that. Day-month-year it is

6

u/alienith Mar 18 '21

“March 18th” sounds a lot more normal than “the 18th of March” in casual conversation (to me, at least).

Not defending month-day-year, but I do get it

6

u/Roadrunner571 Mar 18 '21

Not in my native language.

For me, it‘s „18. März“ ("18th March") today.

5

u/wiencheck Mar 18 '21

Same in polish

It’s really annoying how americans expect all world to follow their formats, maybe they don’t realize that internet is multicultural actually

-3

u/oddjobbodgod Mar 18 '21

But... that's not how I say the date out loud? If someone asked me my birthday I would say "27th of July 1993"

6

u/TruthBisky10 Mar 18 '21

Well I certainly wouldn’t.

2

u/fu_man_cthulhu Mar 18 '21

This is true.

2

u/sanchower23 Mar 18 '21

I don't know anybody paying 70$ for a game on a start, everybody is waiting for sales and discounts.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '21

More like

mobile app: $5.99/week

Personally, I would be thrilled if I only had to pay a relatively affordable fixed sum for an app, I can't bear those expensive subscriptions anymore.

1

u/CuteFattyBee Mar 18 '21

totally different experiences, it's like comparing buying doritos vs a nice meal.

1

u/cyberspacedweller Mar 18 '21

It’s all about value for money. Arguably mobile games are mostly short lived and not as entertaining. You can’t exactly attach a controller and play on a larger screen as easily or comfortably as you can a console or PC.

1

u/Balaji_Ram Mar 18 '21

Top 1% Candy Crush Saga in-app purchasers were splurging $2000 per month on in-app purchases when it was on peak.

1

u/ScarOnTheForehead Mar 18 '21

This is absolutely hilarious!!!