I know not everyone agrees with me on that call, so I’m going to preface this with, you ship who you want to ship boo, but to me she’s very clearly aromantic, possibly demisexual as well.
She shoots down everyone. The only two people we see her open up to easily are the two who don’t immediately flood her with flirtation—Kotallo, who holds a respectful distance despite his admiration, and Alva, who is excited to have someone to geek out with and finally satisfy her curiosity. Her dynamic with them is so different and really highlights how awkward she can be around Varl and Erend.
Varl’s story in particular was so well handled. He’s overtly crushing and he constantly tries to get closer, but it’s like watching a golden retriever try to befriend a cat. He’s not rude and it’s just his warm, friendly nature at work, but he’s always pushing for more than she wants to give and she’s uncomfortable with it. She literally tries to ditch him, twice.
The scene where she sends him off with Zo is such a fantastic pileup of conflicting emotions. On the one hand, there is a small part of Aloy that wants to want these things, I think, and there’s a tiny bit of… jealousy isn’t the right word, but certainly stung pride over being dropped. The rest of her is just straight relief and the way their interactions shift and their friendship develops after this point really speaks to how much of a burden his interest was. That one conversation where he asks her about a fight he had with Zo and Aloy goes, “I literally have no experience, why are you asking me,” made me laugh loudly.
Once Varl moves on, their friendship really blooms.
Erend, on the other hand, flat out makes her uncomfortable. There are times where they bond, and she’s definitely encouraging every time he sits around and bashes himself (which is every time), but the noncommittal replies she makes when he drops comments about having, “more competition,” when she brings more people back to the base—oof. It’s clear that he has never accepted Aloy’s polite rejection. The scene in the Daunt where he’s drunk and bitter and belligerent over being left behind and she’s just blindsided by it was deeply painful to watch.
He’s so clearly the friend who’s hanging around, waiting for her to make a drunken mistake and his vibes make my skin crawl. Erend doesn’t seem to take ‘no’ as an answer and it’s why their connection remains so stilted compared to Aloy’s interactions with other characters.
And Tilda? I could write epics to Tilda. Her character is so good and so beautifully, humanly obsessive and twisted. She’s horrible and I love her for it. Watching her fly around like a creepy tooth fairy was a highlight of the game for me.
But even here, in her biased and gilded recollections of her time with Elisabet, we see signs that it has always been this way. They connect over shared interests and I think there was definitely something, but it was never as deep or as consuming as Tilda wanted. She outright states as much, describing Elisabet as aloof and reserved, like there was a part of her she was always holding back, and Aloy parallels that discreption to a T.
It’s just… it’s so well handled. It’s clear that Aloy is capable of forming deep, abiding attachments to people, so it’s not that her character is flat (literally, this was the story theme lol), but the romantic ones just aren’t there—and that’s okay!! She never feels less fleshed out to me, she doesn’t need romance to be well rounded. She’s awkward and competent and funny and incredibly sassy and a great friend, she’s this whole amazing person that has a deep well of compassion and empathy for the world around her. Being aromantic doesn’t lessen that.
It’s so rare to see, particularly in female characters. I really enjoyed this game and the storytelling they gave us. I hope they don’t give us a romance option for Aloy, she doesn’t need one.