Review: HTC One (M8)
So I got the new HTC One M8 a few days ago and it is a NEAR PERFECT phone. I absolutely love this phone and it is by far the best phone I have ever had. But it is not perfect, it could be fairly easily though.
It is no secret that Samsung Mobile USA has been beating all other cellphone manufacturers the last few years. Largely in part to excellent and expensive marketing campaigns and largely in part to their 6 month release cycle on new versions of their Top-of-the-line devices.
It is my opinion that HTC USA makes a far superior range of devices but they are lost in the hype. With that said HTC could spend an exorbitant amount of money on marketing and eventually get the recognition they deserve or they could focus on making their devices PERFECT and let word-of-mouth and viral-marketing do the rest. With that in mind here are the main problems with the HTC One M8 and how to fix them.
I believe that Overlays like HTC Sense 6.0 should only be used on devices to add additional features to the device. Not for the purposes of hiding/removing/masking/limiting features of a device. While I admit Sense is smooth and beautiful it doesn't do things the way it should.
SOFTWARE:
1.) Sense limits icons in folders to 16 icons. Other android devices running KitKat allow many more icons (64).
2.) When creating folders in the Apps Menu and organizing your icons they should Automatically Alphabetized. Whenever new icons are added they should be Alphabetized. When those folders are copied to the Home Screen they should be Alphabetized. Whenever new icons are added to the folders in the Apps Menu they should Automatically be added to the same folder on the Home Screen.
3.) The Developers Menu should not be hidden. The Developers Menu in KitKat is by default visible but turned off and that is the way it should be on Sense enabled devices.
4.) Long Pressing the Menu button (bottom right of home screen) should bring up the Options/Settings menu of any app or home screen.
5.) There is a distinct lack of options for configuring the look/feel of the device. An example would be when changing themes there is no way to change the background/wallpaper of the menu's.
6.) In lieu of a finger print scanner which was inexplicably not included in this device (but was in the HTC One Max) there should be a Retinal Scanner feature built in. Both cameras on this device are of significant resolution to allow for this. The Retinal Scanner App should be a system app that starts on boot. It should allow for
A.) Unlocking the device
B.) Encrypting/Decrypting the device/sd card
C.) Storing and filling in Passwords and Form Data.
7.) BlinkFeed should be easily customizable. Including the ability to disable/resize/move it. Currently the only real option is to disable the home screen it is preloaded on.
8.) There should be an Option to Add/Configure the Search Bar at the top of the Home Screen. Along with adding the Search Bar the user should be able to configure the Default Search Engine for that search bar.
9.) The phone has an IR Blaster built in but doesn't come preloaded with any software to utilize it. The phone should include an app like the "HTC IR - Universal Remote" that is in the Play Store.
10.) BoomSound - currently BoomSound can not be enabled unless there is a Wired Headphone plugged in. Thus seriously limiting its use and the overall sound quality of the phone. BoomSound should work with any A2DP (Stereo) Bluetooth Device. It should also work when making/receiving calls via Speaker Phone as well as in any app/game when the phone is not being held up to ones head. The light sensor by the front camera could be used to detect if the phone is being held up to ones head and disable BoomSound, the rest of the time it should be Enabled. Additionally, BoomSound should support App Genre Profiles. By that I mean for Games you get to configure the sound one way, for Music/Video Apps it can be configured another way and for Audio/Video Calls (Speaker Phone) it gets configured another way and for Audio/Video Calls (Wired Headset) it gets configured differently as well as for A2DP (Stereo) Bluetooth Audio/Video calls it gets configured differently.
Notice all of those are software related. The hardware in this device is near perfect. In fact the only flaws I can find in the Hardware are:
HARDWARE:
1.) Differing processors. Some phones (networks) get a 2.3Ghz processor while others get a 2.5Ghz processor. The really strange part about this is that Verizon Wireless versions of the phone have the slower processor even though Verizon Wireless has XLTE which enables the fastest download/upload speeds. You would think those devices would have the fastest possible processor but they do not.
2.) Lack of Finger Print Scanner.
3.) Lack of Dual Sim support for would be International Travelers.
4.) Lack of User-Changeable battery - all though this feature is partially mitigated by the exceptional uni-body metal construction of the device.
5.) Lack of FM Radio (HD Radio) Tuner/App - ie Broadcast FM and HD Terrestrial Radio.
6.) Lack of Digital Broadcast TV Tuner/App - in fairness I know of no phone that has this built in which boggles my mind. With the size and power of this phone that should be a relatively simple feature to add to the device and much like most phones with FM tuners it could rely on an external antenna that would plug into the Headphone Jack.
I added 5 & 6 under Hardware simply because DATA CAPS on all US Networks make it extremely expensive to STREAM TV/RADIO via the internet. It would be great to be able to listen to the radio or watch tv without using DATA (except for Program Guides).
In conclusion, if HTC USA would release a Software Update addressing the 10 points shown above under Software the HTC One M8 would be almost PERFECT. Then roll in the 6 points listed under hardware in the future HTC One M9 along with everything the M8 can currently due and you would absolutely have the PERFECT PHONE.