r/huntsman • • Oct 24 '21

Discussion Explanations for inconsistencies in Winter's War

27 Upvotes

I created this subreddit because I genuinely love both films. However, I'm well aware of the inconsistencies between the films. Many fans of the first film despise Winter's War because it's so inconsistent with a film that they loved. Now I honestly believe that the majority of these are genuine inconsistencies on the writers' part and they didn't care to make the films a cohesive series, but most of them CAN be explained if you tried really hard. Here we go...

  1. Why did Finn tell Eric that he killed Sara and why did he imply that Eric wasn't there?

Finn : "I admire your fight, Huntsman. Your wife was the same."

Eric : "What do you know of my wife?"

Finn : "I remember them all. But especially the ones with fight. She screamed your name but you weren't there. Now you can beg her forgiveness in the other world."

When Finn says "them all" he is referring to all the huntsmen who fought for Freya. He is implying that he was there when Sara and Eric were separated. Sara said Eric left her which was part of the illusion conjured by Freya. Even though we never saw Finn in the second movie, he was probably there observing what happened. He probably ran errands for Freya and helped her. Sara screams Eric's name but he wasn't there because in the illusion he had left her. Eric knows that's not what happened, but by bringing up this traumatic memory, he probably was going through a flashback during their fight which threw him off.

2) If Eric was the one who woke Snow White, why did she end up marrying William?

Even before Winter's War came out, I interpreted Snow and Eric's relationship differently than most. I didn't view their relationship as a true romance cause Eric clearly still loved his wife and wasn't ready to move on quite yet. "Then why did his kiss wake her up?" Because when he was talking about his wife over Snow's body, he said "you remind me of her, her heart, her spirit." I think Snow's influence on him reignited emotions in him that he hadn't felt for a long time (the entire theme of Winter's War was about loving when you're trained never to love). I think it's that influx of romantic love for his wife and protective love for Snow that managed to override the spell. Also it could've been a mixture of something else. He could have been IN love with Snow a little too, but relationship-wise he wasn't ready. It's like how Captain America in the MCU had amazing chemistry with Black Widow (and Sharon Carter) but he never truly got over Peggy. I had no issue with Snow marrying William, I think he was better suited for her anyway. As to bringing Sara back in Winter's War, it wasn't NEEDED (I think Eric was on the verge of properly moving on at the start of the film), but their relationship was convincing enough that I got on board. I totally see why Snow reminded him of her. He clearly admired her and I think that's a good summary of their feelings for one another. I think Snow realized that and figured William was a better co-ruler for her.

3) Why did Freya still care about Eric or bother to help him win the day after he killed her brother and helped kill her sister?

The obvious explanation for that is that she didn't know. She has owl spies all over the place, but we saw from the beginning of Winter's War that Eric can usually spot those spies whenever they're in range, which the owl would have to be in order for Freya to witness that. She even said in Winter's War that she didn't know Eric was alive. Some people have said that she must have known because she knew Ravenna was dead, but c'mon. Everyone knew Ravenna was dead, that news kind of gets out when you get overthrown.

4) Why does Freya not need to consume other's youthful beauty to stay young like Ravenna does?

We know Ravenna consumed the youthful essence of young pretty girls to stay young herself and she was able to also keep Finn young as he didn't have his own powers. Freya also has powers, but we don't see her having to consume youth. So, how has she been immortal all this time?

This is a harder one to explain.

One theory I have is: her ice powers include her being "frozen" at one age forever. Another theory being Ravenna kept Finn and her young from a distance but shouldn't Ravenna's death have undone that?

I think the explanation we have to roll with is the first one. I personally don't believe Ravenna was the one keeping her young because it lasted after Ravenna's death. Even if we were to believe that it could last beyond her life, we saw that the second Finn and Ravenna died, they aged back to their true ages, whereas when Freya died, she stayed the same.


r/huntsman • • Oct 27 '21

Image Colin Morgan has had TWO love interests named Freya

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Oct 24 '21

Theory Theory: Did Eric AND William wake Snow?

10 Upvotes

I saw this online somewhere and I can't stop thinking about it. Maybe it was more than a kiss from Eric that woke her from her sleeping death. When William kisses Snow White, a tear falls from one of her eyes. Then Eric kisses her and a second tear falls from her other eye. Perhaps the spell is broken by the love of two men she treasures. Now that's just a theory (a film theor-... okay I'll stop), but definitely a nice catch and something to think about.


r/huntsman • • Aug 19 '25

Video The (Actually Good) Snow White Remake

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • May 11 '22

Image Well this photo didn't age well

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Aug 04 '26

Discussion It's not a "remake" but I appreciate the mention

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Sep 30 '25

Snow White and the Huntsman Appreciation Post for Evil Queen, Ravenna

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Sep 04 '23

Video How to Talk - Kristen Stewart Snow White vs Rachel Zegler

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Nov 28 '21

Fanart Why is this funnier than it should be?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Jan 15 '25

Video Snow White & The Huntsman Is Better Than You Remember

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Sep 15 '23

Image Fun Easter egg in Once Upon a Time

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Feb 28 '22

Fanart Disney with an edge, I love it! (credit: Daekazu)

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Nov 09 '24

Opinion Tell me your favorite character

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Nov 25 '21

Opinion As of now, who is the superior Snow White?

4 Upvotes
59 votes, Dec 02 '21
1 Adriana Caselotti
1 Kristen Stewart
2 Lily Collins
55 Ginnifer Goodwin
0 Eliza Bennett

r/huntsman • • Oct 27 '25

Opinion "Charlize Theron is Evilly Good!"

3 Upvotes

"Snow White and the Huntsman" Review: Charlize Theron is Evilly Good! https://share.google/LQ3WED5SBlUyRTdFw


r/huntsman • • Sep 08 '25

Discussion Interesting thought

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Jan 15 '25

Discussion Who's the better shot?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Nov 14 '24

Fanart That fanfic you don't want to read but can't help but be intrigued (credit: Renny08)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Aug 06 '24

Image A few details I never realized were drawn from the original version of the tale

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Oct 02 '23

Opinion What is your favorite adaptation of the seven dwarves?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Feb 23 '23

Image Happy 40th our beautiful Ice Queen

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Dec 28 '22

Image Deck of cards I made for my sister

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/huntsman • • Oct 26 '22

Opinion Best Snow White movie

3 Upvotes
5 votes, Oct 28 '22
0 Snow White and the Seven Dwarves
2 Snow White and the Huntsman
1 Mirror, Mirror
1 The Fairest of Them All
0 Grimm's Snow White
1 Other

r/huntsman • • Sep 26 '22

Question What other fairytale could've been adapted for this universe?

Post image
3 Upvotes