r/iOSProgramming • • Jun 19 '18

Airbnb sunsetting React Native

https://medium.com/airbnb-engineering/react-native-at-airbnb-f95aa460be1c
175 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

View all comments

54

u/Jublusion Jun 19 '18

The only thing I can think about while reading that article is: Job Security.

7

u/maiam Jun 19 '18

Not sure i understand..

24

u/skilless Jun 20 '18

Some people think that most devs are only proficient in one language. I think that’s a web dev mentality.

13

u/iindigo Jun 20 '18

A lot of web devs I’ve interacted seem to have zero interest in learning anything that’s not JavaScript (or draped over it, like Typescript). It’s a very foreign way of thinking for me.

12

u/KarlJay001 Jun 20 '18

I worked at one place where they kept calling me a specific programmer. It was an old Xbase language and they would never mention any other language. They were trying to keep me in a dying language.

I quit and worked for their largest competitor using a modern language.

Anyone that can program in one language, can program in another.

2

u/akmarinov Jun 20 '18

While that’s true, knowing the framework is the issue here. Everyone that can do ObjC can do Swift just as well, since it’s mostly UIKit and Foundation, but everyone that does UIKit will have quite a bit of learning to do to have the same level of knowledge of Activities, Fragments, etc regardless whether it’s Java or Kotlin.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/damnburglar Jun 20 '18

It’s an inexperienced mentality. New developers often think they can pickup one language, be good with it, and make their careers. Technically you can but you will be pigeonholed like a motherfucker.

Every good web dev I know branches out in different tech and stacks to expand their knowledge, even if they don’t use it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/KarlJay001 Jun 19 '18

React Native (and others like it) are a direct threat to native iOS devs. A native iOS dev would be Objective-C and/or Swift. If React Native were great, the job market could dry up for ObjC/Swift devs.

A LOT of smaller companies will make the argument "Big Company X uses React Native... so we should use it..."

Now the argument could be "Big Company X used React Native and dropped it... and now use Swift"

This is like when FB said "HTML5 was a big mistake"

19

u/skilless Jun 20 '18

It’s basically the same mistake, repeated.

3

u/Rudy69 Jun 20 '18

It's like they're not learning

→ More replies (2)

10

u/anurodhp Jun 20 '18

Worked for a company once which used three twenty. I think we've seen this movie before.

3

u/maiam Jun 20 '18

what is three twenty?? ive never heard of that

5

u/KarlJay001 Jun 20 '18

I think it died off back about 2012 or so. I just looked up a tutorial for it dated 2010.

That's one of the problems with getting hitched to a set of code that doesn't come from Apple. If it doesn't get updated, you're stuck.

3

u/anurodhp Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 20 '18

When iOS came out there weren't enough iOS devs so some people (FB) decided to push an abstraction layer so that web devs could make iOS apps. This was named 320 after the screen resolution (320x480) in the original iPhone. Once iOS phone screens got bigger it died a terrible death. Even FB who was pushing it dropped it and went to native iOS apps.

As an Obj-c developer one of my jobs back in the day was to take all that garbage 320 code and replicate it in native code.

tl;dr; three twenty was one of the first attempts at something like react native

https://github.com/facebookarchive/three20

https://www.facebook.com/notes/facebook-engineering/under-the-hood-rebuilding-facebook-for-ios/10151036091753920/

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KarlJay001 Jun 20 '18

Haven't heard about 320 in a LONG time. I still remember that tutorial when I started.

2

u/ZypherXX Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 20 '18

I know of a few apps using React Native that have gone under.

5

u/KarlJay001 Jun 20 '18

I would be scared to jump over to RN. Given the fact that you have to learn a new language, you might be out of the loop when it comes to using the latest iOS stuff.

Example: if you use ARKit in your app, are you sure that RN will support the latest thing as Apple keeps adding more stuff? If you can't keep up, your competitor might overtake you.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/mattroo88 Jun 20 '18

I’d much rather a native iOS dev writing react native even if he/she had less experience than a web dev guy with loads of react experience...reason being with the web dev I’d end up with a non native looking app. At least with a native dev they would know what an iOS app looks like and would more than likely come up with a native looking app.

3

u/TawaNicolas Jun 19 '18

How come?

20

u/Jublusion Jun 19 '18

Since I'm an iOS developer, React Native is a direct competition to me. As a native iOS developer, if hybrid development becomes flawless, then I'm out of a job. Airbnb (being a reputable company) quitting their hybrid development means that hybrid still has a long ways to go.

9

u/TawaNicolas Jun 19 '18

Oh yeah I kind of agree with that. I felt the same way to be honest. BUT, you can always just learn new things. 🤷🏻‍♂️

10

u/KarlJay001 Jun 19 '18

The problem with:

you can always just learn new things. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Is that it takes YEARS to be skilled at native iOS dev. It takes years to be skilled at whatever you do. Suggesting that someone toss to the side, years of work and then spend years more becoming skilled in something else... doesn't really do the problem justice.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '18

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Falconinati Objective-C Jun 20 '18

Hopefully other companies will see this. My company has been playing with the idea of rewriting our product with a cross platform tool and if they go through with it I'm quitting. I like my job for the most part, but I don't want to go through the hell of a product rewrite.

2

u/arduinoRedge Objective-C / Swift Jul 09 '18

On the plus side all these hybrid developers are wasting years on each new tech that burns out and goes nowhere. Our advantage marches onward. :D

→ More replies (3)