r/iOSProgramming • • Jul 07 '23

Discussion Take this sub public again please NSFW

Make this sub real again. Take it out of private and remove the NSFW tag.

We should be above these petty platform feuds.

At least take a vote and see what the members want, and make it not the choice of a few moderators affecting tens of thousands of iOS developers.

I support protest but only when it might have an effect; this protest was good for about a week but plainly will have no effect so why not resume helping people?

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

7

u/canico88 Jul 07 '23

But it does have an effect. NSFW subs have no ads on them, so it hurts them straight in their pocket.

11

u/bcyng Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 08 '23

It hurts the sub too because there is no new blood due to it being private.

No one came here to play politics. Only to discuss iOS programming - and this gets in the way of that.

3

u/SirBill01 Jul 08 '23

I'm not answering any questions here while it is private, I've decided... an answer should be out to help the world, not a handful of old men hiding behind a wall.

3

u/ankole_watusi Jul 07 '23

Who the hell buys that TEMU crap anyway? That’s all I see, lol.

-5

u/SirBill01 Jul 07 '23

Why would I be happy about reducing overall revenue for core Reddit, making them charge even higher API fees as a result? I thought the goal was lower API fees? This is going the wrong way.

2

u/canico88 Jul 07 '23

That’s a glass half empty view. The glass half full view:

If this happened in more subs, and if their revenue was lower with the fees than before the fees, it could show them the community is against the fees and make them rethink their approach.

6

u/SirBill01 Jul 07 '23

Why would it ever make them rethink the approach? If it really happened at large enough scale, it would make them take NSFW away as a thing and just drop some true NSFW subreddits. Btu as it stands since there are so few meaningful subs still marked NSFW teh only people being harmed is the average iOS developer that wants a subreddit for help.

0

u/SwiftDevJournal Jul 07 '23

Can't people get help at the following Reddit groups that are public?

And if someone wants to avoid Reddit, they can get help at the following forums:

10

u/SirBill01 Jul 07 '23

What about people who are looking for older answers, but can't see into this forum because it's private? Would it be cool to take StackOverflow offline indefinitely?

To me this smacks of the worst form of privilege, to tell a new iOS developer "Well you can't use one of the best resources because we are angry at some totally unrelated party, but by all means enjoy one of these other lesser resources we have left open for you".

The simple fact is not as many people know about the other subreddits, and are you really claiming /r/iosdev with 11k members is in any way a replacement resource to /r/iOSProgramming dev with 127k?

The peasants are hungry for answers? Let them eat iosdev!

3

u/QuackersAndSoup24 Jul 08 '23

Whole heartedly agreed, nothing worse than trying to access a perfect Reddit thread about a topic you need to read to see a dumb pop up keeping you out

1

u/Fantastic_Resolve364 Jul 07 '23

tx - will check them out!

-3

u/Tiinpa Jul 07 '23

Even if I agreed the larger Reddit protests are pointless, I would still want iosprogramming to be private. A sub like this being private is one of the few subs where it does make a noticeable difference: It breaks Google because results will point to this sub but the user will not be able to get their answer. I’m not a business genius but growing your user base seems very important for Reddit.

4

u/SirBill01 Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 08 '23

Let's keep the peasants out forever! Only we shall be the true IOS programmers! Sorry new developers you can pound sand!

I have a lot of answers posted on this sub. Why does MY content get to be hidden from search without my permission?

I just cannot believe there's any subset of the iOS developer community that is so utterly hostile to developers as this action is being. For me one thing I have loved so much about being an iOS developer has been the amazing community and now I just see the most selfish, hate filled actions - what has happened?

Just over on the side bar I see a "for beginners" section with helpful links - well guess you can take that down! No beginners on here ever again. It's just so sad and pointless.

2

u/Tiinpa Jul 08 '23

Reddit is hardly the only game in town. It’s an inconvenience to find the answer somewhere else, they might even ask “duplicate” questions on another site, but there are plenty of other iOS Dev resources on the internet.

I’m actually more suprised you're fine letting Reddit profit from your contributions while they’re being so hostile to their communities. I deleted my old posts.

1

u/SirBill01 Jul 08 '23

What I'm fine with is the PUBLIC being able to see my responses to questions, and I realize that sites I post answers to have to make money to survive so people will see those answers. Was anyone ever upset about StackOverflow making money? No.

What I am not fine with is a handful of people taking my answers hostage and using them to promote their own private doomed crusade without permission.

Yes there are other sites but people use sites they like, and they should be able to use Reddit if they choose.

What really, really pisses me off though is the harm this is doing real people. Just yesterday I answered a question from someone who was asking questions about creating an app to help his son with a medical issue. It was sheer chance I was looking at older posts in /r/iosDev or it would never have been really answered well, whereas on this forum in the Before Times it would have been answered within an hour... as developers we are supposed to be helping tools to make the world a better place, not trying to tear the world down because of personal issues!!!!!!!!