r/iOSProgramming • u/-QR- • Oct 05 '25
Question To implement Photos access?
App got rejected, with below reason.
i would like to inform the user before the app requests the access. How would you do it instead?
Thank you!
——-
Guideline 5.1.1 - Legal - Privacy - Data Collection and Storage
The app encourages or directs users to allow the app to access the photo library. Specifically, the app directs the user to grant permission in the following way(s):
- A custom message appears before the permission request, and to proceed users press a "Grant Photos Access" button. Use words like "Continue" or "Next" on the button instead.
- A custom message appears before the permission request, and the user can close the message and delay the permission request with the Next button.
Permission requests give users control of their personal information. It is important to respect their decision about how their data is used.
60
u/caldotkim Oct 05 '25
the default picker already does a good job explaining. tbh the way you’ve phrased it just makes it sound more sus
2
26
u/davernow Oct 05 '25
Why are you showing this at all? From the description you should only need access when I want to pick a photo. Use PHPickerViewController. It doesn’t require asking for library permission, it just lets them select photos and give you access to only the photos they select.
Broad library access is almost always a bad idea. I wouldn’t trust this dialog because it is literally telling me it is requesting more access than needed.
2
u/-QR- Oct 05 '25
Thank you very much. This looks like a much better solution. I just need to integrate it WkWebviews, which should be doable.
5
u/lwdupont Oct 06 '25
Yup, this for sure.. I am never granting permission to my entire photo library anymore with this new api. If the app isn’t using it, I don’t use the app.
1
u/egesucu Oct 06 '25
Applies for apps requesting single photo Doesn’t apply for image carousel/image editing apps that much honestly
17
2
u/Dapper_Ice_1705 Oct 05 '25
They are telling you to change the working to Continue instead of Grant
1
u/-QR- Oct 05 '25
so changing that button is all that is needed? I’d I remove that button and trigger the request on the arrow button, which is the actual continue”?
2
1
0
1
u/Esteluk Oct 05 '25
Do you use this to launch PHPhotoPicker or just to get full library access?
1
u/-QR- Oct 05 '25
Yes, and when done I show a custom message, depending on the selection the user has done.
1
u/TheSherryBerry Oct 05 '25
Has the same issue
Just change from “Grant Photo Access” to “Next” or “Continue”
1
2
u/RedditMarcus_ Oct 05 '25
based on just this screenshot, i think you might be better off just promoting for image selection every time that part of the app is used rather than asking for full photo library perms at the beginning
1
u/LavaCreeperBOSSB Beginner Oct 05 '25
They told you the issue was to replace the button with "Continue" or "Next" instead of "Grant Photos Access"
1
u/superquanganh Oct 06 '25
It's 2025, everyone has trust issues now, so no need for wall of text explaining you don't have ill intention, just ask when the app really need it (like open a photo picker, not initial setup)
1
u/ChanceMaximum7288 Oct 07 '25
saying you don’t peek makes me feel like you peek bro… just use the default and give a reason in your info.plist
1
1
Oct 06 '25
Explain it in a more formal and emotional way, not in a childish way like "pinky promise" it will make people think as if you are unserious about their privacy.
2
0
90
u/Outrageous-Neck-9338 Oct 05 '25
Pinky Promise? Im uninstalling that shit immediately